The EU’s de facto ban on genetically modified (GM) crops may have caused more harm than good, according to the UK’s chief scientist.
Sir Mark Walport told MPs on the Science and Technology committee on Wednesday: “The consequence of inactions are that we are potentially, particularly in Europe, denying access to technologies that actually will potentially help feed people in ways that damage the environment less.”
He said food security in Europe, particularly in Britain, was more tenuous than people realised and the costs of controlling agricultural pests could be significantly reduced.
Only one GM crop is currently grown commercially in the European Union – the insect-resistant maize MON 810.
Gaining approval for the cultivation of GM crops in the EU has been effectively impossible because each one requires a vote by member states. Many EU countries are sceptical of the technology. So even if a crop is approved by the European Food Safety Authority (Efsa) it is unlikely to make it into commercial fields. New rules allowing member states to unilaterally ban GM may ease this political blockade.
Scientists, including Walport and the EU chief scientist Anne Glover whose role is being axed, say GM is not inherently dangerous, essentially no different to the selective breeding that humans have engaged in for millennia and each crop should be assessed on its own merits.
“It makes more sense to assess crops based on their individual characteristics and the farming practices that accompany them, rather than the method by which they were produced,” says Mark Downs, chief executive of the Society of Biology.
Walport told the committee that the UK’s advocacy for GM crops in the face of EU opposition was scientifically justified. “I do consider that to be an evidence-based policy indeed. The science is very clear and I’m happy that the government have taken on board the science.”
Wendy Harwood, a senior scientist at the John Innes Centre, said GM’s commercial stasis meant useful technologies were being ignored. “As scientists we see promising things coming along and there’s a frustration that these things will never actually benefit people because of the huge costs.”
A study published in the journal PLOS One this year found “on average, GM technology adoption has reduced chemical pesticide use by 37%, increased crop yields by 22%, and increased farmer profits by 68%”.
Advertisement
Jonathan Jones, a plant molecular biologist at the Sainsbury Laboratory, says the tales of missed opportunity are legion because the regulatory requirements for GM crops are “far in excess of what’s rational”. The cost of the process, hundreds of millions of pounds, means very few crops are worth the risk of bringing all the way through. This cost excludes the public sector from developing commercial crops, leaving the sector oligopolised by a handful of massive agro-corporations.
But in Europe, even these well-resourced companies are turning away from the technology. A strain of blight-resistant potatoes was removed from the approval process by agrochemical giant BASF after it became clear that even if it was found to be safe by Efsa, it was likely be voted down by EU politicians.
Jones says the GM potato could have saved millions. Blight costs UK potato farmers around £60m every year in losses and the massive use of chemical sprays. Each hectare has £500 worth of fungicide dumped on it each season.
Jones says there are similar stories for pest-resistant cabbages and broccoli as well as yellow-rust resistant wheat. “These are examples where in a rational world we’d be just getting on with [them].”...
Via
Christophe Jacquet