 Your new post is loading...
 Your new post is loading...
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
October 13, 2013 8:40 AM
|
is a personal Notebook Thanks John Dudley for the following tweet "If you like interesting snippets on all sorts of subjects relevant to academia, information, the world, highly recommended is @grip54 's collection:" La curation de contenus, la mémoire partagée d'une veille scientifique et sociétale
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
Today, 4:30 AM
|
Eye tracking helps simulation teams compare how experienced clinicians and learners visually approach the same task, procedure or decision point, revealing differences that may be difficult to capture through observation alone.
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
Today, 4:23 AM
|
Here’s my idea for a billion-dollar business. Hear me out. 1) We don’t make the product. Experts make it and hand it to us for free. 2) We don’t check the quality. Other world-leading experts do that for us, for free. 3) We don’t run the process. Yet another expert does, for free or close to it. 4) Then we sell the product back to the institutions that paid for it in the first place. Access is exclusive, expensive and locked behind paywalls. 5) Want the whole world to see your work? Become a “gold member.” Pay us thousands, and your product goes free for everyone. Good for you and the world, we’ll say. Good for us, we won’t. 6) The final product? A PDF on the internet. Sounds absurd? This is academic publishing. Last year, Elsevier’s research publishing arm made £2.7 billion in revenue. Springer Nature’s made €1.5 billion. Wiley’s made $1.1 billion. The research is publicly funded, the peer review is volunteered and the editing is often barely paid. Yet the knowledge ends up behind a paywall, or authors pay to set it free. Is it time for change? What would a better system look like?| 27 commentaires sur LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 15, 10:15 AM
|
Academic research as we know it may not last much longer. As AI makes it easier to produce and publish research, distinguishing meaningful contributions from the "lemons" is becoming increasingly difficult.
This is something I've been thinking a lot about recently, and I'll share more thoughts on it soon.
In the meantime, this article in The Atlantic offers a great reflection on where things are heading:
"In some cases, the cycle has become absurd: AI-assisted papers land with overworked editors, who send them to rushed reviewers, who in some cases use AI to write the review, which the authors revise and resubmit using AI."
I'd love to hear other perspectives on this. Are we making research better, or just producing more? Should academic institutions change their incentives?
https://lnkd.in/emuuZffh | 24 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 15, 5:32 AM
|
A new preprint looking at Problematic Journals identified using 3 bibliometric parameters. The study also looks at which countries and institutes are publishing in the flagged journals.
A total of 3,753 journals were flagged by the study in the period 2015-2026. These journals published 0.67 Million research articles in the year they were flagged.
Some important findings of the study:
👉A very small proportion of the flagged journals were actually delisted by Elsevier | Scopus 👉China leads in publications in flagged journals, whereas India leads in publications in delisted journals. 👉Some Universities have more than 18% of their output in such journals.
The study recommends that:
1) Indexing agencies like Elsevier | Scopus should be more proactive in monitoring these signals and take quick action to maintain the quality of their database.
2) Ranking agencies should consider not counting papers and citations to and from problematic journals in the year of problem.
Nature article by Miryam Naddaf (Link in comments).
Link to the preprint in comments.
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 10:29 AM
|
Ma plus grande inquiétude avec l'IA, ce n'est pas qu'elle nous remplace. C'est qu'elle nous fasse tous parler pareil. 😳
Joerg Storm l'a écrit cette semaine. Et les données commencent à lui donner raison.
Des chercheurs ont comparé 2 200 essais de candidature à l'université à des essais rédigés par GPT-4. Chaque essai humain ajouté apportait plus d'idées neuves que chaque essai de la machine. De meilleurs prompts n'ont pas comblé l'écart.
Une autre expérience, publiée dans Science Advances, montre le compromis qui dérange : les histoires écrites avec l'aide de l'IA sont jugées plus créatives et mieux écrites. Mais elles se ressemblent davantage entre elles.
L'IA améliore chaque copie. Et elle appauvrit le groupe.
Vous le voyez déjà dans votre fil. Mêmes accroches. Mêmes formules. Mêmes arguments. Seule la photo de profil change.
Je suis le premier visé : j'écris avec Claude tous les jours.
Ce qui est en train de mourir :
👉 Le style comme acquis. Hier, avoir une voix suffisait à se distinguer. Demain, il faudra la défendre.
👉 L'avantage de l'accès. Tout le monde aura Claude, Copilot ou ChatGPT. L'outil ne différencie plus personne.
👉 Le texte bien écrit comme signe d'une idée forte. La forme est devenue gratuite. Le fond, non.
Comment garder sa voix :
1️⃣ Demander à l'IA de vous contredire, pas d'écrire à votre place. « Qu'est-ce qui cloche dans cette idée ? » rend votre raisonnement plus solide. Et il reste le vôtre.
2️⃣ Partir de votre matière. Un cas client, un échec, une conversation de la semaine. L'IA n'a pas vécu votre semaine.
3️⃣ Garder la dernière main. Relisez à voix haute. Si le texte pourrait être signé par n'importe qui, il l'est déjà.
Ma conviction de vieux briscard : l'avantage ne sera pas d'avoir l'IA. Ce sera d'avoir encore un point de vue quand tout le monde aura les mêmes outils.
🎯 Consultant : Masterclass gratuite Consultant IA 👉 https://lnkd.in/eGBesFpX 🎤 Conférence : Conférence Transformation IA 👉 https://lnkd.in/ec_bt5f2 🚀 Entreprise 2030 : Votre entreprise en 2030, prospective offerte 👉 https://lnkd.in/eg3N-jB8 📬 Newsletter : un cas concret décortiqué chaque semaine 👉 https://decisionia.com/nl 💬 RDV : Un projet IA ? Discutons-en 👉 https://decisionia.com/rdv
Comment utilisez-vous l'IA sans la laisser aplatir votre voix ? 👇 | 49 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 4:10 AM
|
Globe interactif des ressources Géoconfluences
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 3:53 AM
|
❓ In your opinion, is the h-index a meaningful indicator of academic productivity, or does it fail to capture the true value of scholarly contributions? 📜 In our latest article, published in the prestigious Journal of Information Science, we critically examine the h-index, one of the most widely used metrics for assessing academic performance and research impact worldwide. 🧮 Drawing on both quantitative and qualitative evidence, we explore the strengths and limitations of the h-index and evaluate alternative performance assessment models. By challenging conventional approaches and highlighting the multidimensional nature of academic achievement, our study offers a fresh perspective on how scholarly productivity and research impact should be assessed. 🙏 I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Prof. Dr. Pinar Mert Cuce for her invaluable guidance, insightful contributions, and extensive expertise throughout this research. https://lnkd.in/eXeDte5X Have a look, and let the fake heroes crack! | 20 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 2:12 AM
|
📊 𝗩𝗼𝗶𝗿 𝗲́𝘃𝗼𝗹𝘂𝗲𝗿 𝗹𝗲𝘀 𝘀𝘂𝗷𝗲𝘁𝘀 𝗱’𝘂𝗻𝗲 𝘃𝗲𝗶𝗹𝗹𝗲 𝘀𝗰𝗶𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗶𝗳𝗶𝗾𝘂𝗲
Dans les années 1980, cartographier la dynamique d’un champ de recherche demandait un laboratoire et un logiciel dédié. C’est la méthode des « mots associés » de Michel Callon et Jean-Pierre Courtial, que j’ai appliquée à la veille scientifique que je mène pour Veillemag.
𝗟𝗲 𝗱𝗶𝗮𝗴𝗿𝗮𝗺𝗺𝗲, cinquième outil de L’atelier, range les familles de thèmes en quatre cases : → les sujets centraux et bien structurés → les niches pointues → les carrefours encore peu structurés → les sujets en marge
Juste en dessous, un diagramme de Sankey (que l'on devrait plutôt nommer diagramme de Minard, mais c'est une autre histoire) suit ces familles mois après mois. On les voit grossir, fusionner, se diviser ou s’éteindre. Un clic sur l’une d’elles montre d’où elle vient et ce qu’elle devient.
Comme les autres outils présentés cette semaine, le diagramme décrit ma veille, c’est-à-dire mes choix de lecture, et non l’état de la recherche. Si une famille s’amincit, les chercheurs s’en détournent peut-être... ou j’ai simplement regardé ailleurs ce trimestre-là.
Et vous , quelle méthode, découverte un jour dans un manuel et jugée hors de portée, aimeriez-vous enfin mettre en pratique grâce à l'IA ?
Lien vers le diagramme en commentaire ⬇️
#veille #scientometrie #intelligenceeconomique #vibecoding #IAgenerative
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 13, 3:41 AM
|
It is exciting seeing interest in #serendipity by researchers from so many disciplines and that #LIS and my work in information encountering are contributing to these efforts from the information behavior perspective.
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 13, 3:27 AM
|
Researchers conducted the first large-scale study of how often clinicians use artificial intelligence tools in patient care, who those clinicians are, and what they are using it for.
The study, led by researchers at Harvard Medical School and Brigham and Women's Hospital, looked at how 950,000 physicians, physician assistants, and nurse practitioners in the United States used OpenEvidence, a popular AI-enabled clinical information platform, over the last two and a half years.
The data showed that queries were frequently for aiding in treatment decisions rather than diagnostic tasks and that questions were often about subjects that were outside of the practitioner’s specialty.
“AI tools have become integrated into routine in clinical practice faster than almost any technology we’ve seen, but until now we’ve had very little data on how clinicians actually use them,” said first author Vishal Patel, MD, MPH, HMS clinical fellow in surgery at Brigham and Women’s. “This research gives us an early picture of where these tools fit into clinical decision-making and where we need to study their accuracy and effects on patient care next.”
The next step will be to examine whether use of these tools improves clinical care, the researchers said. | 13 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 13, 3:20 AM
|
Evidence Hierarchies are such a lightening rod in the world of evaluation. i’m not re-posting this one to trigger old debates but to point out a few features of this one.
first, the main purpose of this hierarchy is to help avoid over-claiming in conclusions. i agree with the post that it is all too easy to undo careful explanation in the methods and results with more sweeping statements in the conclusion (and executive summary).
second, i appreciated the cautions at the end of the post. that is, this hierarchy is only relevant for questions of causal attribution. if you want to answer other questions, then look to other approaches.
and quality still matters - a well-designed cohort study can tell you more than a poorly designed RCT. randomisation is powerful but we shouldn’t fetishise it!
finally, it’s useful to be reminded of the suite of go-to methods (of causal inference) for different fields. there’s no mention here of discontinuity design, diff-in-diff, synthetic controls or interrupted time series, which are common in the social sciences. not a criticism, just a reflection on differences between fields.
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 12, 10:33 AM
|
For some reason I was nervous to hit post on this one, maybe because I want us to use the moment we have well and I worry we are losing the people we most need to be reaching.
More at the link below about why I’d love for us to stop saying we need to save science and that science is back….
https://lnkd.in/gzUmSaJa
|
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
Today, 5:05 AM
|
Update: I tested three more AI-powered tools for literature search, bringing the total number tested to 15. Two new ones were really bad, one finding only one and the other literally none of the studies in the target sample. One performed somewhat better but still rather poorly. I have updated the paper with the new results and a perspective on brighter horizons here https://lnkd.in/ehnmpDcT. I will present the paper at the Leibniz Association Open Science day in Berlin on Tuesday. After the conference I plan to submit the paper for review in Open Research Europe, the new publish - review - curate platform for research in Europe. Your thoughts about the validation study are much appreciated. I particularly hope that the tool producers will review the paper and respond. If you are an employee at Anthropic, Google DeepMind, Undermind, PapersFlow, Elicit, Elsevier | Scopus or know someone working there, please alert them. https://lnkd.in/ewfx7Rev | 15 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
Today, 4:24 AM
|
It is time for universities to stop reducing the assessment of colleagues to Scopus-based indicators, journal rankings and publication counts.
I write as someone the present system serves well. I have just published an article in a Q1 journal, I have one book in press with Routledge and another with Oxford University Press, and I have others under contract. I would rather colleagues assessed that work by what it argues and the evidence it brings than by the quartile of the journal or the name of the press.
The San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA)(sfdora.org) offers a different approach. It came from within the scientific community. Journal editors and publishers drafted it at the 2012 annual meeting of the American Society for Cell Biology, and it was published in 2013.
Monographs, critical editions and articles in leading journals should remain central to academic life. Committees should assess what these works contribute: the originality of the argument, the quality of the evidence, the care taken over method and the significance for the field. The reputation of a publisher or the position of a journal in a ranking records where a work appeared, and a committee should treat it as context for its own reading of the work.
DORA also asks institutions to consider contributions other than conventional publications, including datasets and software, and to take account of qualitative evidence such as influence on policy and practice.
For those of us in the humanities, this should include scholarly translations, archival and editorial projects, digital resources, exhibitions and sustained public scholarship. It should also include research published in languages other than English, and work whose significance becomes apparent over years rather than within a short assessment cycle.
Outputs will still differ in weight. Departments should set clear criteria suited to each discipline, and the colleagues who apply them should take responsibility for an informed evaluation. DORA's guidance supports the responsible use of indicators in context, as one source of information among several.
Many leading European universities have already signed. In the United Kingdom they include Oxford, Cambridge, UCL, King’s College London, Edinburgh and Manchester. In the United States, to my surprise, fewer research universities have signed, and some signatories are units within a university: an appointments and promotions committee at the University of Chicago and a doctoral programme at the CUNY Graduate Center. In the Arab world I know of only one university that has signed, the American University of Sharjah.
Universities should sign DORA. More importantly, they should apply its principles in recruitment, annual reviews, promotion and tenure. #DORA #ResearchAssessment #ResponsibleMetrics #HigherEducation #Humanities #AcademicPublishing #PromotionAndTenure #AcademicAssessment #Assessment #Universities #Promotion | 10 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
Today, 4:22 AM
|
Qui dirige l’hôpital ?
Mon père était chirurgien. Dans les années septante, quand il traversait son hôpital, les religieuses le saluaient.
Cinquante ans plus tard, je traverse les couloirs du mien. Les blouses blanches sont toujours là. Le pouvoir a déménagé.
Entre le bloc opératoire et la direction, on trouve désormais des directeurs adjoints, des consultants, des responsables qualité, des comités de pilotage et leurs indispensables tableaux de bord.
Les chiffres donnent le vertige. Aux États-Unis, entre 1975 et 2010, le nombre de médecins a augmenté de 150 %. Celui des administrateurs de santé de 3 200 %, selon une analyse relayée par athenahealth à partir de données fédérales. En Suède, les effectifs administratifs ont même dépassé ceux des médecins.
Prenons un hôpital de 500 médecins. Une heure par jour de rapports et d’encodages par médecin : 500 heures quotidiennes. Cinquante journées de dix heures. Combien pourraient être rendues aux patients ?
Et si les médecins retrouvaient une véritable place dans la direction des hôpitaux ?
Les études sont intrigantes. Aux États-Unis, Amanda Goodall a observé que les hôpitaux dirigés par des médecins obtenaient de meilleurs classements. Une étude allemande portant sur 370 hôpitaux retrouve une mortalité plus basse pour la pneumonie et une satisfaction des patients plus élevée, sans supériorité sur tous les critères.
Cela ne signifie pas qu’un bon médecin ferait nécessairement un bon directeur.
Mais peut-on diriger efficacement un hôpital sans associer ceux qui connaissent intimement le métier de soigner ?
Était-ce mieux avant ? Pas sûr. Les mandarins avaient leurs abus, les religieuses n’étaient pas infaillibles, et la médecine moderne exige une administration compétente.
Je ne propose pas de supprimer les gestionnaires. Mais pourquoi ne pas commencer par les rapports que personne ne lit, les doubles encodages et les réunions qui ne décident rien ?
Une administration efficace se mesure aussi au temps qu’elle rend aux soignants. Pas au nombre de procédures qu’elle produit.
Car tout système finit par obtenir les comportements qu’il récompense. Traitez des professionnels autonomes en exécutants, ils raisonneront en salariés. Ils compareront leurs horaires, leurs rémunérations, leurs conditions. Et parfois, ils partiront.
Nous cherchons partout des médecins. Demandons-nous aussi pourquoi certains n’ont plus envie de rester.
Les religieuses de l’hôpital de mon père ne géraient peut-être pas mieux que nos diplômés d’école de commerce.
Mais elles savaient pourquoi l’hôpital existait.
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 15, 9:09 AM
|
GOOGLE JUST AUTOMATED RESEARCH PAPERS 🤯
It is called PaperOrchestra.
A multiagent framework that writes submission ready scientific papers from scratch.
You input a raw idea and experimental logs.
The system takes over entirely.
It uses a swarm of specialized agents to handle the workload:
> lead researcher writes the outline > literature review agent prioritizes sources > plotting agent generates visuals from code > reviewer agent forces autonomous revisions
The output is a fully formatted LaTeX manuscript.
This drops the cost of producing scientific literature to zero.
The peer review system is already overloaded.
Now anyone can generate perfectly formatted research at scale.
repo: https://lnkd.in/eTG_eNKa streamlit demo: https://lnkd.in/eycmYeDY | 120 comments on LinkedIn
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 10:54 AM
|
« Publish or perish » : peut-on encore réformer l’édition scientifique ? Frais de publication qui explosent, évaluations bâclées, rapports rédigés par une IA… L’édition scientifique est sous pression, et personne n’y est tout à fait innocent : ni les maisons d’édition, ni les universités, ni les chercheuses et chercheurs, soumis au H-index.
Angela Huttner, professeure associée au Département de médecine de la Faculté de médecine de l’UNIGE, médecin adjointe agrégée au Service des maladies infectieuses des HUG et rédactrice en cheffe de CMI Communications, fait le bilan. Dans notre newsletter, elle raconte son expérience de chercheuse et de rédactrice en cheffe, et explique pourquoi la priorité serait de réduire le poids des facteurs d’impact dans l’évaluation des carrières.
👉 L’entretien complet : https://lnkd.in/e8piyppB 📄 Huttner A. The beating heart of a broken machine. CMI Communications, 2026 ; 3. https://lnkd.in/es89KUF5
Université de Genève HUG - Hôpitaux Universitaires de Genève #PublishOrPerish #EditionScientifique #OpenAccess #IntegriteScientifique
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 10:23 AM
|
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 3:54 AM
|
J’ai mis en libre accès un outil que j’utilise au quotidien : un skill Claude pour faire une revue de littérature rapide sur PubMed.
Le principe : vous posez une question clinique précise, par exemple « quelle prise en charge pour une pseudarthrose du scaphoïde chez l’adulte jeune ? ». L’outil procède ainsi : - il reformule la question en PICO et propose un plan de recherche ; - il lance une série de recherches PubMed (5, 10 ou 20, au choix), en affinant les termes à chaque tour ; - il vérifie que chaque référence citée existe bien dans les résultats PubMed de la session ; - il livre un document Word : une synthèse, un tableau des preuves et une liste d’articles à lire, avec les liens DOI et PubMed. Il fonctionne grâce au connecteur MCP PubMed de Claude. Les recherches portent donc sur la vraie base PubMed, pas sur la mémoire du modèle. Ce que ce n’est pas : une revue systématique. Il n’y a ni double sélection, ni évaluation du risque de biais, ni méta-analyse. C’est une carte de la littérature pour s’orienter vite et savoir quoi lire en premier. Il n’a pas été validé à grande échelle : il fait ce qu’il annonce dans mon usage, rien de plus. Chaque référence doit être relue avant d’être citée. L’idée originale vient de Consensus.app. Je l’ai adaptée à PubMed et à la pratique clinique. Le skill est gratuit, sous licence MIT. Les retours, critiques sont les bienvenus.
https://lnkd.in/e5kwd3_7
#ChirurgieDeLaMain #RechercheClinique #IA #PubMed #OpenSource
_____
I’ve made a tool I use every day freely available: a Claude skill for fast literature reviews on PubMed.
How it works: you ask a precise clinical question, for example “how should scaphoid nonunion be managed in young adults?”. The tool then: - reframes the question as PICO and proposes a search plan; - runs a series of PubMed searches (5, 10 or 20, your choice), refining the terms each round; - checks that every cited reference actually appears in the session’s PubMed results; - delivers a Word document: a synthesis, an evidence table and a reading list, with DOI and PubMed links. It runs on Claude’s PubMed MCP connector, so the searches hit the real PubMed database, not the model’s memory. What it is not: a systematic review. There is no dual screening, no risk-of-bias assessment and no meta-analysis. It is a map of the literature to get oriented fast and know what to read first. It has not been validated at scale: it does what it says in my own use, nothing more. Check every reference before you cite it. The original idea comes from Consensus.app. I adapted it to PubMed and clinical practice. The skill is free, under the MIT license. Feedback, criticism are welcome.
https://lnkd.in/e5kwd3_7
#HandSurgery #ClinicalResearch #AI #PubMed #OpenSource
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 3:51 AM
|
Does anyone at BMJ know how I can submit to their Christmas issue? I have an anlaysis looking at citations ranking papers/authors by how funny they are..
I call it the h-ha index!
(Serious tho)
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 14, 2:03 AM
|
10 AI Tools Every Academic Researcher Should Know About in 2026! 👇 AI is transforming academic research, making literature exploration, paper analysis, writing, and evidence synthesis more efficient. Here are 10 practically useful AI tools for researchers and PhD scholars: 1. ChatGPT ➤ Brainstorming and research questions ➤ Conceptual explanations and paper structuring ➤ Draft refinement, coding and data interpretation 2. Claude ➤ Long-document and thesis analysis ➤ PDF reading and manuscript feedback ➤ Academic writing support 3. Perplexity AI ➤ Literature exploration ➤ Source-backed answers ➤ Recent research and topic scoping 4. Elicit ➤ Literature reviews ➤ Research data extraction ➤ Evidence synthesis tables 5. Consensus ➤ Evidence-based academic searches ➤ Answers from peer-reviewed studies ➤ Exploring scientific consensus 6. SciSpace ➤ Understanding complex papers ➤ PDF interaction ➤ Explaining research methods and findings 7. ResearchRabbit ➤ Discovering related papers ➤ Citation networks ➤ Mapping authors and research connections 8. Litmaps ➤ Visual literature mapping ➤ Tracking research developments ➤ Identifying overlooked studies 9. scite ➤ Analysing citation contexts ➤ Identifying supporting or contrasting evidence ➤ Evaluating research claims 10. NotebookLM ➤ Organising research documents ➤ Source-grounded summaries ➤ Research notes and study guides 💡 A word of caution: AI is a research assistant, not a substitute for scholarly judgement. Always verify references, validate findings, assess evidence critically, and maintain academic integrity. The real value of AI lies not in using more tools, but in using the right tools intelligently. Which AI tool has made the biggest difference to your research? #AcademicResearch #AIinResearch #PhDResearch #ResearchMethodology #HigherEducation #JGU # ODS
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 13, 3:38 AM
|
It's important to understand that the Open Source Initiative (OSI) never worked to define open source (maybe a bit with AI), but only to protect the "Open Source Definition" — both are incompatible. They missed decades of debates regarding the meaning of open source beyond software.
- 2006: in a critics of Creative Commons Non-Commercial/derivative clauses, the Definition of Free Cultural works was suggested. In order to guarantee freedom they mention the need to access to source files. [https://lnkd.in/ddHgzjAA]
- 2007: writing of a research article "Defining Open Source" by Russ Nelson, former ephemere OSI director (in 2005), with a dedicated "beyond the Definition" mentionning that "The concept is applicable to anything which has separable design elements." [https://lnkd.in/dBJK3h23]
- 2014: A github employee, Ben Balter (in interaction with Karl Fogel), while working on the glossary wrote the article "Open source, not just software anymore" and extended the notion to cover other kind of editable resources. The definition of the main open software platform is not software centric. « @benbalter The internet has noticed that you tried to define “open source” », but the organisation that supposedly define it didn't. [https://lnkd.in/dH_WCPed]
- 2017: Launch of the journal of Open Source Education (JOSE) section, an "an affiliate of the Open Source Inititative". In their about section (that can be find from first availble archived version) they explain the notion of "open-source educational materials". « "Open-source" implies that there are source files that are converted and rendered into a final learner-presentable form. » [https://lnkd.in/dz9a_CAy]
- 2021: paper "Open Source Educational Resources" to distinguish OER with available source files, open source being theorized explictely beyond software, echoing (JOSE) position. [https://lnkd.in/dHCE-_Ji]
- 2023: I asked the OSI directly by email around "open source image", a PNG with available svg file. An OSI staff told me "If you provide the source for the image so that I can modify it and it uses an OSI compliant license, then yes, I would say it's an open source image. What constitutes Open Source or not is very clear now for software, but for other artifacts, that might not be so clear.". They may acknowledge open source beyond software, they don't consider working on it.
- 2026: 6 Month of wikipedia page reoriented toward open source resources, my research paper in front of the place. The silence again. Even had a meeting with the OSI director when I published my paper, not really engaging with the reasoning just saying management of source files with other resources is different (waiting more details on it). [https://lnkd.in/eJQfjcFH]
If this organisation was really looking to understand open source, they probably wouldn't have missed all of this.
The open source community follow a blind authority with convictions ❤️
Erratum: Some coma of the OSD changed to accomodate some licences
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 13, 3:22 AM
|
As #Route66 marks its 100th anniversary, the Kansas City Fed’s Byways Report explores how tourism can serve as an economic development tool for rural communities.
Discover how communities can turn the place and stories that make them unique into opportunities for local growth.
Take the scenic route to rural prosperity: https://bit.ly/4kGE6Qs
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 13, 3:07 AM
|
|
Scooped by
Gilbert C FAURE
November 12, 6:02 AM
|
I applaud the courage in this commentary about the state of academic publishing in our field!! AI is not the problem; we are, as put eloquently by Mike Schmierbach:
"The current state of academic publishing means that in order for an individual to reap personal rewards, they must act in a way that damages the field as a whole. By incentivizing number of papers above all else, we have created the necessary conditions for the downfall of academic publishing."
I invite other journal editors and academic leaders to join this conversation so we can fix it!
https://lnkd.in/eFyVdpAz | 56 comments on LinkedIn
|