ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS is a division of KROTOASA RESEARCH INTENSIVE INSTITUTE (KRII), which refers to all Alkebulan communities and Diaspora Slave Descendants who lost their claims to land through colonialism and slavery, also communities with deep historical indigenous ties to the lands, natural resourses and environment, who maintain unique cultures, traditional practices and self-governance,. Alkebulan is considered the oldest and indigenous name for the continent of Africa, translating to "Mother of Mankind" or "Garden of Eden". Used by ancient Moors, Nubians, and Ethiopians, it predates the European-imposed name "Africa" and represents a push to reclaim pre-colonial African identity and history.
Alkebulan Indigeon also points to the rich diversity of Africa's original inhabitants, whose traditional lives and rights are central to understanding the continent's complex history and ongoing social dynamics. These are groups of people native to a specific region, people who lived here before colonist arrived.
Indigenous People like the San and Khoekhoe population both carrying mtDNA +100 000 years in Southern Africa are recognised indigenous peoples by the United Nations and UNDRIP., These two groups chose different lifestyles as hunters and herders but after colonialsm many Khoekhoe populations became hunters due to dispossesion and Genoicide by European and Bantu Settlers. Bantu Settlers was named by the Khoekhoe people as "Xhosas" and adopting the cultures and rituals of the KhoeKhoe population, Bantu's are distinct from the majority African populations who migrated and lost their historic continuity of their culture, tribes, indigenous livestyles, territories and surrounding natural resources.
Political Participation: Indigenous People lack political representation and participation, economic marginlization and poverty, lack of access to social services, discrimination, and protection of rights.
Alkebulan's marginalization in global politics and economics stems from a mix of historical legacies of colonialism, global politics and global economic structures that favor commodity exports, leading to asymmetrical trade, capital flight, and limited industrialization. Key factors include dependence on external powers, poor infrastructure, illicit financial flows, and structural disadvantages within global trade rules, despite rich resources.
Alkebulan's revolution of sweeping transformation, primarily the anti-colonial independence movements (Decolonisation of Africa 1950 -1970s), the anti-colonial restistance, the political revolution, the economic and social revolutions, the labour revolutions with key drivers and goals of self-determination by ending foreign control and achieving political independence and economic independence by moving from exporting raw materials to manufacturing in areas where extraction taking place.
Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management: An International Journal
The purpose of this paper is to explore Indigenous Works’ efforts to facilitate Indigenous-led research that is responsive to the socio-economic needs, values and traditions of Indigenous communities.,This paper is grounded in an Indigenous research paradigm that is facilitated by Indigenous-led community-based participatory action research (PAR) methodology informed by the Two Row Wampum and Two-Eyed Seeing framework to bridge Indigenous science and knowledge systems with western ones.
The findings point to the need for greater focus on how Indigenous and western knowledge may be aligned within the methodological content domain while tackling a wide array of Indigenous research goals that involve non-Indigenous allies.,This paper addresses the need to develop insights and understandings into how to develop a safe, ethical space for Indigenous-led trans-disciplinary and multi-community collaborative research partnerships that contribute to community self-governance and well-being.
This paper explores the integration of holistic knowledge systems with Western scientific perspectives through the concept of Two-Eyed Seeing (TES). By examining philosophical underpinnings of TES, particularly through the lens of Wilfrid Sellars' synoptic view, the paper highlights the potential for creating a more comprehensive understanding through the concept of Two-Eyed Seeing with epistemic insight. The Synoptic Transfer Framework (STF) as a Western educational variant of TES inspired by Sellars’ philosophy is introduced. TES, as conceptualized by Indigenous Elders, and the Western STF both advocate for a multi-perspective approach to the world, where the scientific and holistic images complement rather than compete with each other. The paper also addresses the chances and challenges of applying TES in educational contexts, particularly in Education for Sustainable Development (ESD), identifying common pitfalls such as the naturalistic and the moralistic fallacy. Furthermore, it argues for the importance of educational frameworks that incorporate TES to foster culturally responsive and inclusive science curricula. The study underscores the relevance of TES and STF in addressing sustainability issues, emphasizing the sentient persons approach and the normative perspective in both. The braid metaphor is used to illustrate the continuous, dynamic interaction between perspectives rooted in factual evidence and societal values to ensure a sustainable future for humanity.
In the face of the environmental crises of our time, and in recognition of the enduring wisdom inherent in Indigenous ways of living, the National Science Foundation (NSF) has recently established the Center for Braiding Indigenous Knowledges and Science (CBIKS) (University of Massachusetts, 2023; Little Bear, 2000). These practices are part of a rich oral tradition that embodies their reciprocal connections to the Earth (Little Bear, 2000). CBIKS aims to explore the effectiveness of integrating the expertise of Indigenous Elders and custodians of Indigenous ways of living in Mother Earth, and the technical expertise of scientists and engineers. The project uses the strategies of “braiding”, “bridging” and "Two-Eyed Seeing" to bring together diverse perspectives and methodologies, while ensuring that each retains its unique characteristics.
The metaphor of “braiding” scientific knowledge and Indigenous wisdom comes from Indigenous peoples (Dion, 2009). When committed Indigenous people receive a Western message (however braided), the Indigenous person invariably divides it into four pieces in order to address the brain, heart, body, and soul (Little Bear, personal communication); some of which are engaged holistically, but not necessarily equally. A Western person needs to be conscious about communicating in all four channels.
However, the basic conviction of this article is that, despite the fundamental differences in how Indigenous and Western cultures approach understanding reality, there is a shared human impulse at their core: the quest to make sense of the world and to ensure survival and well-being within it.
In this perspective article, as researchers of science education who have worked on questions of cultural border crossing - also in Western cultural contexts - for many years, we would like to point out that Wilfrid Sellars’ concept of the synoptic view (Sellars, 1962), particularly as elaborated recently by Esfeld (2020), might provide a philosophical background for addressing epistemic and cultural differences, building a bridge from Western culture to TES. Beyond any syntactic problems, there seems to be a deep kinship between these two approaches to ‘knowing one's way around’. We would also like to introduce the Synoptic Transfer Framework inspired by Sellars’ synoptic view and point out that this framework helps to argue why Two-Eyed Seeing may be an important approach to issues of sustainability, particularly Education for Sustainable Development (ESD), and how it can help to avoid common fallacies in this context.
It is a particular concern especially of one of the authors (GA) that, given the diversity of humans, those who identify as originally Western, modified by experiences with an Indigenous culture, do not fit the pure Western way of making sense of their world. Such a transformation along a continuum by a strongly Western scientist is enhanced through a mentored cultural immersion program. The reverse applies to Indigenous Elders learning enough science to braid with a scientific culture. That is a key challenge for endeavors like CBIKS.
1.2. Two-Eyed Seeing
The term ‘Two-Eyed Seeing’ (TES) was coined by Mi'kmaw Elders Albert and Murdena Marshall from the Eskasoni First Nation in Nova Scotia, Canada. It emphasizes a unique dual approach: integrating Indigenous wisdom and Western science in a way that respects the distinctiveness of each while fostering collaboration and understanding. The historical roots of TES are embedded in Mi'kmaq culture, language, and spiritual traditions. Building on their insight, Elders Albert and Murdena Marshall articulated TES. In 2004, TES gained academic prominence through its inclusion in an Integrative Science research program supported by the Canada Research Chair in Integrative Science. This initiative sought to address environmental and ecological challenges by weaving Indigenous knowledge systems, particularly their relational and spiritual dimensions, with Western scientific methodologies. By 2014, TES was formally incorporated into the Canadian Institutes of Health Research's (CIHR) five-year strategic plan for Indigenous health, signaling its broader applicability beyond environmental science to health research (Roher et al., 2021).
Aikenhead and Michell (2011) summarized what each eye might process when engaged in TES. Indigenous perspectives are deeply anchored in their respective cultures. Indigenous people tend to emphasize a profound connection with Mother Earth, viewed as mysterious and constantly changing (Little Bear, 2000). This worldview integrates the physical and metaphysical realms, suggesting a monistic approach where all elements of reality are interconnected and interdependent. The Indigenous understanding of nature is not just about the environment but encompasses a broader, holistic view of the world that includes spiritual, social, and cultural dimensions and sense of place.
The Western scientific perspective might typically focus on universal theoretical insight, empirical analysis, categorization, and a dichotomous separation between humans and nature. This implies that Western scientific perspectives tend to dissect and analyze the world in parts, sometimes neglecting the interconnectedness and interdependence central to Indigenous worldviews (ibid.).
TES emphasizes the importance of integrating the strengths of multiple knowledge systems—most notably, Indigenous and Western scientific perspectives—to foster a richer understanding of the world. At its core, this concept encourages co-learning and the respectful weaving of diverse worldviews while maintaining their distinctiveness. Co-learning in this context involves mutual respect and active engagement between diverse worldviews. For instance, scientists might collaborate with Indigenous Elders to understand local ecological systems, combining scientific methods with generations of lived experience and oral traditions. 'Weaving' reflects this partnership, where each perspective retains its integrity but contributes to a shared understanding. The metaphor of TES conveys the act of learning to see from one eye with the strengths of Indigenous knowledges and ways of knowing, and from the other eye with the strengths of Western knowledges and ways of knowing, and learning to use both these eyes together for the benefit of all (Bartlett et al., 2012).
Roher et al. (2021) translate "Etuaptmumk", the Indigenous term for TES, as “the gift of multiple perspectives.” They assert that in this translation the door may be opened to non-Indigenous interpretations of TES, and to “extend it beyond Indigenous and non-Indigenous perspectives” (p. 7/22). They explain that this flexibility is one of the strengths of TES, allowing ”the guiding principles to contribute to different projects in different and customized ways” (p. 3/22).
The back-translation of “Etuaptmumk” into “Two-Eyed Seeing” points to the inherent syntactic problem of cultural border crossing described above. One cannot speak of two eyes in Western languages without inherently suggesting a dichotomy. From this perspective, an approach to monistic versions of TES in a Western context will always be misguided. However, once this is acknowledged, it becomes clear that Western culture is not as monolithic as is sometimes suggested in the TES literature, but offers a treasure of concepts and syntax that can be used to build bridges, for instance, by expressing oneself using a continuum between two extremes, rather than a dichotomy.
1.3. Wilfrid Sellars’ synoptic view
Wilfrid Sellars (1912–1989) was a prominent American philosopher who sought to integrate various philosophical perspectives into a cohesive understanding of human knowledge and reality. Central to his philosophy is the concept of the "synoptic view," which aims to reconcile the "manifest image"—the world as perceived through human sense impression—with the "scientific image"—the world as described by scientific theories and evidence (see below).
Sellars introduced the distinction between these two images to address the apparent conflicts between common-sense understanding and scientific explanations. Historically, Sellars' work emerged during a period when analytic philosophy was grappling with the implications of scientific advancements for traditional philosophical questions. His synoptic view sought to bridge the gap between the rich, qualitative aspects of human experience and the quantitative, often abstract descriptions provided by science. By advocating for a unified perspective that acknowledges the validity and limitations of both images, Sellars aimed to provide a more comprehensive framework for understanding reality.
In contemporary philosophy, Sellars' synoptic view remains relevant as it addresses ongoing debates about the relationship between science and human experience. His insistence on the importance of integrating diverse perspectives continues to influence discussions in epistemology, philosophy of mind, and metaphysics, encouraging philosophers to seek a balanced understanding that honors both empirical evidence and the complexities of subjective experience (deVries, 2021).
As in Indigenous TES, the basic idea of Sellars’ stereoscopic view is that the world ‘as it is’ does not reveal itself to us directly but is seen through two perspectives: a scientific eye and a holistic eye. This results in two images of the world — the scientific image and the manifest image. Both images are necessary for a broad understanding of the world, each complementing the other by addressing different perspectives.
Sellars suggests that this complementarity arises not merely from differences in how knowledge is acquired (epistemology) but from deeper differences in what is considered to exist (ontology). The scientific image consists of matter in motion primarily characterized by their relative position to each other. The purpose and strength of the scientific image is to define these relative positions and predict their change. It typically reduces complex phenomena to the arrangement of their simplest, most fundamental ontological primitives, often at the atomic or subatomic level. For example, when studying a river, the scientific image reduces the complex phenomenon of a flowing water body to its simplest components. At the atomic level, the water in the river is understood as a collection of H₂O molecules, composed of hydrogen and oxygen atoms.
The manifest image is the result of a perspective that focuses on the qualitative, normative, and social dimensions of human life. It can be understood as the way humans perceive and interpret the world based on everyday experiences, social norms, and personal values. It views sentient persons as ontologically primitive, meaning that individuals and their perceptions are fundamental to understanding our world. The resulting image is based on perceptual holism and emphasizes normativity, referring to the network of rights, obligations, and social constructs governing human relations — aspects that the scientific image's ontology of matter in motion is not rich enough to fully capture or explain. For example, in the manifest image, a river is not merely a collection of molecules or a system of physical processes—it is a multifaceted presence that holds cultural, emotional, and symbolic significance. Humans may have rights to enjoy the river as a place of recreation, such as fishing, kayaking, or simply enjoying its beauty, and obligations, for example, to protect the river's flow and water quality to ensure it continues to support ecosystems, wildlife, and human communities dependent on.
Thus, while the scientific image provides crucial insights into the workings of the physical world, it must be integrated with the manifest image to achieve a fuller understanding of human existence. This integration recognizes that while scientific knowledge can inform our understanding of what is physically predictable or probable, it does not encompass the totality of human experience, particularly aspects related to personal identity, agency, and normative considerations. By maintaining both the scientific and the manifest image, we acknowledge the value of scientific explanations in understanding the physical universe while affirming the importance of personal sense perceptions, qualities, and norms in shaping our understanding of the world and ourselves. Sellars speaks of a fusion of the two images, but we suggest that the term "braid" is more appropriate because it symbolizes an ongoing process of multiple switches between the two perspectives.
While both Indigenous Two-Eyed Seeing and Wilfrid Sellars’ stereoscopic view aim to integrate diverse perspectives for a more comprehensive understanding, they differ in many aspects. However, both approaches seem to embody some essence of TES, enriching each other in a mutual relationship of benefit. Indigenous wisdom may be conceived as a vivid variant of Sellars’ manifest image, illustrating its appearance, particularly in terms of spirituality and holism, highlighting its indispensability alongside the scientific image. Furthermore, the Indigenous approach underscores the complementary relationship between the manifest and scientific images, rather than advocating a fusion of the two.
In contrast, though Sellars' philosophy is different in its articulation, it may be viewed as an ontological framework for TES. It highlights the sentient person-orientation of Indigenous wisdom, focusing on the qualitative, normative, and social dimensions of human life and communities, versus the matter in motion-orientation of the scientific image, which emphasizes empirical analysis and reductionist methodologies. Sellars’ stereoscopic view also suggests a perceptual holism of the Indigenous image compared to the position-reductionism of the scientific image. Sentient persons are considered ontologically primitive in the manifest image, which may also characterize Indigenous sapience. In this sense, Indigenous wisdom may be seen as a rich example of what Sellars called commonsense philosophies.
1.4. Two-Eyed Seeing with epistemic insight
One of the main challenges to generalizing TES to non-Indigenous approaches seems to be that Indigenous TES always takes the Indigenous perspective as the counterpart to the scientific image. In this context, Michie et al. (2023) distinguish three types of braiding. They consider contrasting the Indigenous perspective to the scientific perspective as the simplest form of inclusion. Here, Indigenous knowledge is included with limited regard for its context, and this approach is often criticized as stereotypical, tokenistic, and a caricature of reality, representing a superficial and fragmentary understanding of Indigenous knowledge.
As a next step, these authors propose the Two-Ways/Two-Eyed Seeing approach, which compares Indigenous knowledge with Western scientific interpretations, presenting two potentially conflicting ways of knowing. This approach aims to bridge cultures more effectively than the tokenistic Indigenous perspective but risks being comparative and polarizing rather than fostering a true understanding of how each knowledge system comprehends a particular topic.
To overcome this, these authors suggest that the TES approach with epistemic insight should be considered, where the two ways of knowing are viewed as complementary. Epistemic insight, sometimes referred to as “knowledge about knowledge (Billingsley et al., 2018)” includes the context of the knowledge and the ways of understanding it. This approach typically involves comparing localized Indigenous explanations with universal Western science, exploring how the two worldviews can complement each other. Importantly, as Michie et al. point out, this method requires a deep understanding of both cultural and Western scientific knowledge, building on relationships through the sharing of knowledge and mutual understanding.
This third approach, TES with epistemic insight, is suitable for generalization. Indeed, we argue that the Indigenous perspective can, in principle, be replaced by other perspectives that are conceived as complementary to the standard scientific perspective. The term 'holistic' then signifies this complementary role, as the scientific perspective is indeed reductionist in a non-pejorative, atomistic sense, as it eventually reduces all phenomena to suitable spatial arrangements of matter in motion (Esfeld, 2020).
Sellars’ synoptic view can be understood as a framework of TES with epistemic insight in the following way:
•
The framework contains two “eyes,” representing two visions of the world. The first eye stands for a kind of non-scientific holistic perception of the world. The second eye is the scientific eye.
•
The two visions result in two images of the world: the manifest image and the scientific image. The two images are complementary on an ontological level, i.e., on the level of what exists.
•
The epistemic differences between knowledge in the manifest image and the scientific image are explained by the two different ontological contexts. Knowledge in the manifest image is intuition-based sapient knowledge about sentient persons, condensed in commonsense or perennial philosophy. The essence of the findings from the scientific process is distilled into the body of scientific theory and knowledge.
From this point of view, in Western scientific and philosophical literature, many concepts support a dichotomous view of the world for 'finding one's way around' (Sellars, 1962) and thus may be candidates for TES with epistemic insight. Here we think, for example, of the theory of Person-Thing Orientation (Kuhn and Wolter, 2022) and Dual-Process Theories (Evans, 2019). This is not meant to imply conversely that all such concepts are identical. On the contrary, the important question of how they relate to each other and to TES seems to open a wide field of future research.
2. Educational applications
2.1. Two-Eyed Seeing in Indigenous education
Indigenous TES has been frequently used in educational settings to develop inclusive, culturally responsive science curricula in Indigenous contexts. It helps create teaching materials and curriculum content that include Indigenous perspectives alongside Western science, fostering a richer and more inclusive educational experience (Michie et al., 2023; Sam et al., 2022). In particular, Michie et al. (2023) focus on integrating TES into educational curricula in Australia and Canada, emphasizing practical applications in developing teaching materials that include Indigenous perspectives alongside Western science. Cirkony et al., 2023 have adapted the TES framework specifically for science education through the development of the Two-Eyed Seeing for Science Education (TESSE) framework. This adaptation integrates the 5Es inquiry approach — Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, and Evaluate — promoting an inquiry-based learning process, and the 8 Aboriginal Ways of Learning — Indigenous teaching and learning practices including storytelling, learning maps, non-verbal learning, symbols and images, land connections, non-linear thinking, deconstruction/reconstruction, and community connections — to create a culturally responsive teaching and learning environment.
2.2. The synoptic transfer framework in Western science education
An educational approach inspired by Sellars' synoptic view has been elaborated in the context of Science|Environment|Health (S|E|H), a new science pedagogy developed during the last decade in a special interest group of the European Science Education Research Association ESERA (Zeyer and Dillon, 2019). The basic concern of this pedagogy is to establish a genuine transdisciplinary dialogue between science education, environmental education, and health education from research and practice and thus to exploit a win-win situation that has not yet been productive enough. Based on results in a participatory action research setting with student science teachers (Zeyer, 2024), the Synoptic Transfer Framework (STF) was elaborated collaboratively to address the complexities of S|E|H pedagogy (Zeyer et al., 2023). In the context of these efforts, the concept of transfer has become important. Transfer, in the realms of S|E|H, is about effectively disseminating and applying scientific knowledge across these fields to ensure that education is not only interdisciplinary but also relevant and applicable to lifeworld situations. This involves ensuring that the knowledge generated through educational or interdisciplinary research studies is put into a context where it can serve societal and practical needs. In this understanding, transfer is not merely a unidirectional transmission of knowledge; it also includes participation and co-construction to empower people to make informed decisions in everyday life. The Synoptic Transfer Framework (STF) represents the braiding of the two Sellarian images by a double way of transfer (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1.. The Synoptic Transfer Framework ('Two-Eyed Seeing'). Explanation in the text. Adapted from Zeyer (2024).
In the process of development, the term of manifest image was replaced by “lifeworld image”, because it was better understandable and underlined the role of personal experience and sensual perception in this image. We speak now from a family of lifeworld images, as well as a family of scientific images, in order to acknowledge the postmodern transformation societal discourse has undergone since the times of Sellars’ philosophical work. In the same way the term of commonsense philosophy or perennial philosophy was replaced by the term of reference narratives, in order to embrace today's variety and diversity of sense making. Still, the basic idea of this approach is that when replacing Indigenous wisdom by reference narratives about sentient persons living in a Western culture, this remains a TES approach with epistemic insight.
2.3. A comparison of Two-Eyed Seeing and the Synoptic Transfer Framework
Indigenous educational approaches of TES, such as those described by Michie et al. (2023) and Cirkony et al. (2023), are naturally focused on incorporating the Indigenous perspective into the classroom. Indeed, studies of TES in Indigenous learning contexts have shown significant benefits in improving student achievement and motivation (Onwu and Mufundirwa, 2020). It provides a more holistic understanding of environmental and health changes (Abu et al., 2020). Indigenous versions of TES can address pedagogical challenges, reduce binary perspectives, and create safe learning spaces for students, making it a valuable tool for indigenizing scientific disciplines (Moorman et al., 2021). ‘Indigenizing scientific disciplines’ involves integrating Indigenous knowledge, epistemologies, and methodologies into scientific research and education. It recognizes the value of traditional ecological knowledge and Indigenous ways of knowing (Tsosie and Claw, 2020) and challenges the dominance of Western modern science (Moko-Painting et al., 2023).
Such an approach has been formulated particularly clear and inspiring in what is referred to as the C4-R4 philosophy of Indigenous Two-Eyed Seeing. C4 represents Co-learning, Co-designing, Co-creating, and Co-sharing, while R4 emphasizes building Good Relationships grounded in Respect, Responsibility, Reciprocity, and an equal foundation for collaboration (Hogue and Provost, 2023).
On the other hand, the strength of the STF is that it operationalizes the educational process into sequential switches of two well defined perspectives in a circular way, aiming at a reflective equilibrium between the scientific and the lifeworld image. Inspired by the synoptic view it emphasizes the integration of both perspectives as complementary aspects of ‘knowing one's way around’. It avoids attempting to 'Indigenize' science, also when Western, place-based, and community-rooted lifeworld contexts are included within a broader interpretation of the term. On the contrary, in the developmental process mentioned above, the S|E|H group used the dichotomy for identifying critical educational hotspots, where a dichotomous distinction between scientific and manifest image are crucial. It provides four educational hotspots, each of these equally important, i.e. none is prioritized over the others in terms of significance or sequence. In Fig. 1, this is indicated by omitting numbers when referring to the hotspots and calling the two transfers explanatory and interpretative. In Fig. 1, exemplifying questions are also provided for each hotspot.
The educational hotspot ENG (Engagement Contexts) focuses on the explanatory transfer of knowledge from the lifeworld image to the scientific image. The aim is to engage target groups by exploring their existing worldviews and using familiar contexts to introduce and explain scientific concepts. In this hotspot, educators can also explore how current, relatable contexts can be used as entry points and how new contexts can be created to attract attention.
The educational hotspot ISC (Scientific Integrity) focuses also on the explanatory transfer from the lifeworld image to the scientific image, but it prioritizes the integrity of scientific knowledge. This hotspot examines the key scientific concepts that should be communicated to target groups and explores how these ideas can be communicated accurately. The aim is to assess how well target groups understand the science presented to them and to identify common misconceptions that need to be addressed.
The educational hotspot APL (Scientific Application) examines how well target groups understand and apply scientific knowledge, i.e., the interpretative transfer from the scientific image to the lifeworld image. The focus here is on assessing whether the target group uses scientific information correctly and effectively in everyday contexts. Educators examine the cognitive understanding of scientific ideas and assess whether communities apply scientific knowledge in their understanding of lifeworld situations.
The educational hotspot SNR (Narrative Shaping) also examines the interpretative transfer of knowledge from the scientific image to the manifest image, with a focus on the manifest image as a context for interpreting and applying scientific knowledge. This hotspot explores how learners' intuition-based, everyday reference narratives are shaped by their interpretation and use of scientific concepts. Educators may also investigate whether this process results in key narratives that were intended by their intervention.
2.3. Two common fallacies
An important educational insight that can be framed by the dichotomous approach, and may well be important for both Indigenous and Western versions of TES, is the identification of two dangers in transfer situations. The first danger is that a dichotomous understanding of TES may inadvertently prioritize one perspective—often the scientific image—over the other, undermining the balance and mutual respect essential to TES. Indeed, many Western scientific dualities tend to exaggerate the importance of the scientific image over that of the manifest image. This is probably most famously seen in the context of dual-process theories, where default interventionist versions have clearly prevailed over parallel processing models (Evans and Stanovich, 2013). Sellars criticizes approaches that attempt to subsume all knowledge under the scientific image, suggesting that reducing ethical or philosophical claims to scientific facts alone can lead to a misunderstanding of the different roles these images play in our understanding of the world. Esfeld (2020) recalls here the “naturalistic fallacy”. He discusses how the error of assuming that science can dictate norms for both society and individuals originated with Enlightenment thinkers such as La Mettrie and later influenced Marxism (p. Viii of the introduction). An example of the naturalistic fallacy in ESD would be assuming that a scientific explanation of ecosystems directly implies how humans ought to interact with nature.
There is a converse danger of a monistic approach, the danger of misunderstanding the scientific image as simply an extension of the manifest image. Sellars warns against the temptation to see the scientific image as merely a refined version of the manifest image, emphasizing that the scientific image is not an extension but a rival image that purports to be complete in itself. “The fact that every theoretical image is a construction on a foundation provided by the manifest image and in this methodological sense presupposes the manifest image makes it tempting to suppose that the manifest image is prior in a substantive sense…” (8 p. 10/20). This second pitfall is sometimes called the moralistic fallacy, i.e., the conceptual opposite of the naturalistic fallacy. It occurs when one infers “what is” directly from “what should be (Davis, 1978).” An example of the moralistic fallacy may be the assumption that integrating sustainability into business strategies, such as through the Sustainability Balanced Scorecard (SBSC), inherently leads to meaningful corporate contributions to sustainability (Hahn and Figge, 2018).
3. Two-Eyed Seeing and STF in Education for Sustainable Development (ESD)
3.1. S|E|H and ESD
As has been said above, the STF has been developed in the context of the (S|E|H pedagogy. It draws on a nuanced understanding of sustainability as it has been defined for example in (Guidotti, 2015), as a state which limits the downside risk of disruption and future scarcity and protects the benefits that one generation enjoys while allowing future generations to reuse or harvest at least as much resources as current generations. Such definitions underscore a multidimensional and long-term perspective of sustainability, which inherently supports the aims of ESD. The connection to existing frameworks in science and ESD is made explicit by situating the S|E|H framework alongside comparable approaches such as One Health (Lerner and Berg, 2017), Planetary Health ( Whitmee et al., 2015), and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (United Nations General Assembly, 2015).
3.2. Perspectives for curricula in ESD
Within these approaches, TES can help to emphasize the need for interdisciplinary collaboration and reinforce the notion that curricula in ESD should be explicitly concerned with both factual knowledge and the cultivation of a holistic, value-laden understanding of rights and obligations towards the world (Heuckmann and Zeyer, 2022). The Indigenous C4-R4 philosophy as described above can provide here an important perspective on how facts and values can be integrated on equal terms into such curricula.
Western thinkers like Bruno Latour underscore this perspective by highlighting how Indigenous wisdom prioritizes interconnectedness, challenges the Western dichotomy of nature and culture, and recognizes the agency of non-human entities. By shifting humanity's role from dominance to relational co-existence within the biosphere, this approach aligns with the concept of Gaia as a living, responsive entity. Integrating Indigenous perspectives fosters sustainable and ethical navigation of ecological crises, offering a transformative understanding of humanity's place in the planetary ecosystem (Latour, 2017). Endeavors like the CBIKS mentioned in the introduction set their hope into these aspects of Indigenous wisdom. Indigenous cultures, with their deep connection to sustainable living, are presented as an essential component in averting future tipping points in climate change (Aikenhead, 2024).
Such views and hopes, from the point of Sellars’ philosophy, interpret Indigenous wisdom in terms of the manifest image, which prioritizes sentient and normative understanding, rather than with the scientific image. From a monistic point of view, this may be questionable and even misleading. However, according to Sellars, characteristic for the manifest image is exactly the holistic perception through the lens of sentient people in communities and the consecutive relationship to the world in terms of rights and obligations. Esfeld (2020) elaborates on the manifest image's normativity by explaining that it begins with persons as ontologically primary and then conceptualizes everything else in analogy to persons, varying in degrees of similarity—for instance, cats are closer to persons than trees, and even inorganic matter retains a faint connection to personhood. In this way, any manifest image, if Indigenous or Western, in TES provides a value perspective for ESD. In Indigenous TES, this is indeed a highly concerned aspect (Hatcher et al., 2009), and it is often used to argue that TES could be a royal road to ESD (Guzmán et al., 2021).
At this point, the STF firmly requests that TES should not forget the scientific perspective and its indispensable role for ESD. As Fig. 1 shows, for STF the double transfer of explanation and interpretation between the person-oriented, intuition-based and value-laden lifeworld image, and the things-oriented, evidence-based and factual scientific image is central. In this way, the STF establishes solid grounds for creating ESD curricula and teaching practice that take both images into account (Heuckmann and Zeyer, 2022). It also provides a concrete guide for classroom activities (Zeyer, 2024). The four educational hotspots describe critical aspects of the teaching process, and the exemplifying questions in Fig 1. may scaffold instructors and teachers towards successful planning, implementing and evaluation of lessons.
In this way, and importantly, the STF also supports a clear rejection of fake news and science denial, thus promoting trust in science. If we are to take the concept of TES seriously, it means always using both eyes, not just one — be it the holistic eye or the scientific eye. This seems to be a challenge that will be decisive in ensuring a sustainable future for humanity.
Declaration of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process
During the preparation of this work the first author used DeepL and ChatGPT in order to improve the language. Literature search was supported by elicit. After using this tools/services, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Albert Zeyer: Writing – original draft, Conceptualization. Glen Aikenhead: Writing – original draft, Conceptualization.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Bringing Indigenous ways of knowing to neuroscience
University of B.C. researchers are working with Indigenous scholars and communities to bring Indigenous perspectives into brain science.
Feb 6, 2025
Dr. Melissa Perreault (centre left) and Dr. Judy Illes discuss Two Eyed Seeing in neuroscience with an audience at the Bill Reid Gallery of Northwest Coast Art in Vancouver during Brain Awareness Week in 2023. (Photo courtesy of Dr. Melissa Perreault)
University of B.C. researchers are working with Indigenous scholars and communities to bring Indigenous perspectives into brain science—hoping to open up new pathways for treating mental health and neurological conditions that are centered on collaboration, respect and self-determination.
In a paper published this week in Nature, Dr. Judy Illes, professor of neurology in UBC’s faculty of medicine and director of Neuroethics Canada, and Dr. Melissa Perreault, a member of the Métis Nation and an associate professor at the University of Guelph, explore approaches to integrating Indigenous knowledge with Western approaches in neuroscience. The paper is a product of the Crosscultural Working Group of the International Brain Initiative. It was also informed, in part, by the work of former UBC graduate student, Louise Harding.
We caught up with Dr. Perreault (MP), Dr. Illes (JI) and Harding (LH) to learn about how— and why— brain researchers are integrating Indigenous ways of knowing into their work.
Why is an Indigenous understanding of brain health important for neuroscience?
MP: In many Indigenous communities, our mental health is understood as being interconnected with other aspects of our being— with our spirituality and physical wellbeing, for example. If a medical doctor is treating an Indigenous person for a mental health disorder, they need to recognize how the spirituality and cultural traditions of Indigenous people can help in their healing process. It’s about thinking about the person as a whole and, Indigeneity aside, we should be doing that for everybody.
JI: The more knowledge we can learn about different ways of understanding, the better care we can offer people when they are affected by neurological and mental health issues.
LH: If we’re not working with Indigenous peoples in the context of colonization, of racism, of healing, of self-determination, then there’s a huge risk of perpetuating and doing additional harm to people. We can’t think about serving Indigenous populations without first considering how the way we’re doing research could be oppressive.
What does incorporating Indigenous ways of knowing into scientific research look like?
JI: When it comes to conducting research, this means engaging communities, with their values and knowledge, as full partners throughout the entire process. One example is the collaborative research we embarked on with the Tahltan First Nation in northern B.C., where a number of families have a unique genetic mutation associated with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease. Through long-term collaboration, we brought together our combined knowledges and understandings about the disease and the needs of the community, where intergenerational fractures occurred because of the history of the Residential School system. This also supported the co-creation of resources that are culturally relevant and meaningful to Tahltan communities.
MP: Communities really need to have a voice in the questions that are being asked in research. It’s important because Western views and Indigenous views—which themselves vary from community to community, culture to culture—might be completely different. For example, depending on the community, they may see a disability completely differently than we see it. That word may not even exist, or they might see it as a gift. It’s about listening and relationship-building, rather than coming in thinking that there is a problem that needs to be fixed.
A visual representation of Two-Eyed Seeing by Rudi Louis Taylor-Bragge.
In Canada, we have a term, Two-Eyed Seeing, which was coined by Mi’kmaw Elders Albert and Murdena Marshall. It means learning to see with the strengths of both Indigenous and Western knowledges and ways of knowing.
How can neuroscience better integrate a Two-Eyed Seeing approach?
JI: The key is partnership that embraces dual and multiple perspectives. It’s about honouring, respecting and appreciating different knowledge systems, definitions, values and priorities, and applying them authentically in research and care.
MP: It’s one thing to think about bringing Indigenous knowledge into neuroscience, but how do we even accomplish that when there are virtually no neuroscientists that are Indigenous? I think capacity-building is critical. There needs to be more support for building environments that Indigenous people can see themselves in.
LH: In working group discussions with Indigenous people for my master’s thesis, something that really came through was that Indigenous Peoples need the same level of access to new and high-tech treatment options as anyone else in the world. Everyone should have the opportunity to self-determine whether and how they integrate their Indigenous healing approaches with Western healing approaches. It’s up to Indigenous people, as individuals, to decide.
Interview language(s): English, French
Read the full interview with Dr. Perreault, Dr. Illes and Louise Harding in Pathways—the UBC faculty of medicine’s digital magazine.
Mobilizing for Socioeconomic Well-Being: Exploring Spaces for Indigenous Engagement within the Economy
Multimedia storytelling with Indigenous youth and post-secondary students: Youth co-creation of a vision for sustainable development as a strategy toward reconciliation (with Kim Matheson)
Mapping Indigenous Economic Venture Responses to the Covid-19 Crisis
Rebuilding Dispersed Indigenous Communities: Creating a Joint Urban Reserve (with Kim Matheson)
BC First Nation Housing Shortfall Assessment
Indigenous Works and Sprott School of Business: Collaboration for Reconciliation in Action (with Kelly Lendsay and Craig Hall, Indigenous Works)
Advancing Intersectional Analyses of Entrepreneurship: A critical exploration of entrepreneurial activity in Canada and the United Kingdom (with Vadim Grinevich, University of Wolverhampton)
Two-Eyed Seeing, Grand Challenges and Wicked Problems: Indigenous-led Responses to the Neoliberal Restructuring of Cities and Urban Centres (with Peter Moroz, University of Regina)
Recent Publications
Henriques, I., Colbourne, R., Peredo, A. M., & Anderson, R. (2020). Relational and Social Aspects of Indigenous Entrepreneurship: The Hupacasath Case. In R. Colbourne & R. Anderson (Eds.), Indigenous Wellbeing and Enterprise: Self-Determination and Sustainable Economic Development. London, United Kingdom: Routledge.
Mika, J. P., Colbourne, R., & Almeida, S. (2020). Responsible Management: An Indigenous Perspective. In O. Laasch, R. Suddaby, E. Freeman, & D. Jamali (Eds.), The Research Handbook of Responsible Management. Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar.
Colbourne, R., Moroz, P., Lendsay, K., Hall, C., & Anderson, R. (2019). Indigenous Works and Two Eyed Seeing: Mapping the Case for Indigenous-led Research. Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management (Special Issue: Indigenous Knowledge, Priorities and Processes in Qualitative Research).
Colbourne, R., & Anderson, R. (2019). Economic Wellbeing of the Indigenous People in the Asia Pacific Region: The Role of Entrepreneurship in Sustainable Development. In C. Fleming, M. Manning, & A. Miller (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Indigenous Wellbeing (pp. 184-193). London, United Kingdom: Routledge Publishing.
Colbourne, R. (2017). Indigenous Entrepreneurship and Hybrid Ventures. In A. Corbett & J. Katz (Eds.), Perspectives and Approaches to Blended Value Entrepreneurship: Advances in Entrepreneurship, Firm Emergence and Growth (Vol. 19). Bingley, United Kingdom: Emerald Publishing.
Colbourne, R. (2017). An understanding of Native American entrepreneurship. Small Enterprise Research, 24(1), 49-61. doi:10.1080/13215906.2017.1289856
Share: Twitter, Facebook Short URL: https://carleton.ca/indigenous-enterprise/?p=154
Over the past sixty years, we’ve witnessed a phenomenal growth in the number of new psychiatric illnesses. The American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, first published in 1952, originally listed about 100 categories of illness.
By the year 2000, that number had tripled. We’ve become accustomed to hearing in the news about “learning disabilities,” “ADHD,” “Asperger’s syndrome,” and other conditions that were virtually unheard of fifty years ago. A report from the National Institute of Mental Health indicates that about one-fourth of the American population suffers from a psychiatric disorder in any given year, and an article in the Archives of General Psychology suggested that over the course of a lifetime, approximately half of all people may suffer from a mental illness sometime during their lives. Add to this the observation by Harvard Medical School professor John Ratey that many people have milder versions of psychiatric conditions (he calls them “shadow syndromes”), and we come to the conclusion that when all is said and done, nearly every individual in the country may have a psychiatric illness to one degree or another.
This epidemic in the growth of mental illness suggests that there is a crisis in the making. How much longer can we continue to add new psychiatric illnesses to the list, before it becomes apparent that we have moved too far in pathologizing a sizeable chunk of the American populace? There is, however, an answer to this crisis. The concept of neurodiversity provides a paradigm shift in how we think about mental functioning. Instead of regarding large portions of the American public as suffering from deficit, disease, or dysfunction in their mental processing, neurodiversity suggests that we instead speak about differences in cognitive functioning. Just as we talk about differences in bio-diversity and cultural diversity, we need to start using the same kind of thinking in talking about brain differences. We don’t pathologize a calla lily for not having petals (e.g. petal deficit disorder), nor do we diagnose an individual with brown skin as suffering from a “pigmentation dysfunction.” Similarly, we ought not to pathologize individuals who have different ways of thinking, relating, attending, and learning
The word neurodiversity was coined in the late 1990’s by two individuals: journalist Harvey Blume, and autism advocate Judy Singer. Blume wrote in the September 1, 1998 issue of The Atlantic: “Neurodiversity may be every bit as crucial for the human race as biodiversity is for life in general. Who can say what form of wiring will prove best at any given moment? Cybernetics and computer culture, for example, may favor a somewhat autistic cast of mind.” Singer in a 1999 book chapter titled: “Why Can’t You Be Normal For Once in Your Life?” observed: “For me, the key significance of the ‘Autistic Spectrum’ lies in its call for and anticipation of a politics of Neurological Diversity, or what I want to call ‘Neurodiversity.’ The ‘Neurologically Different’ represent a new addition to the familiar political categories of class/gender/race and will augment the insights of the social model of disability.”The Wikepedia defines neurodiversity as: “…an idea which asserts that atypical (neurodivergent) neurological development is a normal human difference that is to be recognized and respected as any other human variation.” The online Double-Tongued Dictionary characterizes neurodiversity as: “the whole of human mental or psychological neurological structures or behaviors, seen as not necessarily problematic, but as alternate, acceptable forms of human biology.”
By using the concept of neurodiversity to account for individual neurological differences, we create a discourse whereby labeled people may be seen in terms of their strengths as well as their weaknesses. Dyslexics, for example, can be seen in terms of their visual thinking ability and entrepreneurial strengths. People with ADHD can be regarded as possessing a penchant for novel learning situations.. Individuals along the autistic spectrum can be looked at in terms of their facility with systems such computer programming or mathematical computation. Those with bipolar disorder can be appreciated for their creative pursuits in the arts. While proponents of the concept of neurodiversity do not shirk from the realization that people with dyslexia, ADHD, autism, bipolar disorder, and other psychiatric conditions, often suffer great hardships, and that those hardships require a lot of hard work to overcome, they realize that until an individual’s strengths have been recognized, celebrated, and worked with, nothing substantial can be accomplished with regard to their difficulties.
Eight Principles of Neurodiversity:
The Human Brain Works More Like an Ecosystem than a Machine. Up until now, the most often used metaphor to refer to the brain has been a computer (or some other type of machine). However, the human brain isn’t hardware or software, it’s wetware. The characterization of the brain as an unbelievably intricate network of ecosystems is much closer to the truth than that of a complex machine. We should devise a discourse that better reflects this new conception of the brain.
Human Brains Exist Along Continuums of Competence. Rather than regarding disability categories as discrete entities, it’s more appropriate to speak of spectrums or continuums of competence. Recent research, for example, indicates that dyslexia is part of a spectrum that includes normal reading ability. Similarly, we use terms such as autistic spectrum disorders, to suggest that there are different gradations of social ability that merge ultimately with normal behavior. This suggests that we are all somewhere along continuums related to literacy, sociability, attention, learning, and other cognitive abilities, and thus all of us are connected to each other, rather than being separated into “normal” and “those having disabilities.
Human Competence is Defined by the Values of the Culture to Which You Belong. Categories of disability often deeply reflect the values of a culture. Dyslexia, for example, is based upon the social value that everyone be able to read. One hundred and fifty years ago, this wasn’t the case, and dyslexia was unknown. Similarly, autism may reflect the cultural value that suggests that it’s better to be in relationship than to be alone. We should recognize that diagnostic categories are not purely scientifically-based but reflect these deeper social biases.
Whether You are Regarded As Disabled or Gifted Depends Largely on When and Where You Were Born. In other times and other places, there have been different disability/ability diagnoses depending upon cultural values. In pre-Civil War America, for example, there was a disorder called “drapetomania” said to afflict blacks. Its meaning was “an obsession with the urge to flee one’s slave masters” and reflected its racist roots. In India, today, there are people who would be labeled in the West as schizophrenic, but who are regarded as holy beings by the local population. We should not regard diagnostic labels as absolute and set in stone, but think, instead, of their existence relative to a particular social setting.
Success in Life is Based on Adapting One’s Brain to the Needs of the Surrounding Environment. Despite Principles 3 and 4, however, it’s true that we don’t live in other places or times, consequently the immediate need is to adapt to our current contemporary culture. This means that a dyslexic person needs to learn how to read, an autistic individual needs to learn how to relate to others socially, a schizophrenic individual needs to think more rationally and so forth. Tools such as psychoactive medication or intensive remediation programs can help achieve these aims.
Success in Life Also Depends on Modifying Your Surrounding Environment to Fit the Needs of Your Unique Brain (Niche Construction). We shouldn’t focus all of our attention on making a neurodiverse person adapt to the environment in which they find themselves, which is a little like making a round peg fit in a square hole. We should also devise ways of helping an individual change their surrounding environment to fit the needs of their unique brain.
Niche Construction Includes Career and Lifestyle Choices, Assistive Technologies, Human Resources, and Other Life-Enhancing Strategies Tailored to the Specific Needs of a Neurodiverse Individual. There are many tools, resources, and strategies for altering the environment so that it it meshes with the needs of a neurodiverse brain. For example, a person with ADHD, can find a career that involves novelty and movement, use an iPhone to help with organizing his day, and hire a coach to assist him with developing better social skills.
Positive Niche Construction Directly Modifies the Brain, Which in Turn Enhances its Ability to Adapt to the Environment. In experiments with mice, neuroscientists have shown that a more enriching environment results in a more complex network of neuronal connections in the brain. This more complex brain, in turn, has an easier time adapting to the needs of the surrounding environment.
In conclusion, the potential is great for the neurodiversity movement to create significant social transformation. Already, for example, there are software firms that have recognized the special programming gifts of certain people with Asperger’s syndrome and others on the autistic spectrum, and have hired significant numbers of them to improve their productivity. Similarly, more people are understanding that ADHD brings with it special abilities as well as difficulties, and that appropriate career selection can be an important part of determining whether one will be successful or unsuccessful in a particular job. It is hoped that the concept of neurodiversity will help combat “ableism” or the belief that people who are “abnormal” should be discriminated against, condescended to, and ultimately kept out of the basic affairs of society. Neurodiversity brings with it a sense of hope, that all individuals, regardless of how they read, think, feel, socialize, or attend, will be recognized for their gifts, and accorded the same rights and privileges as any other human being.
The initial, draft proposal release in August 2003 had the stated objectives of boosting South Africa's economic growth rate from 2.7 percent to 5 percent annually, developing a system of tax incentives and penalties to encourage black ownership of companies and businesses and to raise R224-billion to ensure 26 percent black ownership of all equity on the JSE Securities Exchange by 2014.
The tax incentives, on a sliding scale, would be calculated based on a company's rating on a governmental empowerment scorecard and was intended to provide a competitive advantage to racially transformed companies. This was interpreted as a "carrot" to balance the "stick" of legislated transformation requirements and associated penalties.
The initial response from some economist and trade unions was described as "downright cool".
The initiative was subsequently criticised for being too limited, for potentially reducing the tax base and for effectively proposing that a black majority government fund the transformation of white-owned businesses.
A 2004 proposal by the South African Revenue Service for tax breaks to companies that give shares to a broad base of employees was considered to be linked to the Brenthurst Initiative.
Ever since my grandfather first arrived in this country in 1902 the Oppenheimer family has been deeply committed to South Africa and its future.
Unlike many of his contemporaries who flocked to the gold and diamond fields to make their fortunes and then leave, my grandfather saw himself as a South African from the day he arrived. Both as Mayor of Kimberley and as that city’s representative in parliament he set a theme of public service to our country which established a family tradition. Nearly 50 years ago my father, when he was still a Member of Parliament, prepared a memorandum on constitutional reform in South Africa.
Although couched in the language of the day, his proposals called for direct African representation in the Senate and were nothing short of revolutionary at a time when the apartheid government was busily disenfranchising all people of colour. Nevertheless, the proposals embodied his passionate, life-long belief in a common South African nationhood shared by all its people. In a speech in 1954, he said that “the safety, stature and moral progress of our country depend on building up a sense of common loyalty, of common patriotism; of a willingness, if necessary to make common sacrifices: of a conviction of common nationhood in which all South Africans can share.”
It gave him great joy when forty years later that sense of common nationhood finally found expression in South Africa’s re-birth as a free, self-confident, vibrant, multi-racial democracy.
Every true South African who puts the future of the country above his or her own interests accepts, however, that while the country’s political landscape has been transformed, the transformation of the economic landscape is far from complete. Much more needs to be done to ensure that the majority population sees and feels that it has a prominent share in the country’s economic life and wealth and the benefits which a common nationhood should bring.
Initiatives have helped to kick-start that process and I am sure that in a few years the face of South Africa’s business and industrial landscape will indeed look very different to today. The question that now faces us is not who the main figures in that landscape will be, but how big will be the landscape itself and how many people will feel the benefit of that transformation?
South Africa’s economic advancement depends critically on investment, both direct and indirect, and on the sentiment that drives it. As proud South Africans, my son Jonathan and I have, like many people, been troubled by the nervousness over South Africa’s risk and reward ratios which seems to inhibit investment decisions – both local and from abroad.
It set us thinking as to how Government initiatives to accelerate black economic empowerment could, instead of further inhibiting investment, become a tool to strengthen investor confidence and so expand the South African economy for the benefit of all its people.
This concept excited us sufficiently to approach Robin Buchanan, Cyrus Jilla and Alan Bird of Bain & Company in London and ask them to join us in exploring the idea further. The answers produced by this informal think-tank were sufficiently interesting and promising to present to President Mbeki. He in turn was so engaged by our argument that he agreed the time was now right to launch a broader debate on this issue.
On the cricket field I know there have to be winners and losers, but in business I am excited by win-win scenarios. Recent Government initiatives have begun the process of transformation. They are the foundations of the new South African building. How many rooms that building will have, whether it will be large enough for all, or too small for many, will depend on how we proceed beyond this first step to change the composition of South Africa’s boardrooms and the employment profile of its companies.
Without vigorous growth powered by enthusiastic investment, there is a risk that the advantages could be limited to a newly privileged few, rather than spreading the benefits across society, alleviating poverty and eliminating the historic disadvantages of the many.
If instead transformation were combined with a package of other measures designed to attract and encourage investors to commit themselves and their funds wholeheartedly to the future of this country, the outcome could be very different. But – and this is critical – all incentives must be tied inextricably to each company’s commitment to transformation and this commitment must be measured not by goals, but by achievement through the application of simple, precise and transparent standards.
This is what I mean by a win-win scenario: South Africa will, if it follows this path, be seen as committed to expanding and supporting investment. Investors will be seen as committed to and supporting transformation.
Expanding investment will ensure that transformation will empower not just a privileged few, but an ever-expanding element of South Africa’s formerly disadvantaged majority. And an energised and vigorous economy, with business and political leaders sharing a real enthusiasm and commitment to transformation, could become an example to the world.
In 1994 South Africa’s political transformation was just such an example. Over the last decade South Africans have shown that they have the imagination, the will and the leadership to rise above the world’s more dismal expectations and to devise new solutions to old problems. I believe we can do it again and provide – as we had the courage to do in 1994 – unique solutions to unique problems
Although I am excited by the proposals in this document, I am not so naïve as to believe that they will or can resolve all South Africa’s problems. There is no magic bullet. But I remain convinced that they could begin to tilt investment decisions away from an exaggerated risk awareness and towards a real interest in the rewards South Africa has to offer. I accept and indeed hope that the ideas we have put forward will stimulate many questions and improvements on the answers we have suggested. We will not find the answers, however, if we do not debate them.
It was my father’s belief that South Africa would only realise its true destiny when everyone could engage fully and irrespective of race in every strand and level of its economic life. In putting forward these ideas for your consideration, Jonathan and I hope we are taking his legacy forward and closer to the day when his hopes are fulfilled; when everyone will enjoy his or her fair share not only of the existing cake, but in an ever-expanding and vigorous economy with more than enough for all.
In 2007, the ANC held its 52nd National Conference, where the party’s new leadership shredded an economic plan that could have accelerated South Africa’s already strong economic growth.
The decisions made at this conference set South Africa on a path of decline that it is only now starting to recover from.
This is according to former Finance Minister Trevor Manuel, who recently gave a presentation at the National Democratic Revolution (NDR) Seminar in Johannesburg.
Manuel is considered one of the best finance ministers in South Africa’s history, having served in that role from 1996 to 2009 under Presidents Nelson Mandela, Thabo Mbeki, and Kgalema Motlanthe.
When Manuel took office in 1996, the state’s finances and South Africa’s economy were struggling, faced with high debt service costs, volatile inflation, and stagnant growth.
However, Manuel took these challenges in his stride and, during his tenure as Finance Minister, oversaw South Africa’s longest period of continuous economic growth.
By imposing strict deficit reduction, Manuel significantly reduced the state’s budget deficit and delivered the country’s first and only national budget surpluses in 2006 and 2007.
This was done under a macroeconomic strategy called the Growth, Employment, and Redistribution (GEAR) policy, which Manuel spearheaded.
He was also instrumental in formalising South Africa’s inflation-targeting framework, having worked with the Reserve Bank to develop a target to anchor price stability and improve predictability for investors.
Manuel was also a key player in establishing the South African Revenue Service as an autonomous administrative body, and the taxman became a world-class authority during his tenure.
He was also the person who introduced the Medium-Term Expenditure Framework, sometimes called the “mini budget”, in South Africa to improve the state’s transparency about its fiscal health.
Manuel’s efforts could clearly be seen in South Africa’s economic data over that period. By 2006, the country’s economy was expanding at its fastest pace in two decades, and South Africa had just recorded its first-ever budget surplus.
However, all of Manuel’s efforts started to unravel after the ANC’s fateful meeting in Polokwane in 2007.
The meeting that changed South Africa’s trajectory for the worse
Former President Jacob Zuma
At the NDR Seminar, Manuel explained that, having seen the success of the GEAR strategy, the Treasury decided to take things up a notch.
“One of the things we did was to say that this growth of 4.5% is reasonably good. It’s sustainable. But we need to do better,” he said.
“So, we assembled a number of economists from across the world to talk to us, to model with us, to show us what was possible.”
The results of these discussions were then combined into a new economic strategy, called the Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative in South Africa (AsgiSA).
According to Manuel, this initiative had the potential to accelerate South Africa’s growth beyond 4.5% and create a way for these proceeds to be shared very differently than how they had been at that point.
The framework was launched in 2006 under Mbeki’s Presidency, with the goal of halving poverty and unemployment by 2014.
AsgiSA was aimed at addressing six specific binding constraints on South Africa’s economy: infrastructure capacity, skills shortages, currency volatility, spatial constraints, regulatory burdens, and state capacity.
If the strategy had gone to plan, it would have boosted South Africa’s economic growth to at least 6%.
However, it did not go to plan. Manuel explained that, at the ANC’s 52nd annual national conference, AsgiSA was “shredded”.
“AsgiSA was actually abandoned because of a set of circumstances that occurred in December of 2007 in a place called Polokwane,” he said.
“That AsgiSA was shredded. ‘We’re not going to go there. It’s not going to help us. We need to do something else’.”
“We shot ourselves in both our feet and destroyed the potential of the economy.”
This 2007 conference marked a pivotal moment for South Africa because it was also the meeting at which Jacob Zuma was elected ANC President.
The next year, in 2008, the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) happened, which Manuel said gave the country an excuse.
Now, the state could conveniently point to the GFC for South Africa’s problems, rather than blaming itself for taking apart the country’s capacity to build and develop.
“By 2008, the rule book had been shredded, and everything was going to be born there, novel,” Manuel said.
“You can go through that early period – there were ANC weekly documents after the NEC meetings, and the nature of the discussions was reported on online.”
“There was a lot of stuff going down, and you could keep track of developments – but after that moment, nada.”
Under Zuma’s Presidency, South Africa experienced a period of economic collapse, characterised by stagnant growth, State Capture, and the hollowing out of state institutions.
By 2016, South Africa’s economy was growing by a meagre 0.7%, and it has averaged around 1% growth over the past decade – a far cry from the more than 4% experienced during Manuel’s tenure.
Manuel pointed to the moment of AsgiSA’s abandonment as the beginning of a broader move away from cultivating an overarching, disciplined economic and social programme in South Africa.
He emphasised that this loss of strategy has hindered South Africa’s ability to achieve a truly capable and developmental state.
Chapter 4: Progress In Changing Society: Shifting Domestic Balance Of Forces
35. How far then have we moved up the road towards a national democratic society? In what ways has the balance of forces changed since the advent of democracy?
36. Our starting point in this regard is that revolutionary democrats shall not find social relations of the new order ripe and ready for harvesting at the point of transfer of power. A national democratic society is a conscious construct, dependent on conscious action by politically advanced sections of society.
37. A mere decade-and-a-few years after the democratic transition in 1994, the liberation movement can claim great progress towards a democratic and prosperous society.
38. But we are not satisfied with the current order of things. Over the years of democratic rule, we have become even more keenly aware that we should not be blinded by form: the fact that blacks are, for the first time, occupying the highest political offices in the land; as distinct from content: the reality that colonial relations in some centres of power, especially the economy, remain largely unchanged.
39. It is possible in national liberation processes to mark time, tinkering with social relations under the veneer of formal political democracy. Yet as with all historical phenomena, to mark time is to move in reverse. The consequence is either gradual regression, with a self-satisfied elite unsighted; or a rapid collapse of social cohesion under the weight of poverty and lawlessness.
40. The political transition of the early 1990s was premised on a few basic principles: firstly, that the outcome of the negotiations process would not be a compromise between apartheid and democracy but would as rapidly as possible result in democratic majority rule. Secondly, the Interim Constitution prescribed the need for a multi-party government at national and provincial levels. Thirdly, it was considered prudent to ensure orderly management of the exit of senior functionaries of the apartheid state and gradual law-based transformation of state institutions such as the army, the police, intelligence agencies and the judiciary. Fourthly, changes in local government were introduced in stages, with fully-fledged democracy being achieved only in the year 2000.
41. During negotiations, representatives of the previous order sought an outcome that would leave many elements of the apartheid system intact. On the other hand, the liberation movement sued for democratic majority rule as understood throughout the world. The transitional measures were seen by the liberation movement as necessary compromises to ensure the broadest possible legitimacy of the new order and to use the advances made as a beach-head to a truly united, non-racial, non-sexist, democratic and prosperous society.
42. At the point of change of government in 1994, the state was manned at all senior levels by apartheid functionaries; the economy was almost totally in the hands of whites; many of the parties sought constitutional outcomes that would guarantee white privilege; and networks of apartheid and extreme right-wing destabilisation remained burrowed, or had multiple links, within the state. These and other realities impacted on the manner in which the programmes of change were introduced.
43. How has the situation changed since then?
44. South Africa enjoys a system of vibrant multi-party democracy, with a progressive Bill of Rights which recognises political, socio-economic and environmental rights and obligations, and with separation of powers among the executive, the judiciary and the legislatures. Beyond the formal processes of regular elections and legislatures, various forms of legislated and other forums ensure popular participation.
45. The Constitution enjoys the respect of the overwhelming majority of the population, and it is seen as the canvass upon which South Africans’ freedom of spirit can find expression. While some within the ranks of those who were privileged under apartheid may harbour ill-feelings towards the process of change and evince racist attitudes, virtually all of them accept that their aims and views should be pursued within the constitutional and legal framework. While pockets of ethnic chauvinism and regionalism still manifest themselves and may take new forms under the new conditions, our society has made massive progress in ensuring a common national identity.
46. We have started to transform state institutions through policy frameworks and practices that guide them as well as improvements in their racial and gender profiles. A state entity has emerged that enjoys such allegiance that only the most fanatical can dare frontally to challenge it. Yet, much more needs to be done further to transform state institutions, and consolidate their legitimacy in the eyes of society.
47. The ANC must continue to exercise maximum vigilance against forces which seek to subvert social transformation. Indeed, there are continuing attempts by forces connected to the old apartheid order and international reaction to undermine the state and to disorganise, weaken and destroy the liberation movement through clandestine means, including all kinds of manipulation within and outside its ranks. In addition, marginalisation and destitution inherited from apartheid and the kind of greed represented by organised crime do create fertile ground for lumpen elements whose actions can have counter-revolutionary implications.
48. The same applies to weaknesses on the part of government across all spheres progressively to fulfil its responsibilities to communities, including service provision and consultations, which can generate upheavals that may be taken advantage of by forces opposed to fundamental change. Further, weaknesses of organisation and political coherence within the ANC and its broad allies can open up space which can be exploited by counter-revolutionary forces.
49. Many short-comings remain in ensuring that all citizens are able in actual practice to exercise their rights; in the efficiency of the state; and in changing mindsets within various state institutions. However, as a broad canvass, the Constitution and the state system provide the requisite wherewithal to implement objectives of the NDR.
50. Since the advent of democracy, a new polity has emerged, with the liberation movement led by the ANC at its head. This movement has gradually mastered the science and art of electoral politics and grown in experience as the leading force in government. This has, however, been accompanied by a declining presence in the mass terrain.
51. The achievement of democracy has opened up critical space for organisations of civil society to flourish. This finds expression in the growth and activism particularly of the labour movement and some community-based and other non-governmental organisations dealing with generic or single-issue campaigns. However, this ‘social movement’ has manifested contradictory features under democracy. This is partly due to the haemorrhaging of experienced cadreship, and tendencies towards mechanical oppositionism in relation to government or towards an exclusive focus on narrow self-interest. The question of the role of progressive trade unionism within the state, in relation to broader issues of providing services to citizens, the fight against corruption and revolutionary transformation of the state itself has not been adequately addressed.
52. While a battery of legislation and programmes has been put in place to transform the socio-economic dynamics of South African society, the changes in this sphere illustrate the distance that still has to be traversed to achieve national democracy.
The removal of the glass ceiling of apartheid has created space for many Blacks to rise into the middle and upper strata of society. It is in these middle sectors where the greatest dynamism in income mobility is to be found. However, the improvement in Black and female ownership and control of wealth and access to management and many professions is still limited, with overall proportions which are inversely related to the country’s demographics. This is more starkly reflected in terms of land ownership. As such, while progressive forces have attained political power, economic power remains largely in the hands of the white minority.
Even more critically, trends do indicate a persistence of the poverty trap – a form of marginalized Second Economy community excluded form the advanced First Economy mainstream – afflicting mainly Black people, especially women.
Major improvements have been registered at the turn of the Second Decade of Freedom in terms of the economy’s rate of labour-absorption and generation of self-employment. But these have not matched the needs of society. At the same time, while the achievement of macroeconomic balances has released huge resources for social and economic expenditure by government, this has not translated into rates and quality of investment needed to deal with the legacy of apartheid.
Combined with this is the restructuring of the economy, which has resulted in higher levels of competitiveness and better access to world markets; but also in the ascendancy of the services sector which requires fewer, skilled jobs. A tendency has also developed in the period since 1994 for the informalisation of jobs, contracting out and utilisation of labour brokers affecting particular sectors of the economy. While the achievement of democracy has resulted in a better regime of workers’ rights, this tendency has undermined the quality of jobs, job security and union activism in the affected sectors.
The period since 1994 has also seen other macrosocial trends that include:
rapid rates of migration to areas with better economic potential, with resultant sprawls of informal settlements in the major cities and towns;
greater self-assertion by the youth in taking advantage of professions now opened up and opportunities in the arts and other areas; but also marginalisation of millions of young people who do not have the skills required by the economy;
better gender representation in the legislatures and other organs of state; but also slow progress in the private sector and serious manifestations of poverty and women abuse;
better advocacy and access in relation to the rights of people with disability, but a huge legacy of marginalisation; and
greater focus on the rights of children, but still unacceptable levels of child poverty and abuse.
The state has massively expanded access to welfare grants; and the social wage includes such elements for the poor as free and compulsory education, free health care, free basic services, and asset provision through the housing and land reform programmes. Steady progress has been made in the battle against crime. However, the reach of such programmes is still constrained by access to information, availability of resources and capacity of the state.
The gradual reduction in life expectancy at the turn of the 21st Century is a matter of great concern; and it is influenced mainly by the impact of HIV and AIDS. At the same time, we need to address the challenge of crime, particularly unique features such as random violence, disrespect for human life, as well as women and child abuse. These are in part a consequence of social conditions, gender stereotypes and negative value systems such as greed.
The legitimacy of the state system is reflected partly in the growing number of South Africans of all colours who view their national identity as the primary form of self-identification. In the middle rungs of the socio-economic ladder, there is much inter-racial acculturation especially among the youth. But the majority of South Africans still remain separated by a wide chasm of income, skills, assets, spatial settlement patterns and access to opportunities. The majority of the poor are disproportionately Black and female.
Combined with this chasm and high levels of inequality is a value system within society that encourages greed, crass materialism and conspicuous consumption. These are tendencies that go beyond the necessary spirit of entrepreneurship, ambition, daring, competition and material reward that are inherent to a market-based system and perhaps to human development in general. Related to this is the fact that the means of ideological discourse are dominated by forces with an outlook that is either ambivalent or hostile to principles of human solidarity. Among the consequences of all this are vacuous media discourse, corruption in state institutions and corporate greed reflected in outrageous executive packages, short-termism in the conduct of business and private sector corruption.
Overall, since 1994, the balance of forces has shifted in favour of the forces of change. It provides the basis for speedier implementation of programmes to build a truly democratic and prosperous society. The legal and policy scaffolding for this is essentially in place. Most of society wants this to happen. At least in public discourse, except for a tiny minority, those apprehensive about change express their concerns more in terms of pace and scale rather than substance.
The critical questions therefore are: is society mobilised for faster progress! Does the liberation movement have the cadreship able not only to withstand the pull of negative values but also to lead society along the road towards a caring nation that a national democratic society should be!
Chapter 5: Drivers Of Change: Motive Forces Of The National Democratic Revolution
Who then are the drivers of change?
The ANC seeks to mobilise all South Africans to contribute to the ongoing transformation of our country. In doing this, we strive to appeal to and foster a common sense of South Africanness and a shared responsibility for our common destiny among all citizens of South Africa, black and white.
Yet, any major historical process of social transformation has to be driven by a core of classes and strata that objectively stand to benefit from and have the capacity together to drive such change.
It should be emphasised, though, that the mere prospect of objective benefit does not necessarily translate into revolutionary consciousness and resolve to act in the collective interest. Nor does the fact of belonging to either side of the divide remove the possibility of individuals from these classes and strata aligning themselves with the antagonists.
It also stands to reason that the extent of receptiveness to ideas of change and commitment to take part in struggle would in broad terms depend on the role in the production process and the depth of subordination and exclusion. In other words, among the classes and strata suing for change, there will be concentric circles or a hierarchy of involvement.
Historically, the liberation movement characterised Africans in particular and Blacks in general as the motive forces of the NDR. These communities were, by law, defined outside of the political system except as servants of white minority domination. In class terms, they were made up of workers and the rural poor, the middle strata including small business operators, and real or aspirant capitalists.
The liberation movement defined the enemy, on the other hand, as the system of white minority domination with the white community being the beneficiaries and defenders of this system. These in turn were made up of workers, middle strata and capitalists. Monopoly capital was identified as the chief enemy of the NDR. It was also emphasised that apartheid was not in the long-term interest of the white community.
More than ten years into democracy, does this still apply? To answer this question we need to examine the strategic objectives of the NDR and changing socio-political dynamics under the new system.
As indicated earlier, the character of the NDR – in terms of the social contradictions that it seeks to resolve – remains the same. The progress made since the attainment of democracy is such that we are still some way from the ideal society of national democracy. The ownership and control of wealth and income, the poverty trap, access to opportunity and so on – are all in the main defined, as under apartheid, on the basis of race and gender.
As such, the central task in the current period is the eradication of the socio-economic legacy of apartheid; and this will remain so for many years to come. However, the establishment of a government based on the will of the people, progress in the transformation of the state, the codification of rights and implementation of progressive socio-economic programmes represent a major change in the socio-political environment.
Given all these factors, how then do we define the drivers of change today: which are the forces that the ANC relies on to achieve its objectives?
To the extent that the socio-economic legacy of apartheid continues to manifest in national terms, to that extent are Africans in particular and Blacks in general the motive forces of the NDR. Profound self-interest impels them to act in the collective interest to realise the strategic objectives of the NDR. They are the drivers of reconstruction and development. As in the past when they rose above the politics of race hatred, these communities do carry the responsibility of leading the process of nation-building and reconciliation too. Critical for them to play this role is the defence and consolidation of unity across ethnic and racial divides, to fight racism and tribalism whenever and wherever they rear their ugly head.
In class terms, these forces are made up of black workers: employed and unemployed, rural and urban. The early and extensive development of capitalism in South Africa led to the emergence of black workers as the majority in our society. They are located strategically at the heart of modern production and services. Because of and in addition to this, their sense of organisation and mobilisation locates them as the main motive force and the leader of the process of change.
Their tasks in this phase of the NDR include: advancing the struggle for quality jobs and job security; building class and national solidarity among all sectors of workers including causalised, informalised and unemployed workers; ensuring a strategic contribution by public sector workers to the transformation of the state and efficient provision of services to the population; directing the employment of institutional capital in which workers have a large stake towards developmental goals; and leading in the definition of a common vision and in implementing a common programme of action among all the motive forces and the nation as a whole. In addition to leading in mass struggles, the working class will continue to enjoy the confidence of the rest of the motive forces and advance its own interests if it is also able to wield the opportunities and instruments provided by democracy – both economic and political – to advance social transformation.
A significant part of the working class in our country are the rural poor, mostly unemployed, landless, engaged in self-employment through survivalist micro-entrepreneurial activity or farm-workers in insecure low-paying jobs. Land dispossession and marginalisation destroyed any semblance of an African peasantry in our country, reducing these rural areas into reserves for cheap labour. In addition to the strategic challenges that face workers in general, these rural masses face tasks that include: taking active part in defining and implementing strategies for rural development; enhancing the struggle for rural workers’ rights; advancing the land reform programme; and mobilising for the optimal utilisation of agricultural land and other activities in the agricultural value chain.
As part of the motive forces, the black middle strata constitute a critical resource of the NDR. They include the intelligentsia, small business operators and professionals. Besides their varied identification with either of the main classes, these strata – especially the intelligentsia – not only provide professional skills, but also are critical in the determination of culture and value systems. They are called upon to play an active role in the provision of a variety of services to the population; in fostering a culture of searching for new and better ways of doing things; and in promoting progressive intellectual discourse through the media, the arts and other platforms.
The achievement of democracy in 1994 has seen the dramatic, if still exceedingly limited, emergence of the black capitalist group. This group is in most respects a product of democratic change, a direct creation of the NDR. The continued advancement of the revolution, particularly the necessary de-racialisation of ownership and control of wealth and income, is in their objective interest. In this sense they are part of the motive forces, with great potential to play a critical role in changing the structure of the South African economy: developing national forces of production in line with the character of the national democratic society including an extensive manufacturing base, research and development, local economic development, job-creation, skills development as well as national and continental economic integration.
However, because their rise is dependent in part on co-operation with elements of established white capital, they are susceptible to co-option into serving its narrow interests – and thus developing into a comprador bourgeoisie. Because their advancement is dependent on a variety of interventions and, as with all private capital, on opportunities provided by the state, they are constantly tempted to use corrupt means to advance their personal interests – and thus developing into a parasitic bureaucratic bourgeoisie. The liberation movement must guard against and combat these tendencies.
What about the various classes and strata within the white community?
Virtually all South Africans pay allegiance to the Constitution. Increasing numbers, including among the whites, entertain a sense of collective belonging to South Africa. It can be argued that most in the white community have come to realise that, indeed, non-racial democracy is in their immediate and long-term interest. This, combined with the social dynamics within the middle strata and acculturation referred to earlier, brings to the fore the question whether merely by dint of being white, this community still can be defined as antagonists of NDR!
In terms of practical experiences especially in the private sector, public discourse and voting patterns, it seems that many in the white community still have to realise that the poverty and inequality spawned by apartheid are not in their long-term interest, and that black people are as capable as anyone else to lead and exercise authority in all spheres of life. This derives in part from historical socialisation based on the false ideology of racism, which needs continually to be combated.
But, unlike before, when antagonists across the apartheid divide were locked in mortal combat, engagement around issues of transformation in a democracy forms part of legitimate discourse and electoral politics. Those who continue to resist change within the constitutional framework are opponents in a democratic order. Their political and other organisations are legitimate expressions of a school of thought that should be challenged, but at the same time accepted as part of democratic engagement.
It behoves the liberation movement to persist in clarifying the long-term self-interest that the white community shares in ridding our society of the legacy of apartheid. Indeed, formal political democracy including the new human rights regime would be imperilled if conditions of abject poverty and massive inequality persist.
In this regard, the liberation movement must lead each of the classes and strata within the Black community in narrowing the racial chasm. This applies moreso to the working class which, by reaching out across the racial divide within this class, should be the lightning rod to the emergence of inclusive nationhood. But it also does apply in large measure to the middle strata especially the intelligentsia, and the capitalist class.
What about the place and role of monopoly capital? There are fundamental areas of divergence between the objectives and value systems of the ANC and those of monopoly capital. In particular, there is much in the nature and behaviour of private monopolies that has the effect of constraining higher rates of growth and skewing development. These include monopoly pricing and other forms of rent-seeking, selfish import parity pricing, barriers to entry in some industries and a value system based on greed and crass materialism.
The approach of the liberation movement to private capital, including monopoly capital, is informed by our understanding of the national democratic society as a system that encourages competition, promotes sustainable labour-absorbing activity, discourages rent-seeking in the form of super-profits arising from monopoly control and other selfish advantages and so on.
The relationship between the national democratic state and private capital in general is one of ‘unity and struggle’, co-operation and contestation. On the one hand, the democratic state has to create an environment conducive for private investments from which the investors can make reasonable returns, and through which employment and technological progress can be derived. On the other hand, through state-owned enterprises, effective regulation, taxation and other means, the state seeks to ensure redistribution of income, to direct investments into areas which will help national development, to play a central role in providing public goods and broadly to ensure social responsibility. The balance between ‘unity’ and ‘struggle’ will be dictated to by the strategic imperatives of the NDR.
As such, the democratic state should have the strategic capacity and the instruments to deal with these negative tendencies, while at the same time mobilising private capital in general to partner it in increasing rates of investment and sustainable job-creation.
Across all these class and national permutations are to be found women in their various capacities. As workers they bear the greatest burden of super-exploitation and poverty. As survivalist micro-entrepreneurs, they are called upon to provide use-values to working class communities under unbearable conditions. As middle strata and business-persons, they are compelled to hew their way through the jungle of male-dominated professions and environments. In the home, they carry the burden of nurturing families and are forced to reproduce relations of patriarchy. In challenging these anomalies along with progressive men, women form, in gender terms, the bedrock of the construction of a caring nation.
These then are the core, the real and the potential drivers of change in the National Democratic Revolution. Much clearer than before, the concentric circles of united action are taking shape, with Black workers at the core and Black communities broadly as the motive forces.
Unlike before, when white support for non-racial democracy and social transformation was an exception to the rule, large sections within this community accept at least the imperatives of the National Constitution. As such, tapering off towards the outer edges of the concentric circles of drivers of change is the balance of the nation’s majority – made up of all races – steadily forging a social compact of common interest.
Across these circles the intertwining of Black and white interests is taking shape, with the definitions of the past starting to fade. As these circles intertwine and the currents across them flow into one another, so will the objectives of the NDR be reaching maturity. Common interests will increasingly be forged across the racial divide within the various social classes and strata. And so, other defining issues in pursuit of other strategic objectives may become the paramount driving forces for continuing change.
Chapter 6: Organisational Leader Of Change: Character Of The African National Congress
Given the vision of a national democratic society and the motive forces of change, what should be the character of the movement to lead social transformation?
To carry out the NDR in the current phase requires a progressive national liberation movement which:
understands the interconnection between political and socio-economic challenges in our society;
leads the motive forces of the NDR in pursuing their common aspirations and ensuring that their sectoral interests are linked to the strategic objective;
masters the terrain of electoral contest, utilises political power to advance the objectives of the NDR and wields instruments of state in line with these ideals as reflected in the National Constitution;
organises and mobilises the motive forces and builds broader partnerships to drive the process of reconstruction and development, nation-building and reconciliation; and
conducts itself, both in its internal practices and in relation to society at large, in line with the ideals represented by the NDR and acts as a microcosm of the future.
The African National Congress is such a movement. Over the years, it led the struggle of the people of South Africa for the achievement of democracy. In turn, during successive elections since 1994, it has resoundingly been returned to office.
The primary task of the ANC remains the mobilisation of all the classes and strata that objectively stand to benefit from the cause of social change. The dictum that the people are their own liberators remains as relevant today as it was during the days of anti-apartheid struggle.
The dynamics within South African society, resulting in the concentric circles described earlier, impose on the ANC the responsibility more intensely to work among all sectors of the population and to ensure that they join the people’s contract to change South Africa for the better. This includes all the class forces from within the white community, each of which can and should make a contribution to the construction of a better society.
The vision that the ANC pursues is informed by the morality of caring and human solidarity. The kind of democracy it pursues leans towards the poor; and it recognises the leading role of the working class in the project of social transformation. Recognising the reality of unequal gender relations, and the fact that the majority of the poor are African women, the ANC pursues gender equality in all practical respects.
In this context, the ANC is a disciplined force of the left, organised to conduct consistent struggle in pursuit of a caring society in which the well-being of the poor receives focussed and consistent attention. In terms of current political discourse, what it seeks to put in place approximates, in many respects, a combination of the best elements of a developmental state and social democracy. In this regard, the ANC contrasts its own positions with those of:
national liberation struggles which stalled at the stage of formal political independence and achieved little in terms of changing colonial production relations and social conditions of the poor;
neo-liberalism which worships the market above all else and advocates rampant unregulated capitalism and a minimalist approach to the role of the state and the public sphere in general; and
ultra-leftism which advocates voluntaristic adventures including dangerous leaps towards a classless society ignoring the objective tasks in a national democratic revolution.
In order for it to exercise its vanguard role, the ANC puts a high premium on the involvement of its cadres in all centres of power. This includes the presence of ANC members and supporters in state institutions. It includes activism in the mass terrain of which structures of civil society are part. It includes the involvement of cadres in the intellectual and ideological terrain to help shape the value systems of society. This requires a cadre policy that encourages creativity in thought and in practice and eschews rigid dogma. In this regard, the ANC has a responsibility to promote progressive traditions within the intellectual community, including institutions such as universities and the media. Playing a vanguard role also means the presence of members and supporters of the ANC in business, the better to reshape production relations in line with the outlook of a national democratic society.
The activism of the ANC among the motive forces should be a responsibility of members and leaders alike, informed by a coherent cadre policy that takes into account career-pathing among its activists. And wherever they are to be found, ANC cadres should act as the custodians of the principles of fundamental social change; winning respect among their peers and society at large through their exemplary conduct. They must be informed by values of honesty, hard work, humility, service to the people and respect for the laws of the land.
As a multi-class mass movement, the ANC is required to master the science and art of crafting long- and short-term common platforms to ensure that all the motive forces pull in the same direction. We do acknowledge that, at times, the narrow self-interest of a particular class or stratum or group may not necessarily coincide with that of other motive forces. In some instances, as with the working class and the bourgeoisie, these interests may even be contradictory.
However, guided by the ideals of the NDR, the ANC has to ensure that these forces appreciate the common strategic interest. It should strive to manage ‘contradictions among the people’ in such a manner that they do not undermine the long-term goal of national democratic transformation. In attending to these issues, the ANC should remain steadfast to principle, and guard against attempts by any force to turn it into a hostage of narrow sectoral interest.
Our approach to all these responsibilities derives from the understanding that a national democratic society has to be systematically constructed. It is not found ready-made at the point of transfer of political power. Nor can it emerge spontaneously through the agency of the ‘hidden hand’ of the market. What this means is that members of the ANC should continually improve their capacity – both political and technical -to act as the most advanced elements of society.
As such, the ANC cannot conduct itself as an ordinary electoral party. It cannot behave like a shapeless jelly-fish with a political form that is fashioned hither and thither by the multiple contradictory forces of sea-waves. There should be clear value systems that attach to being a member and a leader of the ANC, informed by the strategic objectives that we pursue.
In essence, the ANC is faced with two options: either to act as a party of the present, an electoral machine blinded by short-term interest, satisfied with current social reality and merely giving stewardship to its sustenance. Or it can become a party of the future, using political power and harnessing the organisational and intellectual resources of society to attain the vision of a national democratic society.
This arises in even bolder relief given the new terrain in which we operate. In actual fact, the world of the ANC changed drastically at the point of the 1994 democratic breakthrough. On the one hand, a new critical instrument of struggle, state power, one of the prime prizes of resistance, was attained. On the other, this instrument of power and status can impact in negative ways on a revolutionary movement.
Many leaders and cadres of the movement are found in positions of massive influence in the executive, the legislatures and state institutions. By breaking the glass ceiling of apartheid, the liberation movement opened up enticing opportunities for its cadres in business and the professions. Even within the trade union movement and students’, youth, women’s and other mass democratic organisations, unprecedented opportunities for individual material gain have opened up. All this creates a problem of ‘social distance’ between these cadres of the movement and ordinary members and supporters, the majority of whom are working class and poor.
Political incumbency also presents a myriad of problems in the management of relations within the organisation. Patronage, arrogance of power, bureaucratic indifference, corruption and other ills arise, undermining the lofty core values of the organisation: to serve the people!
How the ANC negotiates this minefield will determine its future survival as a principled leader of the process of fundamental change, an organisation respected and cherished by the mass of the people for what it represents and how it conducts itself in actual practice. A number of principles need to be observed in dealing with this challenge.
Firstly, the critical importance of political power as an instrument to address the ills of colonialism needs to be fully appreciated. In this regard, politics and public service need to be treated as a calling with requisite moral status, in which any of the motive forces can take part, either as a profession or as time-bound service.
Secondly, the ANC should give strategic leadership to those of its cadres in institutions of government, through Conferences, Councils and Branch General Meetings. In this respect, it needs to act as the ultimate strategic ‘centre of power’ for its members.
Thirdly, in order to ensure that its strategic mandate is carried out, the ANC needs massively to strengthen its monitoring and evaluation capacity. This will ensure that cadres deployed in various capacities are able to improve their work in meeting set objectives. At the same time, these cadres should have sufficient space to exercise initiative within the strategic mandate rather than being subjected to micro-management.
Fourthly, systems of information-sharing within leadership structures and across the organisation should afford those outside of government sufficient data to make strategic interventions. In the same measure, all cadres should apply themselves seriously to governance issues, practically to add strategic value to the work of government.
Lastly, in its conduct in relation to the state, the ANC should be guided by its own principles, and act within the framework of the National Constitution and relevant legislation. In this regard, it should manage the state as an organ of the people as a whole rather than a party political instrument.
Within the ANC, the Women’s League (ANCWL) is tasked with the responsibility of helping the ANC to broaden its mass base, as it champions the aspirations of a section of our society which over the decades, has been oppressed and exploited as “a nation”, as a class and as women. It should continue to be the voice of ANC women members, but it should also be at the cutting edge of the Broad Women’s Movement, spearheading gender transformation and the advancement of a women’s agenda in all areas of social endeavour.
In a similar vein, the ANC Youth League (ANCYL) is a critical tool of South Africa’s youth in pursuit of a better life for all. It should continue to function as an organisational and political preparatory school of young activists of our movement, informed by our strategic and tactical positions. The organisational autonomy of the ANCYL always provides organisational vibrancy and the youthful political debate imperative to a revolutionary organisation. It should continually broaden its base and deepen its political and organisational strength. It must strive to galvanise, and place itself at the centre of, the broadest spectrum of youth organisations for reconstruction and development.
As part of the process of preserving its values and culture, while adapting them to concrete conditions in which it operates, the ANC places a high premium on the contribution that veterans of the struggle can make. In this regard, the Veterans’ League has a central role to play both by force of example and in practical organisational and ideological work within and without the ranks of the broad democratic movement.
Historically, the three streams of the national liberation struggle in our country – the revolutionary democratic, the socialist and the trade union movements – have found common cause in pursuit of the objectives of the NDR as commonly understood. This Tripartite Alliance, currently made up of the ANC, the South African Communist Party and the Congress of South African Trade Unions, is therefore not a matter of sentiment, but an organisational expression of the common purpose and unity in action that these forces share, and continue jointly to define and redefine in the course of social transformation. It is a strategic alliance aimed at eliminating the legacy of colonialism in its various manifestations, and not a coalition based on tactical considerations or the subjective mood of the moment. As a leader of the NDR, the ANC will continue to work for strategic unity among all components of this Alliance, in pursuit of a national democratic society.
In line with its responsibility to lead the motive forces of change, the ANC will continue to encourage the formation of, and to work within, progressive civil society: organisations of communities, students, youth, women, people with disability, traditional leaders, business and other non-governmental and community-based organisations. It will also continue to reach out to religious and other institutions to ensure common approaches to challenges of transformation. The ANC will conduct such mass work taking into account the dynamic changes taking place in the social structure and varied lifestyles of South African society.
The character and strength of the ANC must continue to reside in and derive from its mass base. As the leading force in government, the ANC should continually improve its capacity and skill to wield and transform the instruments of power.
The truth of spatial apartheid — ConCourt delivers a history lesson to DA
A landmark Constitutional Court ruling confirms that Cape Town’s government perpetuates spatial apartheid, urging immediate action or equitable housing distribution in the city.
Members of several housing rights movements, including Ndifuna Ukwazi, Intlungu yaseMatyotyombeni and Indibano Yabahlali, march from Hanover Street to Cape Town Civic Centre on Wednesday, 8 February 2022. (Photo: Tamsin Metelerkamp)
In October 2025, Cape Town mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis told Daily Maverick that he considered the term “spatial apartheid” a “kind of propaganda language that is no longer rooted in reality”. When a minor PR crisis ensued, he explained that the DA was not responsible for “perpetuating” the phenomenon. On Thursday, 2 July, in a historic judgment, nine judges of the Constitutional Court ruled unanimously that Hill-Lewis’s party was indeed responsible for its prolongation.
Handed down two days after a nationwide crisis that threatened to sink the country into a maelstrom of xenophobic and ethnic violence, the judgment represents the culmination of a decade-long battle waged on behalf of Cape Town’s marginalised and dispossessed.
As Justice Nonkosi Mhlantla, with the full support of the remaining eight judges on the Bench, noted in the second sentence of the opening paragraph:
“The submissions in these matters have highlighted the crucial distinction between merely distributing resources and ensuring that those resources are distributed in a manner that actively dismantles historical inequalities shaped by race and class along geographical lines.”
The judges were unanimous, in other words, that in enacting section 25 and section 26 of the Constitution, the Western Cape provincial government and the City of Cape Town had always been obligated to pay attention to location — and, specifically, that this obligation entailed the provision of affordable housing not just in the Cape Town CBD but in the upmarket, historically white suburb of Sea Point.
For a tight-knit group of activists and human rights lawyers, the ruling is a profound victory in their bitter and enduring conflict with Cape Town’s development agenda. Back in January 2016, when the Western Cape government — acting on the orders of the then premier, Helen Zille — announced the sale of the mothballed Tafelberg Remedial School to the Phyllis Jowell Jewish Day School for R135-million, the site of the struggle became these empty buildings on Sea Point’s Main Road.
The old Tafelberg School in Sea Point on 9 September 2025. (Photo: David Harrison)
To many Capetonians, the address was an obvious cypher for the city’s blatant imbalances. Why, the question was asked, did the DA government choose to sell the old Tafelberg school at a profit when the people that serviced Sea Point’s economy — the waiters, cleaners, nurses and childminders — were forced to commute for hours every day from the Cape Flats? Why not repurpose the empty buildings for affordable housing?
As it turned out, it was a question tailor-made for a court challenge, one that cut to the heart of South Africa’s post-apartheid promises.
In the original application brought before the Western Cape Division of the High Court in May 2017, the first applicant — and the deponent of the founding affidavit — was Thozama Angela Adonisi, a nurse at the Christiaan Barnard Memorial Hospital and the resident of a basement dwelling in a Sea Point block of flats.
Adonisi, as the court papers made clear, was at the time a member of the leadership committee of Reclaim the City, a voluntary social movement made up of working-class residents that had recently launched its campaign for affordable housing in “well-located areas”.
The movement, backed up by the trustees of housing activist group Ndifuna Ukwazi, successfully persuaded the court — in a judgment handed down on 31 August 2020 — that the sale of the old Tafelberg school was in breach of the Constitution. But less than three weeks later, on 18 September 2020, although Premier Alan Winde had stated in the same media release that he was “absolutely committed to achieving spatial redress” in the province, he explained why he was appealing against the judgment anyway.
Activists from Reclaim the City march on 8 February 2024 in support of releasing the Tafelberg site in Sea Point for social housing development. (Photo: Supplied / Ndifuna Ukwazi)
Fast-forward to 2024, which would witness two significant events in the unfolding saga. In April of that year, the Supreme Court of Appeal would find in favour of the provincial government. In June, at the Sheffield DocFest in the United Kingdom, the documentary film Mother City would make its international premiere, with Ndifuna Ukwazi and the Tafelberg case as its central pillar.
‘No place for old locals’
As articulated by the film’s co-creators, the acclaimed journalists Pearlie Joubert and Miki Redelinghuys, the spatial apartheid that had long characterised Cape Town was by this point inciting a minor insurrection. This new heat, the product of a development policy that foregrounded tourism and economic growth, was all there in Mother City’s strapline: “A daring urban revolution in a city breathtakingly beautiful and brutal.”
In September 2025, Daily Maverick would include all of these details in a feature entitled “Sea Point’s broken promises — no place for old locals,” where we would point out that it wasn’t only working-class Capetonians being kept out of the city’s central districts; it was now the middle-income earners too.
Cape Town's Sea Point gentrification - rising rates, fading community
September 29, 2025
The feature would lead to an in-depth interview with Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis, who in October 2025 would defend his vision for the city’s future.
It was our third question that caused all the trouble.
“As you no doubt know,” we said, “Mother City follows the fight for affordable housing in Cape Town’s ‘well-located’ areas, with social activists demanding that the people who service the tourist economy — from restaurant workers to hotel staff to cleaners — finally be granted housing close to their places of work. In essence, it is a film about spatial apartheid; about the fact that the City of Cape Town seems uninterested in addressing the phenomenon. What are your comments?”
Hill-Lewis, after dismissing Mother City as a “propaganda film” that “tries to provide a tacit endorsement for illegal land occupation,” went on to explain that he had “done more in the last three years to release land for social housing in well-located parts of the city than in the 10 years prior to that combined”. There were at that stage “about 12,000 [affordable housing] units at various stages of development,” he informed us.
Then he said this: “I’m not sure whether those adjectives are [Pearlie Joubert’s] or yours — when you say things like ‘spatial apartheid’ and ‘deliberate exclusion’ — but I think that’s just kind of propaganda language that is no longer rooted in reality.”
Leading affordable housing activist Nkosikhona Swartbooi speaks at a Reclaim the City Rally. (Photo: Supplied)
More than a month later, after the comments had sparked a minor but ongoing PR crisis, Hill-Lewis would insist through his personal assistant that he was “commenting on the narrative put forward by the activists and not dismissing the fact that the legacy of spatial apartheid exists.” In February of 2026, in a widely viewed on-stage interview with Dan Corder, he repeated the explanation.
“The question put to me [by Daily Maverick],” he responded to an audience member during the Q&A, “implied that we are perpetuating spatial apartheid. That notion, the notion that we have some active policy position to perpetuate spatial apartheid, I said is propaganda nonsense, and I stand by that. It would be completely insane to suggest that there is no such thing as the legacy of spatial apartheid.”
On 2 July, by every possible reading, nine judges of the Constitutional Court ruled unanimously that the Hill-Lewis-led City of Cape Town, aided and abetted by the Western Cape provincial government, had indeed been perpetuating the legacy of spatial apartheid.
A story of division
“A city’s architecture tells the story of its soul,” the second paragraph of the judgment began. “In Cape Town, as in most, if not all, South African cities, that story remains one of division — where the echoes of apartheid’s spatial planning continue to reverberate through its streets and suburbs. Every morning, thousands of Cape Town’s workers board buses, taxis and trains in the pre-dawn darkness, travelling for hours from the city’s periphery to its centre. Their daily journey is not just a commute — it is a living testament to the enduring legacy of spatial injustice that this case glaringly exposes before this Court.”
As a corrective, after noting that the provincial government and the City of Cape Town had “failed to comply with their obligations” to implement and complete social housing programmes in the CBD and Sea Point, the Constitutional Court ordered both entities to report back within three months on their housing pipelines and budgets.
By Daily Maverick’s understanding, this injunction was a direct result of the refusal of Winde’s provincial government to accept the high court ruling of August 2020. DM
The intersection of democracy and Indigenous peoples highlights a structural conflict: liberal majoritarian "one person, one vote" systems lead to the marginalization of Indigenous People, whose rights are grounded in ancestral sovereignty, self-determination, and distinct legal systems rather than numerical representation.
The tension between these governance models unfolds across several specific dynamics:
The Core Conflict
Majority vs. Minority: In democratic systems, the majority rules. For Indigenous populations, who are demographic minorities within their own historical territories, this means critical decisions regarding land, natural resources, and cultural preservation can be overridden by the non-Indigenous majority.
Differing Worldviews: Western democracy is typically state-centered and built on individual rights and private property. Conversely, Indigenous political structures often rely on communal land ownership, kinship, relationality, and responsibility to future generations.
Democratic Deficits and Structural Inequity
Historical Disenfranchisement: In colonial and settler states, democratic institutions were often built on the exclusion or active assimilation of Indigenous peoples.
Extractivism and Land Rights: Democratic governments frequently authorize corporate resource extraction or infrastructure projects on Indigenous lands, bypassing Indigenous consent in favor of broader national economic interests.
Pathways to Reconciliation and Reform
To reconcile these differences, modern democracies are increasingly exploring methods to balance majority rule with Indigenous rights:
Reserved Representation: Systems like those in New Zealand (Māori seats) and various Latin American nations guarantee Indigenous representation directly within the national legislature.
Self-Determination and Autonomy: Nations like Canada (e.g., Nunavut) and the United States (tribal sovereignty) have empowered Indigenous nations with varying levels of self-government, jurisdiction, and control over local resources.
Deliberative & Consensual Democracy: Frameworks such as the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) advocate for "Free, Prior, and Informed Consent" (FPIC). This requires governments to consult and reach agreements with Indigenous communities before taking actions that impact their lands or rights.
For deeper empirical research into self-determination and equity, the Harvard Project for Indigenous Governance and Development provides extensive analysis of how autonomous governance consistently yields better socioeconomic and cultural outcomes.
Brought to you by SA Legal Academy: The Department of Science, Technology and Innovation has published draft regulations under the Protection, Promotion, Development and Management of Indigenous Knowledge Act, No. 6 of 2019, for public comment.
In terms of the Protection, Promotion, Development and Management of Indigenous Knowledge Act, No. 6 of 2019, the Department of Science, Technology and Innovation has gazetted draft regulations for public consultation. Interested parties and stakeholders are invited to submit written representations and comments on the draft regulations on or before 3 August 2026.
The draft regulations primarily introduce and regulate “biocultural community protocols”. These protocols are instruments developed by indigenous communities that establish clear terms and conditions for third parties seeking to engage with these communities to access their indigenous resources and knowledge. The framework aims to ensure that any access to or commercialisation of such knowledge is underpinned by the principle of prior and informed consent.
Key Features of the Draft Regulations
The proposed regulatory framework outlines several key mechanisms to facilitate the development and implementation of these protocols:
Biocultural Community Protocols: Standardised instruments created by communities to manage third-party access to indigenous knowledge systems and biological resources.
Departmental Assistance: The Department of Science, Technology and Innovation will provide a structured template and administrative assistance to help affected indigenous communities draft and formalise their protocols.
Prior and Informed Consent: Establishing mandatory procedural steps that third parties must follow to obtain consent before accessing community-held knowledge or resources.
What this means for you, your business, or your clients
For yourself: No direct individual compliance obligations; however, legal and compliance professionals must familiarise themselves with the proposed consent procedures to advise on future intellectual property and bioprospecting transactions.
For your business: Firms operating in biotechnology, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, or agriculture that utilise indigenous biological resources must review the draft regulations to assess how the mandatory biocultural community protocols will impact their research, development, and sourcing pipelines.
For your clients: Clients representing indigenous communities or commercial entities seeking to commercialise indigenous knowledge must prepare to align their access agreements and consent workflows with the new departmental templates and statutory consent requirements before the 3 August 2026 deadline.
Africa’s growing demand for aquatic foods creates a supply gap that sustainable aquaculture expansion could help close
16/06/2026
Fisheries and aquaculture are a key source of food, nutrition and livelihoods in Africa. But as demand for aquatic foods continues to rise, supply is struggling to keep pace.
The 2026 edition of The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture, launched today by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) during the Our Ocean Conference in Mombasa, Kenya, finds that global production of aquatic animals and algae totalled 235 million tonnes in 2024. Aquatic animal production alone hit a record 195 million tonnes, driven largely by the rapid expansion of aquaculture. Despite this growth, challenges remain in meeting demand in regions such as Africa.
Africa has the lowest availability of aquatic animal foods per capita globally, yet these foods provide a significant share of animal protein across the continent – about 19 percent on average.
“Across Africa, communities rely on aquatic animal foods for nutrition, and in some countries these foods provide as much as 54 percent of animal protein,” says Abebe Haile-Gabriel, FAO Assistant Director-General and Regional Representative for Africa. “Their production also supports jobs, highlighting their critical role in the blue economy, especially for low-income and vulnerable populations”.
Capture fisheries remain central to food supply and jobs
Marine capture fisheries are a leading source of aquatic animals for the entire region, with 7.1 million tonnes produced in 2024. Morocco is the number one producer at almost 1.4 million tonnes, followed by Mauritania, Angola, Senegal and South Africa.
Inland fisheries provide a key source of food and jobs, especially in rural areas and in low-income and landlocked countries. They contributed 3.7 million tonnes of aquatic animals in 2024, a third of all global inland catches.
According to available data, production is unsurprisingly concentrated in countries with major freshwater systems such as river basins and lakes. Among the top five producers, Uganda leads with output of just over 0.5 million tonnes, followed by the United Republic of Tanzania, Nigeria, Egypt and the Democratic Republic of Congo.
Aquaculture is expanding rapidly, offering a path to meet rising demand
Aquaculture accounts for 18 percent of total aquatic animal production in Africa and is expanding rapidly, with strong potential to help meet rising demand and sustain the livelihoods of a growing population.
Globally, aquaculture has been the main driver of growth in aquatic animal production. In Africa the sector is expanding at the fastest rate in the world, growing to over 2.4 million tonnes in 2024, an average annual growth rate of 8 percent since the year 2000 - well above the global average of 5 percent a year over the same period.
Aquatic animal farming is highly concentrated, with the top five producing countries accounting for 90 percent of the continent’s output. The leading producer is Egypt with 1.6 million tonnes in 2024 (66 percent of the regional total), followed by Nigeria, Ghana, Uganda and Zambia.
Amid rapid population growth, demand outpaces supply
Rapid population growth, urbanization, rising incomes and changing consumer preferences are driving increasing demand for aquatic foods across Africa, placing increasing pressure on supply.
While the total per capita availability of aquatic animal foods in Africa has increased over time, it remains the lowest in the world at 9.1 kg per person per year – less than half the global average of 21.1 kg per person per year in 2023.
Around a third of this availability comes from imports, supplementing domestic availability, according to the report. At the same time, Africa maintains a positive trade balance (USD 2 billion) and a net gain in protein (126 000 tonnes), as it exports high-value commodities and imports low-value, yet nutrient-rich, aquatic animal products that support food security and nutrition.
Looking ahead, demand is expected to continue rising. By 2034, Africa is projected to produce around 7 percent of aquatic animals at the global level, with fisheries and aquaculture output growing by 13 percent compared to 2024.
Small-scale fisheries sustain communities, and women are at the forefront
Fisheries and aquaculture are estimated to support 600 million livelihoods across the value chain in the world. Of these, 65.3 million people were directly employed in the primary sector in 2024, and around 9 percent were based in Africa, the second largest workforce globally.
Inland fisheries are a major source of jobs, particularly in rural and landlocked parts of Africa, employing 3.2 million fishers and accounting for 63 percent of those employed in fisheries on the continent.
Aquaculture, despite its rapid growth employed 0.6 million people in the primary sector in 2024, compared to a global total of 23.1 million fish farmers employed globally.
Most of those engaged in the sector are small-scale operators. Small-scale fisheries form the backbone of both marine and inland production systems. In Africa, these fisheries are deeply embedded in local economies and food systems, supporting household nutrition, subsistence activities and informal markets. Women play a particularly important role in post-harvest activities such as processing and marketing.
“When accounting for the full value chain, including informal and subsistence activities, the sector supports tens of millions of livelihoods across the African region, both directly and indirectly,” says Abebe Haile-Gabriel. “Strengthening fisheries and aquaculture will be essential to meet growing demand, improve food security and sustain livelihoods across Africa.”
About the report
The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture is an FAO flagship report that analyses the status and health of global fishery stocks as well as trends in fisheries and aquaculture at the global and regional level, including data on production, trade, employment and availability of fisheries and aquaculture products.
Africa in numbers
1. Production
Fisheries and aquaculture production(aquatic animals and algae) World Africa 235 million tonnes 13.5 million tonnes or 6 percent of global output Production of aquatic animals World Africa 195 million tonnes 13.2 million tonnes or 7 percent of global output Production of algae World Africa 40 million tonnes 0.3 million tonnes or 0.9 percent of global output Aquaculture production World Africa 142 million tonnes of which - 103 million tonnes of aquatic animals - 39 million tonnes of algae 2.7 million tonnes or 2 percent of global output Capture fisheries production World Africa 93 million tonnes of which - 92 million tonnes aquatic animals - 1.3 million tonnes of algae 10.8 million tonnes aquatic animals or 12 percent of global output
2. Availability of aquatic animal foods
Global availability of aquatic animal foods (2023) World Africa 171 million tonnes 13.4 million tonnes Global availability of aquatic animal foods per capita (2023) World Africa 21.1kg 9.1 kg
3. Employment
People employed in primary production World Africa 65.3 million 6.1 million or 9 percent of the world total
4. Trade
Trade of aquatic animal products Exports World Africa USD 184 billion USD 8.4 billion or 5 percent of total world’s exports in aquatic animal products Imports USD 5.9 billion or 3 percent total world’s imports in aquatic animal products
5. Top producers
Aquaculture: Top five producers of aquatic animals in 2024 (Million Tonnes) Egypt 1.6 Nigeria 0.3 Ghana 0.1 Uganda 0.1 Zambia 0.1 Marine capture fisheries: Top five producers of aquatic animals in 2024 (million tonnes) Morocco 1.4 Mauritania 0.6 Angola 0.6 Senegal 0.5 South Africa 0.5 Inland fisheries: Top five producers of aquatic animals in 2024 (million tonnes) Uganda 0.5 Tanzania 0.4 Nigeria 0.4 Egypt 0.3 Democratic Republic of Congo 0.3
Contact
Zoie Jones Regional Communications Officer FAO Regional Office for Africa Accra, Ghana
A recent meta-analysis of twin studies examined whether specific cognitive abilities, like reading and math, have genetic foundations distinct from general intelligence. The researchers found that specific cognitive skills are highly heritable, even when statistically separating them from a person's overall intellectual capacity.
In this time of reconciliation, Indigenous researchers-in-relation are sharing research paradigms and approaches that align with Indigenous worldviews. This article shares an interpretation of the Mi’kmaw concept of Two-Eyed Seeing as the synthesis of Indigenous methodology and participatory action research situated within an Indigenous paradigm of relevant, reciprocal, respectful, and responsible research. Two-Eyed Seeing is discussed as a guiding approach for researchers offering Indigenous voices and ways of knowing as a means to shift existing qualitative research paradigms. The author offers practical considerations for conducting research with Indigenous peoples in a “good and authentic way.” Through the co-creation of knowledge with Indigenous communities, a collective story was produced as a wellness teaching tool to foster the transfer of knowledge in a meaningful way.
In this episode of YourForest podcast, host Matthew Kristoff engages with Dr. Cristina Eisenberg to explore the powerful concept of "Two-Eyed Seeing". Dr. Cristina Eisenberg is an Associate Dean at Oregon State University, specializing in tribal initiatives and climate resilience. As a community ecologist with Māori and Western Apache heritage, she combines Indigenous and Western knowledge to address environmental challenges.
Dr. Eisenberg shares her experiences and insights from the report "Braiding Indigenous and Western Knowledge for Climate Adapted Forests" or ”Braiding Sweetgrass Report” which she co-authored. Here are the 5 Key Recommendations of the “Braiding Sweetgrass Report” from Dr. Eisenberg’s experience:
Adopt proactive stewardship.
Recognize and respect Tribal Sovereignty and Indigenous Knowledge.
Provide the flexibility to steward dynamic landscapes and navigate uncertainties under rapidly changing conditions.
Ground agency planning, and land and resource stewardship policies in ethics of reciprocity and responsibility to many future human generations.
Catalyze innovative approaches to forest stewardship.
The discussion delves into climate change, forest stewardship, and how Indigenous ecological practices can help create the future of sustainable forest stewardship.
Dr. Eisenberg and Matthew dive into the concept of "Two-Eyed Seeing" and how it can reshape forest stewardship. They discuss the importance of cultural burning, proactive management, and Indigenous sovereignty, all of which are central to creating climate-resilient landscapes. The episode highlights the benefits of using both Indigenous ecological practices and modern environmental strategies to steward the land for future generations.
Key Takeaways:
Two-Eyed Seeing: This concept involves viewing the world through both Western science and Indigenous knowledge, leading to more holistic and effective forest management strategies.
Proactive Stewardship: Dr. Eisenberg emphasizes the need for proactive, place-based stewardship that prioritizes forest resilience, especially in the face of climate change.
Reciprocity with Nature: Indigenous ecological practices are based on reciprocity, where humans take from nature mindfully and give back to maintain balance.
Recognizing and Respecting Sovereignty: It is crucial to respect tribal sovereignty and involve Indigenous communities in decision-making processes for forest management.
Healing from Past Harms: Acknowledging historical trauma caused by colonization and implementing Indigenous-led approaches to restore ecosystems.
[00:27:00] Dr. Cristina Eisenberg: "Two-eyed seeing, where Indigenous knowledge and Western science are integrated to provide a holistic view of environmental stewardship, allowing for a more complete understanding of the natural world."
[01:13:41] Dr. Cristina Eisenberg: "We did damage to these forests without realizing it. You know, settlers did in multiple ways"
[00:19:08] Dr. Cristina Eisenberg: "Reciprocity means that the forest is here to take care of us, but we have a huge responsibility to take care of the forest. And that means we take what we need, and we give back more to the forest."
Takeaways
(00:00:15) The Importance of Fire in Indigenous Stewardship
Dr. Eisenberg emphasizes the importance of fire as a tool in Indigenous cultural practices to maintain soil health and the overall ecosystem. She discusses how the suppression of cultural burning has caused unintended damage to forest systems.
(00:18:57) Reciprocity: The Foundation of Indigenous Practices
In Indigenous cultures, reciprocity is a core value. Dr. Eisenberg explains that reciprocity involves giving back more to nature than what is taken, ensuring a balanced, sustainable relationship with the environment.
(00:26:53) Two-Eyed Seeing: A Holistic Approach to Knowledge
Dr. Eisenberg introduces the concept of two-eyed seeing, where Indigenous knowledge and Western science are integrated to provide a holistic view of environmental stewardship, allowing for a more complete understanding of the natural world.
(00:30:46) The Role of Elders and Tribal Knowledge in Stewardship
Dr. Eisenberg emphasizes the importance of integrating tribal elders’ knowledge with Western science. Elders possess ancestral wisdom about forest ecosystems, which, when combined with scientific methods, can lead to more effective land stewardship.
(00:36:28) Proactive Stewardship vs. Reactive Management
Dr. Eisenberg critiques the reactive approach to forest management, where action is only taken after a crisis, advocating instead for proactive stewardship that anticipates environmental challenges and takes preventive measures.
(00:54:27) Acknowledging Indigenous Sovereignty in Land Management
Dr. Eisenberg points out that while Indigenous sovereignty is recognized by law, the true respect and inclusion of Indigenous practices in forest management are often lacking. She calls for greater respect and collaboration with Indigenous communities.
(01:00:18) Historical Trauma and Forest Stewardship
Dr. Eisenberg addresses the intergenerational trauma resulting from colonization, forced assimilation, and the exploitation of Indigenous lands. This historical trauma still impacts Indigenous communities and their relationship with land stewardship today.
(01:15:47) Cultural Burning and Ecosystem Health
Dr. Eisenberg highlights the importance of cultural burning, explaining that these burns are done based on the ecosystem's needs, rather than rigid governmental regulations, which often miss the right timing for ecological health.
(01:22:31) The Future of Forest Stewardship: Learning by Doing (01:22:31)
Dr. Eisenberg discusses how Indigenous practices involve a dynamic, adaptive approach to forest management, where outcomes are continually measured and adjusted. This flexible, hands-on method is essential for responding to rapidly changing environmental conditions.
Restoring Forests and Building Climate Resilience - Two-Eyed Seeing with Dr. Cristina Eisenberg
Forest stewardship is crucial in the age of climate change. Western science often leads the conversation about forest management, using data and models to guide decisions.
However, Indigenous communities have long practiced sustainable forest care, offering a different approach. Combining these two systems can create a more complete way to restore and conserve forests.
Dr. Cristina Eisenberg plays a key role in this effort. As the Associate Dean for Inclusive Excellence at Oregon State University's College of Forestry, she leads projects that blend Indigenous knowledge with Western science.
Dr. Cristina is a Native American and Latinx ecologist. She works with Tribal Nations on forest restoration. She is also a member of the Adaptive Forest Stewardship team. Her work focuses on fire ecology, wildlife ecology, and the use of cultural knowledge to restore ecosystems.
In this article, we will look at the value of using both Indigenous and Western approaches. We will explore the key themes of forest resilience,
Moreover, we will learn about the role of traditional practices like cultural burning and how these methods can help tackle climate change. Understanding this can improve forest health and create sustainable solutions for future generations.
How Indigenous and Western Knowledge Combine for Forest Stewardship
Indigenous and Western knowledge offer distinct approaches to forest stewardship. Combining both perspectives leads to a more holistic understanding of how to restore forests, especially in the context of climate change.
Indigenous communities have managed forests for thousands of years, using practices like cultural burning. This traditional method promotes forest health and resilience.
Western science, on the other hand, often approaches forest management through data-driven, hypothesis-based models. Both approaches have strengths, but using them together can yield better outcomes.
A Collaborative Report on Forest Stewardship
One successful example is a project in Montana, led by Dr. Cristina Eisenberg, focusing on grassland restoration with the Fort Belknap Indian Community.
This collaboration, funded by the Bureau of Land Management, highlights the value of integrating Indigenous stewardship methods with Western science.
Reciprocity with Nature: Indigenous knowledge views humans as part of nature, not as rulers. This perspective emphasizes taking care of the forest, which nurtures us. This contrasts with the Western view of humans controlling and exploiting nature at the top of a pyramid.
Restoring Forest Resilience: The report emphasizes bringing Indigenous and Western knowledge together to restore forest resilience, especially in climate change. By integrating cultural burning with Western forestry practices, forests can better withstand fires and other environmental stressors.
Ongoing Debate and Learning: Throughout the report's creation, there were healthy debates about key concepts like resilience and the role of cultural burning. This cross-cultural collaboration allowed for a richer, more inclusive understanding of forest restoration.
Overall, combining both Indigenous and Western approaches provides a more complete picture of forest health and climate resilience, making it possible to achieve long-term sustainability for forests worldwide.
Why Proactive Forest Stewardship Is Essential for Forest Conservation
Proactive stewardship involves addressing environmental issues before they escalate into crises. This approach contrasts with the historically reactive management of forests, where actions are taken only after disasters, such as wildfires, occur.
Traditional Reactive Approaches and Their Limitations
In the U.S. and Canada, natural resource management agencies have typically operated reactively. When a crisis occurs, such as a devastating wildfire, agencies respond by taking immediate action.
However, this approach often stems from funding limitations and historical practices rooted in colonialism.
European settlers applied unsustainable land management methods that had already failed in Europe. These practices focused on short-term gains like timber extraction, led to long-term ecological damage.
The Shift Towards Proactive Forest Stewardship
Proactive stewardship calls for anticipating future needs and implementing measures to prevent environmental crises.
This involves forward-thinking strategies such as:
Restoring Indigenous Practices: Indigenous peoples have long employed sustainable land management practices, including cultural burning, to maintain forest health. Reviving these methods can help restore resilience to forests.
Place-Based Co-Stewardship: Proactive stewardship must be specific to each landscape and involve collaboration with Indigenous communities. This ensures that forest management strategies are effective, culturally respectful, and inclusive.
Adapting to Climate Change
The growing unpredictability of climate change adds urgency to the need for proactive forest management. Scientists have observed that climate change is accelerating faster than predicted, increasing the frequency and intensity of wildfires.
Proactive forest stewardship, which includes planning for future generations, is essential to building resilience in forest ecosystems.
By adopting proactive measures, we can better protect forests, address climate change, and ensure that these vital ecosystems thrive for future generations.
The Importance of Place-Based Forest Stewardship
Place-based co-stewardship involves using localized knowledge and expertise to manage and care for forests. It focuses on understanding the unique needs of each forest and ensuring that strategies are developed with input from Indigenous communities and local stakeholders.
Why a One-Size-Fits-All Approach Doesn't Work
Forests vary greatly depending on their location, ecosystem, and threats. A one-size-fits-all solution for forest management is ineffective.
Each forest type requires specific treatments that address its unique challenges, such as threats from wildfires, pests, or climate change. Place-based forest stewardship allows for tailored solutions that respect the forest's natural environment and cultural heritage.
The Role of Local Knowledge and Indigenous Wisdom
Place-based forest stewardship involves collaboration between Indigenous communities, who have ancestral knowledge of the land, and local non-Indigenous people, who may also possess deep, generational ties to the region.
Together, they identify the forest that stands most at risk and apply treatments that align with the historical and ecological needs of the landscape.
Key Elements of Place-Based Forest Stewardship
Listening to the land: Understanding what the forest needs by observing its current condition and recognizing historical practices.
Engaging local communities: Involving Indigenous and non-Indigenous people with long-standing knowledge of the landscape.
Customizing solutions: Adapting treatments and management practices to fit each forest's specific ecological and cultural characteristics.
A Holistic Approach to Forest Care
Co-stewardship goes beyond management; it involves a deep, reciprocal relationship with nature. Stewardship emphasizes caring for forests like one would care for family, giving back more than one takes.
This approach integrates ethical principles, such as reciprocity and long-term sustainability, ensuring that forests remain healthy for future generations.
Place-based co-stewardship allows communities to work together using Indigenous knowledge and Western science to create adaptive, sustainable solutions for forest conservation.
How Colonization Altered Forest Ecology in North America
The colonization of North America drastically changed the ecological balance of its forests. Fire suppression became widespread after colonization.
Before European settlement, Indigenous people actively managed the landscape through cultural practices like controlled burning. These practices shaped the health and resilience of ecosystems.
However, when European settlers arrived, they prioritized suppressing fires to protect timber resources. As a result, forests became denser and more prone to catastrophic wildfires. The absence of regular burns also led to a decline in soil health.
Need for a Paradigm Shift in Forest Stewardship
Studies now show that even moist forests, previously thought to be less influenced by human activity, experienced regular fires set by Indigenous peoples, which were crucial for ecological balance and biodiversity.
Recognizing these historical impacts calls for a shift in forest management paradigms. Modern management practices must integrate cultural and ecological knowledge to restore and maintain healthy forest ecosystems.
This includes:
Returning to Cultural Burning: Reintroducing controlled burns as part of forest management to reduce excessive undergrowth and prevent severe wildfires.
Incorporating Indigenous Knowledge: Using historical and cultural insights to inform contemporary ecological practices, ensuring that management strategies align with natural ecological cycles and cultural traditions.
Flexible Management Approaches: Adapting management strategies based on specific forest conditions and historical data, moving away from a one-size-fits-all approach to a more tailored, dynamic method of forest stewardship.
So, by recognizing and respecting Indigenous knowledge, we can improve forest health and create more sustainable, resilient landscapes for future generations.
Conclusion
In conclusion, combining Indigenous and Western knowledge offers a balanced approach to forest stewardship. Indigenous practices like cultural burning foster resilience, while Western science contributes data-driven methods.
Together, they create stronger, more adaptive strategies for forest health. Proactive stewardship, focusing on place-based solutions, ensures forests thrive for future generations. As climate change accelerates, integrating these knowledge systems becomes essential.
We must respect both cultural traditions and scientific innovation to maintain healthy forests. Embracing this collaboration can help us restore and sustain forests worldwide, ensuring their vitality and resilience for years.
FAQs
What is forest stewardship, and why does it matter?
Forest stewardship involves managing and caring for forests to ensure their long-term health. It matters because forests support biodiversity, clean air, water, and climate regulation.
How do Indigenous communities practice forest stewardship?
Indigenous communities use sustainable methods like cultural burning, which maintains forest health, promotes biodiversity, and reduces the risk of wildfires.
What role does Western science play in forest stewardship?
Western science provides data-driven approaches like satellite monitoring and predictive models to guide forest management and assess ecological health.
How can forest stewardship help address climate change?
Forest stewardship helps by improving forest resilience, reducing the impact of wildfires, and maintaining forests' role as carbon sinks, which slow climate change.
How does forest stewardship impact local communities?
Effective stewardship provides communities with cleaner air and water, promotes biodiversity, and protects resources vital for their livelihoods and culture.
The integration of Indigenous perspectives and knowledge with biomedical approaches in neurosciences can significantly broaden the understanding of the human brain and mind. Drawing upon the writings of Elders in Canada, we refer to this integration as Two-Eyed Seeing or Etuaptmumk.
We discuss how Two-Eyed Seeing and other dual perspectives can bring both breadth of knowledge and humility to the development of research and clinical practices for brain health. In this forward-looking discussion, we include both traditional academic and non-academic traditions and the work of Indigenous scholars on methodologies, life, health, culture, language and history. To describe challenges and consider solutions, we offer broad strategies for allyship, humility and universalism and situate them in four specific examples pertaining to disability, suicide, migration and the environment.
We further advance the power of Two-Eyed Seeing in the context of new considerations for communication and public engagement. Two-Eyed Seeing, per se, is only one approach, but as neuroscience becomes ever more global, inclusive and ethically proactive, it must universally see the world of brain and mental health through the eyes of both reductionism and holism. Combining Indigenous insights with neuroscience methods through Two-Eyed Seeing can broaden the understanding of brain function and mental wellbeing by merging reductionist and holistic perspectives across various domains, while promoting allyship, humility and inclusive communication.
To improve the way neuroscience is conducted in Canada, and better reflect the country’s diversity, a University of Guelph professor is working with the Canadian Brain Research Strategy (CBRS) to apply an Indigenous lens to the field and to those working in it.
Dr. Melissa Perreault
CBRS brings together more than 30 world-leading neuroscientists with Canadian mental health institutes and programs to better understand the central nervous system with the goal of becoming a leader in open and ethical brain research.
Conducting work rooted in traditional Western methods, to the exclusion of others is a failure, she said.
Perreault is an Indigenous Knowledge Holder in a group formed by CBRS that comprises Indigenous leaders with research interests in the brain and mental health.
The initiative is the first of its kind in neuroscience, she said, and is designed to ensure Indigenous voices are integrated “into every area that they are working on.”
A workshop was held to understand how to best weave Indigenous knowledge “into the fabric of CBRS,” connecting Indigenous researchers in neuroscience, non-Indigenous researchers who work with Indigenous communities and others interested in learning Indigenous perspectives on mental wellness.
In sharing circles, members of the Indigenous Knowledge Holders Group posed the question: “How does the brain learn, adapt and remember?”
Spirituality neglected in Westernized understanding of mental health
Indigenous ways of knowing differ in vital ways from Western knowledge when it comes to mental health, said Perreault, who co-authored a paper on the initiative, published in The Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences.
Indigenous knowledge carries the belief that everything is connected: ancestral spirits and the mortal world; the land, water and animals; humans and their environment. Understanding that connectivity is a “critical step” in understanding Indigenous decision-making and how experiences can change a person and the brain, the paper says.
The practice of connectivity is rooted in Indigenous culture and has become a theme in systems-level neuroscience, Perreault said.
Indigenous communities take a holistic view of health and wellness that includes four components of oneself: physical, emotional, mental and spiritual, Perreault said. A balance must be maintained, with disruptions in this balance potentially leading to illness. In the case of mental illness, for example, spiritual injury can be an integral contributor.
Western ways of knowing examine mental health disorders from a mechanistic point of view. Therefore spirituality “is not considered in the therapeutic strategy for mental health disorders in Indigenous individuals,” she added. “There needs to be a reclaiming of Indigenous cultural and spiritual traditions when it comes to therapies.”
In addition to supporting Indigenous research and improving relations between academics and Indigenous communities, the initiative aims to demonstrate how to support Indigenous researchers no matter their field of study, Perreault said.
“There should be Indigenous voices in all disciplines, regardless of what those disciplines are,” she said. “Those people become role models.”
One of the largest barriers, she said, is that Western scientists think from a Western perspective and often assume Western methods are the only way — and the “correct” way.
Two-eyed seeing an inclusive balance that values Indigenous knowledge
Two-eyed seeing, or Etuaptmumk — conceived by Mi’kmaw Elder Albert Marshall in 2004 — is the notion of learning to see from one eye the strengths of Indigenous knowledge, and from the other eye the strengths of Western knowledge. Using both eyes together, neither approach dominates, enabling Indigenous ways of knowing to be recognized.
“It’s a balance where you take the best from both worlds to make something better,” Perreault said. “The goal is to form relationships and find that connectedness to bring together these different ways of knowing and learning to develop something that’s even better for the benefit of everyone, where the value is equal.”
Diversity extends beyond non-Indigenous and Indigenous connections, too, Perreault pointed out. In Canada, there are more than 630 First Nations, 53 Inuit communities and nearly 600,000 Métis people. For these efforts to be successful, neuroscience must tailor research methods to specific communities and invest the time to understand how each is unique, according to the research, she said.
A more cohesive approach to research and research methods creates a more inclusive field, while also creating space for new Indigenous students, Perreault said.
Reflecting on the isolation she has experienced in her career, she defines success as ensuring that, “Indigenous students do not feel isolated, and they know they are welcome and belong.”
“The supports aren’t there, in general for Indigenous students, but it’s particularly bad for Indigenous students in STEM,” said Perreault, who offers support as one of the faculty members in the Indigenous STEM Mentorship Program.
“Empowering them to follow their own dreams and do what they’re passionate about (is vital) instead of being forced into this ideal that they have to do a certain thing.”
The notion of ‘sustainability’ in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development echoes the concept of ‘living heritage’ in the 2003 Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage.
The 2030 Agenda refers to sustainability as ‘development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs’. Transmitted from generation to generation, living heritage is a source of community-based resilience, which can be a driver of sustainable development in many different ways:
The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development It constitutes a plan of action addressing the three dimensions – economic, social and environmental – of sustainable development through 17 Sustainable Development Goals as highly interdependent spheres of action: SDG 1: no poverty SDG 2: zero hunger SDG 3: good health and well-being SDG 4: quality education SDG 5: gender equality SDG 6: clean water and sanitation SDG 7: affordable and clean energy SDG 8: decent work and economic growth SDG 9: industry, innovation and infrastructure SDG 10: reduced inequalities SDG 11: sustainable cities and communities SDG 12: responsible consumption and production SDG 13: climate action SDG 14: life below water SDG 15: life on land SDG 16: peace, justice and strong education SDG 17: partnerships for the goals
local knowledge, skills and practices, maintained and adapted over time, provide a vital source of revenue and decent work for many around the world, including poor and vulnerable ones, through crafts, tourism, among others;
traditional agricultural systems provide many societies worldwide with a varied diet for adequate nutrition, while preserving ecosystems and maintaining genetic biodiversity;
inherited healing systems, traditional physical activities – such as sports and games – and festive events strengthen the health and wellbeing of communities for all at all ages;
youth learn about their values and culture through the transmission of their living heritage, constituting a key pillar of their education;
living heritage can shape gender roles and identities, key for achieving gender equality;
communities have developed innovative and adaptive strategies to optimize the use and management of water and minimize the consumption of energy;
through their celebration of cultural diversity, carnivals, fairs and festivals can contribute to harmonious social relationships, within and between urban and rural areas;
living heritage contains locally-rooted knowledge and practices that provide a source of resilience against changing climate conditions and help protect biodiversity;
local social practices of dialogue, conflict resolution and reconciliation help regulate access to shared spaces and natural resources and promote peace and social cohesion.
The Secretariat is to release in December 2020 a set of visualizations providing in-depth illustrations of the relationships between intangible cultural heritage and sustainable development. A Massive Open Online Course project will also be released in 2021 on the topic.
Daggers have been drawn between tenants and activists and the Western Cape government over its decision to build affordable and social housing at the historic Oude Molen Eco Village precinct. Last month, the Heritage Western Cape’s (HWC) appeals committee dismissed the Western Cape Department of Infrastructure’s (DOI) appeal and upheld the rejection of its heritage impact assessment (HIA).
The HIA was found to be non-compliant with the National Heritage Resources Act. The DOI, which owns the Pinelands property, says the development will comprise 1 364 housing units, with 34% allocated to inclusionary, social and first home finance and subsidy assistance housing. The remaining 66% will be sold on the open market. The plans also include office and retail space, as well as an interpretive centre.
This week, DOI spokesperson Melt Botes said his department believed it had satisfied the legal requirements and that its plan would best serve the wider Western Cape communities. “Our vision has always been to facilitate an integrated, residentially led mixed-use development that provides much-needed affordable and social housing. This development is essential for connecting our people with economic opportunities and education while preserving natural and heritage resources.
“We will be following the appropriate legal and administrative avenues to address the Heritage Western Cape decision, ensuring that all our ongoing developmental processes remain transparent and compliant with statutory frameworks,” Botes said. But Adv Rod Solomon, the Oude Molen Eco Village Tenants Association (Omevta) chairperson said the tenants had support from numerous entities and would consider legal action. In its objection to the proposed development, Omevta, which represents about 150 residents, said the site was home to 45 enterprises that provided livelihoods for about 350 people. “Over three decades, with minimal assistance from the state, this community has restored a neglected site and built on it a functioning settlement that already delivers the very things this application claims it will provide — affordable living, education, healthcare, food production and dignified work for historically disadvantaged people.
“The application does not engage that community, build on it or accommodate it. Instead, it removes and replaces it.” In a submission to the HWC against the DOI’s appeal, Khoi leader and convener of of Save our Sacred Lands Tauriq Jenkins questioned the motives of the department, suggesting “motivations coming from the commercial entities that are backing this development” He said the equestrian culture at Oude Molen Stables was a living heritage, with the horses supporting therapeutic programmes.
“We still do not know who the so-called clients would be and for whom this multi-billion rand proposal is going to be prepared for. It becomes obvious that despite of two rejections from Heritage Western Cape and outright rejection of the appeal, they are still adamant of their stance,” said Jenkins. A petition against the development has garnered more than 3 600 signatures on Dear South Africa. Professor Leslie London, the former chairperson of the Observatory Civic Association, said he had signed the petition. “The developers failed to understand how the diverse array of activities on the site for the last two decades actually does knit a form of living heritage,” London said.
South Africa has entered its Second Decade of Freedom with the strengthening of democracy and acceleration of the programme to improve the quality of life of all the people. Steadily, the dark night of white minority political domination is receding into a distant memory.
Yet we are only at the beginning of a long journey to a truly united, democratic and prosperous South Africa in which the value of all citizens is measured by their humanity, without regard to race, gender and social status.
The achievement of democracy in 1994 marked the birth of our country as an African nation on the southern tip of the continent. It provided South Africans with the opportunity to:
set up a government based on the will of the people and on people-centred and people-driven principles as part of the process to de-racialise the economy and society at large;
pursue economic growth, development and redistribution so as to achieve a better life for all;
strengthen the ANC as a leader in the implementation of a practical programme of social change and a movement rooted among the people;
build democracy, a culture of human rights and a value system based on human solidarity; and
work with African and global progressive forces to advance human development in our country, our continent and across the globe.
These tasks, which are at the core of the National Democratic Revolution, have to be undertaken in a global environment of contradictory tendencies.
The dominance of a capitalist system with minimal regulation presents enormous challenges for social development and for global governance and security.
At the same time, programmes of progressive social change are finding pride of place on the agenda of many developing nations and some global institutions. Most African countries have successfully set out to resolve conflict, entrench democracy and reconstruct economies in a manner that benefits the people.
This environment provides a basis for the advancement of the National Democratic Revolution (NDR) in our country.
However, this cannot be assumed. It depends on the ability of progressive forces to promote the positive elements in both the global and domestic settings and to assert a progressive vision of the world we want to live in.
For the ANC, this also means forging a corps of cadres unwaveringly committed to the cause of change, and the mobilisation of the majority of South Africans to act as one in pursuit of a better life for all.
Chapter 2: Where We Come From: Streams Of An Emergent Nation
The South African nation is a product of many streams of history and culture, representing the origins, dispersal and re-integration of humanity over hundreds of thousands of years. Archaeological findings in various parts of the country and the rest of Africa have located South Africa and the continent at large as the cradle of humankind and early forms of human civilisation.
From the earliest manifestations of intellectual activity; the settlements of pastoral communities characterised by foundries, artisanship and trade across oceans; colonisation by Europeans; the slave trade and indentured labour – South Africa has emerged as one of the most diverse nations across the globe. This is our collective national heritage which we should continue to research and engage, the better to appreciate who we are as a nation.
Besides African inter-communal co-operation and wars of nation-formation, the greatest impact on the evolution of the South African nation-state was made by European colonial settlement. On the one hand, colonialism interrupted internally-driven advancement of indigenous South African communities along the ladder of human development. It resulted in the subjugation of the African population, including the Khoi and the San who were subjected to genocidal campaigns, as well as Indian communities and slaves from Southeast Asia and other areas. On the other hand, the advanced industrial base of the colonial powers which made such subjugation possible, introduced into the South African geographic entity the application of advanced forms of economic production and trade.
The South African nation-state is a product of these interactions, characterised between 1652 and 1994 by ongoing and mostly violent conflict between the oppressors and the oppressed. Despite their heroic resistance, the African people were defeated in a series of wars that took place over two-and-half centuries of colonial expansion. Part of this resistance took the form of slave revolts in the Cape Colony and elsewhere. Besides the advanced productive forces at the disposal of the colonial powers, one of the central reasons for the defeat of indigenous communities was division and conflict among these communities themselves.
It speaks to South Africa’s strategic geographic location that this territory experienced colonial intrusion earlier than most African societies. The discovery of gold and diamonds in the latter half of the 19th century laid the basis for industrialisation, the emergence of more complex links of economic dependence with Europe and North America, and the subjection of the Black population to the needs of an emergent colonial capitalism. As a consequence of these and other factors, the colonial designs of the imperial powers were applied more systematically; the European settlers fought intensely among themselves over the territory; and most of these settlers came to characterise South Africa as their home.
As such, what emerged in our country was Colonialism of a Special Type, with both the coloniser and the colonised located in a common territory and with a large European settler population. The deal between the descendants of Dutch settlers and the British imperial power at the end of the so-called Anglo-Boer War formalised, in 1910, South Africa’s statehood, premised on the political oppression and social subordination and exclusion of the majority of the people.
The African National Congress (ANC) was formed in 1912 in part as a response to this deal among the colonisers, as well as the defeat of the Bhambatha Rebellion of 1906 which marked the end of armed resistance against colonial occupation. It was also a product of new forms of African resistance across various parts of the country and the globe.
Starting off with petitions to the colonial powers, the ANC over the years developed ever more militant forms of struggle, and finally adopted armed struggle and formed Umkhonto weSizwe in 1961, a year after its banning. Combined with armed actions, the ANC and other resistance movements used international mobilisation, underground organisation and mass mobilisation to challenge colonialism and its apartheid derivative. In these various terrains of struggle, workers, the rural masses, women, youth, students, the religious community, the intelligentsia, professionals and other sections of society played a critical role. As during the wars of resistance and the anti-slave revolts, they displayed selflessness and heroism that will remain an inspiration to future generations.
As a result of generalised mass revolt, a situation was reached in the late 1980s in which the system of white minority domination could no longer be sustained. Yet at the same time, the liberation struggle at the head of which was the ANC had not as yet amassed sufficient strength to overthrow the apartheid regime.
Elements within the South African ruling class and its international allies started to weigh the implications of continuing popular revolt -and its culmination in the overthrow of the apartheid regime – on their interests within the country and the region. While it had always accepted the human and material cost of protracted struggle, the ANC had, as a matter of abiding principle, sought a more humane resolution of the conflict without compromising the basic objectives of struggle.
Conditions were thus created for a negotiations process which resulted in a settlement underpinned by non-racial democracy, with the first ever democratic elections held in April 1994.
South Africa’s colonial experience was based on the intersection of relations of power based on class, race and gender. These social and/or biological features have been used in human history to exclude, to repress and to stymie the progress of individuals and communities.
Across the globe, these practices represented and in the main still represent the exercise of raw power as opposed to human compassion; relations based on subjugation as opposed to human solidarity; greed and self-aggrandisement as opposed to shared prosperity; religion and other belief systems used as justification for hatred and war as opposed to spiritual and cultural advancement; and treatment of the world as a theatre for narrow self-interest as opposed to the collective well-being of humanity.
Because the struggle against colonialism sought to eliminate most of the manifestations of these iniquitous social relations, it evolved to embrace the best in human civilisation and value systems.
While the anti-colonial struggle could easily have been conducted as one against a racial group, it rose above these categories to embrace the principle of non-racialism: to see humanity as one and diversity as a source of strength. While all communities, including the oppressors and the oppressed, evinced patriarchal relations of power, the struggle evolved to appreciate the real and potential role of women, and that their liberation from patriarchy was and should be an integral part of the new democracy.
While in the early years, the liberation movement reflected some characteristics of elitism, it developed over the decades to appreciate the place and role of the working class and the poor both as a critical social force in production and trade and as a militant contingent against apartheid colonialism.
As such, the liberation struggle by oppressed communities, even in the midst of bitter confrontation, developed moral values of human compassion and solidarity far beyond the narrow confines of its opposition to the apartheid social system. It represented something good, not just something better than apartheid. It asserted the humanness of the human spirit – the search for societies at peace within and among themselves. It developed to advocate the use of human intelligence to advance collective social comfort and to preserve the endowments of our planet and outer space for the sustenance of current and future generations.
In this sense therefore, it is both an honour and a challenge for the ANC to claim the legacy of the liberation struggle, to occupy the high ground of its moral suasion and wield its compass.
Chapter 3: Vision Of Our Collective Effort: Character Of The National Democratic Revolution
If the progress we have made since 1994 constitutes only the beginning of a protracted process of change, what is it that we aim for! What kind of society do we seek to create? What is the character of the NDR?
Colonialism of a Special Type contained within itself contradictions that could not be resolved through reform. It had to be destroyed. As such, the system we seek to create will stand or fall on the basis of whether it is able to eliminate the main antagonisms of this system.
A national democratic society constitutes the ideal state we aspire to as the ANC and the broad democratic movement. It should thus not be confused with tactical positions that the liberation movement may adopt from time to time, taking into account the balance of forces within our country and abroad. Circumstances in which we conduct social transformation will change all the time. And in the process of effecting such transformation, there will be successes and setbacks.
The liberation movement should avoid the temptation to crow over such successes in these early years as if we had already achieved our ultimate objective. Nor should we seek to justify mistakes and setbacks as unavoidable, pleading a fixed set of circumstances and thus leading us into the danger of redefining the ultimate objective.
This is where the line should be drawn between strategy – the ultimate goal; and tactics – the methods and actions that respond to changing immediate circumstances. Clearly, at all times we should develop tactics that are suitable for the specific conditions under which we operate. But such tactics should be informed by our commitment to the strategic goal.
What does this mean in actual practice?
Our definition of Colonialism of a Special Type identifies three interrelated antagonistic contradictions: class, race and patriarchal relations of power. These antagonisms found expression in national oppression based on race; class super-exploitation directed against Black workers on the basis of race; and triple oppression of the mass of women based on their race, their class and their gender.
The National Democratic Revolution is defined as such precisely because it seeks to abolish this combination of sources of social conflict. It has national and democratic tasks, and it should strive to realise:
a united state based on the will of all the people, without regard race, sex, belief, language, ethnicity or geographic location;
a dignified and improving quality of life among all the people by providing equal rights and opportunities to all citizens; and
the restoration of the birthright of all South Africans regarding access to land and other resources.
The NDR seeks to build a society based on the best in human civilisation in terms of political and human freedoms, socio-economic rights, value systems and identity.
Such human civilisation should be reflected, firstly, in the constant improvement of the means to take advantage of our natural environment, turn it to collective human advantage and ensure its regeneration for future use. Secondly, it should find expression in the management of human relations based on political equality and social inclusivity. If there were to be any single measure of the civilising mission of the NDR, it would be how it treats the most vulnerable in our society.
One of the most critical acts of the NDR is the creation of a legitimate state which derives its authority from the people, through regular elections and continuing popular participation in the processes of governance. Mobilised around a clear vision of the kind of society we wish to become, the nation should act in partnership – each sector contributing to the realisation of the common good. The means should be put in place for citizens to exercise their human rights, and for the checks and balances necessary in a law-governed society. The democratic state should also have the organisational and technical capacity to realise its objectives.
As with any nation, South Africans will continue to have multiple identities based on class, gender, age, language, geographic location, religion and so on. In a national democratic society, such diversity should feed into an overarching national identity. In its own unique way, South Africa should emerge as a united African nation, adding to the diversity and identity of the continent and humanity at large.
The main content of the NDR is the liberation of Africans in particular and Blacks in general from political and socio-economic bondage. It means uplifting the quality of life of all South Africans, especially the poor, the majority of whom are African and female. At the same time it has the effect of liberating the white community from the false ideology of racial superiority and the insecurity attached to oppressing others. The hierarchy of disadvantage suffered under apartheid will naturally inform the magnitude of impact of the programmes of change and the attention paid particularly to those who occupied the lowest rungs on the apartheid social ladder.
Precisely because patriarchal oppression was embedded in the economic, social, religious, cultural, family and other relations in all communities, its eradication cannot be an assumed consequence of democracy. All manifestations and consequences of patriarchy – from the feminisation of poverty, physical and psychological abuse, undermining of self-confidence, to open and hidden forms of exclusion from positions of authority and power – need to be eliminated. Critical in this regard is the creation of the material and cultural conditions that would allow the abilities of women to flourish and enrich the life of the nation.
A nation’s success depends also on its ability to encourage, harness and incorporate into its endeavours the creativity, daring and energy of youth. This relates to such issues as access to social and economic opportunities, engendering activism around issues of development and values of community solidarity and creating the space for youth creativity to flourish.
Among the most vulnerable in society are children and the elderly: and a national democratic society should ensure their protection and continuous advancement. Such is the challenge also in relation to people with disability – not merely as a matter of social welfare; but based on the recognition of the right of each individual to dignity and development and of the contribution that each can make to the collective good. In many respects, there is a critical link between the objective condition of children, the elderly and people with disability and poverty.
Implementing these corrective measures requires more than just references to general political rights. A continuing element of democratic transformation should be a systematic programme to correct the historical injustice and affirm those deliberately excluded under apartheid – on the basis of race, class and gender. The need for such affirmative action will decline in the same measure as all centres of power and influence and other critical spheres of social endeavour become broadly representative of the country’s demographics. In the process, all inequalities that may persist or arise will need to be addressed.
Apartheid colonialism visited such devastating consequences on Black communities because it ordered the ownership and control of wealth in such a manner that these communities were deliberately excluded and neglected.
Therefore, fundamental to the destruction of apartheid is the eradication of apartheid production relations. This is more than just an issue of social justice. It is also about the fact that these relations had become a brake on the advancement of technology and competitiveness of the economy.
A national democratic society should be founded on a thriving economy the structure of which should reflect the natural endowments of the country and the creativity that a skilled population can offer. It should be an economy in which cutting edge technology, labour-absorbing industrial development, a thriving small business and co-operative sector, utilisation of information and communication technologies and efficient forms of production and management all combine to ensure national prosperity. This is conditional on ensuring that the brain and brawn of all of society are brought to bear on all economic activity. It requires de-racialisation of ownership and control of wealth, management and the professions.
In this regard, such a society will place a high premium on redistribution of land in both urban and rural areas for the benefit of those who were denied access under colonialism. Such access must be provided for a variety of purposes including agriculture, housing, environmental preservation, mining and other economic activity, public utilities and spaces, entertainment and other uses. In order to ensure effective and sustainable land and agrarian reform, effective measures will be put in place to assist ’emergent’ and small-scale farmers and co-operatives.
A thriving economy in a national democratic society requires as efficient a market as possible, shorn of the racial and gender exclusions that characterised apartheid colonialism, and freed from the barriers to entry and competition that the economy endured under colonial capitalism. It will also require a state able to use its capacities to direct national development through fiscal redistribution, utilisation of State-owned Enterprises and effective regulation.
A national democratic society will have a mixed economy, with state, co-operative and other forms of social ownership, and private capital. The balance between social and private ownership of investment resources will be determined on the balance of evidence in relation to national development needs and the concrete tasks of the NDR at any point in time.
In this regard, the state will relate to private owners of investment resources in the context of the national objective to build a better life for all. Through its various capacities the state will encourage socially-beneficial conduct on the part of private business. Similarly, through such capacities, it will ensure that these investors are able to make reasonable returns on their investments.
Social cohesion in a national democratic society will also depend on the extent to which the rights of those in the lower rungs of the socio-economic ladder are protected. Such a society should proceed from the obvious premise that workers’ rights are human rights; and these rights should find expression in law-governed measures to ensure decent jobs, job security and a living wage. Through legislation and other means, the state should manage the environment for fair and balanced relations between employers and employees.
Particular attention in such a society should be paid to conditions of the poor in rural areas. This also applies the life circumstances of such groups as citizens in informal settlements as well as female-headed and single households.
A national democratic society should use the redistributive mechanism of the fiscus to provide a safety net for the poor. As such, built into its social policy should be a comprehensive social security system which includes various elements of the social wage such as social grants, free basic services, free education, free health care, subsidised public transport and basic accommodation.
A national democratic state should continually implement integrated anti-poverty programmes, ensuring that these programmes address not only social assistance, but also the sustainable integration of all communities into economic activity. This is critical in dealing with poverty in general, but also in addressing the condition of the majority of women.
All these measures are important for social cohesion. They should be supported by joint efforts among all sectors of society to strengthen community organisation and mobilisation around issues pertaining to sport, women’s rights, youth interests, the battle against crime and so on. There also should be deliberate collective action to promote a positive role by the institution of the family. The public media also have a critical role to play in promoting social cohesion.
Critical elements of a value system based on human solidarity should include pride in social activism and respect for an honest day’s work. They should include social dissuasion against conspicuous consumption, ostentatiousness and corruption. This is part of the ideological engagement that should be a permanent feature of the process of change, involving both the state and civil society.
Whether such common social decency is achievable under a market-based system with its tendency to reproduce underdevelopment and inequality, in a globalised world, is an issue on which society should continually engage its mind. Concrete practice, rather than mere theory, will help answer this question. What is clear though is that such was the symbiosis between political oppression and the apartheid capitalist system that, if decisive action is not taken to deal with economic subjugation and exclusion, the essence of apartheid will remain, with a few black men and women incorporated into the courtyard of privilege. The old fault-lines will persist, and social stability will be threatened.
A national democratic society is, by definition, made up of various classes and strata. The NDR seeks to eradicate the specific relations of production that underpinned the national and gender oppression and super-exploitation of the majority of South Africans. It does not eradicate capitalist relations of production in general. It should therefore be expected that in a national democratic society class contradictions and class struggle, particularly between the working class and the bourgeoisie, will play themselves out. As such, a national democratic state will be called upon to regulate the environment in which such contradictions manifest themselves, in the interest of national development including fundamental socio-economic transformation.
In broad terms, the NDR seeks to ensure that every South African, especially the poor, experiences an improving quality of life. It seeks to build a developmental state shaped by the history and socio-economic dynamics of South African society. Such a state will guide national economic development and mobilise domestic and foreign capital and other social partners to achieve this goal. It will have attributes that include:
capacity to intervene in the economy in the interest of higher rates of growth and sustainable development;
effecting sustainable programmes that address challenges of unemployment, poverty and underdevelopment with requisite emphasis on vulnerable groups; and
mobilising the people as a whole, especially the poor, to act as their own liberators through participatory and representative democracy.
The ANC therefore seeks to build democracy with social content. Informed by our own concrete conditions and experiences, this will, in some respects, reflect elements of the best traditions of social democracy, which include: a system which places the needs of the poor and social issues such as health care, education and a social safety net at the top of the national agenda; intense role of the state in economic life; pursuit of full employment; quest for equality; strong partnership with the trade union movement; and promotion of international solidarity.
52nd National General Council: Adopted Strategy and Tactics of the ANC 20 December 2007
Building A National Democratic Society
Chapter 7: The Global Balance: Character Of The International Situation
The ANC was formed and it evolved as part of progressive forces across the globe in the fight against colonialism, racism, poverty, underdevelopment and gender oppression. It drank and continues to drink from the well of these progressive global experiences. The strategic objectives of our National Democratic Revolution reflect some of the best values in human civilisation.
In its conduct of struggle, the ANC takes into account the global balance of forces, the better to help create and take advantage of opportunities for decisive advance and to avoid pitfalls of adventurism. In this regard, we proceed from the understanding that it is the task of revolutionary democrats and humanists everywhere to recognise dangers; but more critically, to identify opportunities in the search of a just, humane and equitable world order – a world with greater security, peace, dialogue and better equilibrium among all nations of the world, rich and poor, big and small.
What then is our assessment of the major trends in the world in which we live?
Today, the system of capitalism holds sway across the world; and it is underpinned by the unique dominance of one ‘hyper-power’. This situation of unipolarity also has secondary multi-polar features reflected in geopolitical blocs among developed and developing countries, and the historical resurgence of China, India, Brazil and Russia as centres of growth and development. These multi-polar features require continuing research and engagement.
The world-wide system of capitalism is characterised by globalisation, which has seen impressive advances in the development and utilisation of technology, integration of production and management processes across oceans, massive trade in financial instruments and expansion of trade in goods and services.
But beyond this its technical expression, globalisation has also been shaped by the agenda of dominant global forces. These include transnational corporations controlling trillions of Rand of humanity’s wealth, alliances around one ‘hyper-power’ whose dominance is reminiscent of empires of a bygone era, and cultural domination reflected in trends towards homogenisation of media content and the arts. A critical consequence of all this is the undermining of the system of global governance.
At the political level, the dominant imperialist powers have historically used various means to assert their geo-political and economic interests. This finds contemporary expression in unilateralism and militarism which have reared their ugly head on a scale hardly witnessed in recent history. In intellectual and policy discourse, notions of empire and benevolent colonialism find respectable articulation. In many respects, the current global balance is evocative of the situation in previous eras of dominant empires and colonialism when brute force was the currency of geo-political intercourse.
In a situation in which an exploitative socio-economic system rules the waves, the danger should not be underestimated of widening wars of conquest and other more sophisticated means of subversion in search of resources, markets and geo-political advantage. Indeed, notions of ‘pre-emptive wars’ and ‘regime change’ are becoming the political stock-in-trade. This imperils sovereignty of smaller and weaker nations.
Attached to this phenomenon is the assertion of shallow and populist ideologies such as the so-called ‘clash of civilisations’ premised on varied expressions of religious fundamentalism, which seek to justify political crusades of blood and gore. By-products of this mindset include racial profiling, the undermining of rule of law both in domestic and global conduct and systematic violation of human rights.
The growing threat of terrorism on a global scale, conducted by state and non-state agencies alike, forms an indistinguishable part of this phenomenon. Masked as resistance against imperialism or a fight against so-called “forces of evil”, terrorism – which is the deliberate targeting of civilians in violent conflict – is both inhuman and repugnant. Militarism and terrorism feed one another. They are two sides of the same coin.
However, these dangers manifest themselves in a period in which humanity is keenly aware of the disastrous consequences of war and the dehumanisation that can result from warped ideologies of race hatred and religious intolerance. Ordinary citizens across the globe are finding various ways of resisting the encroachment of the rapacious licence of empire. Through mass mobilisation and progressive political parties, and through the power of the vote, continuous processes of self-correction do assert themselves.
At the socio-economic level, the wonder of technology including computing, genetics and nano-technology continues to broaden the horizons of human civilisation and create possibilities that only a few decades ago existed only in the wildest of human imagination. It is the irony of our age that such possibilities for the resolution of problems of health, environmental degradation as well as poverty and under-development are appropriated for the benefit of a few, and are seen to impress mainly in the shock and awe of war.
Technological advancement has created a global economic system that increasingly works as ‘a unit in real time on a planetary scale’. The advantages of this are limitless.
On the other hand, these opportunities can be abused through financial systems in which paper money begets paper money: with new ingenious ways found to extract so-called shareholder value that has little bearing on actual production. This also creates an environment for a pervasive short-termism that can hold back the development of productive forces. Related to this is the growing tendency to sustain and justify staggering packages and astonishing lifestyles of corporate executives and so-called celebrities, with levels of inequality that are reminiscent of the eras of slavery and feudalism.
Globalisation also impels the search for the lowest in human deprivation to locate production and extract maximum returns, with developing countries encouraged to bid one another lower on a catwalk of mutual beggaring. Combined with this is the utilisation of economic power to rip open frontiers of protectionism among the weak, while doing the opposite in developed countries. All these developments and others such as rapid and unregulated capital flows that include complex derivatives and private equity takeovers negatively impact the sovereignty of developing countries.
These are some of the fundamental shortcomings of a rampant and poorly regulated market-based system. This system perpetuates under-development and deepens inequality within and among nations, creating what are in fact two global villages. It fuels corruption on a massive scale. It also precipitates migration from poor to rich countries, resulting in a debilitating brain drain and illegal escapades that heighten inter-state tensions. In addition, this system entrenches patriarchy, including the vicious exploitation of female labour, trafficking in women and children and poor representation of women in global positions of authority.
Globalised capitalism has also generated careless exploitation of natural resources, endangering the long-term survival of the human species. The wanton destruction of the environment, the threat to biodiversity and the danger of global warming are all a grave challenge that should receive priority attention. These developments take place in an era in which oil reserves as a non-renewable source of energy are declining at a rapid pace, and sources of potable water are diminishing relative to social and economic needs. At the same time, food production is not keeping pace with the needs of humanity and food stocks such as fish are being senselessly plundered.
Parallel to these short-comings has been the widening access to modern technology and foreign markets across the globe. Nations which organise and position themselves to take advantage of this are advancing at a rapid pace. New economic growth centres are emerging – in Asia – and Africa is poised to join the trend.
It is a measure of the changing global economic balance that the fastest growing regions of the world are located in developing countries. Their share of global production has increased dramatically, with profound implications for global economics and politics. In various parts of the ‘developing world’, including Latin America, there is a growing assertion of national and collective sovereignty and a progressive developmental agenda. As a consequence, the voice of the South is growing stronger by the day. Both from the point of view of their common historical experiences and common current interests, countries of the South need to strengthen co-operation among themselves. They need to build people-centred and people-driven systems and pool their sovereignty through strategic partnerships.
Globalisation also means growing inter-dependence among nations, reflected among others in production and trade, financial flows, environmental challenges, health issues and migration. Further, improved platforms of mass communication help lay bare the advances in human comfort and thus the unfairness of massive global inequality.
The global mass movements around these and other issues attest to the impact of these factors on global human consciousness and conscience. Public opinion is steadily turning. Progressive parties, workers’ and women’s organisations, popular campaigns around local development and environmental issues, associations of professionals and movements of people with disability, indigenous communities, the homeless, the landless and so on -all have resolved to challenge the negative effects of globalisation.
It is in part a result of these trends that the United Nations Organisation (UN) has put high on its agenda the notion of human security as encompassing issues of poverty and underdevelopment. Whatever their limitations, initiatives such as the UN Millennium Development Goals, the programme for sustainable development, and the development round in global trade negotiations do reflect the positive impact of a progressive global paradigm. At the same time, the voices calling for democratisation of the UN and other multilateral institutions and the restructuring of the global exercise of power are growing.
South Africa’s interests in a complex and unpredictable global environment necessitate the building of capacity for strategic as well as rapid responses to changes in our region, Africa and the world. Within this context, our global strategy for the coming years will remain firmly anchored on the African continent and the developing countries.
Africa has the best possibility in this milieu to emerge from an era of political and social decline into a renaissance of hope and social progress. It can on a massive scale turn adversity into opportunity. A new spirit is abroad on the continent, and the people of Africa are determined to use their newly-harnessed energy, pride and self-assertiveness to chart their own course of development and extricate themselves from the lowest rungs of human development.
Most of the conflicts on the continent have been resolved. Democracy is spreading. Economic growth is accelerating. And there is a collective determination to turn Africa into one of the centres of rapid industrialisation and social development.
While historical experiences of subjugation have much to do with Africa’s current position, it is Africans themselves partnered by others, who can bring about the renaissance of their nations and their continent.
The most immediate challenges in this regard consist in the development of infrastructure for economic activity and social services, the deepening of democracy and mass participation and improved public service. Also crucial are regional integration and assertion of national and collective continental sovereignty in pursuit of a higher trajectory of development and in relation to global partners.
The ANC forms part of the global forces – including governments, political parties and civil society organisations in developing and developed countries – campaigning for a humane and equitable world order. In its history it has gained from and contributed to a culture of human solidarity across the globe. It is informed in its international work by values of internationalism, promotion of human rights against all abuses and violations, and support for national liberation. In this regard, the ANC supports the right of all peoples to fight against oppression and tyranny.
The ANC will continue to work with other countries and progressive forces to promote the transformation of the global order away from unilateralism and conflict. It will continue to seek a path of hope and human solidarity, to pursue resolution of conflict through dialogue and peaceful means and to promote mutual friendship among peoples of the world. This we shall do, proceeding from the premise that all nations have a shared responsibility collectively to improve the human condition.
Our standpoint on these matters is both a matter of profound self-interest and an issue about the humanity of our own outlook. We will continue to build and strengthen progressive alliances and networks across the globe, including inter-state, party-to-party and people-to-people relations in Africa and further afield in pursuit of an equitable and humane world order.
Chapter 8: Steps Towards The Vision: Programme Of National Democratic Transformation
What then are the main steps that we need to take, in the programme of the democratic state in the current phase, to bring us closer to the ideal of a national democratic society?
The answer to this question is informed by the character of the NDR, actual practical experience since 1994 and our reading of the current balance of forces. In broad terms, our approach is informed by the ideals contained in the Freedom Charter, adopted at the Congress of the People in 1955. The practical measures towards a national democratic society are contained in the Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP) adopted by the ANC, the Tripartite Alliance and the broad mass democratic movement in the run-up to the first democratic elections. This was further updated and elaborated in Election Manifestos during subsequent elections.
What we outline hereunder are the main emphases in the work of the ANC government in the coming decade.
Constitution and governance
The National Constitution sets out the framework within which to manage social relations. Some of the basic principles include: multi-party democracy; the doctrine and practice of separation of powers in a constitutional democracy; equal human rights and access to opportunity; freedom of speech and of the media; equality of all before the law; respect for the rights of linguistic, religious and cultural communities; social equity and practical corrective action against racial, gender and other forms of discrimination.
In order to ensure popular involvement in the processes of change, the ANC will continue to build partnerships across society. Practically, the ANC will strengthen institutions and practices of popular participation and encourage efforts to build an enduring people’s contract – for each sector to contribute to the common objective.
There will be continuing work to improve the legitimacy of the democratic state, encourage national identity and the role of the state as an instrument of social cohesion. Informed by this legitimacy, the state will also ensure that its collective national authority as regulator of social relations is respected, in the context of rule of law.
The ANC will consistently improve the role played by legislative organs of government as tribunes of the people, and as platforms to monitor and advance the programme of change. It will continue to promote the transformation of the judiciary and to consolidate the legitimacy of this important arm of the state in a constitutional democracy. Informed by the doctrine of separation of powers, the ANC will encourage mutual respect among the three arms of the state – the legislature, the executive and the judiciary – in dealing with matters of common interest.
Building a developmental state
The first attribute of a developmental state in our conditions should be its strategic orientation: an approach premised on people-centred and people-driven change, and sustained development based on high growth rates, restructuring of the economy and socio-economic inclusion.
The second attribute of our developmental state should be its capacity to lead in the definition of a common national agenda and in mobilising all of society to take part in its implementation. Therefore, such a state should have effective systems of interaction with all social partners, and exercise leadership informed by its popular mandate.
The third attribute should be the state’s organisational capacity: ensuring that its structures and systems facilitate realisation of a set agenda. Thus, issues of macro-organisation of the state will continue to receive attention. These include permutations among policy and implementation organs within each sphere, allocation of responsibilities across the spheres, effective inter-governmental relations and stability of the management system.
The fourth attribute should be its technical capacity: the ability to translate broad objectives into programmes and projects and to ensure their implementation. This depends among others on the proper training, orientation and leadership of the public service, and on acquiring and retaining skilled personnel.
The ongoing transformation of the state is meant to ensure that these capacities are attained; and the process of identifying weaknesses and correcting them will be intensified. This includes engendering new doctrines, culture and practices as well as ensuring that state institutions reflect the demographics of the country, including appropriate representation of women and people with disability.
This applies to the public service in its totality as well as specialised institutions such as the judiciary, the police, intelligence agencies and the defence force. All these organs should serve the people in an efficient and impartial manner.
Accelerated and shared growth
Central to the country’s economic challenges in the current phase is to build an integrated and growing economy from which all South Africans can benefit.
The ANC will continue to strive for macro-economic balances that support sustainable growth and development. This applies to such indicators as the budget deficit, inflation and interest rates. In other words these balances shall not be treated as things-in-themselves, but as requirements that ensure higher rates of growth, labour-absorption and poverty-reduction.
Government action will be guided by an industrial strategy and a corresponding programme which continually identifies and addresses constraints to investment. This will help build an economy that is characterised by high levels of manufacturing activity, modern services, expanding trade, cutting edge technology and a vibrant small business and co-operative sector. State and private capital as well as resources and capacities in the hands of communities will be mobilised for this purpose. During various periods, specific industries will be identified for concerted joint action by all economic partners. A critical element of this strategy will be a comprehensive programme of land and agrarian reform.
To ensure that benefits of growth are shared by all, there will be focus on creating decent jobs and ensuring an improving quality of life for workers. Government will implement programmes to eliminate economic dualism and exclusion. These include skills development, specific attention to industries that lend themselves to involvement by marginalized communities, access to micro-credit and small business assistance, land reform, public works projects and promotion of sustainable livelihoods at community and household levels.
The government will intensify broad-based programmes to empower those previously excluded from mainstream economic activity, including women. To ensure balanced and sustainable spatial development, systematic analysis will be conducted of economic potential and incidence of poverty in various geographic areas, and the three spheres of government will integrate their development plans to address these issues.
Macrosocial tasks – meeting social needs
The central objective of social policy should be to preserve and develop human resources and ensure social cohesion.
To achieve this objective, the ANC government will continuously improve service to society, through enhanced public infrastructure, efficient systems and requisite personnel. We approach these issues proceeding from the premise that the state has a critical role to play in providing public goods such as health, education, housing, public transport, education and social security.
The ANC will implement a comprehensive social security system which brings together initiatives such as free basic services for the poor, passenger transport subsidy, social grants, expansion of the asset base of the poor through housing, small business and land reform programmes as well as private retirement savings, unemployment and accident insurance and medical aids.
Government will align and integrate the various programmes – economic and social – directed at eradicating poverty with the aim of ensuring effectiveness and better monitoring and evaluation. Given the reality of feminisation of poverty, central focus in this regard will be paid to the conditions of women, especially in rural, ‘township’ and informal settlements.
Central to the preservation of human resources is the issue of the nation’s health profile and causes of death. The ANC government will strive massively to reduce cases of TB, diabetes, malnutrition, maternal deaths and malaria, as well as violent crime and road accidents. Over and above this, the impact of the pandemic of HIV and AIDS requires a massive joint effort of the state and all sectors of society so as to reverse and finally eradicate it. Government will intensify its implementation of the comprehensive strategy against this pandemic and mobilise all sectors and all citizens to play their role.
The ANC government will implement a comprehensive human development strategy which includes: improvement of the general education system; intensification of education in mathematics and natural sciences; promotion of social sciences that help build social cohesion; expansion of the nation’s artisanship base; improving throughput and research in the universities; and an effective adult basic education programme.
Specific programmes of redress such as land restitution and follow up to the recommendations of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission will continue.
Building social cohesion – promoting values of a caring society
The government led by the ANC will consolidate partnerships across society to strengthen social cohesion and ensure that our nation achieves the values of a caring society, inspired by the traits of human compassion which informed our struggle against colonialism. Indeed, the need to build co-operation among all South Africans applies more so to matters of spiritual sustenance such as beliefs and moral values, which are as communal as they are profoundly personal.
This we shall do, proceeding from the understanding that comprehensive social transformation entails changing the material conditions of all South Africans for the better; but also ensuring that we forge a nation inspired by values of human solidarity. It is the combination of these factors that describe the civilisation of national democracy that we seek to build.
Liberation also means engendering freedom of the human spirit to search for better ways of doing things, to express oneself freely and to enjoy the creative endeavours of humanity. But, informed by the precepts of the country’s Constitution, including the Bill of Rights, we do recognise that attached to individual freedom is individual responsibility; attached to collective freedom is collective responsibility.
We will work with all sectors of society to promote an overarching South African identity, recognising the diversity of the country’s people. We will promote pride in our heritage including geographic and place names, our African identity and our common humanity as global citizens.
In this regard, we shall ensure that the content of the education system encourages the inculcation of these values while at the same time promoting critical thought.
In promoting intellectual discourse, media freedom and diversity of views, the ANC will encourage appreciation by the media fraternity and the intelligentsia as a whole of the role that they can play in promoting human solidarity and a caring society. The same applies to the arts including music, the oral and written word, crafts, theatre and film.
The ANC government will encourage development and promotion of languages used by South Africans. Traditions, religious expressions and other belief systems which are consistent with the values of the country’s Constitution form a critical part of the nation’s collective resource in the promotion of humane values. In this regard, we will seek to emphasise that which is common and good.
By encouraging a positive role for the institution of the family and community, youth involvement in a variety of social endeavours, patriotism and civic responsibility, community activism, sporting and other social activities, we will seek to promote healthy lifestyles, moral integrity and role models informed by human compassion, generosity, incorruptibility and accountability.
While encouraging individual initiative, drive and entrepreneurship, we shall also promote appreciation of the responsibility on the part of those who command political, social, material and other forms of power towards poor and vulnerable sectors of society. In this regard, we will fight against all manifestations of racism, super-exploitation, patriarchy, ethnic chauvinism, religious and political intolerance, and abuse of women and children; discourage greed and the arrogant display of wealth; and campaign against the abuse of drugs and alcohol.
Central in this endeavour will be the mobilisation of all South Africans to strengthen the nation’s moral fibre informed by the ideals of human compassion and solidarity.
Safety and Security
The national struggle for freedom was the critical over-arching vehicle to bring about peace, security and stability to our society. In dealing with issues of crime, the ANC proceeds from the premise that a rising quality of life also means improvement in the safety and security of citizens in their homes and environs where they live, work and engage in extramural activity.
Three principles are critical in addressing the challenge of crime, especially its uniquely random and violent nature in our country.
The first of these is that the battle against crime cannot be separated from the war on want. In the main, incidents of contact crime such as murder, grievous bodily harm and rape occur among acquaintances in poor communities where living and entertainment environments do not allow for decent family and social life.
Secondly, specific mindsets and historical conditions drive elements of the crime problem. These are the proliferation of firearms in the hands of civilians, greed and conspicuous consumption, the psychology of patriarchal power relations and attitudes towards weaker members of society especially children.
Thirdly, the networks of crime have grown in their reach and sophistication across national boundaries. These include syndicates that deal with money laundering, human smuggling as well as drug trafficking and abuse.
The overall programme of national democratic transformation will gradually eliminate some of the conditions that breed social crime. So shall our contribution to creating an environment of peace, stability, economic growth and social development in Southern Africa and the rest of the continent.
Critically, focus must be placed on mobilising society to make life difficult for criminals in our midst. This should include an overhaul of gender and family relations and intolerance of abuse within communities. The transformation of institutions dealing with crime, including integrated efficiency is also critical. This applies to management, expansion of personnel, utilisation of latest technology, enhanced intelligence capacity, commitment to work with the people and eradication of corruption within the ‘criminal justice system’. It also applies to the efficient regulation of the private security industry to ensure that its various capacities, integrity of its recruitment practices and employees’ conditions of service are in line with the requirements of what is otherwise an important part of our nation’s security establishment.
Government will continue to expand and deepen co-operation among law-enforcement agencies in the region and further afield. At the same time we will enhance our systems of border control and improve the capacity of our defence force and intelligence agencies to secure the integrity of our nation-state. We will continue to pay attention to any remaining networks from apartheid’s ‘dirty war’ some of which are an integral part of the criminal networks.
Chapter 9: Conclusion
Contained in this outline of our Strategy and Tactics is the ANC’s assessment of the environment in which we live and the immediate and long-term tasks that we face. It is our collective view of the theory of the South African revolution.
During the First Decade of Freedom, we were able to consolidate and deepen our democratic system and introduce critical programmes for social transformation. The progress we have made is commendable; and the decisive actions in the early years of the Second Decade of Freedom hold out the promise of faster progress towards our ideals. But we are only at the beginning of a protracted process of change.
The ANC celebrates the end of the first century of its existence wielding political power – a critical platform to improve the quality of life of South Africans and contribute to building a better world. The strategic task remains the same. But the environment in which it has to be pursued has changed significantly for the better.
In this phase of national democratic transformation, the ANC commits itself to intensifying its work around the five pillars of social transformation:
the state,
the economy,
organisational work,
ideological struggle, and
international work.
We will undertake these tasks conscious of our responsibility as one of the battalions of the global army for progressive social change, a disciplined force of the left.
The ANC is confident that South Africans will persist in building an enduring national partnership further to change our country for the better. Working together with them, we shall spare neither strength nor courage, until the strategic objective has been attained.
The struggle continues!
GLOSSARY
African People: The indigenous inhabitants of the country principally composed of the Zulu, Xhosa, Pedi, Sotho, Tswana, Tsonga, Swazi, Venda, Ndebele, Khoi and San.
African Renaissance: A programme to renew and rebuild the African continent, from underdevelopment, poverty and Afro-pessimism.
Anglo-Boer War: A war fought between the Afrikaners and the British between 1899 and 1902.
Apartheid Colonialism: A variant of colonialism that existed in South Africa where the coloniser and the colonised shared one country Apartheid: An oppressive system based on white minority-rule over all other population groups – Blacks in general and Africans in particular – that started long ago, but was given this name and consolidated into a vicious state policy of the Nationalist Party Government since 1948.
Archeological findings: The study of ancient civilizations by scientific analysis of physical remains found in the ground as in Mapungubwe, Cradle of Humankind and Taung.
Autonomous Leagues: The principle that the ANCYL and the ANCWL operate independently, next to and in addition to ANC structures but within the framework of the constitution and policies of the ANC.
Balance of Forces: A power balance between contending forces in a conflict: the strengths and weaknesses of each contender at each moment.
Battalion: A section of the army
Bedrock: Foundation stone. Cornerstone.
Black People: These are the people in our country who suffered from apartheid generally composed of Africans, Coloureds and Indians.
Bureaucracy: A civil service of the state.
Bureaucratic Bourgeoisie: A capitalist class that depends for its existence and survival on the state through tenders, corruption and so on Bygone era: Past period
Capitalism: A system that makes profit by exploiting people who work for a wage.
Chasm: A big gap.
Classes: Large groups of people involved in social production, who differ from each other by the place
Codification: Made into law
Cold War: A situation of uneasiness in some instances involving arms race, contest for spheres of influence and propaganda warfare, that never involved direct physical confrontation between the Soviet Union and the United States and their allies since the end of the Second World War.
Colonialism of a Special Type: A variant of colonialism where both the coloniser and the colonised share the same boundaries, within same territory of one state.
Colonialism: When countries establish their rule in other parts of the world outside their national borders.
Colony: A country or territory forcibly deprived of political and economic independence by a foreign state and exploited for the benefit of that other country.
Communication and technological revolution: Significant advancements in the computer field, that resulted in the development of robotics, cellular telephones, digital networks and the Internet.
Comprador bourgeoisie: A pseudo-capitalist that is a front, a public face or a representative of the real bourgeoisie, local or transnational.
Concentric Circles: An arrangement where the centre is the core and the less connected to the centre, the more to the outer periphery, the less significant Consensus: Agreement of almost everyone involved.
Corruption: Dishonesty especially offering and/or accepting bribes for performance of some function
Cradle of Humankind: A place where because of archeological and palaeontological findings indicates that human evolution from its early stages flourished.
Currency speculation: Plotting and foreseeing how currencies are likely to perform in the stock market and taking advantage of this by playing the market.
Developmental State: An activist state that intervenes decisively in the economy with a generally progressive agenda
Eliminate: Bring to an end
Emancipation: Liberation from bondage, and the obtaining of the right to determine a community or nation’s destiny.
Endogenous factors: Factors that influence the balance of forces from within.
Endowments: Benefits
Epoch: An important stage in the development of society with historical implications both domestically and at an international level.
Evolution: Gradual development that leads to change overtime Exogenous factors: Factors that influence the balance of forces from outside.
Feminisation of poverty: When women personify poverty. When women carry the burden of poverty in a patriarchal society
Feudalism: Landlordism. A class divided society of big landowners and serves who worked on the farms
Fratricidal ethnic groups: Ethnic groups that wage intra-communal warfare.
Freedom Charter: A document containing the essential policy of the ANC, adopted by the Congress of the People in 1955 and adopted by the ANC in 1956.
Galvanise: Conscientise and mobilise
Gender relations: Relations that of economic, political and other forms of social power between males and females, and in recent centuries it has been reflected in the domination of men and the subordination of women.
Genocide: Deliberate extermination of people on a large scale
Globalisation: The internationalisation of production, exchange and distribution of wealth, as well as culture and communication, which is currently reflected in the expansion of capitalism and its rules and methods across the world.
Harare Declaration: A Charter of the OAU Sub- Committee on Southern Africa, meeting at Harare in August 1989 which outlined the steps to be taken to find a negotiated settlement in South Africa.
Hemorrhaging: Bleed to death
Historical injustice: Unjust relations in Society that have accumulated over a period of time.
Human civilisation: The existence of a human race on earth and its advancement in all areas of social activity.
Hyper-power: An ultra super-power like the US after the Cold War
Ideological Struggle: A battle of ideas Imperialism: A stage of capitalism characterised by the high degree of concentration and centralisation of production, emergence of giant monopolies and efforts to dominate the world by the capitalist powers.
Insurrection: An intense mass uprising that can lead to take-over of state power.
Intelligentsia: The intellectuals. The educated crop of society
Legacy: An inheritance of those who came before to those who came after Macro-social trends: Those major movements that are taking place within society like migration, urbanisation, etc.
Marginalisation: A feeling of being an outsider, not engaged or disregarded, both real and imagined
Metropolis: The colonial power. A state that extends its power to other parts of the world outside its national border.
Millennium: A period of a thousand years.
Motive forces: These forces that benefit when a revolution is victorious, and often push for its success.
Multilateral institutions: Those institutions that govern international inter-state relations, involving a large number of states, such as the United Nations and its agencies.
Multilateralism: The use of international organisations and agencies like the UN, WTO, etc.
Multi-polar: More than one centre of power
Myriad: Large number
Nation: A historical community of people established on the basis of a common economic life, live a common territory and share a common identity about that territory.
National Democratic Revolution: A process of struggle that seeks to transfer power to the people and transform society into a non-racial, non-sexist, united, democratic one, and changes the manner in which wealth is shared, in order to benefit all the people.
National Liberation Movement: An array of forces organised to achieve political freedom: in South Africa it took the form of the Tripartite Alliance, the Mass Democratic Movement and other sectoral forces, led by the ANC.
National Oppression: The system which suppressed and discriminated against the African people in particular and Blacks in general. Neo-liberalism: See globalisation.
Oppression: A situation where a category of people are held in a subservient position of total inequality by another.
Ostentatiousness: Negative display of wealth and possessions intended to impress people or make them envious; like flashy cars, expensive houses, labeled clothes, hot furniture, dated alcohol and jewelry.
Paradigm: Pattern
Parasitic bourgeoisie: A capitalist class that depends for its existence and survival on the State through tenders, corruption and so on.
Pastoral Communities: Those communities in the rural areas dependent on livestock and subsistence farming for their livelihoods.
Patriarchal: A system of male domination.
Patriotic bourgeoisie: Those people who own businesses and industries in the Country and remain loyal to the objectives of society as a whole.
Peaceful forms of resistance: Forms of struggle such as petitions, demonstrations, strikes and boycotts such as pursued by the ANC from 1912 to 1961. This policy changed with the adoption of armed struggle in 1961.
Peasantry: Those people who depend on land for their livelihood
Perception: A concrete and sensual image of objects of reality resulting from their direct impact on sense organs. Socially, it means an interpretation of events on the basis of concrete experience or of the influence of others.
Political incumbency: Being in state system
Political liberation: To get freedom to elect your own government, be represented in all bodies that make laws, to have a new flag and a new anthem.
Protracted: Taking a long time
Pseudo: A false or unreal.
Racial superiority: A backward mentality of imagining that some races are superior and better than others
Rampant: Unrestrained
Rapacious: Greedy with desire to rob and plunder
Revolution: Fundamental change in society.
Ruling bloc: Those forces that hold decisive elements of state control directly and indirectly by various means.
Slave revolts: Uprising by slaves against the system of slavery
Slavery: A class divided society of slave owners and slaves who lived and worked under inhuman conditions
Social Cohesion: A feeling of being together as one
Social Distance: A real and imagined distance in lifestyle, interaction and even geography between deployed cadres or leadership and the masses of our people.
Socialism: A social system midway between capitalism and communism
Sovereignty: State independence and official status for its decisions, borders and existence.
Statist: Putting too much focus on the State both in theory and practice
Stoicism: Extraordinary bravery, courage and steadfastness.
Strategic objective: The final aim to be achieved by the freedom struggle, to establish a non-racial, non-sexist, united, democratic society.
Strategy: The long-term objective and how to arrive there.
Stratification: Division into layers each with a different status.
Subjugation: To be put in an inferior or oppressed position
Survivalist micro-entrepreneurial activity: Those methods of living from hand to mouth, from day to day
Symbiosis: A mutual relationship of benefiting from each other
Tactics: The immediate things that are done depending on objective situation to arrive at the strategic goal.
Terrorism: Deliberate targeting of civilians in conflict they occupy in that system of social production.
Tripartite Alliance: An Alliance of the national liberation forces as led by the ANC, composed of working class organisations in the form of the Communist Party and a progressive trade union movement.
Triple Oppression: The oppression of women in South Africa that usually take the form of class, race and gender
Ultra-leftism: Excessive subjectivism that confuses what is desirable with what is objectively possible here and now.
Unilateralism: When one superpower by-passes and undermines the UN and other multilateral bodies and takes action on its own in the world, almost as a global policeman.
Unipolar World: The collapse of the Cold War two bloc world system and the ascendance of the U.S as the only surviving superpower.
The KrotoaSA Foundation, and the Indigenous Alliance Collective, reject and distance ourselves from the flawed debate on “WHO OWNS THE CAPE? “on 24 June 2026 at the Academia Library.
The KrotoaSA Foundation is a South African non-profit entity built on the philosophy and vision of its founder which serves as a catalyst for the “ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS”. It is operating as a think tank, policy centre, knowledge hub, “Restoring Indigenous Memory” and advocacy group dedicated to the continents socio-economic and indigenous renewal. Alkebulan Indigenous center on the rights, self-determination, and protection of Indigenous People which involve resolving historic injustices, combating structural discrimination, protecting sacred lands and environments, preserving cultural identities, and achieving equitable health and socio-economic holistic outcomes.
We have the ethical right and power to reject and distance ourselves from the debate that excludes the affected KhoiKhoiXam indigenous tribes, clans and population. Participating in such a debate can inadvertently legitimize flawed extractive, exploitative and predestined outcomes, creating the illusion of a fair, inclusive consensus. We reject the “CODESA 3” event which demonstrates the same patterns as the CODESA 1 & 2 exclusion of the indigenous population and tokenism participation.
We reject all forms of tokenism and put on record that no participant has a mandate or consent from the Indigenous Population to engage on this topic and or any other topic affecting the indigenous marginalized populations land, culture, identity, heritage etc. without giving us a platform to speak for ourselves eliminating our lived experiences to intellectually engage the talking points.
We strongly protesting this event and would like to elevate the voices of the absent indigenous population by emphasizing our capacitated speakers that can represent and defend indigenous philosophies, narratives and ideologies on this topic.
We promote ethical inclusive dialogue for public participation, the below KrotoaSA Foundation guiding principles are designed to ensure that public engagement processes make better decisions that reflect the interest of all participants specifically the Indigenous Population.
Public Participation is a Right: Indigenous Population affected by a decision or debate have the right to be involved in the decision-making process
Input Influence Decision: The Indigenous Population contribution must genuinely influence the final decision.
Sustainable Decisions: Processes must promote sustainable decisions by recognizing and communicating the needs and interest of all Indigenous Participants.
Inclusive Involvement: Organizers of events must seek out and facilitate the involvement of the potentially affected Indigenous Population by or interested in the decisions of the debate or event.
Participants Designed: Indigenous Participants provide input into designing how they participate.
Meaningful Participation: Indigenous Participants must be provided with the information necessary to participate in a meaningful way.
Transparent Communication: Indigenous Participants must be provided with the information necessary to participate in a meaningful way like concept documents, agendas, objectives and outcomes required.
Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC): Indigenous Populations must be given all necessary information and the ability to accept, modify or reject concept documents or agendas before an event begins preferably with the first invitation or public announcement.
We invite all Indigenous TRIBES, CLANS and COUNCILS to support this media statement. A list of supporting Indigenous tribes, clans and councils will be added to this statement.
Indigenous Alliance Collective
KrotoaSA Foundation — Executive Chairperson, Dr Lendy Spires
Alkebulan Restorative Reservoir of Wisdom (AAROW) — Kai Bi’a !Kora, Dr Neville Felix
Goringhaicona Khoi Khoin Indigenous Traditional Council (GKKITC) -Autshumato Shiraatz GKKITC
Taaibosch Kei Korana Royal House — Kai Bi’a Glen Taaibosch
Gorachouqua Tribe — Regent Kai Bi’a !Kora, Dr Neville Felix
Transfrontier Kei Koranna — King and Principal National Leader, Melvyn Arendse
Katz Korana Royal House — PC Regan James
Cochoqua First Indigenous Aboriginal Tribe South Africa (CFIATSA) — King Dr John Pietersen
Yzerbeck Korana Royal House — King Daniel Beck
Chainuqua Sousoequa Kingdom — Danab Goab //Gam Ta Gab Koopman
PROTECTION, PROMOTION, DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE ACT 6 OF 2019
[Updated to 19 August 2019.**]
**Date of last changes incorporated in this Act.
________________________
(English text signed by President.)
(Assented to 13 August 2019.)
__________________________
Published: G. 42647, 19 August 2019
Commencement: To be proclaimed
ACT
To provide for the protection, promotion, development and management of indigenous knowledge; to provide for the establishment and functions of the National Indigenous Knowledge Systems Office; to provide for the management of rights of indigenous knowledge communities; to provide for the establishment and functions of the Advisory Panel on indigenous knowledge; to provide for access and conditions of access to knowledge of indigenous communities; to provide for the recognition of prior learning; to provide for the facilitation and coordination of indigenous knowledge-based innovation; and to provide for matters incidental thereto.
Preamble
RECOGNISING that the liberation of South Africa and its people from centuries of racial discriminatory colonial rule and domination and the establishment of a constitutional democracy was, is and will remain a historic achievement of all our people;
EMPHASISING that the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, enshrines the founding values of human dignity, the achievement of equality, non-racism and non-sexism, as well as the Bill of Rights entrenches inalienable rights to and freedom of human dignity, equality, education, culture, religion, language, research, creativity, environment and property, among others;
NOTING that the Republic of South Africa as a sovereign democratic state has taken its rightful place in the family of sovereign states and is committed and obligated to observe international treaties, covenants, as well as international law;
REALISING that the Government of the Republic of South Africa is committed to the economic, cultural and social upliftment and well-being of its people, free of discrimination;
TAKING into account that in the exercise of its sovereignty, South Africa has enacted and continues to enact legislation that underpins the protection, promotion and development of indigenous knowledge systems and indigenous knowledge;
RECOGNISING that indigenous knowledge is a national asset and that it is therefore in the national interest to protect and promote indigenous knowledge through law, policy and both public and private sector programmes;
WISHING to encourage the use of indigenous knowledge in the development of novel, socially and economically applicable products and services;
ACCEPTING that indigenous innovation is a unique approach to social innovation that informs and underpins the work of indigenous communities,
BE IT THEREFORE ENACTED by the Parliament of the Republic of South Africa, as follows:—
ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS
CHAPTER 1
DEFINITIONS
Definitions
CHAPTER 2
APPLICATION AND OBJECTS OF ACT
Application of Act
Objects of Act
CHAPTER 3
NATIONAL INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS OFFICE
Establishment of NIKSO
Functions and Powers of NIKSO
Administration of NIKSO
Establishment of Advisory Panel
Role of Advisory Panel
CHAPTER 4
PROTECTION OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Subject matter of protection
Term of protection
Eligibility criteria for protection
Vesting of rights in indigenous knowledge
Rights conferred
CHAPTER 5
RECOGNITION OF PRIOR LEARNING OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE PRACTITIONERS
Accreditation of assessors
Certification of indigenous knowledge practitioners
Register of Designations
CHAPTER 6
REGISTRATION OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Registration Office for Indigenous Knowledge
Curator of indigenous knowledge
Register of indigenous knowledge
Registration of indigenous knowledge
Inspection of Register
Certificates of Curator to be prima facie evidence
Register to be constructive notice
Amendment of Register
CHAPTER 7
COMMERCIAL UTILISATION OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Product development, commercialisation, services and processes
Access to and use of indigenous knowledge
CHAPTER 8
ENFORCEMENT OF RIGHTS
Dispute Resolution Committee
Offences and penalties
CHAPTER 9
GENERAL PROVISIONS
Transnational arrangements
Multiple claims to indigenous knowledge
Regulations
Effect on other laws
Transitional arrangements
Short title and commencement
CHAPTER 1
DEFINITIONS
Definitions
In this Act, unless the context indicates otherwise—
“access” includes the acquisition of indigenous knowledge by natural and legal persons as facilitated by NIKSO in terms of this Act;
“accreditation” means a formal procedure by which NIKSO grants or delegates authority to an assessor to assess and verify the qualification of indigenous knowledge practitioners in accordance with pre-determined requirements for purpose of certification;
“assessor” means a qualified person accredited and assigned by NIKSO to assess applicants according to applicable pre-determined standards having regard to that person’s possession of indigenous knowledge, expertise and skills for the purpose of being certified as an indigenous knowledge practitioner;
“benefit sharing” means the fair and equitable sharing of monetary and non-monetary benefits in terms of a benefit sharing agreement between the trustee of the indigenous community and the licence holder;
“certification”, in respect of indigenous knowledge practitioners, means the formal qualification acknowledgment, subject to an assessment by an assessor of a practitioner within a discipline or practice, according to applicable, pre-determined standards, having regard to that person’s possession of indigenous knowledge expertise and skills;
“commercial use” means the use of indigenous knowledge for financial gain;
“Constitution” means the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996;
“cultural and social identity” means the particular and distinctive identity or characteristics of a certain indigenous community or of an individual as far as he or she is influenced by belonging to a certain indigenous community;
“Curator” means the Curator of indigenous knowledge, who is the head of the Registration Office of Indigenous Knowledge appointed in terms of section 18 of this Act;
“Department” means the department responsible for science and technology;
“discipline of practice” means a group of people who share the same understanding and methodology of a given practice, craft or profession, which—
(a) evolved spontaneously; or
(b) is created based on people’s engagement,
in a process of collective learning in a shared domain of human endeavour;
“functional”, in relation to indigenous knowledge, means knowledge that is scientific and, or technical in nature;
“indigenous community” means any recognisable community of people—
(a) developing from, or historically settled in a geographic area or areas located within the borders of the Republic;
(b) characterised by social, cultural and economic conditions, which distinguish them from other sections of the national community; and
(c) who identify themselves as a distinct collective;
“indigenous cultural expression” means expressions that have a cultural content that developed within indigenous communities and have assimilated into their cultural and social identity, including but not limited to—
(a) phonetic or verbal expressions;
(b) musical or sound expressions;
(c) expressions by action; and
(d) action tangible expressions;
“indigenous knowledge” means knowledge which has been developed within an indigenous community and has been assimilated into the cultural and social identity of that community, and includes—
(a) knowledge of a functional nature;
(b) knowledge of natural resources; and
(c) indigenous cultural expressions;
“indigenous knowledge practitioner” means a person who is certified as sufficiently knowledgeable in indigenous knowledge practices to render a related service, subject to section 15 of this Act and relevant prescribed practice standards being met;
“licence holder” means any person who successfully enters into a licence agreement with an indigenous community to use indigenous knowledge;
“Minister” means the Minister responsible for science and technology;
“natural resources” means any materials and components that can be found within the environment and may exist as a separate entity, such as genetic resources, fresh water, air, and mineral deposits with actual or potential use or value;
“NIKSO” means the National Indigenous Knowledge Systems Office established in section 4;
“prescribed” means prescribed by regulations;
“prior informed consent” means the consent in respect of indigenous knowledge granted by a trustee, which has been obtained—
(a) free from any manipulation, interference or coercion;
(b) after full disclosure of the intent and scope of the activity; and
(c) in a language and process understandable to the community;
“Registration Office” means the Registration Office for Indigenous Knowledge within NIKSO;
“Register” means the Register of indigenous knowledge provided for in section 19, and includes any official documents, compilations or records, including databases, reflecting information in respect of indigenous knowledge kept by NIKSO;
“Register of Designations” means a register of names and levels of competencies of certified indigenous knowledge practitioners and accredited assessors;
“regulations” means regulations made in terms of this Act;
“this Act” includes the regulations; and
“trustee” means a natural or legal person that is duly delegated in terms of the practices of an indigenous community to represent that indigenous community in matters pertaining to indigenous knowledge and to be vested with the custodianship of indigenous knowledge emanating from it, which person is deemed to be a trustee appointed in terms of the law of trusts and to have the powers and duties of such a trustee, with any reference in this Act to an act performed, or the rights held, by an indigenous community deemed to be a reference to that act performed, or rights held, by the trustee of that indigenous community.
CHAPTER 2
APPLICATION AND OBJECTS OF ACT
Application of Act
This Act applies to all—
(a) persons in the Republic, including the State; and
(b) indigenous knowledge registered under this Act.
Objects of Act
The objects of this Act are to—
(a) protect the indigenous knowledge of indigenous communities from unauthorised use, misappropriation and misuse;
(b) promote public awareness and understanding of indigenous knowledge for the wider application and development thereof;
(c) develop and enhance the potential of indigenous communities to protect their indigenous knowledge;
(d) regulate the equitable distribution of benefits;
(e) promote the commercial use of indigenous knowledge in the development of new products, services and processes;
(f) provide for registration, cataloguing, documentation and recording of indigenous knowledge held by indigenous communities;
(g) establish mechanisms for the accreditation of assessors and the certification of indigenous knowledge practitioners; and
(h) recognise indigenous knowledge as prior art under intellectual property laws.
CHAPTER 3
NATIONAL INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS OFFICE
Establishment of NIKSO
NIKSO is hereby established within the Department.
Functions and powers of NIKSO
The functions and powers of NIKSO include—
(a) implementation of this Act;
(b) protecting and recognising indigenous knowledge as property owned by indigenous communities;
(c) facilitating the redress of rights and benefits to indigenous communities which have previously been deprived of such rights and benefits;
(d) facilitating and coordinating the development of indigenous knowledge;
(e) establishing and managing the registration of assessors and indigenous knowledge practitioners;
(f) empowering indigenous communities through education and awareness campaigns to enable them to recognise and utilise indigenous knowledge for cultural and economic benefit;
(g) determining the criteria for issuing licences for the use of indigenous knowledge;
(h) certifying licence agreements for the use of indigenous knowledge;
(i) assisting indigenous communities in the negotiation of benefit sharing agreements for the use of indigenous knowledge;
(j) facilitating the negotiation of licences between trustees and users for the use of indigenous knowledge for commercial purposes;
(k) making recommendations to the Minister regarding norms and standards for the certification of indigenous practitioners;
(l) liaising with the Department to facilitate the entering into of licence agreements with users of indigenous knowledge on behalf of an indigenous community where the relevant indigenous community cannot be identified;
(m) ensuring that the Register of Designations is maintained and made available; and
(n) carrying out any functions that are consistent with the objects of this Act.
Administration of NIKSO
(1) The Minister must appoint a suitably skilled and qualified person as the Head of NIKSO in accordance with the Public Service Act, 1994 (Proclamation 103 of 1994).
(2) The Head of NIKSO—
(a) is responsible for the administration and general management of NIKSO, subject to directions and instructions issued by the Minister or the Director-General as delegated by the Minister; and
(b) must report to the Director-General on all matters relating to the management of NIKSO.
(3) The staff of NIKSO consists of such number of employees as may be—
(a) appointed by the Minister, in accordance with the Public Service Act, 1994; or
(b) seconded from any organ of state,
as are necessary to enable NIKSO to perform its functions.
Establishment of Advisory Panel
(1) The Minister may establish an Advisory Panel based on criteria as prescribed, consisting of a minimum of five, but no more than ten, members on specific matters relating to the objects of this Act.
(2) The Advisory Panel must be broadly representative of the—
(a) different relevant government departments;
(b) indigenous knowledge practitioners;
(c) industry; and
(d) specialists in the discipline of practice,
based on criteria as prescribed.
(3) The Advisory Panel may be convened by the Head of NIKSO, as and when the need arises.
(4) The members of the Advisory Panel, with the exclusion of subsection (2) (a) representatives who are subject to public service remuneration prescriptions, must only be remunerated for time spent on the business of NIKSO, in accordance with rates determined by the Minister, with the concurrence of the Minister of Finance.
(5) A member of the Advisory Panel holds office for a period of three years and may, upon expiry of that period, be reappointed for a further period of three years.
(6) Notwithstanding subsection (5), for the sake of continuity, the Minister may reappoint a core of at least three members of the Advisory Panel, as prescribed.
(7) The Minister may, subject to the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act, 2000 (Act 3 of 2000), remove a member of the Advisory Panel for—
(a) non-performance;
(b) serious misconduct;
(c) conduct that undermines the integrity or objective of the Advisory Panel; or
(d) being convicted of a criminal offence and sentenced to imprisonment without the option of a fine.
(8) NIKSO must provide administrative and secretarial support to the Advisory Panel.
(9) For the purpose of subsection (2) (c), “industry” means any sector of an economy dealing in the commercial use of indigenous knowledge based products and services.
Role of Advisory Panel
The Advisory Panel must—
(a) provide expert and strategic advice to NIKSO in respect of the protection, promotion, development and management of indigenous knowledge;
(b) assist with the mobilisation of indigenous communities for purposes of pursuing specific activities conducted by NIKSO; and
(c) advise NIKSO on any specific issue referred to it and execute any task that NIKSO may entrust to it in terms of this Act.
CHAPTER 4
PROTECTION OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Subject matter of protection
(1) This Act protects registered indigenous knowledge.
(2) Indigenous knowledge constitutes property of indigenous communities within the meaning of section 25 of the Constitution.
Term of protection
(1) Indigenous knowledge is protected for as long as it meets the eligibility criteria set out in section 11.
(2) If indigenous knowledge ceases to meet the eligibility criteria set out in section 11, it falls into the public domain from the date of proven ineligibility.
Eligibility criteria for protection
The protection of indigenous knowledge contemplated in section 9 applies to indigenous knowledge, which—
(a) has been passed on from generation to generation within an indigenous community;
(b) has been developed within an indigenous community; and
(c) is associated with the cultural and social identity of that indigenous community.
Vesting of rights in indigenous knowledge
(1) Subject to section 9, the custodianship of indigenous knowledge eligible for protection vests in the trustee of that indigenous community.
(2) The trustee of the indigenous community—
(a) holds the indigenous knowledge in trust on behalf of the indigenous community; and
(b) is responsible for and accountable to the indigenous community for the protection of their rights.
(3) In the event that, and for as long as, the indigenous community of the relevant indigenous knowledge cannot be identified and designated, NIKSO must act as custodian of that indigenous knowledge, with the rights and obligations of a trustee in respect of that indigenous knowledge.
Rights conferred
(1) Subject to subsection (3), the indigenous community holding indigenous knowledge has the exclusive right to—
(a) any benefits arising from its commercial use;
(b) be acknowledged as its origin; and
(c) limit any unauthorised use of the indigenous knowledge.
(2) Subject to subsection (3), a person wishing to make commercial use of indigenous knowledge must—
(a) apply through NIKSO for a licence in accordance with section 26 (1); and
(b) when so applying, must indicate—
(i) the identity of the indigenous community;
(ii) the place of origin of the indigenous knowledge; and
(iii) whether prior informed consent of the indigenous community has been obtained and a benefit sharing arrangement entered into with that indigenous community.
(3) An individual member of the indigenous community holding indigenous knowledge who wishes to make commercial use of the indigenous knowledge—
(a) must obtain permission from the indigenous community; and
(b) may only make commercial use of that indigenous knowledge in a manner and subject to the indigenous community imposed terms and conditions as formalised in an agreement with the trustee.
CHAPTER 5
RECOGNITION OF PRIOR LEARNING OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE PRACTITIONERS
Accreditation of assessors
(1) A certified indigenous knowledge practitioner may apply to NIKSO in the prescribed manner for recognition and accreditation as an assessor.
(2) In processing a subsection (1) application, NIKSO—
(a) must evaluate each application in accordance with the prescribed procedures and requirements; and
(b) may issue an accreditation certificate to act as an assessor if it is satisfied that the applicant meets the prescribed criteria.
(3) NIKSO may impose any reasonable conditions on such accreditation.
(4) NIKSO may, in the prescribed manner, cancel the accreditation of an assessor, if the assessor has—
(a) made a false declaration or intentionally submitted a fraudulent application to NIKSO;
(b) failed to comply with or contravened any of the conditions of the accreditation;
(c) failed or refused to comply with the prescribed accreditation process;
(d) accepted unlawful compensation, in respect of the certification of an indigenous knowledge practitioner;
(e) charged excessive or unreasonable fees in respect of the certification of an indigenous knowledge practitioner;
(f) undermined, through any act of omission, the interests of the discipline or practice for which the assessor is registered; or
(g) been convicted of a criminal offence and sentenced to imprisonment without the option of a fine.
(5) The Minister must prescribe accreditation procedures to be followed by registered assessors.
Certification of indigenous knowledge practitioners
(1) Any person who wishes to register their qualifications as an indigenous knowledge practitioner must apply, in the prescribed manner, to NIKSO to be so certified and recorded in the Register of Designations.
(2) NIKSO may refer the application for certification to an assessor for assessment and recommendation.
(3) In assessing the eligibility of an applicant, the assessor must apply the prescribed norms and standards for certification of indigenous knowledge practitioners.
(4) Upon completion of the assessment, if an applicant meets all the prescribed requirements, the assessor must recommend to NIKSO that a certificate of competency be issued to the applicant for purposes of certification.
(5) Subject to subsection (4), NIKSO must—
(a) issue the certificate of competency to the applicant; and
(b) record the applicant as a certified indigenous knowledge practitioner in the Register of Designations.
(6) Subject to subsection (5), no indigenous knowledge practitioner may practice for gain, unless the practitioner is registered with the relevant government department and been granted permission to practice in terms of the applicable prescribed practice standards.
(7) NIKSO may, in the prescribed manner, revoke the certification of an indigenous knowledge practitioner if such practitioner has—
(a) made a false declaration or intentionally submitted a fraudulent application to NIKSO;
(b) failed or refused to comply with the prescribed certification procedures;
(c) failed to comply with or contravened any of the conditions set out in the certificate;
(d) undermined, through any act or omission, the interests of the discipline of practice for which the practitioner is certified;
(e) been convicted of a criminal offence and sentenced to imprisonment without the option of a fine; or
(f) voluntarily relinquished practice as an indigenous knowledge practitioner.
(8) The Minister must prescribe application standards and procedures to be followed by applicants.
Register of Designations
(1) NIKSO must—
(a) keep the Register of Designations in the prescribed manner; and
(b) ensure the security of the Register of Designations.
(2) Where information may be accessed by persons other than the indigenous community or an individual within that indigenous community, NIKSO must facilitate such access on payment of a prescribed fee.
CHAPTER 6
REGISTRATION OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Registration Office for Indigenous Knowledge
NIKSO must establish a Registration Office for Indigenous Knowledge.
Curator of indigenous knowledge
(1) The Minister must appoint a suitably skilled and qualified person as the Curator of indigenous knowledge in accordance with the Public Service Act, 1994 (Proclamation 103 of 1994).
(2) The Curator is responsible for the control of the Registration Office, subject to the directions and instructions issued by the Minister or the Director-General as delegated by the Minister.
(3) The Curator may delegate any of the powers and entrust any of the duties assigned to him or her by this Act, to any officer within NIKSO.
(4) The Curator must permit the trustee to act on behalf of the indigenous community for whom he or she is a trustee, in connection with registration under this Act or any proceeding relating thereto.
Register of indigenous knowledge
(1) NIKSO must—
(a) keep a Register of Indigenous Knowledge in the prescribed manner; and
(b) ensure the security of the Register.
(2) The Curator must record in respect of each item of indigenous knowledge—
(a) the particulars of the indigenous community from which the indigenous knowledge originates;
(b) whether the indigenous knowledge is functional indigenous knowledge or an indigenous cultural expression, or both;
(c) whether the information provided may only be shared with persons outside the indigenous community with its prior informed consent;
(d) whether any agreements have been entered into between an outside party and the indigenous community;
(e) whether the indigenous knowledge is closely related to indigenous knowledge registered by another indigenous community, and if so, details of that indigenous knowledge; and
(f) any such other particulars as may be prescribed.
(3) The Register is presumed to be evidence of any matters directed or authorised by this Act to be recorded therein.
Registration of indigenous knowledge
(1) The trustee of an indigenous community may apply to the Curator in the prescribed manner for the registration of indigenous knowledge.
(2) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Curator may—
(a) approve the application;
(b) approve the application subject to any conditions or limitations, and register the indigenous knowledge; or
(c) reject the application if it does not meet the criteria set out in section 11.
(3) The Curator must, within 30 days after the registration of the indigenous knowledge—
(a) issue to the applicant a certificate of registration in the prescribed form; and
(b) publish, in the prescribed form, a notice of registration in the Indigenous Knowledge Bulletin and any appropriate publication.
(4) In order to exercise any right in respect of indigenous knowledge under this Act, the indigenous community must register the indigenous knowledge in terms of Chapter 6.
Inspection of Register
(1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Curator must make the Register available for inspection by the public during working hours, upon payment of the prescribed fee.
(2) Notwithstanding subsection (1), additional documents relating to the registration of indigenous knowledge may only be made available to the public, if the person seeking access enters into a prescribed non-disclosure agreement.
(3) The Curator must, as prescribed, at the request of any person, and on payment of the prescribed fee, furnish a copy of an extract of the Register, or a copy of a certificate of registration.
Certificates of Curator to beprima facie evidence
(1) A certificate appearing to be issued by the Curator, in respect of any record authorised by this Act, is presumed evidence of the content thereof and action authorised therein, unless proven otherwise.
(2) In any judicial proceedings—
(a) printed or written copies or extracts appearing to be copies of or extracts from the Register; or
(b) any document relating to indigenous knowledge certified by the Curator of the Registration Office,
is presumed evidence of the content thereof, unless proven otherwise, and may be admitted as evidence without further proof or production of the original.
Register to be constructive notice
In any proceedings regarding the rights registered in respect of indigenous knowledge, it may be presumed—
(a) that every party to those proceedings was aware of the particulars entered in the Register from the date of the section 20 (3) (b) publication; and
(b) that any person using the indigenous knowledge did so knowing that it was registered and that it was a pre-condition of use that the person should have entered into a benefit sharing agreement before commencing use.
Amendment of Register
(1) The Curator may—
(a) upon receiving an application from an interested person in the prescribed manner; and
(b) after granting the indigenous community an opportunity to make representations in response to the application, amend the Register.
(2) The Curator must amend an entry in the Register in accordance with any finding by a court.
CHAPTER 7
COMMERCIAL UTILISATION OF INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Product development, commercialisation, services and processes
(1) NIKSO may, at the request of an indigenous community, provide assistance or facilitate the commercial use of its indigenous knowledge.
(2) NIKSO must, in respect of commercial use of indigenous knowledge—
(a) promote partnerships for innovation and product development;
(b) coordinate funding;
(c) develop market strategies; and
(d) promote commercial use of products, services, processes and the use of technology.
Access to and use of indigenous knowledge
(1) Any person who intends to use indigenous knowledge for commercial purposes must—
(a) apply in the prescribed manner for a licence authorising the use of that indigenous knowledge; and
(b) enter into a licence agreement with the trustee of the relevant indigenous community for the use of that indigenous knowledge,
as facilitated by NIKSO.
(2) NIKSO must consult with the trustee on the terms of the subsection (1) (b) licence agreement for the intended use and benefits payable by the licence holder.
(3) In the event that the indigenous knowledge, which is the subject of the licence agreement, is—
(a) functional in nature, then any obligation on the part of the licence holder to pay a royalty expires 20 years after the date of agreement; and
(b) an indigenous cultural expression, then any obligation on the part of the user to pay a royalty expires 50 years after the date of agreement.
(4) No prior informed consent for the use of indigenous knowledge is required for—
(a) criticism or academic review;
(b) reporting news or current events;
(c) judicial proceedings;
(d) any use that is incidental to the above purposes; and
(e) in circumstances of national emergencies or natural disasters, as long as the relevant indigenous community is compensated for the use of their indigenous knowledge.
(5) A licence holder must, subject to subsection (1), acknowledge the relevant indigenous community by mentioning them or the geographical place from which the indigenous knowledge originated.
(6) Any person who is aggrieved by a NIKSO decision or the conditions imposed with regard to access, may within 60 working days declare a dispute and refer the matter for resolution in terms of section 27.
CHAPTER 8
ENFORCEMENT OF RIGHTS
Dispute Resolution Committee
(1) The Minister may, subject to prescribed terms and conditions, appoint members of the Dispute Resolution Committee to resolve any dispute arising from this Act on an ad hoc basis.
(2) In resolving a dispute, the Dispute Resolution Committee must consider customary laws which may have a bearing on the subject matter of the dispute.
(3) Any party to a matter referred to the Dispute Resolution Committee may take the matter for review to the High Court.
(4) The Dispute Resolution Committee may, as a sanction:
(a) issue a written warning to the licence holder;
(b) issue a notice prohibiting the unauthorised use of indigenous knowledge by the licence holder; and
(c) recommend to NIKSO the cancelling, suspending or revoking of the licence rights of a licence holder.
Offences and penalties
Any third party who—
(a) knowingly makes commercial use of indigenous knowledge in a manner which is not in accordance with an agreement entered into with the indigenous community; and
(b) infringes the rights of that indigenous community,
is guilty of an offence and on conviction liable to pay a fine as prescribed.
CHAPTER 9
GENERAL PROVISIONS
Transnational arrangements
(1) Indigenous knowledge originating in a foreign jurisdiction must be given the same protection granted to indigenous knowledge originating in the Republic, if the laws of that foreign jurisdiction provide reciprocal protection to indigenous knowledge originating in the Republic.
(2) In instances where indigenous knowledge originates in one or more indigenous communities in foreign jurisdictions and in the Republic, NIKSO must assist the relevant foreign authorities and the indigenous community of the Republic to conclude an arrangement to share equitably in the proceeds accruing to the indigenous communities in terms of that benefit sharing agreement.
Multiple claims to indigenous knowledge
(1) Where there are multiple claims to indigenous knowledge, any remuneration payable under a benefit sharing agreement must be apportioned equally among the trustees.
(2) Where an existing benefit sharing agreement in terms of subsection (1) does not include all the trustees of the relevant indigenous communities, the agreement must be amended accordingly.
Regulations
(1) The Minister may make regulations regarding any matter pertaining to—
(a) the protection, promotion, development and management of indigenous knowledge;
(b) procedures for securing registration in the Register and obtaining licences to use indigenous knowledge from NIKSO;
(c) matters which may or must be prescribed in terms of this Act; and
(d) in general, any ancillary or incidental matter that it is necessary to prescribe for the proper implementation or administration of this Act.
Effect on other laws
(1) This Act does not alter or detract from any right in respect of any statute or the common law.
(2) Compliance with any procedures or requirements laid down in this Act does not constitute compliance with any procedures or requirements imposed in any other Act.
Transitional arrangements
(1) An indigenous community wishing to register indigenous knowledge already in existence at the time of commencement of this Act, must register such indigenous knowledge in terms of this Act.
(2) Any continued use of indigenous knowledge, after the commencement of this Act, must be regulated in terms of a licence agreement between the trustee of the relevant indigenous community and the potential licence holder, entered into within 12 months from the date of commencement of this Act.
Short title and commencement
This Act is called the Protection, Promotion, Development and Management of Indigenous Knowledge Act, 2019, and comes into operation on a date determined by the President by proclamation in the Gazette.
The Department of Science, Technology and Innovation gazetted draft regulations under the yet-to-be-commenced 2019 Protection, Promotion, Development and Management of Indigenous Knowledge Act, calling for public comment.
Among other things, the draft regulations provide for ‘biocultural community protocols’ as ‘instruments developed by indigenous communities’ setting out ‘clear terms and conditions to third parties for engaging with ... (them) when accessing their resources and knowledge’. This is in the context of rights conferred. Each protocol would set out access-related procedures underpinned by the principle of prior and informed consent.
It is envisaged that, using a template provided, the department would assist each affected indigenous community in developing a protocol that:
includes ‘the social processes by which indigenous knowledge is acquired and used’
sustains the knowledge system entailed, preserving its ‘distinct character’
is ‘shaped by the unique cultural and spiritual values and beliefs’ of the affected community, and
takes account of:
a community’s leadership structure in the context of its custodianship of the resources concerned, and
the rights, responsibilities and obligations of a community according to customary, national, and international law.
The draft regulations also provide for:
the registration of indigenous knowledge (with draft forms)
the accreditation of assessors (with a list of the criteria to be met)
a register of certified practitioners (with a list of the criteria to be met)
the appointment of an advisory panel (with lists of qualifying criteria and operational procedures)
Intelligent people often update beliefs mid-conversation, reflecting cognitive agility.
Higher intelligence tolerates ambiguity and thrives on revising ideas.
Belief updating showcases intelligence, while fence-sitting signals cognitive weakness.
We tend to picture intelligence as exemplary mental organization: crisp opinions, sharp delivery, and confident stances held firmly. The “smart person” in the room isn’t the one who hedges or backtracks. It’s the one who walks in already knowing the answer, delivers it cleanly, and moves on. But that picture, research increasingly suggests, has it backwards.
Highly intelligent people are not always faster, calmer, or more decisive. Sometimes, their minds are busier, slower, and more conflicted. In my work as a psychological researcher, I’ve noticed that people with higher cognitive ability are often misunderstood simply because their mental habits don’t always look the way we expect intelligence to look. Two habits in particular tend to get them misread, and both are far more cognitively sophisticated than they appear.
1. Changing Their Mind Mid-Argument
Few things irritate people more in conversation than someone who contradicts themselves. Someone who states a position with apparent confidence, then stops mid-thought and says, “Actually, I think I was wrong about that.” It reads as wishy-washy, underprepared, or lacking conviction. In a meeting, it can cost someone credibility. In an argument, it looks like surrender.
What it actually reflects, however, is one of the clearest behavioral markers of higher intelligence: belief updating, or the willingness to revise a held position when confronted with new evidence, even when that confrontation happens in real time, in public, at social cost.
A 2024 study published in Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications found consistent evidence that individuals with higher fluid intelligence changed their attitudes more readily in response to correction, while those with lower reasoning ability showed a stronger tendency to persist with misinformation even after receiving a correction message. In other words, the person in the room most willing to say “I was wrong” is often, cognitively speaking, the most capable one there.
This connects to a broader pattern researchers have identified in how intelligent people relate to uncertainty. Research shows that individuals with a lower need for cognitive closure tend to tolerate ambiguity more easily, and separate lines of work suggest that higher cognitive ability is associated with greater openness and cognitive flexibility. Where most people feel pressure to land on a position and hold it, highly intelligent individuals are more comfortable sitting in the revision process, even when that process is visible to others.
The frustrating part for observers is precisely this: the intelligent person doesn’t feel the urgency to perform with certainty before they’re ready. And if the thinking is still happening, they’ll do it out loud.
Consider the colleague who, midway through a strategy meeting, says, “I want to walk back what I said ten minutes ago,” and the room visibly deflates. To everyone else, it signals confusion. To that person’s brain, it signals that something more accurate just became available, and loyalty to the original position would mean ignoring it.
The distinction worth drawing is between belief updating and chronic fence-sitting. Updating is responsive, that is, it moves in reaction to new evidence. Fence-sitting is avoidant, as it moves in reaction to social pressure. One reflects cognitive strength. The other can signal the opposite. But in everyday settings, the two tend to get collapsed into the same frustrated label: unreliable.
2. Giving Too Much Unnecessary Context
Imagine you ask a simple question to someone and receive a five-minute answer that starts three steps before the point. There are caveats, qualifications, historical background, and exceptions to exceptions. The person doesn’t seem to register that you needed a sentence, not a seminar. It can feel patronizing, exhausting, or simply socially tone-deaf.
What you are almost certainly witnessing, however, is a well-documented cognitive phenomenon called the Curse of Knowledge—and it correlates directly with genuine expertise and deeper cognitive ability.
The Curse of Knowledge is a cognitive bias that causes the brain to overestimate how much other people understand. When we master an idea, we lose access to the memory of how it felt not to understand it. This creates a blind spot that makes it difficult to empathize with people who don’t share our background. The deeper the knowledge, the harder it is to locate the entry point for someone who doesn’t share it.
Highly intelligent people have often, entirely unconsciously, built elaborate mental scaffolding around a topic over years of thinking about it. When they try to explain it, they dismantle that scaffolding from the top down, which means they start with all the architecture you don’t yet have, rather than with the ground-floor answer you actually asked for.
When experts develop complex mental models for organizing information, the problem in communication arises because those models aren’t shared—the explanation becomes accurate, thorough and, for the listener, completely impenetrable.
To the person on the receiving end, this registers as a failure of social awareness. But it’s a side effect of too much knowledge, not too little. The highly intelligent person isn’t unable to read the room; they genuinely can’t locate where the room is relative to where their own thinking begins.
Think of the researcher who responds to “what do you work on?” with a ten-minute tour of their entire field. Or the engineer who answers “how does this feature work?” by explaining the underlying architecture from first principles. The intention is almost always generosity: a desire to give you the real answer, the full picture, the thing that actually makes sense of it. The social effect, unfortunately, is often the opposite.
It’s worth noting that the Curse of Knowledge doesn’t excuse poor communication—over time, it’s a skill gap worth closing. But understanding its origin matters. The next time someone overexplains to the point of frustration, the more useful question isn’t “why can’t they read the room?” It’s “how much do they actually know about this?” The answer, often, is more than they can easily compress.
To get content containing either thought or leadership enter:
To get content containing both thought and leadership enter:
To get content containing the expression thought leadership enter:
You can enter several keywords and you can refine them whenever you want. Our suggestion engine uses more signals but entering a few keywords here will rapidly give you great content to curate.