ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS
19.8K views | +0 today
ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS
ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS is a division of KROTOASA RESEARCH INTENSIVE INSTITUTE (KRII), which refers to all Alkebulan communities and Diaspora Slave Descendants who lost their claims to land through colonialism and slavery, also communities with deep historical indigenous ties to the lands, natural resourses and environment, who maintain unique cultures, traditional practices and self-governance,. Alkebulan is considered the oldest and indigenous name for the continent of Africa, translating to "Mother of Mankind" or "Garden of Eden". Used by ancient Moors, Nubians, and Ethiopians, it predates the European-imposed name "Africa" and represents a push to reclaim pre-colonial African identity and history.
Alkebulan Indigeon also points to the rich diversity of Africa's original inhabitants, whose traditional lives and rights are central to understanding the continent's complex history and ongoing social dynamics. These are groups of people native to a specific region, people who lived here before colonist arrived.

Indigenous People like the San and Khoekhoe population both carrying mtDNA +100 000 years in Southern Africa are recognised indigenous peoples by the United Nations and UNDRIP., These two groups chose different lifestyles as hunters and herders but after colonialsm many Khoekhoe populations became hunters due to dispossesion and Genoicide by European and Bantu Settlers. Bantu Settlers was named by the Khoekhoe people as "Xhosas" and adopting the cultures and rituals of the KhoeKhoe population, Bantu's are distinct from the majority African populations who migrated and lost their historic continuity of their culture, tribes, indigenous livestyles, territories and surrounding natural resources.

Political Participation: Indigenous People lack political representation and participation, economic marginlization and poverty, lack of access to social services, discrimination, and protection of rights.

Alkebulan's marginalization in global politics and economics stems from a mix of historical legacies of colonialism, global politics and global economic structures that favor commodity exports, leading to asymmetrical trade, capital flight, and limited industrialization. Key factors include dependence on external powers, poor infrastructure, illicit financial flows, and structural disadvantages within global trade rules, despite rich resources.

Alkebulan's revolution of sweeping transformation, primarily the anti-colonial independence movements (Decolonisation of Africa 1950 -1970s), the anti-colonial restistance, the political revolution, the economic and social revolutions, the labour revolutions with key drivers and goals of self-determination by ending foreign control and achieving political independence and economic independence by moving from exporting raw materials to manufacturing in areas where extraction taking place.
Your new post is loading...
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
October 31, 4:42 PM
Scoop.it!

A Biography of Bones: Tracing the Shifting Meanings of Griqua Remains from Their 1961 Exhumation to the Present 

A Biography of Bones: Tracing the Shifting Meanings of Griqua Remains from Their 1961 Exhumation to the Present  | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

Abstract

Buried in 1858, Cornelis Kok II’s grave lay undisturbed in Campbell, Northern Cape, until 1961 when a multiracial coalition, driven by their own sets of interests, unearthed the Griqua leader’s remains. The bones again took centre stage with the collapse of apartheid when different groups called for their return and reburial, with an assertion, variously, of ascendant Griqua, indigenous, Khoisan, and Khoikhoi identities. The 2007 reinterment again courted controversy and protest, while the contemporary neglect of the new gravesite symbolizes feelings of exclusion and marginalization among some Campbell Griqua today.
 
By tracing the life history of Kok II’s remains, well past his natural life, we demonstrate how they serve as a flashpoint mobilized by actors with different aims and objectives at different moments. These motivations range from scientistic confirmation of genealogy and identity under apartheid rule, to post-apartheid calls for repatriation anchored to a global indigenous rights framework, to factional contestations over ownership. Marshalled towards different political projects, for all these actors, the bones nonetheless serve as a resource and link to a 19th century frontier past.
 
No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
October 31, 4:15 PM
Scoop.it!

In Search of the Griqua … and their Real Identity

In Search of the Griqua … and their Real Identity | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

In search of the Griqua … and their real

21 MAY 1999, 00:00
17 min read

 

The Griqua people have a long history of dispossession. Now, with political parties courting their vote, the y are asking some searching questions about themselves. John Matshikiza went looking for the people and their leaders.

 

A quiet drama unfolds in a small room in a building squashed between the police station and the Mary Moffat Museum in Griquatown.

 

It is the office of Kaptein Johannes Jakobus Waterboer. The heir to the Griqua Paramount Chieftaincy, surrounded by a few councillors, is going over a report in the Diamond Fields Advertiser, the local version of the Johannesburg Star. The question in the report is: will the Griqua take part in the general election? There is a strong suggestion that there will be a boycott from the entire Griqua community if certain pressing questions are not resolved before June 2.

 

The key issue, as articulated by Martin Engelbrecht, national co-ordinator of the Khoisan National Council, is the recognition of the Griqua as a sovereign group within the South African constitutional arrangement. The Griqua, he argues, have slipped through the cracks of the negotiated new dispensation, and neither their language rights nor their legitimate land claims have been taken into account. As such they continue to be dispossessed. The threat of a boycott is designed to draw attention to an age-old grievance.

 

It is a finely timed intervention in the politics of the Northern Cape. Who will win the votes of the Griqua community? Is it a significant vote in any case? Who, and how many, are the Griqua?

None of the major parties have been able to avoid the issue. The National Party has always thought that it could count on the Griqua vote, packaged in as it was with the controversial, broader ”coloured” vote that secured it the Western Cape and a substantial representation in the Northern Cape in the last election.

Its successor, the New National Party, is now crying foul at what it calls the ”sudden interest” of the African National Congress and the Inkatha Freedom Party in one of their traditional strongholds , Griqualand West. The ANC and the IFP, in turn, along with lesser parties, are frantically courting rival claimants to the Griqua throne. It seems that there is more at stake than the usual campaign politics.

 

So who are these Griqua that are causing all the excitement?

Alf Wannenburgh, in his book Forgotten Frontiersmen, paints a compelling picture of the Griqua as a tribe of nomadic hunters and traders, descended from South Africa’s oldest inhabitants, but with their blood mixed with many other nationalities. The founding father, Adam Kok, was a leader of a series of migrations that preceded the Great Trek, and gave his name to the town of Kokstad, on the border between KwaZulu-Natal and the Transkei.

Kok and his successors made and remade alliances with Xhosa, Zulu and Afrikaner groups and individuals whose way of life was being threatened by the expansion of the Cape colony. The Griqua personified the last frontiers of a noble resistance.

 

In the end, the last strands of the resisting Griqua retreated into the sands of the Namib desert, and their history all but came to a halt.

 

And yet the name lived on. It was a sort of a joke. Their blood was scattered all across Southern Africa, but no one came forward and said, ”I am a Griqua.” Not with pride, anyway. They became a strategic addendum to the human category classified as ”coloured”. In the old system, the Griqua were one of 10 official categories of non-whites and non- Africans, along with Indians, Chinese, ”Cape coloureds” and ”other coloureds”. In terms of group areas, education and general perception they were coloured.

 

Through most of the four decades of apartheid government, the Griqua’s interests were spoken for by a man named Bishop Daniel Kanyiles. He held the title of Paramount Chief of the Griquas of Griqualand West and Albania, but he was not part of the bloodline of Adam Kok or any of the other Griqua Chiefs. Some claim that he was not even a Griqua. He was, and still is, a staunch member of the National Party. He runs Griqua affairs from the Provincial Capital of Kimberley, and is seldom seen in Griquatown.

 

Griquatown is a quiet village on a spur between Upington and Kimberley. There is one main street, on which sits the one hotel, along with the instruments of law and order and the museum that valiantly keeps a record of its history.

What I was looking for, however, was not the fragments of stone and wood and faded photographs captured in the glass cases of the tiny museum. I was looking for real Griqua who could tell me their story. I thought this would be easy, standing here in Griquatown. I was wrong.

 

The curator of the museum tried to be helpful, but there was something preventing her being direct about my question about the Griqua. She called a young coloured lady out of the building next door and asked her if she could help me. The young lady called two men out to come and join in the discussion. They all looked at me appraisingly for a long while, and then shyly muttered that it would be impossible to do anything until ”the kaptein” was around. The kaptein was away in Kimberley having discussions with Premier Manne Dipico. His deputy was with him. No one else was entitled to speak to strangers about the Griqua.

 

I was baffled. Haltingly, I asked one of the young men if he was not himself a Griqua. He laughed in amazement. He was a coloured, he said. He couldn’t tell me anything about any Griqua. One of them tried to suggest to the others that there was an old Griqua woman in the Griqua township who might be able to tell me something, but the others discouraged this initiative, for fear of terrible retribution on the kaptein’s return.

 

Like any other uitlander, I was baffled. At that time, I didn’t realise that the line between Griqua and coloureds was such a defined one, and that penetrating it could be so difficult. There was a huge, almost terrified silence about the Griqua in Griquatown.

I left my contact details for the kaptein, and moved on, holding out little hope that I would be able to speak to him.

 

It took three weeks before I was able to have a face-to-face meeting with Kaptein JJ Waterboer. In the interim I had several hushed telephone conversations with an Afrikaner woman who appeared to be the kaptein’s spokesperson and champion. She spoke on condition that I did not identify her in anything I wrote about the Griqua. The plot was getting thicker.

 

The kaptein, she told me, spoke very little English, and I was unable to communicate in Afrikaans. Therefore she would speak for him.

She conveyed the impression of a man who immediately impressed with his regal authority. She was a believer in his claim to the Griqua throne. She proceeded to tell me softly about the history of the Griqua of Griquatown, and why it was that the restoration of their monarch and their dignity was of such urgency.

 

She told me the history of Kaptein JJ Waterboer’s forbears from the early 1800s – how the Waterboers had assumed authority over the region when Adam Kok, frustrated by the interfering missionaries who wanted to tell him how he should govern his people, had left Griquatown and settled first in Campbell, 50km to the east, and then in Philippolis and Kokstad to the south, the area that became Griqualand East. Andries Waterboer, and his son Nikolaas after him, kept the Griqua flag flying in Griqualand West, and when the remnants of Kok’s people finally returned to Campbell in the latter part of the 19th century, it was accepted that Waterboer was the Paramount Chief.

 

This was not enough to guarantee stability, however. Waterboer’s territory was being pressured by the Cape colony and the Boer republics. The Griqua chief went to the supreme court to fight for his territorial rights. After seven years, in 1871, the court found in his favour. But 1871 was also, critically, the year that diamonds were found at Kimberley, in the northern part of the Griqua territories. This was a different ball game. A second supreme court judgment ruled that, although Waterboer was indeed the rightful ruler of the Griqua, his rule did not extend over the land that they lived on.

 

The way was clear for Cecil Rhodes and the De Beers Diamond Company to annex the land of the Griqua for mineral exploitation. Even the farms that Waterboer and his people lived on disappeared beneath their feet, as they were forced to sell them off to pay the huge legal fees that had been incurred to achieve that short-lived victory in the courts.

 

Around 1905, Waterboer’s son Nikolaas Waterboer II took over the captaincy (a title that was bestowed on the first Griqua leader by the Cape colony in recognition of his pacifying role among the other Khoi groups). He had no male heirs, but at the time of his death in 1962 he had grandsons to whom he bequeathed the staff of captaincy. Because these grandsons were still children, Nikolaas II appointed his bodyguard, a former policeman who was later to become a bishop in, and later the patriarch of, the Independent African Orthodox Church, to be regent over the Griqua until the boys reached maturity. Bishop Daniel Kanyiles has had control over Griqua affairs ever since.

 

Johannes Jakobus Waterboer, grandson of Nikolaas II, is now 44 years old. He is a small man with sharp features and a soft voice. He speaks little, and what he says is uttered with caution. He is taking his role as Griqua captain-in-waiting very seriously. He and one or two of his councillors are sporting ANC election T-shirts as they sit in the office, discussing the newspaper report about whether or not the Griquas will go to the polls, and who they will vote for if they do.

 

What the report in the Diamond Fields Advertiser does not address is the position of the man whose photograph dominates the report: the stern-looking Bishop Kanyiles, who the newspaper describes as the Griqua paramount chief.

 

”I have documents,” says Waterboer, ”that prove that Kanyiles has no right to call himself paramount chief. He was appointed regent, but he has sat on the paramountcy for nearly 40 years now, and he must restore my rights. And yet he is blocking me. If he continues to block me, we will go to court.”

 

Kanyiles also insists that he has legal documentation proving his right to the paramountcy, and goes on to say that no one has approached him about surrendering it. Quietly, however, he has said that, at his advanced age, he is prepared to consider retirement. This could be everybody’s let- out.

 

Kanyiles also insists on setting the record straight about his role in Griqua affairs. He says that it is entirely thanks to him that the Griqua regained their separate identity after the introduction of the 1955 Population Act – otherwise they would still have been ”other coloureds”. He was therefore the major Griqua activist of the 1950s, and has been the guardian of the cause ever since.

 

Martin Engelbrecht is the new activist for the Griqua cause, and it is due to him that the whole issue of the Griqua succession has come to the fore at this time. Although he professes respect for Kanyiles’s position, his activism has brought the two men into confrontation.

 

Until two years ago the Griqua captaincy was defunct. Waterboer was living an unremarkable life in Griquatown, working as a master bricklayer. Before that he had served in the South African army for two years, and then as a prison warder and as a municipal superintendent. To all intents and purposes, his life was similar to that of any other coloured man in the Northern Cape.

 

Engelbrecht had had a similarly undramatic history, growing up in a coloured township on the outskirts of Kimberley, working as a machine operator in the diamond mines, and then migrating to Pretoria, where he worked as a computer operator, as well as dabbling in music.

 

He returned to Kimberley and worked in journalism, then worked in the ANC office. That is when he started reading, finding books and archive material about Griqua history that opened his mind to his heritage. He climbed deeper and deeper into this scattered material, gradually weaving together a version of what had happened to himself and his people, and gaining an overview that offered itself as a strategy for the future. His first step was to alert the heir to the Griqua throne about his duties.

 

On the road from Kimberley to Griquatown and back, Engelbrecht never stops talking. He has all the dates off pat, and illustrates this tale of dispossession with vivid detail.

 

We started off, naturally, at the Groot Gat in Kimberley. The ugly sore left on the earth’s surface is both a metaphor for and a graphic illustration of Engelbrecht’s theme. De Beers, he says, may have signed deals with gullible Afrikaners to obtain mining rights on their farms, but they never signed the same kind of deals with the Griqua kings. The Griqua still have access to the treaties by which they are demonstrated to be the rightful owners of the land. These treaties have never been cancelled, and restoration is the bottom line.

 

The long, straight road west out of Kimberley is surrounded on both sides by fenced-off land, all once belonging to the Griqua, says Engelbrecht. To prove his point, he makes me stop at a grave site just off to the side, near the banks of a river. A group of graves, none marked with names, only identified with broken personal belongings cast on top of the stone mounds.

 

”When we showed De Beers these graves to prove that our people had always been living here,” says Engelbrecht, ”they threw another fence around the area so that we couldn’t even tend the graves.” The new fence has recently been torn down, and people obviously come and go to pay their respects to long- gone relatives.

 

”Once the Griqua had been removed from their land, they had nowhere to settle. They were only allowed to squat like gypsies at the outspans that had been set aside for the trek boers.” When the ox wagon went out of style, the outspans disappeared, and the Griqua had nowhere to go but to the settlements around the mission stations and the landdros courts.

 

A little further down the road, he invites me to turn off again to take in another amazing scene. This is the town made up of 4 500 army tents, home to a huge community of ”bushmen” who have been relocated from southern Namibia. These are the men who served as trackers for the South African Defence Force at the height of the anti-Swapo/ANC wars, and who have now been dumped at this spot in the Northern Cape with their families: former nomads, former military pawns, now awaiting a new identity in the new South Africa.

 

Their children go to the Afrikaans-medium school housed in rows of corrugated iron structures on one side of the camp. Outside the school perimeter, the only languages spoken are !Xu and Khwe. Like the Griqua, this is one of the groups whose interests Engelbrecht’s Khoisan Representative Council has been set up to articulate.

 

Returning from Griquatown through the dusk, we stop in Campbell. The first landmark is the Livingstone Liquor Store, a reminder that that frightfully abstemious Scottish doctor spent much time there proselytising among the Griqua in the 1830s. Today the forlorn collection of sandstone and breeze-block houses waits for the next emancipation. Women and old men sit immobile in their kitchen doors, flat on the ground, sucking in the thin winter sun, watching the world go by.

 

Jan Balie’s family has lived in Campbell since before Adam Kok’s group returned from Kokstad. The old man is not impressed with any of those who pretend to the Griqua throne – not even the current Adam Kok V, the IFP’s man and a challenger to Waterboer’s claims on the paramountcy, and a resident of Campbell.

”The trouble is,” says Balie, ”none of them can talk. Waterboer can’t talk. Adam Kok can’t talk. Louis Luyt was here just now, also trying to talk to the Griquas. The only reason anybody went to listen to him is because they know him from the rugby. But that’s another thing, Martin,” he continues, pointing a gnarled finger in Engelbrecht’s direction, ”while you’re busy talking about restitution, you can tell them to pay compensation for stealing our name for that rugby team of theirs. Not so much as a please or a thank you.” The old man turns back to me: ”Now, this Martin,” he says approvingly, ”the others don’t know how to talk, but Martin, he can really talk.”

 

Which is confirmation of what I have been beginning to suspect. If the Griqua and the other Khoi groups are players on the political field in 1999, it is largely through Engelbrecht’s subtle manipulation. Does he have a personal, long-term agenda in national politics? He doesn’t say.

For now the issue is about something far greater than personal ambition. It is a massive question about identity.

 

Earlier, in the kaptein’s office in Griquatown, the question of identity had been raised in relation to Kanyiles and the Griqua throne. The room had grown uneasy. Nobody was sure, but everybody felt that there was something in this rumour that Kanyiles was not a real Griqua. Finally Councilor Visagie, who is blind, had spoken up:

”We don’t want to discriminate against anyone,” he had said, ”but we have heard that this Kanyiles is an African man who was employed by the old South African police, and who then became regent here.”

 

The unease in the room deepened.

”What do you mean, ‘an African’?” said one voice. ”Are Griqua not Africans?”

 

”A black man, then,” replied Visagie.

”Are Griqua not black people? Are we not Africans?”

”’n Griqua is nie ‘n swart man, en hy is nie ‘n coloured [A Griqua is not a black man, and he is not a coloured],” Visagie had replied. But the questioner was not satisfied. He had opened up a can of worms, and was forcing into the open the issue of who the Griquas are, where they stand in the debate about coloured, black and African, and with whom they intend to identify.

This quiet and insistent voice belonged to Engelbrecht, Khoi activist extraordinaire, self-appointed voice of the revival of the Griqua people and spokesperson for many other ancient identities long hidden under the apartheid cloak.

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 5:17 PM
Scoop.it!

Russia’s Indigenous Communities and the War in Ukraine

Russia’s Indigenous Communities and the War in Ukraine | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
Russia’s Indigenous Communities and the War in Ukraine
Posted date/time:March 27, 2025

 

By Izabella Tabarovsky

 
 
Kennan Institute
Image Credit

Russia’s recruitment of soldiers to fight in its war in Ukraine has disproportionately drawn from the country’s Indigenous peoples. Individuals from these communities—most notably Buryats, Tuvans, Kalmyks, as well as members of small-numbered nations—have been recruited at above-average rates and experienced higher-than-average combat death rates. While these elevated recruitment and death rates affects the entire regions where these groups reside—often some of the poorest regions in the country—it is their specific ethnic communities that face the most long-lasting and potentially devastating consequences.

 

Disproportionate Losses

 

According to Alexandra Garmazhapova, president of the Free Buryatia Foundation, at least 2,470 Buryatia residents have been killed in action since the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The figure, which is based on open sources and therefore is likely to be an undercount, includes both ethnic Buryats and Russians. In a republic with a population of only 980,000, of which 30 percent are Buryat, this translates to 252 combat deaths per 100,000 residents.

For comparison, the number of Muscovites killed in action is estimated at 1,215. In a city of 13.2 million, this translates into 9.2 combat deaths for 100,000 residents. Looking at the broader Moscow region (population 8.7 million), it has suffered 1,236 combat deaths, equating to 14.2 deaths per 100,000 residents. (Data about soldiers killed in action is from Mediazona). Data for Saint Petersburg and the Leningrad region likewise show figures that are much lower than those in Buryatia.

 

“Rational Economic Choice”

 

The Kremlin prefers to recruit troops from remote, impoverished, and sparsely populated regions for both political and economic reasons. Russian law prohibits sending conscripts into active combat zones, especially abroad. The Kremlin, therefore, relies on contract soldiers to fill the ranks of those fighting in Ukraine. In these regions, high levels of poverty make outsized signing and death bonuses an attractive proposition.

Buryatia is a case in point. It is one of the poorest regions in the country and has “one of the highest concentrations of military units or military bases in the region per capita,” Maria Vyushkova, a scholar at the University of Notre Dame, told the Kennan Institute’s Russia File podcast last year. According to her, the army has long been one of the region’s largest and most stable employers, offering benefits such as “housing, mortgages, and other perks” that are especially attractive to men with young families.

With the start of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, enlisting in the military became “a rational economic choice,” the Wall Street Journal reported last fall. New recruits are offered high salaries and bonuses that can exceed the national average wage by up to five times. In poor regions, families of killed in action receive “life-changing” sums of up to $150,000—more than a 35-year-old could earn in total “working as a civilian until the age of 60,” according to economist Vladislav Inozemtsev. The Journal also noted that from January of 2022 to November 2024, bank deposits in Buryatia grew by 81 percent. Residential construction was up 32 percent for the year in November 2024, compared with the 2 percent national average.

 

Devastating Impact

 

The smaller the Indigenous group, the higher the impact of these cynical recruitment policies. For some communities, the stakes are existential. According to Pavel Sulyandziga, president of the International Indigenous Fund for Development and Solidarity “Batani” and lifelong advocate for Indigenous peoples, there are 42 small-numbered Indigenous nations living in Siberia and the Russian Far East. Of these, 7 have fewer than 1,000 members, 12 have fewer than 2,000, and none exceed 50,000. For these groups, every loss to recruitment—and certainly every combat death—poses a potential threat to the survival of the entire ethnos.

Sulyandziga’s organization estimates that in Khabarovsk region, where military casualties among Indigenous men are disproportionately high, Indigenous communities were targeted for recruitment nearly three times more often than non-Indigenous ones, he said at a recent Kennan Institute webinar.

This suggests that the “disproportionately high military casualties among the Indigenous population” in this region are the result of a “disproportionate forced recruitment into the war.” He described a village in Khabarovsk region where, during the “partial mobilization” drive of 2022, the entire male population aged 18 to 50 got recruited, leaving behind only women, children and the elderly. It was only after the women began to raise the alarm that the authorities relented and allowed some of the men to return.

Sulyandziga warns that this could have generational consequences. Many small Indigenous communities are already on the brink of extinction, he explained.  The recruiting of men from these communities is pushing them even closer the edge—the final step in a long process of dispossession, stemming from loss of their lands and access to traditional hunting, herding, and fishing grounds. If widespread deforestation caused by rapacious logging practices previously accelerated these trends, the war may prove to be the final blow against these communities.

 

Propaganda Does Its Work

 

As in other parts of the country, men returning in coffins have not sparked serious protests in the regions disproportionately impacted by casualties. There are many reasons for that. For one thing, speaking out against the war and the regime has dire consequences. Psychological factors play a role as well. “For a mother who lost her son in the war, it’s hard to accept that his death may have been in vain,” Garmazhapova said. On top of that, “Kremlin propaganda is always one step ahead,” quickly seizing on new cultural trends and repurposing them for its own aims.

One example is the patriotic song “Russians Don’t Surrender, Buryats Don’t Run,” which has become a hit. Inspired by an interview with Putin, in which he praised the courage of Buryat soldiers, it invokes pride in Buryat ethnicity while underscoring unity with Russia and Russian patriotism. Propaganda outlets now frequently spotlight Buryat war heroes, portraying them as brave defenders of the “Russian world,” Garmazhapova explained. She noted the “sticky” quality of the song: “You catch yourself humming it even though you disagree with the message.”

Russia has also coopted the United Nations to shield itself from international scrutiny and prop up its narratives internationally. According to Sulyandziga, the Kremlin has placed its own representatives in both UN bodies dealing with Indigenous issues: the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues and the UN Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Rather than represent genuine Indigenous interests, they are using their positions to promote Russian propaganda and deflect attention from Russia’s abuses of Indigenous populations.

Religious authorities in Russia, including Buddhist leaders, are fully under the heel of the state and actively promote pro-war narratives as well, she said. According to one popular narrative, the Buryats are fighting for the “Russian world” in order to preserve the “Mongolian world.” (One possible interpretation of this overt non-sequitur is that the “corrupt” West and “Nazi” Ukraine threaten both.)

 

Buryat Diaspora Growing

 

While few risk protesting, anecdotal evidence suggests that those who can are doing their best to leave the country. In a recent investigation, award-winning journalist Olga Mutovina documented the growing Buryat diaspora in the US. Today, an estimated 10,000 ethnic Buryats live in the US, making it one of the largest Buryat diaspora communities in the world. Gathering information about this group can be a challenge, she notes. When the emigrant society Shambala tried to run a community census, many people declined to participate. Many feared harming their relatives back home. Some did not even tell their loved ones that they had moved to the US.

When it comes to Russia’s Indigenous peoples, the effect of Russia’s war in Ukraine goes beyond the tragedy experienced by individual families. Its devastating toll on its Indigenous communities and small-numbered peoples is one of the many unforeseen consequences of this war that Russia will be grappling with for years and decades to come.

The opinions expressed in this article are those solely of the author and do not reflect the views of the Kennan Institute.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 4:54 PM
Scoop.it!

Disasters and Indigenous Peoples: A Critical Discourse Analysis of the Expert News Media 

Disasters and Indigenous Peoples: A Critical Discourse Analysis of the Expert News Media  | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

 

A Critical Discourse Analysis of the Expert News Media

Anuszka Maton-Mosurska, Aaron Clark-Ginsberg, Susannah M. Sallu, James D. Ford

 

May 19, 2022Published in: Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space(2022). 

 

Attempts to shift the ways disasters have traditionally been managed away from authoritarian, top-down approaches toward more bottom-up and inclusive processes often involve incorporating viewpoints from marginalised and vulnerable groups. Recently as part of this process, there have been calls for greater inclusion of Indigenous peoples in disaster management. In theory, this also suggests a shift in power structures, towards recognising Indigenous peoples as experts in disaster management.

 

However, in popular imagination and policy Indigenous peoples often appear to be caricatured and misrepresented, for instance through tropes of Indigenous peoples as custodians of the environment or especially vulnerable to environmental change. These framings matter because they can result in disaster management policies and practices that do not capture Indigenous peoples' complex realities. However, these framings have not been analysed in the context of disasters. In this article, we aim to better understand these framings through a critical discourse analysis of how Indigenous peoples in disasters are represented in the expert news media.

 

We identify five discourses, including a dominant one of disasters as natural phenomena to be addressed through humanitarianism and technocratic interventions. Such discourses render Indigenous peoples helpless, depoliticize disasters and are justified by framing governments and NGOs as caring for Indigenous peoples. However, we also identify competing discourses that focus on systems of oppression and self-determination in disaster management.

 

These discourse recognise disasters as political and include discussion of the role of colonialism in disaster creation. As care emerged as a means through which intervention was justified, we conclude by asking questions of who is cared for/about in disasters and how that care is performed.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 4:28 PM
Scoop.it!

Indigenous Sovereignty and Human Rights in the United States | Harvard Kennedy School

Indigenous Sovereignty and Human Rights in the United States | Harvard Kennedy School | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
April 15, 2024

On today’s episode of Justice Matters, co-host Mathias Risse talks with Angela Riley, Chief Justice of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation and Professor of Law and American Indian Studies at UCLA, about indigenous sovereignty and human rights in the United States. 

Together, they discuss the Citizen Potawatomi Nation, what sovereignty means for tribes in the U.S. compared to indigenous communities globally, the tribal government’s relationship to U.S. federal and state governments, recent changes to the Citizen Potawatomi Nation’s constitution, the Potawatomi judiciary system, and Intellectual Property law in the U.S. and its relation to indigenous knowledge.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 4:25 PM
Scoop.it!

Conflict, Militarization, and Exploitation of Indigenous Land and Resources | Harvard Kennedy School

Conflict, Militarization, and Exploitation of Indigenous Land and Resources | Harvard Kennedy School | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
 
Description
 

The 2021 Indigenous Women Convening for Peace, Justice, and Reconciliation Conference brought together Indigenous scholars and female leaders from seven Indigenous socio-cultural zones around the world. Together, they shared stories of war and conflict in their territories and discussed collective ways of ideating Indigenous conflict resolution and peacemaking processes.

 

The event was organized by the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy; the Committee on Ethnicity, Migration, and Rights; the Scholars at Risk Program; and the Global Alliance of Indigenous Peoples, Gender, Justice, and Peace. Co-sponsors included the Center for the Study of World Religions; the Department of Slavic Languages and Literatures; the Harvard College Writing Program; HUNAP; Religion, Conflict, and Peace Initiative; and the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs. The event was moderated by Jacqueline Bhabha, FXB Director of Research and Professor of the Practice of Health and Human Rights at the Harvard School of Public Health, and Shelly Lowe, Executive Director of the Harvard University Native American Program. Opening remarks were provided by Raquel Vega-Duran, Chair of the Committee on Ethnicity, Migration, and Rights, and Sushma Raman, Executive Director of the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy.

 

This publication features the 10 speakers of the conference and their profound statements on the state of human rights and peacemaking in their respective Indigenous zones.

Citations

Carr Center Human Rights for Policy. 10/12/2021. Conflict, Militarization, and Exploitation of Indigenous Land and Resources. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Kennedy School.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 3:50 PM
Scoop.it!

The World Conference on Indigenous Peoples: A View From Indonesia | Council on Foreign Relations

The World Conference on Indigenous Peoples: A View From Indonesia | Council on Foreign Relations | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
The World Conference on Indigenous Peoples: A View From Indonesia
 

Global Memo by Authors: Vidhyandika Perkasa, Senior Researcher, Department of Politics and International Relations, Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), Jakarta; and Nukila Evanty, Executive Director, Rights Foundation, Jakarta

 

PublishedSeptember 22, 2014 3:25 p.m.
 
 

There are approximately 370 million indigenous peoples comprising around 5,000 tribes in more than ninety countries around the world. While indigenous peoples make up only 6 percent of the world’s population, indigenous territories hold around 80 percent of the world’s remaining biodiversity. Yet, despite this natural wealth, the majority of indigenous populations suffer from economic hardship and poverty, as well as political marginalization by majority groups and discrimination at the hands of their governments.

 

The plight of indigenous populations was first seriously considered at the international level during the first and second International Decades of the World’s Indigenous Peoples which began in 1994. By 2007, the UN had established a Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, the Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues. And in 2007, the UN General Assembly adopted the historic United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. This convention sets a minimum standard for the protection of human rights of indigenous populations, as well as their rights to self-determination; spirituality; territories; resources; language; lands; and free, prior and informed consent.

 

Building on this progress, the UN General Assembly will hold the first UN World Conference on Indigenous Peoples on September 22 and 23, 2014, in New York. This meeting provides a significant forum for indigenous populations and their governments, as well as the private sector, to develop best practices on the realization of the rights of indigenous peoples. The conference will be attended by over 1,000 indigenous representatives, among which will be the Masyarakat Adat communities of Indonesia, including groups such as the Dayak Benuaq, the Orang Tengger, and the Orang Badui.

 

Indonesia represents a worthy case study for countries struggling to adjust policies to help indigenous peoples. Approximately 50-70 million people in Indonesia could be classified as indigenous and they live in almost every province. The upcoming conference presents an important opportunity for Indonesia’s indigenous population to be heard, and for the incoming government to recognize the rights of its indigenous peoples while enacting a reformed strategy to ensure their rights.

Indonesia’s Indigenous Peoples

Indonesia—a country with more than 13,000 islands spanning over 7 million square km—has a population of 253 million comprising more than 1000 ethnic and sub ethnic groups. While Indonesia has a single national language, Bahasa Indonesia, there are at least 700 local languages spoken throughout the country’s thirty-four provinces. Indonesia’s diversity and multiculturalism form the nation’s rich heritage, but also present significant challenges, particularly relating to the existence of indigenous peoples.

 

Indigenous peoples are often associated with negative labels in Indonesia, such as “living in poverty,” “disadvantaged,” “marginalized,” or “extinct.” Yet, compared to their status during the authoritarian rule in the 1970sthrough thelate 1990s, indigenous peoples tend to be relatively better off in the current democratic era. And they have become engaged in the struggle for their rights, building up their organizational capacity, receiving support from civil society, and pushing for the state to acknowledge indigenous groups through policies, regulations, and the ratification of international treaties. At the forefront of these efforts, the Aliansi Masyarakat Adat Nusantara (Indigenous Peoples Alliance of the Archipelago or AMAN) is a nongovernmental organization that acts as a representative of the indigenous peoples in their struggle for the right to exist and their right to sovereignty in managing their lives and natural resources. AMAN, which is supported by other NGOs such as Forest Watch Indonesia and Friends of the Earth of Indonesia, fronted a major victory in May 2013 when Indonesia’s Constitutional Court adopted a law submitted by the group, effectively handing control of more than sixty million of hectares of government-controlled forest land back to indigenous communities.

 

Despite such progress, indigenous groups still face significant challenges to maintaining their rights vis-a-vis state policies, regulations, and development processes. The outgoing administration of President Yudhoyono has faltered on his election promises to uphold the rights of indigenous peoples. The May 2013 law to return control of forest lands to indigenous groups, for instance, has yet to be implemented by the government, and in May 2014 the government launched a national inquiry due to the continued violation of indigenous groups’ rights, especially related to the rejection or violation of the law by extractives companies and others working under the guise of conservation efforts.

 

In 2012 Indonesia received a troubling assessment in the UN’s first Universal Periodic Review—a report assessing the state of human rights in the UN’s 193 member countries over the course of four years. Commenting on this review, Survival International summed up the continued violation of indigenous communities’ right, noting frankly that “Indonesia treats its indigenous and tribal people…worse than any other country in the world.” The continued denial of the very existence of indigenous peoples in Indonesia is symptomatic of the government’s disregard for indigenous rights.

Challenges Facing Indonesia’s Indigenous Peoples

There is indeed complexity when talking about the challenges faced by indigenous peoples in Indonesia. The lack of accurate data about the number and locations of indigenous peoples in the country impedes efforts to fully understand their current state. Despite the lack of data, it is commonly understood that indigenous peoples are facing hardship, and widespread poverty is one of the main indicators. Indigenous people frequently lose the rights to their land and other natural resources in the name of development. In addition, the state continues to transfer land ownership to private industrial companies without implementing the process of free, prior, and informed consent. In this case, impoverishment of indigenous peoples is due to the lack of legal recognition of their right to adat (local) and natural resources.

In an era of decentralization and increased regional autonomy, governor and heads of district have significant power over land use and the transfer of natural resources. Due to practices of collusion and nepotism made by local elites with national or foreign investors, indigenous communities tend to be disadvantaged. A 2012 report from the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) points to the example of East Kalimantan, where, due to the lack of legal recognition and protection of customary rights over land and natural resources, “the local government took lands and forests of indigenous peoples and allocated it for logging concessions, mining, and plantations without prior consultation with or adequate compensation to the affected communities.”

 

Due to poverty and remoteness, many indigenous peoples do not have access to proper health and education services. Lack of infrastructure and transportation also poses a barrier that hampers indigenous peoples’ ability to pursue a better life. Another problem is the inability to sell their lands due to the loss of legal rights. The IFAD report notes that “structural inequities and inequalities were further reinforced by the legislation of discriminatory and oppressive land laws which ignored indigenous peoples’ customary land tenure systems and laws. In Indonesia, the indigenous peoples are limited by government policies that do not acknowledge their rights to their traditional lands and natural resources.”

 

In addition, massive logging, plantation, and mining activities have caused pollution and destruction—the UN Environmental Programme estimates that around 98 percent of Indonesia’s natural rainforests could be lost by 2022. This degradation of indigenous peoples’ land and natural resources furthers the cycle of oppression and hardship. The government’s ambitious fifteen-year economic plan (Master Plan for Acceleration and Expansion of Indonesia’s Economic Development) unveiled in 2011 has provoked strong resistance from indigenous peoples and local communities. This includes, the Merauke indigenous community’s opposition to the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate at Urumuka and Mamberamo hydropower stations in Papua, as well as the indigenous community of Central Kalimantan’s opposition to that province becoming a center for large-scale mining. Such projects tend to aggravate conflicts between indigenous or rural communities, and companies or the government. In 2012 alone, HuMa (a local NGO) recorded seventy-two ongoing cases of forestry-related conflicts in an area of more than two million hectares; the conflicts have already resulted in many deaths.

The Regulatory Dimensions

From a regulatory standpoint, there has been some progress in recognizing indigenous peoples’ rights and sovereignty on paper, but most of these legal conventions have yet to be implemented or enforced by the government in reality. The Second Amendment to the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, for instance, ensures state recognition and respect for societies that live by customary law (that is according to the customs or usual practices of the indigenous communities). Another—the People’s Consultative Assembly Decree No 9/2001 on Agrarian Reform and Natural Resources Management—acknowledges societies that live by customary law with respect to agrarian reform and the management of natural resources. And the Basic Agrarian Law No 5/1960 and Indonesian Forestry Act No 41/1999, both regulate customary law on land, water, and forests.

 

Just as important and related to regional autonomy is Local Government Act No. 32, Year 2004 (which replaced Act No. 22, Year 1999), which states that “Villages, or other forms of settlement henceforth called villages, are units of law-based society which have the authority to manage and take care of local communities’ interests based on their origins and local customs, within district territory and as recognized by the national government system.” It also states that “local government regulations…must recognize and respect villages’ rights, origins and customs”. Act No 39 of 1999 on Human Rights clearly provides an explicit formulation of the recognition and protection of indigenous peoples and their cultural identity. It also recognized property rights and acquisition of property rights, respectively, which become relevant in the framework of protection of indigenous rights. Finally there is also Act No 27/2007 on Coastal and Small Islands Management which recognizes the rights of indigenous peoples to manage coastal and small islands.

Indonesia has adopted the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rightswhich were ratified by the government in 2006. In 2007, the Indonesian government supported the UN General Assembly’s adoption of the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), which sets the international minimum standard for the protection, respect, and fulfilment of the rights of indigenous peoples, but noted that the text did not apply in the context of Indonesia. Yet the Indonesian government has ratified a number of international conventions on human rights relating to indigenous peoples in the past, including the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. In addition, the government ratified Law No 29/1999 on the Ratification of the International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination 1965and Law No 7/1984 on the Ratification of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women.

 

Many regulations concerning indigenous peoples often lack clarity. For instance, Act No 32 on the Management and the Protection of Environmentsays “the State admits and respect the unity of indigenous peoples and their traditional rights as long as they are still existing and in accordance with the society development and based on the foundation of Unitary States of the Republic of Indonesia.”And a formal definition of “indigenous peoples” is hard to find in Indonesian laws. National laws use many terms instead of “indigenous peoples,” such as alien tribal communities, neglected communities, remote communities,customary law communities, and communities governed by custom.

 

Moreover, the development of economic policies on the allocation and management of natural resources have often been tailored to benefit the private sector, and have led to environmental and ecological abuses and damage. The victims of these environmental damages are more ofen than not the indigenous communities that reside near the forests or mining locations. And even though Indonesia has ratified the UN Declaration on the Rights of the Indigenous People, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights,they have not yet been implemented, and no formal state recognition of indigenous peoples exists.

Recent developments

In addition to the regulatory issues, there are some recent developments that could support indigenous rights, but which fail to do so in practice. The National Parliament, for instance, has adopted a draft of the Indigenous Peoples Law (RUU PRHMA). Unfortunately the Ministry of Forestry, designated to coordinate the four ministries within the national parliament to finalize RUU PPHMA for adoption, appears to be deliberately delaying the process. If the law is adopted, it will be a significant step toward the recognition and protection of the constitutional rights of Indonesia’s indigenous peoples and will present an opportunity for reconciliation by eliminating discrimination of indigenous groups. However, an initial observation on the RUU PPHMA indicates that the law does not resolve the structural conflicts emerging in Indonesia that concern indigenous peoples.

 

In addition, the new Village Law No 6/2014 was initially expected to present new opportunities and benefits for indigenous peoples in the context of decentralization, since they mostly reside at the village level. However, this law only concerns the governing system without addressing the rights of indigenous peoples.

Finally, the previously mentioned constitutional court ruling that customary forest is not state forest means that indigenous peoples of the archipelago will get back their rights over their customary forests, seized by the state through forestry law, which could potentially secure land tenure for up to seventy million indigenous peoples in Indonesia. However, as with many legal matters concerning indigenous peoples, this ruling has yet to be implemented.

Recommendations

There is still a long way to go in securing the rights of indigenous peoples. Existing regulations that address the rights of indigenous peoples tend to be cosmetic in nature and lack enforcement capacity. Such regulations tend to focus almost exclusively on economic development, while neglecting indigenous peoples as the subject of that development. In addition, many of these regulations are highly fragmented.

 

In Indonesia, the election of Joko Widodo in July 2014 presents an opportunity to enact change. The president-elect should ensure state recognition of the existence of Indonesia’s indigenous population, while leading legal reforms synergize, coordinate, and integrate laws regarding indigenous populations. In addition, the newgovernment should implement the Indigenous Peoples Law (RUU PPHMA), while incorporating the rights of indigenous peoples into the law andharmonizingRUU PPHMA with existinglegislation. Finally, the new government should include the condition of indigenous peoples in their State Report and Universal Periodic report.

 

At the international level, countries should take action to implement the recommendations set out by the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples to ensure the civil, political, social, economic, and cultural rights of their indigenous populations. It is important to recognize that the upcoming World Conference on Indigenous Peoples, while an important platform to highlight indigenous people’s issues, is just a forum. Real change will require actionable goals from indigenous populations’ governments. To that end, countries should help their indigenous populations achieve the development goals specified in the conference’s forthcoming outcome document, as well as committing to specific and actionable goals to achieve the recommended human rights standards.

Information

Global Memos are briefs by the Council of Councils that gather opinions from global experts on major international developments.

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 3:33 PM
Scoop.it!

Constitutional Morarchy Failures: Democracy Power People

Constitutional Morarchy Failures: Democracy Power People | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

The World Today

Published 1 April 2001

Updated 26 October 2020 —6 minute READ

 

Britain is about to elect a new government. But how democratic will it be and how does the present one fare on this front? An international audit of democracy, being applied to a number of countries, has produced disturbing findings about the United Kingdom. The centralised executive is seen as an obstacle to protecting civil and political rights. Checks on this power are a myth and there has been a reluctance to redress the imbalance between executive and parliamentary power.

 

David Beetham - Director, Centre for Democratisation Studies, University of Leeds

Stuart Weir - Director of Democratic Audit, University of Essex

 

Representative democracy is making fitful progress around the world, with remarkable advances in some regions and major setbacks in others. Its progress is menaced by religious fundamentalism, ethnic domination and conflicts, military coups and war. For every Yugoslavia where the people rose in protest against rigged elections, there is a Zimbabwe where a brutal electoral dictator seeks to perpetuate his corrupt rule by subverting the rule of law, using state and irregular forces to terrorise political opponents and the media, and systematically spreading fear. But there are other more insidious menaces too.

People in new and democratising states embrace the idea of democracy with enthusiasm, but that enthusiasm too often turns to disillusionment when they find that they still have limited purchase on power and their daily lives are little changed.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 3:10 PM
Scoop.it!

Consult and Cooperate in Times of Great Need: Indigenous Rights and the Just Transition 

Consult and Cooperate in Times of Great Need: Indigenous Rights and the Just Transition  | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
November 14, 2024 • 2:00 – 3:30 pm EST
 
 
 

In September the UN Secretary General’s Panel on Critical Energy Transition Minerals released its report Resourcing the Energy Transition: Principles to Guide Critical Energy Transition Minerals Towards Equity and Justice. These principles aim to center human rights as well as the integrity of the planet and environment. They also recognize that “[a] world powered by renewables is a world hungry for critical minerals.” The vital and irreplaceable nature of these minerals alongside the human rights, environmental justice, and equity focus often come into conflict. 

 

Human history is rife with examples of this conflict being borne by indigenous peoples. As recognized by the report, “Mining, at all scales, large and small, has too often been linked with human rights abuses, environmental degradation and conflict. Indigenous Peoples’ lands and resources have been dispossessed and the lives of local peoples upended.”  The ILO has similarly recognized this concern, resolving to “establish a mechanism for dialogue with indigenous and tribal peoples so as to acquire knowledge and develop a road map for a just transition.” The first of these dialogues is set to be held in Brazil in December 2024. 

 

This past cannot be repeated. A just transition would be a boon for populations near mineral wealth that have too often been neglected and would create wealth and advancement for developing states. In order for prosperity to be shared and past human rights abuses to be avoided, real consultation and cooperation is necessary. This discussion aims to bring together experts in indigenous rights and critical minerals to discuss what real consultation and cooperation would look like and how human rights protections can play a vital role in the current critical minerals environment. 

 

This event is made possible through generous support from the International Labour Organisation office for the United States and Canada.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 22, 4:11 AM
Scoop.it!

"Indigenous Land does not Equal to Collective Consent!": SA’s Land System is Broken, but Collective Consent Offers a Way Forward

"Indigenous Land does not Equal to Collective Consent!": SA’s Land System is Broken, but Collective Consent Offers a Way Forward | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

South Africa’s land and mining crisis is political and structural, and experts at the 2026 Mining Indaba agree that reform requires collective, democratic community control over land.

 

The coffee was strong, the room was tense, and the choreography of politeness was slipping. At the Investing in Africa Mining Indaba 2026, during a co-hosted breakfast by CNV Internationaal and the Initiative for Responsible Mining Assurance (IRMA) on customary governance and accountability, one question refused to stay quiet:

 

Who truly speaks for the land?

 

It is the question South Africa has tried to dodge for three decades. It unravels the politics of mining, land, legitimacy, identity and justice. It exposes what many communities, activists and even some traditional leaders have long known: our land governance system is collapsing under pressures it was never built to withstand.

 

Across our panel spanning traditional authorities, mining executives, labour, community foundations and social auditors, a rare consensus emerged: the crisis is not technical. It is political. It is structural. It is about power. But amenable through dialogue.

This echoes the persistent warning from land activists, who have illuminated the core problem: South Africans cannot meaningfully negotiate mining, conservation, or development without secure, democratic governance over land. Without land rights, communities do not participate; they plead.

 

SA’s land and mining governance framework still carries the imprint of a 20th-century logic: centralised authority, extraction-first economics, and a technocratic state that presumes legitimacy without earning it.

 

Meanwhile:

 

This is unjust and obsolete in a world defined by rising community expectations, AI-powered transparency, climate-driven land pressures and global solidarity networks. Largely, this is why SA’s land and mining debate remains trapped in a zero-sum struggle: commodity versus identity, traditional authority versus democracy, white majority-owned multinational mining house (except Patrice Motsepe and a few others) versus black community. This binary is not a failure of policy. It is a failure of imagination.

To break the stalemate, we must flip the script entirely and build a new system in the cracks of the old.

Four Innovations That Could Transform SA’s Land Future

These aren’t policy tweaks. They are deep systemic redesigns, which are practical, ambitious, and aligned with the urgent demands for land justice voiced across the country.

1. The “Living Land Title”: A Legal Hybrid That Ends the False Choice

SA’s land debate has been trapped between two inadequate options: individual freehold (land as commodity) and insecure communal tenure (land as identity without protection).

The Living Land Title creates a third way. It is issued to a democratically constituted community entity, such as a trust, cooperative or certified Traditional Council, and guarantees perpetual, secure tenure. Embedded in the title is a Community Consent clause, requiring a supermajority for any lease or sale, protecting against elite capture.

 

A mandatory Intergenerational Commons, including a school, cooperative garden, grazing land, or renewable energy microgrid, ensures shared benefit and intergenerational equity. This title makes land generative commons, not an elite possession.

This land reform strengthens democracy, not weakens it.

2. The “Soil & Soul Fund”: Financing Land Justice Without a Bankrupt Fiscus

Land reform is trapped because it relies on state budgets and commercial banks, both incapable of funding transformation at scale. The Soil & Soul Fund breaks this dependency. It is capitalised through:

  • A time-bound Common Good Levy on agricultural exports, mining revenues and commercial farming profits.
  • Diaspora bonds inviting global South Africans to invest in land justice.
  • A mandated allocation from large pension funds, especially those built on the labour of communities that lost land.

The fund finances land acquisition, post-settlement support, regenerative agriculture and cultural restoration, such as memorials, heritage sites and renewal centres.

It shifts the narrative from “state must pay” to a shared national social contract, acknowledging historical debt while investing in collective futures.

3. The “Customary Constitution”: Renewing Ancestral Governance in a Modern Era

One of the deepest tensions in rural SA lies in the gap between imposed forms of traditional authority and the lived expectations of communities whose governance practices have always been collective, relational and accountable.

 

The Customary Constitution draws directly from these indigenous principles. It offers a community-driven, culturally grounded process through which people can affirm, in their own language, customs and values, the rules that guide their shared life. Through inclusive dialogue, the community defines:

  • How leaders emerge and are entrusted with authority, based on service, lineage, merit and community confidence.
  • How land is held, shared and allocated, reflecting ancestral practices of custodianship rather than ownership.
  • How disputes are resolved, using restorative and consensus-based mechanisms.
  • How consent for mining or development is given, through collective deliberation rather than individual signatures.

Once affirmed through broad community agreement, the Customary Constitution becomes a recognised expression of the community’s will, binding on all, including companies seeking access to land.

This approach renews the oldest African governance principle: authority flows from the people, not over them.

It moves power away from individuals acting without accountability and restores it to the collective, where Free, Prior and Informed Consent becomes a living practice rooted in tradition, not a bureaucratic ritual imposed from outside.

4. The “Generational Tribunal”: A Living Archive of Land and Renewal

SA operates a mixed legal system, a hybrid of Roman-Dutch civilian law, English common law, customary law and religious personal law, yet cannot process the full weight of historical land dispossession. Many claims are lost, undocumented or buried in trauma.

 

The Intergenerational Tribunal is a non-judicial, statutory body that:

  • Investigates and publicly witnesses past and ongoing land injustices.
  • Collects oral histories and genealogies.
  • Maintains a public digital archive.
  • Issues Certificates of Moral Claim that communities can use in land negotiations.
  • Protects the intergenerational wealth and wellbeing of future generations.

 

It transforms buried pain into visible knowledge. It creates a national memory too powerful for policymakers to ignore. More importantly, it allows healing, not forgetting, to shape the future.

These innovations matter because each disrupts a different layer of the system:

  • The Living Land Title rewrites the rules of property.
  • The Soil & Soul Fund rewrites the financing logic.
  • The Customary Constitution rewrites the power dynamics.
  • The Intergenerational Tribunal rewrites the national narrative.

 

Together, they form the foundation of a new land governance regime, embedded with pluralistic, generative, democratic principles.

They answer the question that echoed in that Mining Indaba room: Who speaks for the land?

The response should be: The people rooted in it. Democratically. Collectively. With dignity and power.

It is clear that SA’s mining crisis is not technical; it is a crisis of governance and imagination, a land crisis, a democracy crisis.

The land is speaking. Communities are speaking. History is speaking. The future is calling. The only question left is: Will we finally listen?

 

This article was first published by the Daily Maverick.

 

The views expressed in this publication/article are those of the author/s and do not necessarily reflect the views of the South African Institute of International Affairs (SAIIA).
 
No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 20, 3:59 PM
Scoop.it!

KhoiKhoiBushman "Fake Linton Panel" Rock Art: How South Africa’s Coat of Arms got to Feature an Ancient San Painting

KhoiKhoiBushman "Fake Linton Panel" Rock Art: How South Africa’s Coat of Arms got to Feature an Ancient San Painting | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

"KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous People of South Africa put on record the attempt to ERASE ORIGINAL Southern Africa Rock Art History in Partnership with Universities and the Rupert Foundation.. We do not acknowledge this "New Rock Art" as the original Linton Panel discovered in 1918."

 

KhoiKhoiBushman Indgenous People of South Africa, as official recognnized by the United Nations in 2007does not include Bantu Xhosa West African Settlers, who are the Black Majority in South Africa. We REJECT this claim by Bantu Xhosa's in its entirety.

______________________________________________________________

 

A new exhibition in Johannesburg titled ǃke e꞉ ǀxarra ǁke – People who are Different: Come Together celebrates the rock art of the San people, the first inhabitants of southern Africa. Presented by the University of the Witwatersrand’s Rock Art Research Institute and the Origins Centre, the exhibition includes an ultra-high-resolution facsimile of a San rock art panel called the Linton Panel. The panel contains the image chosen for South Africa’s national coat of arms. The exhibition also features a new artwork by descendants of the San people, as well as a book launch. We asked the head of the institute, Sam Challis, to tell us how the painting rose to such national prominence.

Who are the San and what’s their rock art about?

The names San and Bushman refer to the indigenous hunter-gatherers of southern Africa, and their descendants, whose ancestors lived here for many thousands of years. Both names have been used pejoratively – as demeaning terms – for centuries. But now both have been reclaimed as identities to be worn with pride. Some groups prefer either one term or the other, depending on the historical use in their region. South Africans prefer the word San while those in the Kalahari Desert region – and the artists from Nieu Bethesda in South Africa whose work we commissioned for the new exhibition – prefer Bushman.

The rock art is an indigenous archive of San religion: their beliefs about how to transcend realms to heal the sick, influence the movements of animals and control the weather. It is not a “menu” of animals they liked to eat, and these are no idle doodles or simple “records” of events.

 
 
An explanation of the Linton Panel (click to enlarge). Courtesy Rock Art Research Institute

In the 1860s and 1870s, two linguists, Bleek and Lloyd, recorded the language of San Bushmen prisoners being held in Cape Town. Later, scholars realised that these |Xam (San/pronounced “Kgamm”) testimonies produced a “fit” with rock art images, which until then had been poorly understood. Dorothea Bleek’s 1932 study Customs and Beliefs of the |Xam Bushmen proved an almost inexhaustible resource for understanding this religious art from the perspective of the artists. Especially when these beliefs intersected with those of the Maloti Mountain San and Kalahari Bushmen, and other communities who inherited them.

What San painting was used in the coat of arms?

In 2000, President Thabo Mbeki’s office approached the Rock Art Research Institute because they wanted an indigenous rock art image to grace the coat of arms of the new South Africa. (The old shield had contained ox wagons and other colonial images.) The institute’s scholars offered several appropriate options, and the government chose the human figures from the famous Linton Panel, which is displayed at Iziko South African Museum in Cape Town.

 
 
The design for the coat of arms. Courtesy Rock Art Research Institute

With various partners we have reproduced the panel digitally. The art can now be viewed on an interactive zoom console in which visitors can highlight various motifs with explanations.

The two human figures come from one painting of a male figure. In the original, he most likely represents a San healer and game control specialist. He’s been mirrored and stylised to form a gesture of greeting.

How did a San phrase become a national motto?

Mbeki’s office also asked the institute to deliver a new national motto using the |Xam San language. Our professor, David Lewis-Williams, chose the |Xam words “ǃke e꞉ ǀxarra ǁke” from the phrases “people who are different” and “come together”. It can be translated as “diverse people, unite”. The language is no longer spoken (and so does not favour any of the country’s 11 official languages) but it is important to recognise that the people survive. There will be 16 individuals of |Xam descent at the opening, from the Bushman Heritage Museum. Three of these are the artists whose work forms part of the exhibit, in a modern |Xam take on the imagery in the national coat of arms.

There’s also a book being launched?

It is very fortunate timing that the institute’s honorary research fellow, Jeremy Hollmann, is launching a revised edition of his book Customs and Beliefs of the |Xam with Wits University Press at this time. Based on Dorothea Bleek’s 1932 Customs and Beliefs of the |Xam Bushmen, it brings the testimony of the |Xam to a wider audience, making San beliefs more accessible.

Why is this exhibition important?

As part of Wits University’s centenary celebrations, the new exhibit takes a fresh look at the symbols of what it means to be South African while also reflecting on what it means to be colonised and marginalised, as the San were and are. We celebrate the efforts to illuminate the indigenous archive, and to decolonise the images of these and other African ancestors. The Rock Art Research Institute is the first and foremost centre of its kind in the world.

 
 
Wits University Press

From the 1980s, its scholars, with David Lewis-Williams, joined the academic fight to bring to light the religious, and serious, nature of indigenous images and history. From the 1990s, its teachings have spanned the globe and influenced hunter-gatherer studies from Spain to Siberia and from Cape Town to Canada.

From the late 1990s, under Ben Smith, it strengthened connections across Africa (hosting the digital collections of several other nations) and in the 2000s created the Origins Centre (which then became a separate entity).

The exhibition opens at Origins Centre in Johannesburg on 28 November 2022

Author

  1. Sam Challis

    Senior Researcher, University of the Witwatersrand

Disclosure statement

Sam Challis works for Wits University's Rock Art Research Institute. He receives funding from the National Research Foundation African Origins Platform (Grant no. AOP117735). RARI acknowledges the generous sponsorship of Canon SA and the Rupert Art Foundation. The exhibit is funded by the Wits Centenary Fund.

Partners

 

University of the Witwatersrand provides support as a hosting partner of The Conversation AFRICA.

The Conversation is funded by the National Research Foundation, eight universities, including the Cape Peninsula University of Technology, Rhodes University, Stellenbosch University and the Universities of Cape Town, Johannesburg, Kwa-Zulu Natal, Pretoria, and South Africa. It is hosted by the Universities of the Witwatersrand and Western Cape, the African Population and Health Research Centre and the Nigerian Academy of Science. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is a Strategic Partner. more

DOI

https://doi.org/10.64628/AAJ.93s7gw4dn

We believe in the free flow of information
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons licence.
Republish this article
Support non-profit journalism

Dear Reader, I’m reaching out because The Conversation Africa is facing financial strain. As the philanthropic landscape shifts rapidly, funding for independent media is shrinking, putting our newsroom at real risk. We bring you free, evidence-based analysis straight from academic experts, helping millions make sense of our world. But quality journalism comes at a cost. To keep our content accessible to all without paywalls, we urgently need your help. If you value trusted, educational information in a world full of noise, please donate today. Your support right now will keep us publishing.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 20, 2:16 PM
Scoop.it!

KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous People of Southern Africa History: Ancient Southern African Rock Engravings Finally Find a Fitting Home 

13 January 2020 - Tammy Hodgskiss and Amanda Esterhuysen

The Origin Centre has added a new wing that's perfect for a visit, the Rock Engraving Archive.

 

The Origins Centre housed on the campus of the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg has just opened a new Rock Engraving Archive to the public. This is the biggest collection of rock engravings on display on the continent. It is the culmination of decades of shifting policy – and perceptions – of how South Africa should curate its rock art heritage. The exhibition marks a coming home of these extraordinary rocks that it’s now recognised should never have been removed from their natural environment.

The archive contains 76 boulders engraved with intricate images. The engravings depict animals (both realistic and mythological or zoomorphic) and geometric designs. Some have depictions of wagons or text.

 

Most of the engravings of animals may have been created by San hunter-gatherers, or their ancestors who were among the first people of southern Africa. There is an ongoing debate about whether the geometric images mark the arrival and movement of the Khoi or Khoekhoen stock-herding people. The geometrics may represent the spread and change of ideas among the San and a change in their hunter-gatherer way of life.

 

The majority of the engravings are on hard dolerite rocks. The mains techniques used to engrave the rocks are pecking or fine-lines, where the markings are made with a sharp object (such as a harder, denser rock or metal).

 

Some of the engravings can only be seen with lighting at a certain angle, as would have been the case when they were in their place of origin in the landscape – at certain times of day, and in certain light, the engravings would have ‘magically’ appeared. The sound that some rocks made when struck would have added to the experience on an auditory level, and a mark would have been left with each strike. Marks from the sharpening of tools and weapons against the hard surfaces also add a layer of meaning to the rocks.

 

A brand new installation at the Origins Rock Engraving Archive. Tammy Hodgskiss

There are other non-human traces to be found on some of the rock surfaces. Marks made by the repeated rubbing of animals against the rock surface, or through wind and water erosion.

The epic journey of the rocks

Today, every effort is made to conserve rock engravings in their original context. But in the first half of the 1900s many painted and engraved panels were removed to museum collections. At the time it was believed that this was the best way to protect them.

In the 1960s Wits University’s Dr Emil Paul Friede and Prof Revil Mason from the South African Archaeological Society assembled a major collection of rock engravings that had been removed from their original locations. The rocks had come from the Magaliesberg and around the Klerksdorp and Schweizer-Reneke region of the North West Province.

 

The engravings were arranged for exhibition to the public in a special display in the Johannesburg Zoological Gardens (now the Johannesburg Zoo). This was officially opened on 5 September 1970 as the Museum of South African Rock Art.

Workers move the boulders to Wits University’s Origins Centre. Tammy Hodgskiss

 

However, the exhibit was difficult to maintain, and staff and public grew increasingly uncomfortable about the social implications of displaying indigenous art in a zoo.

 

In the early 1990s the rock engraving exhibit was closed. The smaller pieces were taken to Museum Africa, but 36 larger pieces were left on display at the zoo. Over time the rock engravings at the zoo were neglected and became covered in moss.

 

In May 2000 the boulders were removed to Wits University under the curation of the Rock Art Research Institute, with funding from the Department of Arts and Culture.

 

Between 2000 and 2004 a team of conservators worked on cleaning, conserving and restoring these engravings. The engraved boulders housed in Museum Africa were moved to Wits University in 2005.

 

The boulders at the new museum, still wrapped in plastic to protect them. Tammy Hodgskiss

 

In 2017 these boulders were moved to the Origins Centre’s new wing and in 2019 the archive was opened to the public. The completion of the archive was funded by the National Institute for Humanities and Social Sciences.

The stories that the engravings tell

The first debates and publications about South African rock art centred on who made the rock art and why. Most incorrectly attributing the art to foreigners. While these early interpretations were entirely untrue, the interest in rock art raised an awareness about the need to protect it from damage and destruction. This led to South Africa’s first heritage legislation – the Bushman-Relic Protection Act of 1911 – which protected rock art, artefacts, and burials, and controlled the export of material to foreign museums.

One of the intricate engravings on a boulder in the museum.

 

Origins Rock Engraving Archive/ Tammy Hodgskiss

 

Until the 1980s little attention was given to recording the original context of the rock engravings. This changed when researchers began to appreciate how the engravings interacted with the landscape – how the experience of the art transforms with the light, wind, rain, sounds and the perspective of the viewer. Many of the meanings of the engravings may be unknown to us but the stories and beliefs of numerous individuals have been carefully engraved on these boulders.

 

The Origins Centre Rock Engraving Archive is the largest archive of rock engravings in the country. With the Rock Art Research Institute, it aims to facilitate the collection and organising of information and interpretations about these displaced pieces of art.

 

These national treasures are now a permanent component of the Origins Centre Museum experience – go and explore it for yourself.

 

Tammy Hodgskiss, Curator at the Origins Centre Museum, University of the Witwatersrand and Amanda Esterhuysen, Associate professor School of Geography, Archaeology and Environmental Studies, University of the Witwatersrand. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

 

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 18, 3:07 PM
Scoop.it!

Special Committee on Decolonization Approves Draft Resolution on Tokelau as It Concludes 2009 Resumed Session 

Special Committee on Decolonization Approves Draft Resolution on Tokelau as It Concludes 2009 Resumed Session  | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
GA/COL/3198
23 June 2009
Special Committee on Decolonization Approves Draft Resolution on Tokelau as It Concludes 2009 Resumed Session
23 June 2009   General AssemblyGA/COL/3198   Department of Public Information • News and Media Division • New York

Special Committee on

Decolonization

11th Meeting (AM)


SPECIAL COMMITTEE ON DECOLONIZATION APPROVES DRAFT RESOLUTION ON TOKELAU
AS IT CONCLUDES 2009 RESUMED SESSION

 


Members Hear from Titular Head of Government, Approve Report of Regional Seminar


The Special Committee on Decolonization concluded its resumed session this morning by taking up the question of Tokelau, the report of the Caribbean Regional Seminar and the report on issues related to its own work.


Acting without a vote, the Special Committee approved a draft resolution on the question of Tokelau, a Pacific Non-Self-Governing Territory administered by New Zealand, recommending that the General Assembly note the continued recognition by the Government of New Zealand of the right of the Territory’s people to self-determination and the firm commitment of both Tokelau and New Zealand to ongoing development for the long-term benefit of the Territory’s people.


While noting that referendums in 2006 and 2007 had not produced the two-thirds majority required to change the Territory’s non-self-governing status, the Assembly would further acknowledge the decision of the General Fono (the national Parliament) that consideration of any future act of self-determination would be deferred, and that New Zealand and Tokelau would devote renewed efforts to strengthening essential services and infrastructure on the atolls, thereby ensuring an enhanced quality of life for the people.  The Assembly would also acknowledge Tokelau’s initiative in devising a strategic economic development plan for the period 2007-2010.


Introducing the draft resolution, the representative of Papua New Guinea said the text welcomed the assurance by the Government of New Zealand that it would continue to meet its obligations with respect to Tokelau.  It also welcomed the cooperative attitude of other States and territories of the region and their support for Tokelau’s economic and political aspirations, and the Territory’s increasing participation in regional and international affairs.  He reiterated the co-sponsors’ commendation for New Zealand’s readiness to cooperate with the Special Committee and its exemplary efforts in assisting the people of Tokelau in their endeavours to realize self-determination.


The representative of Fiji, the second co-sponsor, thanked New Zealand for its financial support of Tokelau, while also acknowledging the work of the United Nations and stressing his recognition of the decolonization processes in Tokelau and New Caledonia.  Fiji saw no better way to achieve the Special Committee’s mandate.


Echoing that sentiment, Faipule Foua Toloa, Ulu o Tokelau (Titular Head of Government of Tokelau), said: “I believe that Tokelau is moving in the right direction and, already, the wind that fills our sails grows stronger day by day as we strengthen the capacity of our resources and develop our infrastructure.


Speaking as a petitioner prior to the Special Committee’s approval of the draft resolution, he said Tokelau would not give up its aspirations for self-determination, while stressing that the challenge for its leaders continued to be the strengthening of institutions and the unity of the people.  The General Fono had resolved in February 2008 that a lot of work remained to be done in strengthening local capacity and infrastructure, and in promoting economic development.  While work on self-determination would continue, it would be several years before another referendum was considered.


Like all nations around the globe, Tokelau was feeling the effects of the global financial crisis and taking measures to address it, while instilling confidence that its policies made the best use of scarce resources, he said.  It was establishing its development priorities, setting realistic targets and working towards integrating good governance practices into its public management systems.  Tokelau would then realign public expenditure to reflect the focus on those areas.


The relationship between Tokelau and New Zealand was significant, he said, as witnessed by their Joint Principles of Partnership signed in 2003 and the current support arrangement, which stood at NZ$43.1 million for 2008-2010.  During its upcoming first meeting with the Prime Minister of New Zealand, the Council of Ongoing Government hoped to convey the importance of that special relationship.  Tokelau would continue to seek New Zealand’s support as it strove to determine its own future.


He also outlined Tokelau’s efforts to contain the outbreak of H1N1 influenza and to address the effects of global warming and rising sea levels, pointing out that access to funding from the climate change adaptation programme had been thwarted by its status as a Non-Self-Governing Territory of New Zealand.  He called on the international community to continue to advocate Tokelau’s position on that issue, and to take practical and immediate steps to reduce the types of activities that impacted negatively on the environment and caused global warming.


For its part, Tokelau was working on an energy policy that would allow its small atolls to operate on 100 per cent renewable energy, he said, adding that the Territory’s development priorities were identified in its National Strategic Plan for the next five years.  Its other programmes included a joint Tokelau-New Zealand shipping project; the construction of two schools and a health centre under its infrastructure project; efforts to develop human resources capacity; a project to strengthen the delivery of village-level judicial services; and a waste management programme.


The Tokelau Trust Fund now stood at some NZ$56 million, he continued, pointing out that the Territory continued to build a reputable status in the region and at the international level.  The ingredients of nation-building were now in place, including the Constitution and the flag.  The Constitutional Committee would meet later this year to discuss governance structures.  “We will line our canoe with the support from our main partner, New Zealand, in cooperation with this Committee, but at all times we will keep the interests of the people of Tokelau at the heart of our efforts.  Our canoe will be lined with the elements of good governance, sustainable development strategies, robust infrastructure, qualified and experienced personnel and a clear vision for the direction that we want to take.”


New Zealand’s representative said the past year had been a challenging one for Tokelau, yet considerable achievements had been made.  The global economic crisis had not bypassed the Territory, despite the isolation of its three remote atolls.  Ensuring that the 1,500 people of the three atolls had access to essential services and enjoyed a good quality of life were core objectives for both Tokelau and New Zealand.


She said substantial efforts had been devoted to enhancing economic development and making improvements in the core sectors of water and sanitation and waste management.  Finding programmes and strategies that worked for Tokelau and were fully compatible with local values was an important goal for New Zealand, as well as agencies of the international community.  New Zealand was committed to working closely and cooperatively with the Ulu, his fellow leaders and officials to deliver the best possible service for the people of Tokelau in the present challenging times.


The increasing spread of H1N1 influenza had not left Tokelau untouched and its health system was under pressure as it dealt with a number of possible cases, she said.  However, through very close cooperation with the World Health Organization and the New Zealand Ministry of Health, Tokelau was very well prepared and had support for the challenges that lay ahead.  The new Prime Minister, during a forthcoming visit to Samoa, would meet with Tokelau’s leaders in Apia for the first time since the change of Government in November 2008.  It would be an important opportunity to affirm New Zealand’s commitment to Tokelau, and the shared determination of both parties to work for a viable and forward-looking community on the atolls of Tokelau.


Also this morning, the Special Committee adopted the report of the Caribbean Regional Seminar on Implementation of the Second International Decade for the Eradication of Colonialism, to be annexed to the Special Committee’s report for the current session of the General Assembly.  The Seminar took place in Saint Kitts and Nevis on 12-14 May.


In other action, the Committee approved, also without a vote, a text on matters related to its work (document A/AC.109/2009/L.14), including the convening of a series of meetings away from Headquarters; representation at seminars, meetings and conferences of intergovernmental and other organizations; the pattern of conferences; control and limitation of documentation; consideration of the list of Territories to which the Declaration on the Granting of Independence is applicable; the Second International Decade for the Eradication of Colonialism; and participation by representatives of Non-Self-Governing Territories in the Special Committee’s work.


In connection with the Second International Decade, the Special Committee would inform the Assembly of its decision to organize, in 2010, a seminar in the Pacific region, to be attended by representatives of all Non-Self-Governing Territories.


Closing the session, Special Committee Chair R.M. Marty M. Natalegawa ( Indonesia) reiterated his conviction that the Committee must redouble its efforts to help ensure that the decolonization process became more relevant and beneficial to the 16 Non-Self-Governing Territories under its purview.  Throughout its substantive session, the Special Committee had endorsed 11 draft resolutions and 3 reports, and would submit all relevant information and documents to the General Assembly through the Fourth Committee (Special Political and Decolonization).


The Special Committee, he continued, had an ongoing responsibility to make tangible progress in implementing the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples (resolution 1514 (XV) of 14 December 1960), subsequent relevant General Assembly resolutions, and the principles and provisions of the United Nations Charter.  The Special Committee must also continue exploring further how to guide the decolonization process through the many challenges and opportunities of the contemporary world.


He said the upcoming conclusion of the Second International Decade underlined the urgent need to support the Non-Self-Governing Territories in establishing the conditions for full self-government, which would allow them to demonstrate their will regarding their future political status through a valid internationally recognized act of self-determination, eventually leading to their “de-listing”.

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
October 31, 4:37 PM
Scoop.it!

The Making of Griqua, Indigenous Struggles for Land and Autonomy in South Africa

The Making of Griqua, Indigenous Struggles for Land and Autonomy in South Africa | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

Abstract

With the dawn of democracy in South Africa in 1994, the struggle of indigenous Griqua for land has gained new momentum. Having lost most of their ancestral land in the 19th century due to colonialism, Griqua people are now using new legal opportunities to reclaim land. On their reobtained land Griqua people dwell, farm, celebrate indigenous festivals and create cultural villages for tourists. In doing so, Griqua people are currently contributing to the making of Ethnicity, Inc., the double process of commodification of culture and creation of ethnic businesses. The pdf is an excerpt of the book which comprises the contents, the introduction, chapter 4 and 9.

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 5:52 PM
Scoop.it!

Indigenous Knowledge vs Space: Ever Forward - The Unique Relationship Between the Arctic and Space


Posted date/time: November 1, 2024

By David Marsh

 
 
 

 

In 1892, a group of adventurers settled on a new idea for Arctic exploration. Rather than using a regular sailing vessel, optimized for speed on the open ocean but weak to the crushing forces of sea ice, they built a ship designed to freeze. As ice closed in, this ship’s rounded hull would allow it to “float” above, riding the icepack through the winter and, hopefully, making it through the Northwest Passage. They named this ship Fram, Norwegian for “forward.” Fram would participate in three polar expeditions: one, led by Fridtjof Nansen in an attempt to reach the North Pole; a second, led by Otto Sverdrup, which charted a massive section of the Northwest Passages and charted  the islands now known as the Sverdrup Islands in the Canadian Arctic Archipelago; and a third, led by Roald Amundsen, on the first expedition to reach the South Pole. Amundsen later led the first successful ship-borne journey through the Northwest Passage on a different ship, the Gjøa, in 1906.

 

Today, in 2024, a different group of adventurers will pioneer another new idea for Arctic exploration. They will not travel by ship, skis, sled, or plane - instead, they’ll travel by spacecraft. They’ll become the first people to orbit the Earth in a polar orbit, “floating” over the North and South poles approximately every ninety minutes as they conduct science experiments and observations. Launching from Cape Canaveral on a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket, they’ll fly onboard a SpaceX Crew Dragon spacecraft. But they call their mission Fram2.

 

The Fram2 expedition is only the most recent example of the relationship between space exploration and the Arctic region. Since the days of Sputnik, launched in 1957 during the International Polar Year of international cooperation, these two domains have been tied together by geography and necessity. During the Cold War, the Arctic was heavily militarized, with radar stations and satellite ground antennas strategically placed to cover the shortest distance between the two superpowers, ready to track ballistic missiles. 

 

Now, as competition between NATO, the Russian Federation, and the People’s Republic of China heats up, the Arctic is well-understood as a military domain influenced by space - the latest DoD Arctic Strategy, released in July 2024, mentions space capabilities nineteen  times; an increase from thirteen mentions in the 2019 edition. The US and China currently operate independent military branches dedicated to space (the US Space Force - which has a base in Greenland - and the People’s Liberation Army Aerospace Force, while the Russian military is quick to demonstrate and deploy offensive space capabilities.

 

However, the ties between space and the Arctic expand beyond military maneuvering. There is a larger political, economic, and social relationship that not only impacts the millions of people who call the Arctic home, but everyone on Earth who stands to be affected by climate change. It can even teach us important lessons about life on other planets. In August, I was able to spend two weeks in the Arctic studying this relationship on an expedition sponsored by The Explorers Club and Adventure Canada, and this post includes some observations from that research.

 

First, we need to talk about physics and geography. Activities in space are intrinsically tied to the geography of the Earth. The most efficient way to launch a rocket is directly to the East and right at the equator, taking maximum advantage of the Earth’s rotation. This is why the main American launch sites are in Florida and southern California; European rockets launch from French Guiana; and the heaviest Chinese rockets take off from Hainan Island in the South China Sea. Sometimes, however, rockets launch in less efficient directions to place payloads in specific orbits. Polar orbits, in which a spacecraft passes over the North and South poles, are used for Earth observation, reconnaissance, weather monitoring, and some telecommunications satellites. Certain near-polar orbits, known as sun-synchronous, are timed to allow a spacecraft to pass over the same spot on the Earth at the same time each day - so that shadows remain the same in every image. Other orbits, such as Molniya and Tundra orbits, are highly elliptical and allow for longer “dwell time” over high latitude areas. 

 

No matter the orbit, spacecraft need to be in communication with the ground as they travel around the planet - about once every ninety minutes, in a polar orbit - and require ground stations with powerful antennas. This results in stations scattered across the globe, from the Australian outback to South Pacific Islands, and, of course, the Arctic. In order to expand their satellite control ability beyond their borders, the PRC operates a fleet of satellite command ships and built a ground station in Argentina. In another example of political geography determining space activities, the orbit of the International Space Station (ISS), which is in Low Earth Orbit at an inclination of about 51.6 degrees, was selected by a joint committee of NASA and Roscosmos. It was chosen over lower (more efficient) orbits because it is the lowest inclination reachable from Baikonur Cosmodrome (the southernmost launch site operated by Russia) without overflying mainland China.

Due to these geographic facts, space and the Arctic are intrinsically connected. The United States, Norway, and Russia each operate launch sites in or near the Arctic Circle, specifically for placing satellites into polar orbits.

 

Original map from the DOD Arctic Strategy 2024, edited by the author to include dark triangles representing launch sites in Kodiak Island, Alaska; Andøya, Norway; Esrange, Sweden; and Plesetsk, Russia.

 

Not only are Arctic ground stations, like those in Svalbard, Norway and Gilmore Creek, Alaska, required to maintain continuous contact with these polar-orbiting satellites, but space-based capabilities often represent the most efficient way to monitor the Arctic due to remote communities and extreme environments. 

Some of the earliest comprehensive analysis of Arctic and Antarctic ice sheets was conducted via satellite, such as NASA’s GRACE (Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment) and ICESat (Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite) programs in the 2000s, which provide key data sets for understanding the progression of climate change.

 

Just this year, two major Arctic-related weather missions launched, both products of international cooperation. First, the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF), an American NGO, partnered with the New Zealand Space Agency to build and launch MethaneSAT, a satellite designed to monitor global methane emissions. Placed into a sun-synchronous orbit by a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket (with New Zealand launch competitor Rocket Lab contributing a mission operations center), MethaneSAT will track Arctic oil and gas facilities. In August, the European Space Agency’s (ESA) Arctic Weather Satellite mission launched (again on a Falcon 9). This satellite, with industrial contributions from twelve ESA member-states, carries a microwave radiometer to measure humidity and temperature.

 

NASA’s Landsat program, culminating in Landsat9 launched in 2021, has been gathering images of the Earth for more than fifty years. A stable of commercial imagery services, like Maxar, Planet, Spire (all publicly traded) and other smaller startups image every inch of the planet and offer their data to paying customers. These services continue to expand - there were over 1,000 Earth observation satellites orbiting in 2023. 

 

While these types of satellite missions gather terabytes of data every day, that data is only relevant to Arctic communities if it can be accessed when needed and linked to real situations on the ground. Projects likeSMARTIce, which pairs local knowledge with satellite data and employs indigenous observers, and IcySea, a commercial mapping application that provides timely, low-bandwidth imagery, weather, and navigation data to Arctic operators, help promote this accessibility. But without reliable access to the internet, these data and services are operationally useless. Satellite communication networks like Iridium, Telesat, and SpaceX’s Starlink provide internet access to the most remote communities, those unreachable by fiber optic or submarine cables. These networks, and the chase to build and expand them, result in some huge economic figures. SpaceX’s Starlink generates more than six billion USD in revenue per year.

 

The Canadian government has invested nearly two billion USD in Telesat’s domestic alternative to Starlink, called Lightspeed; and an indigenous-owned private equity group, Sixty North Unity, is buying Northwestel, the leading northern Canadian communications utility, from Bell Canada.  Northwestel has signed deals with both Telesat and OneWeb for satellite services. Beyond commercial services, the US military has pushed for enhanced communication capabilities in high latitudes. The Arctic Satellite Broadband Mission, a partnership between the US Space Force and Space Norway, consists of two interoperable satellites carrying a variety of commercial and government payloads to support communications about sixty-five degrees. Launched in August 2024 onboard a (you guessed it!) SpaceX Falcon 9, this mission is the first time an operational Department of Defense payload is carried on an international spacecraft. As climate change continues, more commercial activity takes place in the region, and geopolitical tensions increase, the resilience of communication services, navigation capabilities like GPS, and other tracking capabilities such as AIS and ADS-B will be critical to ensuring safe operations and peaceful cooperation.

 

When we talk about space, it’s not just satellites. Space exploration also involves people. Whether the civilian crew of Fram2 or the International Space Station astronauts from NASA and other space agencies, human exploration has always been a driver of our reach into the cosmos. As NASA prepares to send humans back to the Moon and SpaceX prepares Starship for eventual Martian landings, the Arctic plays a role here, too. Devon Island, the largest uninhabited island in the world, hosts two “analog astronaut” facilities: one, the Haughton Mars Project (HMP) is operated by NASA; the other, the Flashline Mars Arctic Research Station (FMARS) is owned by a private, non-profit organization, the Mars Society. Both of these analogs are located within the Haughton crater, a thirty-million-year-old impact site, and host temporary crews of “astronauts”, who go through the motions of living and working on other planets.

 

The environment on Devon Island - windswept, barren, and rocky - simulates the Martian surface, and the analog astronauts conduct their work as if they really were on Mars - including wearing spacesuits outside and imposing a delay on their communication with the outside world (light takes between three and twenty minutes to travel from the Earth to Mars, depending on their orbital alignment). These expeditions gather valuable information about crew psychology and group dynamics while testing equipment, procedures, and techniques for future space-bound missions. 

When Fram2 launches, it will also carry amateur radio equipment, which will be used to conduct a STEM competition amongst universities and secondary education organizations around the globe. Just as the Northwest Passage captured the attention of adventurers for centuries, space is an opportunity to inspire the next generation of scientists, leaders, and explorers. The Arctic is a perfect place to see how those achievements in space matter for the people who live on Earth - no matter where they call home.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 5:05 PM
Scoop.it!

Indigenous People and New Global Capitalism in Transition

Indigenous People and New Global Capitalism in Transition | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

 

The Trilateral Commission convened in 2021 distinguished business leaders, scholars, and policymakers from around the world in its Task Force on Global Capitalism in Transition.


The time was right for this effort. Capitalism or market-based economies are at a historic transition point. Capitalism’s positive impact on prosperity and well-being is unmatched. Nonetheless, many people are frustrated today by its inability to handle some of the greatest challenges facing society. There are growing concerns about whether market-based economies will be able to address three major challenges. First, climate change. Second, the disruptions triggered by the digital revolution. Third, rising inequalities.


This report represents the culmination of this Trilateral effort to understand these challenges and chart a path forward. This report calls for a new “Social Compact with the Next Generations.” This compact prioritizes equality of opportunity. The report does not offer one-size-fits-all solutions. Rather, it suggests an overall direction for governments, businesses, and nonprofit institutions and specific steps they can take to achieve critical common goals.


Moving toward a more sustainable and inclusive capitalism is a defining challenge of our age. The task force hopes its work stimulates discussion, debate, and, ultimately, decision.

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 4:31 PM
Scoop.it!

Foundations of Indigenous Nation Building | Harvard Kennedy School

Foundations of Indigenous Nation Building | Harvard Kennedy School | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

A renaissance among Native communities has been powered by the energy and determination of the country’s American Indian nations. And, since 1987, by the Indigenous Governance and Development program.

 
 
 
 
Fall 2024

THERE IS A RENAISSANCE among native communities throughout the world. In the United States, that resurgence has been powered by the energy and determination of the country’s more than 570 American Indian nations. And, since 1987, those efforts have been supported by the Harvard Kennedy School Project on Indigenous Governance and Development, a program housed at the Ash Center for Democratic Governance and Innovation and founded and led by Joe Kalt, Ford Foundation Professor of International Political Economy, Emeritus. Through the work of its staff and advisory groups, a majority of them Indigenous, the project has helped develop, share, and honor best practices in Indigenous governance by way of its flagship national awards program, Honoring Nations, which is celebrating its 25th year (and is generously supported by the Bush Foundation).

“It would be almost impossible to overstate the importance and impact of the Harvard Project and Honoring Nations. The program has changed the way Indian Country think about questions of governance and government performance.”
Honorable Chief Oren Lyons, faithkeeper of the Onondaga Nation
 

The project has found that success in Indigenous self-determinations rests on four core principles: sovereignty, institutions, culture, and leadership. Read about some of the program awardees below.

 

SOVEREIGNTY MATTERS

Self-determination through local self-government works. When Indigenous nations make their own decisions, they consistently outperform non-tribal decision-makers.

School-Based Health Centers, Fort Peck Tribes

Located in the unhealthiest county in Montana, the Fort Peck Tribes’ School-Based Health Centers bring quality health care into the schools, serving all youth, Native and non-Native. The centers are an outstanding example of self-determination and a powerful reminder that having healthy citizens is critical for building strong nations.

Air Quality Program, Gila River Indian Community

The Gila River Indian Community’s Air Quality Program reviews operating permits of Native- and non-Native-owned industrial facilities located on the reservation. It monitors compliance and issues fines when necessary. Not only do their efforts improve air quality for the tribe, but they also improve it for the entire Phoenix, Arizona, metropolitan area.

Child Welfare Program, Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe 

The Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe created its own Child Welfare Program and took control over federal funds for child welfare, a first among tribes in the United States. Governing guardianship assistance, foster care, and adoption assistance, Port Gamble has reclaimed control over the placement of children and changed Washington State law to redefine “family” as “tribe.”

 
 

 

INSTITUTIONS MATTER

Assertions of sovereignty must be backed by effective governance. Stable systems, independent dispute resolution, and sound management are key.

Wellness Programming, Yurok Tribe 

Grounded in Yurok values of reciprocal responsibility, the Yurok tribal court’s Wellness Court Programming is reclaiming its people—and its future. The court practices concurrent jurisdiction with the state of California and infuses traditional tribal values into contemporary jurisprudence to serve tribal citizens in effective and culturally appropriate ways.

Ho-Chunk, Inc., Winnebago Tribe of Nebraska

Ho-Chunk, Inc. is a vehicle for self-sufficiency by diversifying the Winnebago Tribe’s economic landscape. It creates jobs through its business enterprises, joint ventures, and passive investments, reducing unemployment rates from 78% to 5% in just 10 years. The revenue funds key governmental services and supports the region’s infrastructure beyond the reservation boundaries.

Fisheries Department, Nez Perce Tribe

In an effort to restore salmon populations that were decimated by dams and habitat destruction, the Nez Perce Tribe built one of the largest and most successful fisheries departments in the United States. Working with federal, state, and tribal counterparts, the fisheries department reclaimed a leadership role in managing natural resources throughout the region. It was instrumental in restoring salmon to the Columbia River Basin.

Agricultural Programs, Quapaw Nation

The Quapaw Tribe Agricultural Programs are a farm-to-table initiative that houses the first USDA-certified meat processing plant in Indian Country. Promoting healthy diets and job creation, the programs focus on sustainable and humane methods of breeding, raising, and processing livestock as well as planting and harvesting crops for the community.

 
 

 

CULTURE MATTERS

Nation-building success requires culturally grounded institutions of self-government. The huge diversity of Indigenous cultures means that one size does not fit all, and effective governing solutions do not have to look “Western.”

Environmental Program, Native Village of Kotzebue

The Native Village of Kotzebue Environmental Program advances village research priorities that meld Iñupiat traditional knowledge with Western science, influences state and federal policy, and fully participates in the management of natural resources critical to protecting and sustaining their cultural, nutritional, and spiritual lifeways. 

Myaamiaki Eemamwiciki Program, Miami Tribe of Oklahoma

The Miami Tribe of Oklahoma created the Myaamiaki Eemamwiciki Program to strengthen kinship ties and culture, reconnecting citizens with their Indigenous value system. The program is reviving a dormant language, restoring cultural traditions, overcoming centuries of displacement and assimilation, and demonstrating the resilience of the Myaamia people.

Archie Hendricks, Sr. Skilled Nursing Facility, Tohono O’odham Nation 

For decades Tohono O’odham elders in need of skilled nursing had two choices: move far away from home to receive care, or forgo long-term care services. With the opening of the Archie Hendricks, Sr. Skilled Nursing Facility, O’odham elders can now remain in the community. Grounded in their traditional core value of Himdag, the facility fuses the latest technologies and world-class clinical care with traditional values. The nursing home is also a major employer in the area, creating good, stable jobs. It has become one of the finest elder care facilities anywhere in the country, receiving a five-star certification.

 
 

 

LEADERSHIP MATTERS

Self-determined success in nation building rests upon leaders who can both carry out community decisions and act as educators who inform and inspire their fellow citizens.

Walleye Recovery Project, Red Lake Nation

As one of the most successful fish population recoveries in North America, the Red Lake Walleye Recovery Project demonstrates how tribal governments can strengthen their sovereignty by preserving precious resources for future generations. This recovery effort restores the promise of cultural continuity, economic means, and pride to the community.

Health Aide Training Programs, Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium

Visiting a medical professional is rarely easy in rural Alaska. Communities are isolated, medical needs are significant, and patients’ cultural and linguistic backgrounds can affect diagnoses and treatments. As the backbone of the Alaska Native health care system, the Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium trains and certifies aides in community, dental, and behavioral health, serving over 170 communities in rural Alaska and cities across the state.

Prison Reintegration Program, Muscogee Nation

Working closely with Oklahoma corrections officials and district judges, the Muscogee Nation operates a prisoner reintegration program to rehabilitate Muscogee citizens who have gotten into trouble with the law. Ex-offenders come home to the Muscogee Nation and, once settled, begin to make their own contributions to strengthening the Nation and the state of Oklahoma.

— 
Photos courtesy of:

Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium, Blue Lake Rancheria, Citizen Potawatomi Nation, Sarah Grucza, Megan Minoka Hill, Moana Palelei Iose, Amy Besaw Medford, John Rae/NYC, Martha Stewart, Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians, Sitka Tribe of Alaska, and Yukon Kuskokwim Health Corporation

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 4:27 PM
Scoop.it!

Reflections on the Importance of Indigenous Peoples’ Day | Harvard Kennedy School

Reflections on the Importance of Indigenous Peoples’ Day | Harvard Kennedy School | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
Reflections by Mathias Risse, Carr Center Faculty Director

On this Indigenous Peoples’ Day, I am moved to share some thoughts on why this holiday is so important. Much of my own research in recent years has been about Indigenous thought and how to integrate it better into mainstream debates. I am in the process of completing a book tentatively called Indigenous Thought: A Renewed Engagement for the 21st Century, and I’ve started to teach a new class at Harvard Kennedy School called “Indigenous Philosophies for the Technological Era.” The motivation for both is that, for a variety of reasons, it behooves us all to take Indigenous thought more seriously, if only to have better ways of thinking about our relationship with the rest of nature.  

I often ask my students four questions to assess how much they know about the role of Indigenous peoples in American history. Typically, and troublingly, nobody knows the answer to any of these questions, even though we are talking about major events in American history. And I will admit that I didn’t know the answer to any of these questions either until a few years ago. It’s clear that we need to try to do better in this domain. 

Question 1: Have You Heard of King Philip’s War?  

King Philip’s War was a major conflict in New England in the 1670s that killed several thousand people, both Native Americans and settlers. This amounted to a considerable share of the population at the time, making it a conflict of existential proportions.  

English settlement in what then came to be known as Massachusetts began systematically in the mid-1620s, and Boston itself was founded in 1630. When English settlers began to arrive in larger numbers, most Indigenous people in the area—including most Massachusett and large numbers of Wampanoag—had already perished from European diseases spread by earlier sporadic encounters. They had no biological defenses against smallpox, measles, and the like. English settlers arrived in a landscape where, in many locations, about 80% of the population had already perished.  

While initial relations with the remaining Wampanoag and other groups were fairly peaceful, that changed quickly as more and more settlers arrived. Within a few decades it was clear to Indigenous Americans that they were in a struggle for survival, and a war resulted in which many settlements in New England were burned down. Eventually the tides turned, and the Native Americans were defeated and basically ceased to exist as a political and military force to be reckoned with in New England. (To be sure, to this day there continue to be both Massachusett and Wampanoag.) Their leader was Metacom, known to the English as King Philip. This conflict set the stage for future encounters between settlers and Indigenous people. A good book to read on this is Jill Lepore’s King Philip’s War and the Origin of American Identity.  

Question 2: Have You Heard of the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy and How it Influenced the American Constitution?  

The Iroquois Confederacy—or in their own terminology, the Haudenosaunee Confederacy—was a group of initially five, later six, tribes in upstate New York, including the Mohawk and the Seneca. After a history of bitter fighting, they united under the leadership of a legendary peacemaker and governed themselves through federal structures.  

In the decades preceding the American Revolution, the Confederacy had regular encounters with some of the people later involved in the Revolution, including Benjamin Franklin. It will be hard to prove conclusively just how these encounters shaped the mindset of the revolutionaries, but it is hard to ignore the fact that the United States ended up with a constitution that enshrined both federalism and democracies—neither of which were practiced in England, but both of which were practiced by their Haudenosaunee neighbors.  

Recent research has delivered insights as to the larger impact of encounters with Indigenous peoples and their governance structures on the Enlightenment era. A good book to read on this is The Dawn of Everything, by David Graeber and David Wengrow. 

Question 3: Have You Heard of the California Genocide?  

The United States took over California in the late 1840s, at the same time as a major gold rush. This was awful news for the hundreds of Indigenous groups who lived there. The arrival of many thousands of gold diggers caused a population decline among Indigenous peoples steeper than any other in U.S. history.  

Between 1848 and 1860, the Native population fell from an estimated 150,000 to about 30,000. Many of them, as before, died from diseases brought by the new arrivals. But many others were enslaved and perished that way, or they were simply killed. In 2019, California Governor Gavin Newsom recognized this historical episode as a genocide and signed an executive order formally apologizing to California's Native American populations. A good book to read about this, and about a number of other awful episodes in the history of California, is Jean Pfaelzer’s California: A Slave State.  

Question 4: Have You Heard of the Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890?  

The United States Army conducted decades of wars against Native American tribes following the conclusion of the Civil War as part of westward expansion. In the 1860s and 1870s, the Lakota and other groups in the Northern Great Plains had still managed to offer fierce resistance and inflicted a number of noteworthy defeats on the army, especially in the 1876 Battle of Little Big Horn (also known as Custer’s Last Stand). 

In late 1890, however, a major struggle occurred between the U.S. Army and a group of Lakota in Wounded Knee, South Dakota. As a result, about 300 Lakota, including many women and children, were massacred by the army. This mass shooting marks a major turning point in American history, symbolizing the conclusive end of American westward expansion and the end of any kind of effective Native American resistance.  

The defeat of Native American tribal resistance gave way to the full-fledged implementation of policies of allocation (breaking apart Native American community properties) and boarding-school education that traumatized generations of Native Americans. A good book to read on this is David Treuer’s The Heartbeat of Wounded Knee: Native America from 1890 to the Present.  

On this Indigenous Peoples’ Day, we remember these events—and the other small and large events like it that shaped this country. As for myself, I commit to continuing to learn more about the Indigenous nations, scholars, and leaders that are thriving across the United States today. Their knowledge, history, and valuable contributions are integral to the fabric of our nation. 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 4:02 PM
Scoop.it!

Indigenous Land: "Governing" Urban Fringes Impacts Africas Urban Growth Peri Urban Areas

Indigenous Land: "Governing" Urban Fringes Impacts Africas Urban Growth Peri Urban Areas | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

Governing the urban fringes: the impacts of Africa’s urban growth on peri-urban areas

Conferences
Open event
 

Practical information

 
Thursday 26 September 2024
 
14:30 — 16:30
 
At Ifri — 27 rue de la Procession, 75015 Paris

Accessibility

 
French and English with simultaneous translation in hybrid format
 

The rapid expansion of Africa’s cities is considered as one of the continent’s main socio-economic challenges.

Unlike in Europe, North America and East Asia, the spatial trend of urban expansion in sub-Saharan Africa is horizontal. Rather than growing upward through taller buildings, Africa’s cities expand into their peri-urban rural outskirts. Thus, peri-urban areas are undergoing considerable spatial, socio-economic and administrative change: farmland is absorbed by buildings and commercial activities, land prices are spiking and new class dynamics can be observed.

 

 

The outward expansion of Africa’s cities happens randomly without large-scale urban planning, which makes the governance of peri-urban areas difficult.  

The aim of this conference, which is part of the programme “Governing Africa’s Urban Transitions” is to unpack the rapid transformations occurring in peri-urban areas: experts and professionals will zoom into dynamic land markets and land use change, infrastructure development and economic value chains at the crossroads of urban and rural areas.  

 

Speakers :

Divine Asafo, Senior Lecturer in Human Geography, University of Hull, England

Alix Beranger, Consulting & Operations, Egis

Bérénice Bon, Research Fellow in Geography, Urban Dynamics in the South, IRD, France

Jackson Kago, Senior Lecturer, Department of Spatial Planning and Environment, School of Architecture and Built Environment, Kenyatta University, Kenya

 

Moderation: Sina Schlimmer, Head of the “Governing Urban Transitions in Africa” program, Ifri, France

 

The event will be held face-to-face and in hybrid format (via zoom) in French, with English translation.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 3:46 PM
Scoop.it!

Nnamdi Kanu and the Indigenous People of Biafra Nigeria | Council on Foreign Relations

Published
September 28, 2017 2:25 p.m.
John Campbell
Ralph Bunche Senior Fellow for Africa Policy Studies
 
 
 

The government of Nigeria has formally labeled the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) a terrorist organization. Following a September 14 military attack on his house in Umuahia, the capital of Abia state, the organization’s leader Nnamdi Kanu is nowhere to be found. Kanu’s lawyer maintains that government security services are holding him and members of his family in secret, including his father Eze Israel Kanu, a traditional ruler, and his mother. Government spokesmen are maintaining that Kanu, who has been under house arrest and is facing charges of treason, has jumped bail. According to the Nigerian media, there is speculation that Kanu is dead, killed by the security forces.

 

IPOB agitates for Biafran independence, but asserts that it is non-violent. In 2015, Kanu was arrested and charged with treason. After some eighteen months, he was released, apparently to house arrest, pending his trial, which is scheduled to take place in the next few weeks. Kanu’s lawyer is insisting that the security services are holding him and therefore must present him at the trial. Government spokesmen of variable authority are saying or implying that Kanu has jumped bail. There is speculation that he is hiding out with militants in the creeks.

 

Kanu was born in 1967 in Nigeria. He went to England and attended the University of North London. In the UK, he was the director of Radio Biafra, an advocate for Biafran independence. He maintains that he is a convert to Judaism. 

 

The 1967-70 civil war over the independence of Biafra was in many ways the central event in Nigeria’s post-colonial history. Estimates of those who died before Biafra was re-incorporated into Nigeria range from one to two million. For Nigerian president Muhammadu Buhari and for much of the political class, Biafran separatism is unacceptable. The concern must be that if the government overreacts, it will fuel sympathy for a renewed Biafran independence movement.
 

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 3:15 PM
Scoop.it!

Indigenous Land and Critical Minerals: A Pathway to Responsible Mining in Indian Country

Indigenous Land and Critical Minerals: A Pathway to Responsible Mining in Indian Country | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

Commentary by Daniel Cardenas, Rick Tallman, Brad Handler, and Morgan Bazilian

Published November 9, 2023

 

The demand for minerals critical to both the energy transition and U.S. national security is growing rapidly. At the same time, the reliability of the global supply chain is being challenged by geopolitical events. The result is a growing call to bring more mining for these critical minerals back to the United States, where the vast majority of critical mineral reserves are located on or within 35 miles of Native American reservations.

 

Tribal communities are some of the poorest in communities in the United States. Even though they are collectively the largest landowners outside the federal government, Native Americans continue to experience persistent poverty by every measure. How can the United States have a legitimate critical minerals discussion knowing that its most vulnerable population sits on the largest concentration of mineral wealth left in this nation? 

Historically, mining on tribal lands has been a tale of economic exploitation, abrogated agreements, stolen lands, environmental disasters, and life-altering health impairments inflicted on the Native American community. Indian country continues to grapple with the consequences to this day. On Navajo lands alone, nearly 30 million tons of uranium ore were extracted between 1944 and 1989. This has caused lingering health problems for the Navajo people, from both environmental contamination at the mine and mill sites, and from living in houses built with mine and mill waste.

 

Today, there is a generational opportunity to learn from this very difficult history and introduce a new age of equitable U.S. mining in partnership with tribal communities. Modern sustainable techniques can limit the physical impact of mining and processing activities, and new international protocols have been developed around the world, such as in Canada, to ensure local tribal communities are engaged throughout the process. Unlike most current policies in the United States, these protocols are mandated to seek the consent of local Indigenous peoples before regulatory approval is given.

 

The potential for tribes to benefit from mining is significant. An example is the Thacker Pass lithium mine in northern Nevada. This mine, which is expected to produce enough lithium to supply batteries to roughly one million electric vehicles per year, will at its peak provide 1,100 jobs. The project is located on federal land that are the traditional lands of the Fort McDermitt Paiute and Shoshone Tribe and is culturally, historically, and spiritually significant to the tribe.

 

Tribes can benefit from the Thacker Pass project and others like it by working with developers on community benefits plans (CBPs). These CPBs could include commitments related to construction of the mine related to jobs, workforce development, childcare service capacity and procurement opportunities for tribal member businesses to sell goods and services to the mine. In the long term, the CPBs could include entrepreneurial-focused initiatives, such as business incubation, educational scholarships, housing, and access to clean water and electricity for tribal members.

Most importantly, any new approach to mining in the American West should recognize and respect tribal sovereignty, and provide tribes more control over and access to mining profits. This might be as simple as granting affected tribes an ownership stake, a strategy that was constitutionally provided for in Alaska in 1971 and benefited the communities surrounding the Red Dog Mine in Northwest Alaska, but has never been enjoyed elsewhere in the United States.

 

A logical further ambition is for tribes to develop the capacity to run their own mining companies, staffed with leadership and engineering talent from tribal communities. In order to do this, potential tribal developers need to gain expertise in the mining and processing of critical minerals, which is different from the sand and gravel enterprises, coal mines, or oil and natural gas drilling they know well.

 

It is worth noting that the Interagency Working Group on Mining Laws, Regulations, and Permitting, in its recently issued final report on ways to improve the way mining is conducted on U.S. public lands, included recommendations that would help tribes negotiate CPBs. Specifically, the report recommended early and regular tribal engagement on the design of a new leasing system and environmental review processes and to provide “Grants for Tribes and communities to obtain technical assistance, or support technical reviews during permitting, engagement and consultations.”

 

If the United States is going to develop new critical minerals domestically, it needs to find a new pathway that acknowledges sins of the past, is inclusive to local Native American communities, encourages the financial participation of tribal governments, and provides a legitimate social license to operate.

 

At least three things can help: First, a national dialogue is needed immediately. The long and sordid history of battle between tribal communities, federal and state governments, the mining industry, and environmental groups, as well as disagreements between and within tribal communities, should be resolved. This begins with a full and formal acknowledgement of inequities, both past and present. What could initially be uncomfortable lines of communication have to be established between former adversaries and a common agreement of basic tribal rights established before the United States can move forward as a country. 

 

Second, existing U.S. laws and regulations should be updated and improved to include new protocols that are more in line with today’s international community and seek not just consultation with affected tribal communities, but their consent. It is imperative that tribal governments and their citizens be adequately consulted and included in any proposed mine’s planning, development, construction, and ultimate reclamation—from the start, and on their terms.

 

Third, the federal government needs to create an ecosystem that will allow tribally owned corporations to invest profits into creating and increasing wealth and income over the next decades. New federal economic incentives would greatly accelerate this effort. Tax policy levers could be considered that would make critical minerals development on tribal lands more economically attractive. This could incorporate existing tax credit-based programs, like Opportunity Zones, New Market Tax Credits, or Production and Investment Tax Credits, to specifically encouraging investment in critical mineral operations on tribal lands. There could also be new specific tax credits for things like hiring Native American employees to support critical mineral development and operations.

 

Tribal communities have sacrificed enormously on behalf of the American people for centuries. Now they are being asked once again to offer their lands in the name of a greater good. Their willingness to do so is deeply inspiring and deserves the best of the American people and their government. It also deserves real and lasting economic and social benefits to the tribes.

 

Commentary is produced by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a private, tax-exempt institution focusing on international public policy issues. Its research is nonpartisan and nonproprietary. CSIS does not take specific policy positions. Accordingly, all views, positions, and conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s).

© 2023 by the Center for Strategic and International Studies. All rights reserved.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 24, 3:05 PM
Scoop.it!

The 1926 Slavery Convention’s Centennial in Context

The 1926 Slavery Convention’s Centennial in Context | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

Commentary by John Cotton Richmond

Published September 22, 2026

 

What do you do when you realize moral failure has underwritten your life? The global community faced that same reckoning in 1926. The passage of the 1926 Slavery Convention highlighted the dramatic tension between what is right, what is possible, and what sets up a flourishing future.

In 1926, the world was addicted, not to opium or an intoxicating substance, but to the profitable exploitation of people. The same year, as world leaders gathered to craft the Slavery Convention, they admitted that the systems prior generations handed down to them were utterly corrupt. Yet, deconstructing those systems seemed absurd because they propped up the global economy and power structures. The hull of the ship of state was rotten, rendering it unseaworthy, even as it sailed.

 

Complicated Mixed Motives

Untangling exploitation from the economy was a massive undertaking. Any first step of progress would seem insufficient in isolation. Like learning one’s letters for the illiterate or adopting a modest diet for the chronically unhealthy, the first steps toward a better way are not an ultimate fix and do not generate immediate results. Yet, without the first step, there can be no second or third steps in the better direction.

 

This is the context in which the authors of the 1926 Slavery Convention wrestled. They were thoughtful and imperfect individuals who knew that forced labor and sex trafficking were a moral abomination and who likely wished prior generations had not kicked the proverbial can of abolition down the historic road. Yet, like a bloated national debt haphazardly passed to future generations, slavery’s bill came due.

 

The 1926 Slavery Convention may be one of the short-lived League of Nations’ greatest contributions. It was the first international legal instrument to attack the pernicious practice of slavery. At that time, the United Kingdom had already ended its transatlantic slave trade and emancipated many enslaved people, and the United States’ Thirteenth Amendment, which outlawed slavery, was 61 years old.

 

By 1926, industrialization had transformed the global economy, marginalizing the plantation-based slavery model. Concerns about the “white slave trade” were also sweeping Europe and North America, generating a fresh wave of selective empathy. Although the convention’s drafters were not united in their motivations or strategies, they were all in a world that was shifting away from a legal ownership slavery model toward a system of forced labor based on coercion.

 

The Slavery Convention’s Compromises

There were those debating the 1926 Slavery Convention who wanted complete abolition of slavery in all its forms, including private and public forced labor. Others sought only to solidify the gains already made over the prior 119 years since William Wilberforce led the end of the UK slave trade. It was a duel between those seeking what was best and right and those seeking what was politically possible. Ultimately, the Slavery Convention compromised principle and only banned slavery-as-ownership, not slavery-as-practice: Article 1 defines slavery as “the status or condition of a person over whom any or all of the powers attaching to the right of ownership are exercised.”

 

The convention legalistically framed slavery as a property issue, sidestepping forms of bondage where no one claimed formal “ownership.” That gap is why forced labor and sex trafficking compelled by force, fraud, and coercion went unaddressed in this first international legal step. The Slavery Convention also did not apply to forced labor in the British, French, and other imperial powers’ colonies, and Article 9 of the Slavery Convention gave governments an additional line-item opt-out provision from the Slavery Convention’s requirements if they wanted to enslave people. The Slavery Convention seemed like a lackluster social signaling exercise rather than a bold commitment.

 

Progress Since 1926

With a century of distance, the many additional steps toward abolition that followed the Slavery Convention are visible. It is easy to criticize the 1926 leaders for not condemning human trafficking in all its forms, but perhaps people can only leap so far from the gravitational pull of their historic context.

Since the 1926 Slavery Convention, the international community has taken many more steps away from slavery and toward freedom. The most significant may be the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which renounced slavery in Article 4 and expanded the definition beyond formal legal ownership. The 2000 UN Protocol against trafficking in persons, which addresses the coercive means modern human traffickers employ, is one of the most adopted international legal instruments, ratified by 185 countries.

The UN Protocol matched the reach of the U.S. Trafficking Victims Protection Act. Since 2000, the United Kingdom and other Commonwealth countries have passed increasingly stringent modern slavery acts. Now, virtually every country in the world has a law against human trafficking. Although they vary in quality, this legal consensus signals a 180-degree shift in global thinking on human trafficking since the abolition of the slave trade and the Slavery Convention.

 

Many countries have also passed laws to ensure that governments do not prosecute human trafficking victims for the unlawful acts their traffickers compel them to engage in, sometimes called “forced criminality.” Seeing governments arresting sex trafficking victims for selling commercial sex, many countries enacted laws that only hold those purchasing sex or managing the sale of others for sex accountable. The world has also witnessed supply chain laws, transparency laws, forced labor bans, due diligence laws, as well as tariffs and sanctions to discourage modern human trafficking.

 

These subsequent steps beyond the Slavery Convention reached not just slavery-as-ownership, but slavery-as-practice. And these important developments occurred while combating new forms of exploitation, such as online sex trafficking, peer-to-peer file sharing of child sexual abuse material (CSAM), live streaming of CSAM, and sextortion rings. In the last six years, internet-fueled scam centers have developed a model of double victimization. Traffickers use forced labor victims within the scam centers to create financial fraud victims around the world. A tremendous amount of work remains unfinished.

 

Today’s Unfinished Business

The global community has come a long way. An honest assessment of the 1926 Slavery Convention should not be too simplistic; it was not a “one and done” international instrument that fully addressed slavery. The convention was incomplete at its creation, yet it also holds an important place in history as the first international legal instrument to redirect all cultures away from a shared barbaric past. It is right and good to celebrate this historic centennial.

 

Despite the Slavery Convention and all the other important steps that have followed since 1926, human trafficking continues. As laws, culture, political will, technology, and economic circumstances have changed, traffickers have adapted and modernized. While most governments have backed away from publicly supporting human trafficking, 13 governments continue to traffic at least 3.9 million people in forced labor and sex trafficking. These examples of state-sanctioned forced labor resist traditional intervention efforts.

 

Unable to operate in the open, traffickers have now embedded human trafficking into the global economy. The International Labor Organization estimates that traffickers are exploiting 27.6 million people in sex trafficking and forced labor, in farms, factories, mining operations, manufacturing facilities, and massage parlors. Cobalt for batteries, cocoa for chocolate bars, and silica for solar panels are the foundation for industries relying on modern slavery. Many consumers have become accustomed to fast fashion, cheap electronics, and accessible consumer goods without considering how traffickers impact commerce. Yet, it is the companies using forced labor who receive a significant financial benefit from modern slavery and are in a unique position to demand fair markets.

 

On the 1926 Slavery Convention’s centennial, September 25, let us celebrate incomplete progress without allowing complacency to mute the urgency to take additional steps. The millions of victims suffering today should motivate all to drive another century of effort to build a principled foundation for freedom.

John Cotton Richmond is a senior adviser (non-resident) with the Human Rights Initiative at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C., and a former U.S. ambassador-at-large to monitor and combat trafficking in persons.

 

Commentary is produced by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a private, tax-exempt institution focusing on international public policy issues. Its research is nonpartisan and nonproprietary. CSIS does not take specific policy positions. Accordingly, all views, positions, and conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s).

© 2026 by the Center for Strategic and International Studies. All rights reserved.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 20, 4:10 PM
Scoop.it!

KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous People Original History being Replaced by "New Altered Rock Art" New History By Wits and Rupert Foundation: The ancient San painting featured in SA’s coat of arms - Wits ...

KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous People Original History being Replaced by "New Altered Rock Art" New History By Wits and Rupert Foundation: The ancient San painting featured in SA’s coat of arms - Wits ... | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

"KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous People of South Africa put on record the attempt to ERASE ORIGINAL Southern Africa Rock Art History in Partnership with Universities and the Rupert Foundation.. We do not acknowledge this "New Rock Art" as the original Linton Panel discovered in 1918."

 

KhoiKhoiBushman Indgenous People of South Africa, as official recognnized by the United Nations in 2007does not include Bantu Xhosa West African Settlers, who are the Black Majority in South Africa. We REJECT this claim by Bantu Xhosa's in its entirety.

__________________________________________________________________

9 January 2023 - Wits University

 

The exhibition titled ǃke e꞉ ǀxarra ǁke [‘People who are different’, ‘come together’], celebrates the rock art of the San people and is on display now at the Or

 

 

 

The Rock Art Research Institute (RARI), in collaboration with the Origins Centre at Wits University, launched an exhibition of a new ultra-high-resolution facsimile of the exceptional San rock art panel. The panel contains the original painted image chosen for the national coat of arms. 

The exhibition, titled ǃke e꞉ ǀxarra ǁke , which translates to ‘people who are different’, ‘ come together’, celebrates the rock art of the San people, the first inhabitants of southern Africa. The exhibition explores the tales of the San people’s way of life, from religion and beliefs, to the way they hunted or experienced weather. It is an indigenous archive of San tradition.

“The Rock Art Research Institute here at Wits is the first of its kind in the world. From the 1980s, its scholars, led by Professor David Lewis-Williams, joined the academic world to bring indigenous history and images to life,” said Professor Zeblon Vilakazi, Wits Vice-Chancellor and Principal. He added that this archive provided an almost inexhaustible resource for the arts.

It was in the year 2000 that former President Thabo Mbeki approached RARI in search of an indigenous art image for the coat of arms of the new South Africa. Scholars referred Mbeki to the famous Linton panel, a large slab of rock measuring 2m by .8m and recovered from a rock shelter on a farm named Linton in 1918. The panel came to prominence after a male figure from the panel became the figure we see today in the national coat of arms.

Wits Emeritus Professor and rock art specialist David Lewis-Williams was invited to translate the ancient San language for the national motto. He chose the |Xam words “ǃke e꞉ ǀxarra ǁke” from the phrases “people who are different” and “come together”.

“One of the things we constantly come across is the genocide of the Khoi San people in the 18th and 19th centuries. So it is wonderful to have their language displayed in our coat of arms,” said Lewis-Williams.

The exhibition also showcases new artwork by |Xam descendant artists at the Bushman Heritage Museum in Nieu-Bethesda. Their work forms part of the Origins Centre exhibition, in a modern |Xam take on the imagery in the national coat of arms.

 

 

 

In addition to the Origins Centre exhibition, rock art specialist Jeremy Hollmann released his comprehensively revised second edition book, titled Custom and Beliefs of the /Xam, published by Wits University Press as part of its centenary celebrations in 2022. Hollmann has worked extensively with the Bleek and Lloyd Collection over the past 20 years, using the |Xam testimony as an inspiration and source for exploring the meanings of southern African rock art.

“I spent about 69 hours in my chair writing this edition. For roughly two years, this book has been part of our household. The first edition came out in 2004 and I often thought that I am now older and wiser, and I feel that I was able to bring more to the material for this new edition,” said Hollmann.

Based on the articles published in the 1930s by Dorothea Bleek in the journal Bantu Studies, Hollman’s revised and expanded edition brings together a wide range of |Xam beliefs and key narratives, as told to Bleek and Lloyd by |Xam teachers.

Order Hollmann’s book online via Wits University Press.

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 20, 3:11 PM
Scoop.it!

KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous SA Land History: Trump/SA -  How White Victimhood is linked to White Supremacy 

KhoiKhoiBushman Indigenous SA Land History: Trump/SA -  How White Victimhood is linked to White Supremacy  | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it

17 February 2025 - Nicky Falkof

 

Rural violence is a huge problem in South Africa that deserves a strong response. But white people are not the only casualties.

American president Donald Trump has issued an executive order to withdraw aid from South Africa. He was reacting to what he has called the South African government’s plan to “seize ethnic minority Afrikaners’ agricultural property without compensation”. Afrikaners are an ethnic and linguistic community of white South Africans whose home language is Afrikaans.

 

Trump’s outrage is based on a misinterpretation of a new law – the Expropriation Act which came into effect in January 2025.

Trump’s action, amplified by provocative comments from billionaire Elon Musk, has reignited debate about the concept of “white victimhood”. We asked Nicky Falkof, who has researched the idea of white victimhood, for her insights.

What does ‘white victimhood’ mean?

White victimhood refers to a powerful set of beliefs that treats white people as special and different, but also as uniquely at risk. Within this narrative white people see themselves, and are sometimes seen by others, as extraordinary victims, whose exposure to violence or vulnerability is more concerning and important than anyone else’s.

 

White victimhood is usually speculative. It relates not to actual events that have happened, but to white people’s feelings of being threatened or unsafe. Entire political agendas develop around the idea that white people must be protected because they face exceptional threats, which are not being taken seriously by a contemporary world order that fails to value whiteness.

 

This is by no means particular to South Africa; we see it wherever whiteness is predominant. Indeed, ideas about white victimhood play a significant role in the popularity of Trump, whose call to “make America great again” harks back to an idealised past where white people (particularly men) could easily dominate the nation, the workplace and the home.

 

The South African case is important because it plays a central role in global white supremacist claims. These mythologies claim that white South Africans, specifically Afrikaners, are the canary in the coalmine: that the alleged oppression they are facing is a blueprint for what will happen to all white people if they don’t “fight back”.

What is its history?

We can trace this idea back to the start of the colonial project. In 1660 Dutch East India Company administrator Jan van Riebeeck planted a hedge of bitter almond shrubs to separate his trading station from the rest of South Africa’s Cape. This hedge was part of a defensive barrier intended to keep indigenous people out of the Dutch trading post, which had been built on top of ancient Khoikhoi grazing routes.

 

On a practical level, van Riebeeck’s hedge was meant to shield Dutch settlers and livestock from Khoikhoi raiders. On a philosophical level, the hedge situated the invaders as the “real” victims, who desperately needed protection from the violence and wildness of Africa. The bitter almond hedge is still seen as an enduring symbol of white supremacy in the country.

This early paranoia and securitisation has had a significant effect on white South African culture and anxiety. White people who can afford to do so barricade themselves in gated communities and boomed-off suburban streets, behind high walls topped with razor wire, on the assumption that they are the primary victims of South Africa’s crime rate.

In what ways has victimhood been used over the centuries or decades?

Ideas about white victimhood have played a role in many of South Africa’s most influential social formations.

 

The 1930s saw a major panic around “poor whites”, which led to commissions of inquiry, upliftment programmes and other attempts at social engineering. The people and institutions behind these initiatives weren’t concerned about poverty in South Africa in general, even though it was becoming more of a problem as the population urbanised. Their only interest was in poverty among white people, drawing on the assumption that it’s wrong or abnormal for white people to be poor, and that this needed to be urgently remedied.

 

These moves were not simply about philanthropy and offering better life chances to poor people; they were about protecting the boundaries of whiteness. Poor whites were seen as a threat to the establishment because they proved that whiteness wasn’t inherently superior.

 

More recently, the victimhood narrative has been a central part of the panic around farm murders and claims of “white genocide”, an old idea that has been popularised and spread online.

Rural violence is a huge problem in South Africa that deserves a strong response. But white people are far from its only casualties. Indeed, violent crime affects pretty much everyone in South Africa. When the deaths of white people are explained as part of a targeted genocide undertaken on the basis of race, the message is that they matter more than the deaths of everyone else.

Again, this suggests a kind of naturalisation of violence and harm. When terrible things happen to other people they simply happen and are not remarked on. It’s only when white people are affected that they become a pressing issue.

Has it helped white South Africans? Has it been effective as a mobilising tool?

White victimhood, like the racial anxiety it is part of, is not good for white people. It doesn’t keep them safer or help them to live better lives.

 

That said, it’s been quite effective as a mobilising tool. The apartheid-era National Party was skilled at using white fear for political gain. Its communications constantly played on white fears of the swart gevaar, the “black danger”, which encapsulated the powerful belief that whites were more at risk from black people than vice versa, despite all evidence to the contrary.

 

Similarly, contemporary organisations like the Afrikaner “minority rights” pressure group AfriForum and the Afrikaans trade union Solidarity activate and manipulate white people’s senses of extraordinary victimhood. This drives them further into a defensive position, where everything from farm murders and road name changes to the National Health Insurance bill is designed to attack them personally.

 

White support for these kinds of organisations and the political positions they espouse, whether overtly or covertly, is at least in part driven by the effective manipulation of white victimhood.

How effective is it still?

It remains disturbingly powerful. The architecture of white supremacy depends on the idea that white people are extraordinary victims. This is the driving notion beneath the great replacement theory, a far-right conspiracy theory claiming that Jews and non-white foreigners are plotting to “replace” whites. It also underpins violent reactions to the global migration crisis and the rise of populism in the north.

 

I don’t think it’s going too far to say that whiteness as a social construction is intrinsically tied to victimhood. The idea that whiteness actually makes people more rather than less vulnerable is likely to remain a central part of white people’s collective psychic imaginary for some time.

 


Nicky Falkof, Professor, University of the Witwatersrand

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

 

No comment yet.
Scooped by KRII-KROTOASA RESEARCH-INTENSIVE INSTITUTE
September 19, 3:28 PM
Scoop.it!

Approving Work Programme, Fourth Committee Agrees to Consider Decolonization, University of Peace, Outer Space, Atomic Radiation Items

Approving Work Programme, Fourth Committee Agrees to Consider Decolonization, University of Peace, Outer Space, Atomic Radiation Items | ALKEBULAN INDIGENOUS | Scoop.it
GA/SPD/421
1 October 2009
Approving Work Programme, Fourth Committee Agrees to Consider Decolonization, University of Peace, Outer Space, Atomic Radiation Items
1 October 2009   General AssemblyGA/SPD/421   Department of Public Information • News and Media Division • New York
Approving Work Programme, Fourth Committee Agrees to Consider Decolonization,

 

University of Peace, Outer Space, Atomic Radiation Items

 


In a brief organizational meeting today, the Fourth Committee (Special, Political and Decolonization) approved its work programme for the current session, during which it planned to consider more than a dozen topics, ranging from the peaceful uses of outer space to the University of Peace and the decolonization of the remaining non-self-governing territories.


Meeting for the first time since the start of the General Assembly’s sixty-fourth session, the Committee elected Vice-Chairperson Heidi Schroderus-Fox(Finland).  Following that action, Chairperson Nassir Abdulaziz Nassir (Qatar) introduced the other Vice-Chairs, Reniery Valladares (Honduras)and Ridas Petkus (Lithuania), as well as the Committee’s Rapporteur Khalid Ali (Sudan).


According to its work programme (document A/C.4/64/L.1),the Committee would consider a cluster of items relating to decolonization, among them, implementation of the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples, during its general debate from 5 to 9 October. 


Further in that regard, an aide-mémoire and an addendum (documents 01/09 and 01/09/Add.1), containing 96 requests for hearings related to the questions of Gibraltar, Guam, New Caledonia, Western Sahara and the United States Virgin Islands, were issued.  The Chief Minister of Gibraltar and the President of the Government of New Caledonia would make statements, the Chairperson announced.


The Committee would devote one meeting to the University of Peace, on 12 October.  Three meetings would be devoted to considering peaceful uses of outer space, from 20 to 22 October.  The Committee also agreed, as was its tradition, to establish a working group on outer space, to be chaired this year by Colombia.


During three meetings on 13, 14 and 15 October, the Committee would consider questions relating to information.  Delegations would also consider the effects of atomic radiation on 16 October, and would hold a comprehensive review of the whole question of peacekeeping operations, from 23 to 28 October.  On 29 and 30 October, they would consider assistance in mine action.


In addition, the Committee would consider the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) from 2 to 4 November.  From 6 to 10 November, it would take up the report of the Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices Affecting the Human Rights of the Palestinian People and other Arabs of the Occupied Territories.


Panels and interactive dialogues were scheduled under items on the University for Peace, outer space, questions relating to information, peacekeeping and assistance in mine action, as well as UNRWA.


The Committee expected to complete its work by Wednesday, 11 November, once action had been taken on all draft resolutions submitted under the last two agenda items related to the Middle East.


The Fourth Committee will meet again at 3 p.m. on Monday, 5 October, to begin its consideration of the issues relating to the implementation of the decolonization Declaration.

No comment yet.