Metaglossia: The Translation World
583.8K views | +49 today
Metaglossia: The Translation World
News about translation, interpreting, intercultural communication, terminology and lexicography - as it happens
Curated by Charles Tiayon
Your new post is loading...

How 'I love You' becomes 'The moon is beautiful, isn't it?': The Craft of Translation and the limits of AI

"How ‘I love You’ becomes ‘The moon is beautiful, isn’t it?’: The Craft of Translation and the limits of AI


 


According to 2025 industry numbers from Circana Bookscan, 43,259,410 graphic novels were sold last year to readers in the U.S. Of those, 17,529,264 volumes were manga — making up 40% of the market. Manga sales are on the upswing this year. As of the end of October, over 16 million units have sold already, and we’re only just arriving at the strongest sales quarter of the year. Still more of those overall graphic novel sales are comics in translation from other countries.


Though works in translation don’t dominate the market entirely, when U.S. readers think about comics, their picture of the essential classics includes not only works from esteemed U.S. authors like Alison Bechdel's Fun Home and Los Bros Hernández' Love and Rockets, but also the international-in-origin works of Tezuka Osamu, Marjane Satrapi, and Moebius’ oeuvre. Our ideas of market classics don’t even take into consideration popular manga like Horikoshi Kōhei 's My Hero Academia or Oda Eiichirō’s One Piece, the latter of which in particular is everywhere: I can now not only read 112 volumes of the series, but also watch the anime, a number of animated movies, and the new live action adaptation.


The general wisdom in the book market is that books in translation are a microscopic part of the overall market—which makes comics a significant outlier. The historical and contemporary presence of manga publishing in Japan and Franco-Belgian bandes dessinées (BD) has been a substantial part of comics publishing back from the beginning of the graphic novel format in the United States. With constant imports from both manga and BD, US comics readers and publishers have been continually informed of bigger, better-selling international graphic novel publishing industries outside our country. The presence of global comics is an essential part of the US industry, rather than a hyper-literary afterthought, which remains the unfortunate reputation of prose translations.


The comics industry has some larger publishers specializing in manga, like Kodansha, Seven Seas, Viz, and Yen Press, some independent publishers with a strong international program, like Drawn & Quarterly, Fantagraphics, and NBM, as well as many small presses producing an occasional translation, or are dedicated to translated works. Just about every comics publisher has some translations on their list.


Understanding what’s happening with comics in translation today informs a vast swath of the comics market, especially with the explosive growth of manga over the past half-decade. TCJ contributor Zack Rabiroff recently reported in Publishers Weekly that manga sales had grown another 40% in the past year! As they tackle that growth, publishers  of graphic novel translations, whose numbers are only increasing, are now faced with a new question: should they use AI as part of their processes?


The Translation Process
How do those comics in translation come to the United States?


I talked to Peter Anderson, the creator of the online tool AI Manga Translator, about his project and what it does. Talking about how the AI Manga Translator works, he said, “From the user's side it is simple. You upload a manga page, or a whole chapter, and a few seconds later you get the same page back with the dialogue in your language. Under the hood it does roughly what a scanlation group does by hand: it reads the text in the bubbles, whatever language the original is in, translates it with the rest of the page and the previous pages in mind so the dialogue holds together, cleans the original text out of the art, and letters the translation back into the bubbles. The result looks like the original page, just readable.”


But he’s not making his translation tool to preempt the work of translators. He told me, “I built it for myself first. The series I like tend to be the less popular ones, and those are exactly the ones nobody translates. Scanlation groups go where the readers are, and hiring a translator is not something one reader can afford. So for years it was wait, learn Japanese, or give up. Once language models could handle natural dialogue, I put the rest together around that, and at some point it made sense to open it up to other people. I still run it on my own.”


And he’s on the same page with the translators who think that an AI tool can’t replace a human.


“Those translators are right, and I would not argue with them,” he said. “The tool translates from the text, not from the drawings. If a line only makes sense because of a character's expression, or a visual gag, or something that happened forty pages ago, the model may miss it. It does get the whole page and the preceding pages as context, so it is not translating bubbles in isolation, and it handles ordinary dialogue and register better than people expect. Where it falls down is puns, wordplay, honorifics, sound effects, and anything that a good translator would stop and think about for ten minutes. My position is that this is a tool for readers. For an individual reader it is already good enough. You can follow the story, the characters sound like themselves, and a series you could not read at all becomes one you can sit down with in the evening. That is what it is for.”


Negishi from Mantra sees something dissimilar when she’s looking at Mantra’s specialized translation program.


She told me, “I was a freelance translator myself for over twelve years before I joined Mantra. During that time I've experienced similar things [in the challenges with general AI translation], but I think the regular AI that is out there, I think is quite different from what we have. We have a specific AI for translation. We have a specific AI for entertainment translation. Manga translation AI is refined for manga reading. When I actually joined Mantra, of course I took a look at the technology. That was about two and a half years ago, and I was quite amazed as an experienced translator for over a decade to see the AI quality. This is something that I was really inspired by, how Sho and our other co-founder had a vision to actually use AI in a very ethical manner to bring more translation to the world, because there are so many works of manga that are not available anywhere outside of Japan. So that was our motive.”


She continued, “The idea that AI translation is poor quality actually does mean something if you are using AI that is not fine-tuned for a particular usage. But when I actually work with AI at Mantra, it is particularly fine-tuned. If there's anything that I think, ‘maybe this can be better,’ I work really directly with the research team and engineering team to bring the quality up constantly. That's our kind of unique teamwork. We have the translators’ team, which is led by me, who is really translator-minded. And we have the research team, which is led by people who studied similar things with Sho, natural language processing. Then there's also the engineering team, which implements everything really quickly. So we have this cycle.”


“When I see the general output from the general AI, and when I see the Mantra's output for a particular manga, I think it's quite different, there's a big difference,” she concluded. “As a translator, when I see the page Mantra outputs, of course, there are things that maybe I want to fix. I think, ‘This can be better or that.’ After two and a half years of me being like, ‘this needs to be fixed,’ to the other teams, there are not often times when I see, ‘Oh, this is really so horrible that we have to do everything from scratch.’ It's not the case in this company, but I can see the sentiment from different usage.”


Will current thoughts about AI and translation spur publishers to establish firm policies against using AI?


In a recent Publishers Weekly article, writer Sam Spratford said, “AI gives publishers the option to play things safer, and they likely will,” highlighting Harper Collins CEO Brian Murray’s statement on the company fiscal 2026 results call that the publisher plans to use AI in its overseas translations.


Japan and AI
Why is there such a disjunct between what U.S. translators and publishers are saying on one hand, and the growth of AI and adoption for manga translation on the other?


Many people I talked to told me that some of the problems coming up were because of cultural dissonance.


Allen said, “I think genAI is perceived a lot differently in Japan. I don’t see the same sense of urgency there as I do here about the environmental or ethical concerns related to the technology. It’s seen as being like any other software or app that you might use to make your workload lighter or help you sort out your life. People even call ChatGPT by the cutesy nickname Chappy, and my favorite radio show has a segment now on how to use genAI to solve little problems, like what to wear when you have to go to a party after a long day at the office. So publishers in Japan view it as a way to speed up the manga translation process, without realizing that for the majority of fans here, AI is the kiss of death for any project; they won’t touch AI-translated manga with a ten foot pole. So there’s a real disconnect between Japanese and North American perceptions of genAI.”


Other translators I talked to are seeing the same difference between attitudes in the U.S. and Japan.


“I think that Japanese companies have shown a greater interest in AI, but that's likely only because they have fewer means to evaluate the end product and are not familiar with the English market. I think U.S. editors value quality and know their jobs will become more difficult when machine translation is used, so the U.S. side is usually against using AI,” Mitsuko Cash told me.


“Most of manga publishing, they’re almost all staunchly against AI, and I say ‘almost’ because they still have Japanese constituents, and those Japanese constituents are sometimes super crazy about AI, they love that shit, because they poured so much money into it,” said Evelyn. “With certain projects that they're just like, ‘no, we gotta use it, we gotta do something with it.’ But then most of the time, publishers in the West are just like, ‘no one likes AI, no one at the company likes AI, we shouldn't use it, so let's not use it.’”


He continued, “It's just the fallout that I hear, and most of the time, it's like, ‘We don't like AI, get that shit out of here, we don't want it,’ but Japanese companies will always be like, ‘we can always use this here, and we'll make the translators' lives easier.’ It's just like, ‘no, you're gonna make it more difficult if you, if you keep doing stuff like that. It's just going to introduce unforeseen problems that we never would have accounted for.’ Long story short, most of the companies that I've worked for do not encourage or even bring AI into the conversation, even though, maybe some of their Japanese parent companies will nudge towards, ‘hey, maybe you should use this thing.’”


Frank is seeing the same thing. “In Japan, English's use and visibility continues to increase across the board, and in every facet of life," she said. "I think for Japanese publishers, the AI translation is a really exciting new development because it means that they can be entering the global stage much faster, and also without as much help from global partners. So you're seeing a lot of Japanese publishers, with these new AI tools, just simulpubbing manga that is running right now, and there doesn't need to be a delay.”


But she’s also concerned about negative effects.


Frank said, “The problem is that English readers will read these AI-translated manga and be frustrated and disappointed with the quality. Maybe readers and publishers aren't on the same page. There's maybe a little bit less attention on the quality of the product. I think in general, I feel like even with the general public, there's just a lot more curiosity and optimism towards AI in East Asia in general. I can't really speak for culturally why that is, but it is interesting to see because I think a lot of American readers have really gravitated to manga, for these really fresh, inventive stories that they can't find on American shores. So I wonder what the temperature is going to be like when you have more and more of those creatives really embracing AI in totally positive ways. We'll just have to see.”


“It's very weird coming out of Japan, because they're super litigious, and they'll sue you at the drop of a hat for infringing on their copyright, but then they'll go around and use AI willy-nilly, and infringe on everyone's copyright, and then use the tried and true, ‘but it's just a tool, it's just doing the things that humans can do, you wouldn't sue a person who draws in Ghibli art style,’” Evenlyn told me. 


“Those are the comments I’ve heard a thousand times over ad nauseam,” he said. “I don't know why Japan is so horny for it, but they love it. They love it at the corporate level, and they will use it in everything, or they'll try to use it in everything. I guess here, too, corporate loves AI, because it eliminates labor, so they're just like, ‘yeah, we love anything that cuts down on costs and helps you, the employee. Yes, you, the employee that has to use this brainless bot.’ It's just so strange to me.”


Varun Gupta from Manga Mavericks is seeing something similar. He told me, “We have had discussions with some Japanese publishers who have worked with AI companies in the past to release their work, but the expectation when they work with a publisher such as ourselves is that the work will be translated by humans.”


He continued, “I do feel that long-term, we are going to continue to see it as a prevailing topic of debate in manga publishing. The reality is that there is more manga being produced in Japan than can be feasibly published by the existing pool of English publishers, let alone be supported by the current English demand for manga. If a title is not picked up by an English publisher, for some Japanese publishers, producing an AI translation will be viewed as a more ‘cost-effective’ option to get a manga title into English.”


Negishi from Mantra has an altruistic goal with her translating. She said, “I think that there is so much manga available in Japanese, but not available in other languages. Manga is a connector between humans. It goes beyond the Japanese culture. That's one of the reasons I really got into translation myself. We can become the bridge to actually connect people who usually wouldn't be connected. That's something that resonated with me when I joined Mantra, and that's a big part of our core mission: to bring all of the content available to either part of the world, to actually bring people to connect.”


This June, The Japan News announced that the Japanese government was considering providing eleven and a half billion yen (a little more than seven million dollars) in subsidies to manga publishers and anime companies to assist with their overseas sales and distribution. They said, “Through the envisioned subsidy program, the government aims to encourage the recipients to translate works into foreign languages much faster by utilizing generative artificial intelligence.” That level of governmental support can be difficult to say no to.


But just because the publishing industry is leaning in one direction, that doesn’t necessarily reflect the feeling of the creative community.


Øgaard Jensen at ALTA told me, “In some cases, a country’s attitudes are divided up between the publishers and the artists or the creators. There might be publishers from a country that are eager to use AI, but that doesn't mean the creators are. I think it's more that we're seeing a divide between publishers and corporations, and then the humans and the creators.”


That corporate vs. author rift is epitomized by Hayao Miyazaki’s famous quote about using AI in animation. “I strongly feel that this is an insult to life itself.”


AI as Business as Usual
That tension echoes what US authors are feeling as Publishers Weekly reports that 63% of publishing employees are using AI in their work—while many of the major engines are based on illegally pirated copies of the books written by the authors they work with.


Even though publishers are not universally using AI for translation, many are using AI tools in aspects of their translation process.


“As the publisher of Restless Books, agents, authors, translators, and others from around the globe constantly pitch us work they believe deserves to appear in English. Usually, these pitches are accompanied by a brief translated sample: five to twenty pages, often in a rough English style. . . . If we are intrigued by a book but find the sample too short, we ask AI to translate the rest. Although the rendition will be artless, it will give us a sense of plot, central motifs, character development, and the rest,” says Ilan Stevens in World Literature Today.


The same thing is true for Liz Frances at Street Noise. She told me, “I do sometimes ask an intern to do a rough translation of a foreign language work using Google Translate just for me to be able to read through a book before deciding to acquire the English language rights. But then if I do decide to publish it, I will have a professional translation done.”


Terry Nantier at NBM has a similar approach, “I'd expect our translators to work ethically, possibly using AI as an aid tool but no more. I feel pretty strongly that to get the nuances of language, especially spoken language and slang, both in the original and then transferring that in the translation needs a human hand and mind ultimately.”


Kendra Boileau at Graphic Mundi feels the same way about AI tools. “As a translator myself, I would never use AI systems for the wholesale translation of a project, just as I would never use AI systems to write original text that requires human interpretive abilities, rational judgment, ethical reflection, and emotional intelligence. In my view, a successful translation is the result of a human intellectual exercise that is necessarily iterative. Having said that, there are some AI-generated language dictionary tools that I find useful. So, in that sense, I am using AI on a very limited basis as part of my process, as I consider individual word choice. But that’s a very small part of the process, and those choices are always, in the end, subject to actual intelligence rather than artificial intelligence.”


Beyond translation, AI is becoming part of how publishing works today.


The anti-AI in translation sentiment among the publishers I spoke to is happening against the backdrop of the mass adoption of AI tools for the business of publishing at the Big 5 houses. Publishers Weekly said, “the technology is mostly improving life in the back office, where publishers have built tools to automate everyday tasks, including developing metadata, producing royalty statements, proofreading, and providing customer service.”


Several people at larger publishers spoke to me anonymously for this article, or told me they couldn’t discuss this topic without approval from the top of their reporting chain, which was not forthcoming.


Book industry distribution juggernaut Ingram has announced that it would be using AI for a number of business processes, starting this past May.


In a PW article, Phil Ollila, Ingram’s chief commercial and content officer, described what they were rolling out with AI: “IngramSpark Assist generates optimized metadata—audience categories, keywords, regional subject codes—directly from a book’s title and description. . . . Another example is Ingram iD, our consumer advertising platform, which now reaches some 5.4 million readers. It gives the option to use AI to generate ad copy, images, and keyword targeting for social channels. These AI-generated ads are actually outperforming manually created campaigns as measured by click-through rates and purchase intent.”


And as well as those internal-facing services, Ingram is using AI to better target readers. Ollila said, “We’ve built a database of millions of verified reader email relationships. AI helps us analyze that data, identify emerging interests and trends, and connect readers with books that match their preferences.”


In Japan, AI is being incorporated into the business of publishing in a similar way as in the U.S. Crunchyroll reports that publishers Kodasha, Shogakakun, and Shueisha have partnered on a new book distribution program. They say, “The business is set to use A.I. to find where the demand is and get books there as fast as possible and ‘optimize the entire publishing distribution.’”


That tracks with the Book Industry Study Group’s 2026 report on AI usage in publishing across the US and Canada. In the recap, CEO Allison Belan said, “Organizations are increasingly exploring where these tools actually provide value, while also putting more emphasis on policies, controlled workflows, and risk management.”


A recent Wired article reported, “Publishers are now using LLMs like Claude and ChatGPT to email literary agents, write publicity and back-cover copy, design cover art, and generate marketing materials, often at the direction of their executives.”


With comics, those aren’t the only possible creative uses for AI in publishing.


Translation is one of a set of costs for books that’s referred to in the industry as ‘plant costs’—one-time costs that aren’t paid back by royalties, unlike the author advance. Because they aren’t paid back, publishing staff often aim to minimize those costs as much as possible.


Aside from translation, plant costs include hiring freelancers for design, lettering, and coloring; design and lettering tend to be in the same ballpark as the translation, but the cost for coloring can be ten times as much. If there’s a budget to be slashed in plant, translation isn’t necessarily the most obvious candidate or the biggest pain point—despite it being one of the biggest publishing AI hot-button issues right now.


Beyond translation: we all want to connect more books and readers, and to sell more books to U.S. readers (especially since the National Literacy Institute reports that one in four adults in the country read at the lowest literacy level). That’s the bill of goods that’s being sold to us with AI in publishing: publishing staff will have more time to spend on the most important part of their jobs, and we’ll get more people reading more books.


But none of these incorporations of AI into publishing takes into account the potential ecological effects. The companies I talked to who are using AI in translation aren’t doing the math on that aspect of their business.


“On climate, translating a page [with AI] is a small amount of compute, but I have not measured it carefully and I would rather not claim more than I know. I am building something readers clearly want, and I try to be straightforward about what it is and is not,” Anderson from AI Manga Translator told me.


Ishiwatari talked to me about his thoughts on Mantra’s climate effects.


He said, “That question is a difficult one. AI uses electricity. So it does have an environmental impact. To be honest, we have never calculated exactly how much energy it spends. So it's hard to say how much of an impact we are making to the environment when we do manga translation. But the thing is that running a larger model, a more smart model, a more capable model, for a longer time, uses more electricity and has a greater environmental impact. So that's why we think it's important to use the smaller model as much as possible, and a simpler method as much as possible, while maintaining the translation quality. So, it's about balance. If you use a larger model, it's easier to make a better translation. If you use a smaller model, you need more effort to make the translation better.”


He continued, “We are working on it. Of course our research team puts effort into making the machine translation smarter to make the translation more accurate. But at the same time we spend effort on trying to minimize the size of the model we use and minimize the time we run the AI so that we can make the whole machine translation process lighter, and those efforts can help reduce our environmental impact as well. We are not using the whole data center, but we use some machines in the data center. If you do climate simulation, you need to use so many machines at the same time and run a super long process to do the simulation, right? And manga translation is not at that level. It's simpler. The amount of translation we do is limited, so the effect to the environment is not that serious compared to other industries. But it's important for us to try to minimize the computing resources we use.”


With so much of publishing using AI for parts of their business, will we see other indirect costs coming back to hurt the industry, the readers—and the world?


Translation Is Facing Other Problems, Too
One thing that makes this conversation about the future of translation and translators especially tough is the lack of professional standards for the field.


Andy Benzo from the American Translators Association told me that moving to the United States from Argentina, where she—and all other professional translators—have a degree in translation, was a culture shock for her.


She said, “I came here, and the United States, it’s the Wild West. The United States has people who say, ‘I'm bilingual, I'm good.’ I came to this country seeing that there were people who had forty hours of a course, people who had two years of a course, and then people who have PhDs, and it's so all over the map.”


Colleges in the United States do offer classes in translation; and the ATA and ALTA have annual conferences and mentorship programs for translators working professionally. But without an official country-wide standard for translators, it’s tough to set an industry quality standard. That’s especially the case for comics and manga translators, whose commercial work sets them apart from industry organizations with a reputation for the literary.


And it may be harder for any translators to get to that initial needed level of professional competence going forward. When I talked to Japanese-to-English translator Jocelyne Allen, she told me about getting her first jobs in translation: she didn’t just jump into translating manga.


She worked on powerpoint presentations. And legal briefs.


Allen told me, “When I was starting out in translation, there were reams and reams of the most boring documents that needed to be translated, generally for in-house purposes, but also for things like legal discovery. So I would get paid to translate endless email chains or HR Powerpoint presentations. And I can’t stress enough how boring these documents were, but the sheer volume of them paid my rent and taught me how to be a translator at the same time. Translation is one of those things that you really just have to do. You can study theory, and learn techniques, strategies, and best practices, but at the end of the day, you need to put those things into practice and translate a whole bunch of words.”


She continued, “But all that grunt work is essentially gone now, since machine translation is basically good enough for non-public facing, information-only needs, and genAI is being used increasingly for that sort of thing. So there’s nowhere for up-and-coming translators to learn their craft. We used to get paid to learn the job, and now new translators have to pay to learn, by taking university courses like the ones I used to teach or some other workshop or training programme. Which means it’s harder to break into the industry at all, since you have to already have the money to take those courses and put in that time learning, and if you do manage to get your foot in the door, you’re thrown into the deep end, working on public-facing documents where the stakes are higher for getting something wrong. You don’t have the same opportunities anymore to develop your expertise and discover your own translation style.”


With AI, will companies who need that non-literary, non-lyrical translation still need to hire translators going forward? And if not, how will aspiring translators level up, especially when the U.S. doesn’t have formal standards in the field?


Then there’s the recent announcement from Dutch publisher Veen Bosch & Keuning that they would begin to test AI to translate their novels; but only, they shared—presumably in attempt to be reassuring—on the commercial books, not the literary ones. It’s clear where comics are on that scale, and with the continually exploding popularity of manga, it’s hard to argue about its commercial appeal. But where does that leave comics and manga translators hoping not to be replaced by AI?  


Manga has always had an atypical relationship with professional translation, as amateur translators and letters produce scanlations and share publicly online, either for readers to read ahead in comics that are published in Japan and still in the works in the US, or to share manga and have readers get a chance to read projects that may not have a planned US publication. This practice heralded the debut of simulpubs, so readers looking to for the next chapter of their favorite series could have a method to legally purchase it earlier.


“Scanlation groups have been using machine translation for years, quietly, and cleaning it up by hand,” Anderson from AI Manga Translator told me. “What is changing is the floor. The gap between a quick machine translation and a mediocre scanlation has mostly closed, and an individual reader can now do for themselves what used to require a group. I expect the low-effort speed scan groups to lose their reason to exist, and the good groups, the ones with strong translators and typesetters who care about a series, to keep their audience, because what they offer was never just the translation.”


He said about the AI Manga Translator, “On my side, the tool is for a person reading their own files, and each user only sees their own results. And some of the most useful feedback since I opened it up has come from people in scanlation groups themselves, which tells me at least some of them see it as a tool rather than a threat.”


Scanlations have been an omnipresent part of the industry for years; but publishers see them as detracting from their sales rather than growing their potential audience. If they were shut down, I’m not sure that everyone reading comics in translation through scanlations would immediately rush out to purchase those titles—if my library stopped offering the specific ebooks I currently have in my hold queue, I would find something else to read, rather than getting them at my local indie bookstore.


But looking at the money that The Japan Times reports the anime and manga industry loses because of piracy every year—5.7 trillion yen, or thirty-six billion dollars—it’s clear that publishers want some of that back to pay their staff, their authors, and to keep their lights on.


That’s a big impetus for Mantra.


Ishiwatari told me, “Japanese publishers are facing a serious legal problem, which is the piracy of manga. Only around 10% to 20% of Japanese manga are officially translated into other languages. But many, many manga fans are waiting to read the latest chapters of the latest series. There are so many pirated versions of manga that are uploaded and translated by manga fans and are being read for free. That's a huge problem for publishers, and translation is one of the bottlenecks. If we can make a good translation faster, then we can reduce piracy, because it happens mainly because there is no official version, right? So if we can make more official versions of manga translated into many languages, we think that we may reduce the problem of the piracy.”


There are other challenges that come with a higher profile for translation and translators: like online bullying and harassment.


“With publishers now crediting translators and letterers, there is a heightened sense of awareness from readers to identify them as the sole entity responsible for aspects of localization that audiences may fancy or detest,” reported Isaiah Colbert on Gizmodo.


More attention is a double-edged sword: as translators work to get more credit, awareness, and recognition, that increased visibility makes them more findable by everyone who has a translation opinion.


And what do translators get for their work? Not a lot. 


“Once translators’ names are on book covers what else can be done to help them? Better pay,” says Olivia Snajie in a Publishing Perspectives report on discussions of translation at the London Book Fair.


“Rates need to be bumped up,” agreed Evelyn. “They've been stagnant for twenty years or so. Manga and anime, they both need a significant raise.”


“We are seeing what might be termed digital Fordism. Fordism was the process—named after Henry Ford and begun at the turn of the last century—by which skilled mechanics who built cars became assembly-line workers in the name of standardization and efficiency. The skills they had honed through years of experience were no longer needed, resulting in progressive de-skilling. But discontent was high, approaching 400 percent turnover per year, so Ford increased wages ($5.00 for an eight-hour day, up from $2.34 for a nine-hour day). But no increases will be given to translators, as the object is now to reduce dependency on them. Whatever benefits flow from standardization and efficiency, one must ask how they compare to the loss of professional skill, experience, and the pride and independence these confer on the individual,” says translator Kenneth Kronenberg in an article about translation for World Literature Today. 


I asked Negishi from Mantra about how their translators are paid.


She told me, “Internally, we have twenty to thirty people working with us, and they're all from English native countries. They work with us to make sure the final checks are done, but also with the freelance and the external translators. We work with a few hundred people who are actually registered under us, and some of them are actually really, really experienced manga translators. I've also known them before in my translator's time. I think they have twenty to thirty years in experience working with manga translation, probably from the beginning of manga translation till now. They’ve expressed their desired rate with us. We've worked really hard to meet their expectations. They've been with us for over two years. I think they said that Mantra Engine does help their process; it speeds up their process. So everything that they do is not focusing on, for example, glossary lists and word consistency, because the Mantra CAT tool helps with that. They don't need to pay a crazy amount of attention to that, so they can actually put a lot of effort into the creative decisions that they make as translators. They go through the page, but their focus is creative translation. So their speed is actually better than the regular PDF to Excel work.”


She said, “Overall, what I hear from working with the experienced translators is that they're happy working with us for over two years since the beginning of our translation services. They express that they're able to take more work with our AI-assisted translation process, so their overall pay is actually helping them, because they can take on more, and we really work hard to match their rate.”


When translators are already paid poorly, will introducing AI into the equation help?


“There's been a lot of discourse and platforms for literary translators to voice discontent about what they're paid, but manga translators and technical translators, translators for forms that are not seen as literary, do not get that space to participate and voice their discontent,” Frank said to me.


She continued, “I think that's really unfortunate, because manga translation does not pay well at all. I think the thinking with manga translations and why they're paid less, it's like, ‘oh, well, there are a lot of pictures, there are fewer words,’ But there have been projects I've taken where they become unwittingly like research projects. I have to do all this unpacking of cultural references. I write cultural reference notes. I have to translate sound effects. That takes time. And that's a very particular and specific kind of art form in itself. We've talked about a lot of Japanese being high-context language. You add pictures to that, and it’s even more so, because you have to read the picture and then connect them to the words. It is a very specific kind of translation. There are writers who hate writing dialogue. They find it so difficult. You know, manga is dialogue-driven. That's not easy for every translator or writer. You have to create new voices constantly.”


“I do wish those aspects of manga translation were acknowledged more,” she told me. “I think it's a matter of the literary translation community making more space for these graphic novel translators to get involved, and, you know, there are people who really don't think manga or graphic novel translation is literary, and I can't wrap my head around it. I think it's kind of a bigger problem with the way that we view graphic novels in this country in general as an art form—or an artless form. I think the issue kind of starts there and needs to be solved from there.”


Frank concluded, “I'm just excited that more people are interested in the translation aspect of manga and graphic novels, because I think translation in itself is an art form. A lot of people read in translation, and they don't really actually consider the mode in which the book they’re reading was created, the long journey it took to get to your hands in English. So when they’re reading My Brilliant Friend, they're still using the same kind of thinking cap they do for novels originally written in English. But I think if everyone kind of considered the form of translation and the feeling of translation more as readers, we'd all be better and more critical readers for it. I don't see why graphic novels and manga can't be extended the same generosity.”


Ben Passmore felt similarly in a previous article for The Comics Journal, where he talked about the larger picture of AI and its place in art “There isn’t a debate to be had around generative AI’s place in art, and if there is a conversation to be had it’s a very old one. Generative AI is not an exciting new tool for artists, nor is it “democratizing”. Generative AI is just the latest way for rich people to steal our work and sell it back under the guise of convenience. . . . If there’s money to be made in comics, it will trickle down to us last. Artists are just part of the production line for outlets that sell our work, and an inconvenient one at that. We need to eat, sleep and pay our bills, in addition to our exhausting need for free time away from work to find inspiration. The people that make the most money from the monetization of our labor, which is to say rich people, have been using all sorts of tricks to bypass us for a long time.”


As more and more graphic novels are being translated—and AI becomes more and more prevalent in every aspect of publishing—these are all issues the graphic novel industry will be continuing to wrestle with.


What to Can We Do?
If you’ve been in a bookstore lately, you may have noticed a book in translation on display.


That’s in part because they’ve been easier to find and to recognize on the bookshelves—there’s been a growing movement over the past several years to credit the translator on the cover. That change came about because of a campaign from the Society of Authors that prompted authors to ask their agents and publishers for this translator credit on their books—and for them to make it a contractual requirement for the publishers translating their works.


“It's been extremely hard for translators to advocate for getting their names on the covers of books. But this recent campaign through the Society of Authors raised awareness to authors of this being an issue. So I think a lot of authors have also become more aware of the fact that a translator's name belongs on the cover, because they're rewriting the book, and it is a reinterpretation and a new way of experiencing the work,” said Øgaard Jensen from ALTA.


Do authors have the same power to keep people translating their books instead of machines? Øgaard Jensen thinks they do.


She told me, “Authors who are translation-conscious will ensure that their works are translated by humans. But unfortunately, not all authors are. That's why we try to advocate for ourselves. In some countries, it's very common for the authors to make a living doing literary translations from, for instance, English into their own language. This can be a way to sustain the literary culture in a country. It's a way for writers to make a living. Whereas, in an English speaking country, not as much literature gets translated, and it's not as common for authors to do literary translations as a means of making income. So, I can imagine that there might be more awareness in Europe, for instance, around protecting the creator's rights, for the very reason that authors themselves are involved in the conversation as both authors and literary translators.”


As a reader, what can you do to support translators and the publication of graphic novels in translation?


Øgaard Jensen suggested, “Look for books that have the translator's name on the cover, because then you can be certain that that book has been translated by a human. What we're seeing is that if heavy AI use has been involved in the translation of a book, often the translators or the human editors of the AI translation won't be mentioned, and certainly not on the cover, if at all. A human name should be on the cover, either on the front cover or the back cover. Also if you look inside and you see a copyright and ‘translated by,’ then you can also safely assume that it's translated by a human.”


Advocacy for translators and the power of translation can only help keep people translating U.S. graphic novels.


Benzo from the American Translators Association told me, “There was the pandemic, and then we got back into our cave, and we have to get out. We have to get out and spread the word. We have to learn AI because then we can criticize with knowledge, and we can say, ‘you know what, you cannot use it’—if we don't know, people are gonna tell us how to do it. I think that we have a great opportunity to lead the narrative, and to establish the rules, and make sure that people understand that language is important, and cultures are important.”


Evelyn is on the same page. “If we bring forward the importance of how human translators and human letterers and human editors go about doing their job for manga, then a lot of people would open their eyes and go, ‘wow, these are actual people with actual brains, and they're showing me stuff that I never would have thought of.’”


Varun Gupta from Manga Mavericks sees that kind of advocacy as essential. “It's important for customers to continue to echo that they don't want AI translations and not support products produced by AI, so that companies lose the mindset to even view AI as an option.”


Conclusion
What’s next for AI and translation? Most U.S. publishers and translators I spoke to were firmly against using AI for translation.


Right now, a straightforward unedited AI translation isn’t at a publishable level.


Evelyn told me, “AI is useless at its job. And it's useless at its job in the sense that it can't do the things that a human translator can do. And even though it will give the appearance of something that translators can do, it'll never really replicate that kind of decision making; it won't be able to pinpoint a very specific reference within the dialogue. If there's a piece of dialogue that sounds like a line from a movie, it probably won't be able to pick that up. It'll just take it for what it is. Sometimes even human translators will miss that if they don't have that specific knowledge of a certain subject.”


But will that change as LLMs improve, as more AI translation companies spring up, and as more translators and publishers become aware of what the current comics-specific translation AI programs can do?


“I'd like to see a future where copyrighted works are properly protected from piracy and scraping, and a future where there might be such a thing as fair use of AI and machine tools in translation. And a future where AI isn't force fed to our field, like some kind of cannibalism that uses our own copyrighted works to replace our artistic discipline with content,” said Øgaard Jensen at ALTA. 


But Andy Benzo at ATA is optimistic.


She said, “We survived COVID, we survived the pandemic, we're gonna survive AI.”


Thank you to all the translators, publishers, and industry experts who spoke to me—on and off the record—so I could put this article together. Thank you especially to Kristen McLean from Circana Bookscan for sharing the marketplace numbers that open the article; to Jocelyne Allen, who sat down with me as I was just starting to think about this piece and talked me through the manga translation process; her advice and knowledge shaped this whole article. And to Brigid Alverson, who kindly offered to read through and tell me about all the parts where my expertise on the manga industry fell short."
Gina Gagliano | November 16, 2026


Note: A few quotes in this article have
https://www.tcj.com/how-i-love-you-becomes-the-moon-is-beautiful-isnt-it-the-craft-of-translation-and-the-limits-of-ai/
#metaglossia #metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

How the British beat the French (by stealing their language)

English conquered the world by borrowing everyone else’s words, but artificial intelligence is changing the world by making it unnecessary to learn English


The headline is the that language is what creates the concentration of power and Britain has done a good job there, as has France in the past. The question is whether AI will destroy all of this?


From Viking invaders and French aristocrats to American technology and artificial intelligence.


There is something wonderfully ironic about the English language. It has spent more than a thousand years stealing words from everyone else, absorbing foreign expressions, borrowing grammatical ideas, adapting pronunciations and generally behaving like a linguistic pickpocket, yet somehow, it has emerged as the dominant international language of business, science, technology and much of the internet.


The French gave us sophistication, our Germanic ancestors gave us much of our linguistic foundation, the Vikings contributed everyday vocabulary, the Dutch share the ancestry of some of our finest swear words, the Romans and Greeks provided the language of scholarship, and the Americans eventually gave us Silicon Valley and the internet.


Having borrowed so much from everyone else, the English-speaking world now has the audacity to expect everyone else to speak English.


How did that happen, and why has English become so successful when other languages, particularly French, once occupied the position it enjoys today? The answer is an amazing story of immigration, invasion, trade, empire, social snobbery and technological revolution, beginning in a country that barely resembles the England we know today.


Welcome to Engla-lond


One of my favourite explorations of history is The Year 1000 by Robert Lacey and Danny Danziger. In their chapter, Welcome to Engla-lond, the authors explore the language spoken by the Anglo-Saxons around the year 1000, when England was a collection of communities connected by farming, trade, religion and the constant threat of invasion. What makes their discussion particularly interesting is that, although most modern English speakers would struggle to understand a conversation conducted in Old English, they would recognise a surprising number of its words.


Take the hundred most frequently used words in modern English and we find that almost all descend from Old English or related Germanic roots, including the everyday building blocks of communication such as the, and, I, you, he, she, we, man, wife, child, house, bread, water, eat, drink, live and die.


These are not the elaborate expressions of lawyers, academics or politicians, but the words people use to describe their families, their homes, their food and their lives. The foundations of English were established long before Shakespeare, the British Empire or Silicon Valley, and the essential vocabulary of everyday existence remains remarkably recognisable a thousand years later, even though the grammar and pronunciation have changed dramatically.


The interesting thing is that England in the year 1000 was anything but linguistically isolated. The Anglo-Saxons had originally arrived from Germanic-speaking regions of continental Europe, bringing languages that developed into Old English, while the Vikings had spent generations settling, marrying, raiding and trading across large parts of the country. There were Celtic-speaking communities, Latin-speaking churchmen and merchants crossing the North Sea from regions that would eventually become the Netherlands, Germany and Scandinavia. England was already a meeting place for people who spoke different languages, although many of those languages shared common Germanic ancestry.


Imagine an English village a thousand years ago, where a Viking arrives wanting to buy a horse, a trader from the Low Countries wants to purchase wool and a traveller from another kingdom needs somewhere to sleep. Each speaks differently, but they all want to communicate, negotiate and do business. The English villager does not have Google Translate, a language-learning application or an artificial intelligence assistant, so he has to work with whatever words he understands, whatever similarities exist between the languages and whatever expressions he has picked up through experience. Over generations, these encounters help languages influence one another, with words being borrowed, pronunciations changing and different ways of expressing ideas becoming familiar.


This does not mean that English was deliberately invented as a common language for Vikings, Germans and Frenchmen, or that everyone in medieval England could understand everyone else. The language spoken in the year 1000 was still overwhelmingly Germanic, and the great influx of French vocabulary had yet to arrive. Nevertheless, the story illustrates something that would become one of English’s defining characteristics: its extraordinary willingness to absorb vocabulary from other languages while retaining much of its existing linguistic identity.


English became a linguistic magpie, collecting useful words from wherever it found them and showing remarkably little concern about their origins. Over the centuries, this habit would create one of the richest and most varied vocabularies in the world.


Twenty words for everything


There is a popular observation that English has twenty different words for everything, which is obviously an exaggeration but captures something distinctive about the language. We can ask, question, enquire, interrogate, investigate or examine, and although these words have different shades of meaning, they allow us to express closely related ideas with extraordinary precision. We can describe something as kingly, royal or regal, using words inherited through Germanic, French and Latin routes, while freedom and liberty describe related concepts through different linguistic traditions.


The same richness appears in everyday conversation, where we can help someone or assist them, buy something or purchase it, begin a meeting or commence proceedings, and end a relationship or terminate an association. The meaning changes subtly with the choice of word, but so does the social impression we create. Someone who says they want to help sounds friendly, while someone who offers to facilitate assistance sounds as though they are preparing to send an invoice.


This is particularly noticeable in business, where the straightforward Germanic vocabulary of everyday English frequently disappears beneath an avalanche of French- and Latin-derived terminology. A normal person wants to know what something costs, whereas a management consultant wishes to undertake a comprehensive evaluation of the financial implications. A customer wants their money back, while a banker explains that the institution is initiating a structured reimbursement process in accordance with established operational procedures. Both are describing the same thing, although the consultant and the banker have managed to make the process sound considerably more expensive.


The enormous vocabulary of English developed because successive generations borrowed foreign words without consistently abandoning the ones they already possessed. Instead of replacing one expression with another, English often kept both, allowing speakers to choose between simple, direct vocabulary and more elaborate alternatives. This created a language that can be wonderfully expressive, infuriatingly inconsistent and occasionally ridiculous, but one that offers an extraordinary range of possibilities to anyone who wants to communicate.


The French arrive and make everything complicated


Then came 1066, when William the Conqueror crossed the Channel, defeated Harold at Hastings and established a new ruling elite that transformed English society and, eventually, the English language.


For centuries afterwards, varieties of French occupied powerful positions in government, law and aristocratic life, while Latin remained central to religion, scholarship and administration. English survived as the language of much of the population, but it gradually absorbed an enormous amount of French vocabulary, creating a linguistic division that still reveals the social structure of medieval England.


Many of our shortest, most direct words come from Old English, while much of our longer and more elaborate vocabulary entered through French and Latin. This is why some of the most powerful speeches in history rely upon extraordinarily simple language. Martin Luther King did not announce that he wished to communicate an aspirational vision of future societal transformation. He said, "I have a dream."


Four words, all rooted in the oldest layers of English, and considerably more powerful than anything a management consultant could have produced.


And the Dutch taught us to swear … or did they?


Lacey and Danziger also draw attention to the earthy Germanic vocabulary that English shares with languages such as Dutch and Low German, which provides another entertaining illustration of how different linguistic traditions contributed to modern English. Some of our bluntest expressions, including words associated with bodily functions, sex and insults, have close relatives across the North Sea, reflecting the common ancestry of English, Dutch and German rather than a single historical moment when Dutch sailors arrived and taught the English how to swear.


It would be wonderful to imagine that medieval English peasants spent their days politely swearing upon their honour and allegiance until a Dutch sailor arrived in port, stubbed his toe and introduced them to a whole new vocabulary of colourful abuse. Unfortunately, the historical evidence suggests that the English were perfectly capable of being offensive without foreign assistance. The Dutch did not invent our swear words, but they share a magnificent Germanic tradition of expressing displeasure in language that requires remarkably little translation.


Shakespeare, of course, took the art of insulting people to another level, and some of his finest efforts remain wonderfully effective four centuries later.


"Thou art a boil, a plague sore." King Lear
"Thou cream-faced loon." Macbeth
"I am sick when I do look on thee." A Midsummer Night’s Dream
"Away, you three-inch fool!" The Taming of the Shrew
"Thou hast not so much brain as ear-wax!" Troilus and Cressida
"More of your conversation would infect my brain." Coriolanus
"Thy face is not worth sunburning." Henry V
Admittedly, these are insults rather than conventional swear words, but they demonstrate how wonderfully inventive English had become when it came to telling someone exactly what you thought of them. Shakespeare could insult a man’s intelligence, appearance, parentage and personal hygiene without needing to resort to a single modern four-letter word, although his plays contain plenty of earthy language when the occasion demands it.


The relationship between English and Dutch is particularly notable because both belong to the West Germanic branch of the Indo-European language family, sharing vocabulary inherited from common linguistic ancestors. Centuries of maritime trade, migration and cultural contact reinforced those connections, while the Norman Conquest introduced a further distinction between the everyday language of the population and the French-influenced vocabulary of the ruling classes.


There is something wonderfully revealing about this distinction, because when an Englishman wishes to sound educated, sophisticated or professionally important, he frequently reaches for a French- or Latin-derived word, but when he hits his thumb with a hammer, discovers that his train has been cancelled or realises that his bank has charged him another inexplicable fee, he generally returns to his Germanic roots.


The French helped us sound sophisticated, while our Germanic inheritance ensures that we can still express exactly what we think when sophistication is the last thing on our minds.


When French ruled Europe


For centuries, however, the language of international prestige was not English but French. By the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, French had become the dominant language of diplomacy and elite international society across much of Europe, enjoying a position that English could not begin to match. If you wanted to participate in European diplomacy, impress an aristocrat or demonstrate that you were educated and cultivated, French was the language to know, and the ability to speak it became an important marker of sophistication.


The influence was so powerful that European aristocrats frequently used French when communicating across national boundaries, while diplomatic correspondence and international negotiations increasingly adopted it as a common language. French became associated with refinement, intellectual achievement and cultural superiority, and those who could not speak it risked being regarded as provincial, regardless of their other accomplishments.


Consider Carl Gustaf Emil Mannerheim, the Finnish military leader who became one of the most important figures in Finland’s history. Born in 1867, when Finland was part of the Russian Empire, he rose to become a lieutenant general in the Imperial Russian Army before returning to Finland following the Russian Revolution. He commanded the victorious White forces during the Finnish Civil War of 1918 and subsequently became the military leader who helped preserve Finnish independence against the Soviet Union.


His defining moment came during the Winter War of 1939–1940, when Finland resisted a Soviet invasion despite being vastly outnumbered. He later commanded Finnish forces during the Continuation War, when Finland fought alongside Nazi Germany against the Soviet Union, before becoming President in 1944 and negotiating an armistice with Moscow. What makes Mannerheim a very specific historical figure is that he became one of the most decorated military leaders in modern history, receiving honours from Imperial Russia, Nazi Germany, Britain, France, Sweden and numerous other nations, many of them bitter enemies. His career spanned the collapse of empires and two world wars, while his controversial role in the Finnish Civil War complicated a legacy that remains central to Finland’s national identity.


In other words, when all nations were at war, he was the leader who negotiated peace and every nation recognised him for that.


Why do I mention this?


Because the last time I was in Helsinki, I used TripAdvisor to look up things to do. There wasn't much that caught my attention, except a recommendation to visit Mannerheim's house and museum. It was something where I learned a lot, as I had never heard of him before.


He was a spy, politician, leader and soldier. During the tour, I came across an entry in Mannerheim's diary describing his meeting with Robert Baden-Powell, the distinguished British soldier and founder of the Scout movement. Mannerheim considered Baden-Powell unsophisticated and provincial because he could not speak French.


Imagine the irony of a distinguished British soldier who had travelled extensively, commanded troops, written books and established an international movement being considered insufficiently cultivated because he could not conduct a conversation in French. Military achievements, international experience and intellectual accomplishments were apparently not enough to compensate for the inability to order dinner in the language of Paris.


Yet the world has changed so dramatically that the situation is now almost completely reversed. A French business executive who cannot speak English faces considerable disadvantages in international commerce, while a British executive who cannot speak French can still conduct business across much of the world. The language that once demonstrated European sophistication has been overtaken by a language that the European aristocracy previously regarded as comparatively provincial.


And, if you want a particularly delicious illustration of how far the tables have turned, consider Jacques Chirac and the French CNN.


In the early 2000s, the French President revived an ambition to establish an international television news network that would challenge the dominance of CNN and the BBC. France had its own culture, its own political perspectives, its own international interests and, naturellement, its own language, so why should Anglo-American broadcasters dominate the way the world received its news?


Chirac wanted a French international news channel that would project French influence around the globe and provide an alternative to the English-speaking media organisations that had become so powerful. The project had been discussed for years, with research commissioned and plans debated, but there was one rather embarrassing commercial reality: if France wanted to compete internationally with CNN and the BBC, it would have to communicate with audiences who did not speak French.


In other words, France needed to defend the French view of the world by broadcasting it in English.


This was not just my interpretation. As France 24 prepared to launch in December 2006, its president, Alain de Pouzilhac, acknowledged that most of the network’s intended international audience spoke English and that delivering a French perspective therefore required broadcasting partly in English. The eventual result was a French international news network launching simultaneously in French and English.


Imagine the conversation in the Élysée Palace, where the President wants to defend French culture and international influence against Anglo-American domination, only to discover that one of the most effective ways of achieving his objective is to speak English.


For centuries, an Englishman had been considered uncultured if he could not speak French yet, by the twenty-first century, the French were broadcasting in English because they wanted the rest of the world to listen.


C’est la vie.


The British Empire spreads the language


The first great transformation in the international position of English came through the expansion of the British Empire, which carried the language across North America, the Caribbean, Africa, Asia and the Pacific. English became associated with colonial administration, international commerce, education and law, spreading through ships, soldiers, merchants, settlers, schools and institutions rather than through any inherent linguistic superiority.


Yet the British Empire alone does not explain why English dominates international communication today, because empires eventually decline and their languages do not always retain their positions of influence. Latin survived the Roman Empire as the language of scholarship and religion for centuries, while French enjoyed an extraordinary period of diplomatic and cultural prestige before losing much of its international dominance.


English enjoyed a remarkable historical advantage because, just as Britain’s imperial power began to decline, another English-speaking superpower emerged on the other side of the Atlantic.


The United States.


America’s rise to economic, military and cultural dominance transformed English from the language of a global empire into the principal language of international commerce and, eventually, the digital economy. Hollywood, Wall Street, multinational corporations, scientific research, universities and popular music carried American influence into almost every corner of the world, encouraging people to learn English not because they admired British history but because they wanted to participate in the opportunities created by American economic power.


International aviation adopted English as the standard language for communications between pilots and air traffic controllers in international operations, while scientific publishing increasingly favoured English as researchers sought to reach the widest possible audience. Multinational corporations adopted it as a common working language, and international financial markets increasingly operated through English-language contracts, documentation and communication.


The more people learned English, the more useful it became, and the more useful it became, the greater the incentive for others to learn it. Economists would recognise this as a network effect, in which the value of participating in a network increases as more people join it, and the same principle helps explain why English became so deeply embedded in international commerce.


A language does not need to be the most elegant, the most logical or the easiest to learn to become internationally dominant. It needs to be the language that enough other people already use, because once that position becomes established, the advantages reinforce themselves.


Then came the internet.


The development of modern computing and the internet, heavily influenced by American universities, government research programmes and technology companies, meant that the emerging digital world inherited much of its vocabulary, documentation and commercial culture from English-speaking institutions. Programming languages, software manuals, technical standards and early online communities were disproportionately English-speaking, reinforcing the position of English as the language of technology.


As the internet expanded, English became deeply embedded in the digital economy through search engines, online marketplaces, social networks, international business communications and the enormous influence of American technology companies. The internet did not create English dominance, but it amplified an international language that already enjoyed powerful economic and institutional advantages.


Of course, the internet is now far more multilingual than it was during its early development, and billions of people communicate online in Chinese, Spanish, Arabic, Portuguese, Hindi and countless other languages. English is not the language of every internet user, nor does it account for most of the world’s population, but it continues to occupy a particularly influential position in international online communication, technical documentation, scientific research and cross-border business.


A software developer in Bangalore, a banker in Frankfurt, a designer in Seoul and an entrepreneur in São Paulo can collaborate through English without needing to learn one another’s native languages. The common language allows people from different cultures and countries to participate in the same economic and technological networks, reducing the friction that would otherwise make international collaboration more difficult.


There is something rather wonderful about comparing this with the English village of a thousand years ago, where the Anglo-Saxon farmer, the Viking trader and the merchant from across the North Sea needed enough shared language to negotiate the price of wool, exchange goods and establish trust. Today, the village has become the world, and the conversations that once took place around a market stall now take place through video conferences, digital platforms and international financial networks.


The language that borrowed words from everyone else has become the language that everyone else is expected to understand.


And then artificial intelligence arrives


There is, however, one final irony in this story, because artificial intelligence is beginning to challenge one of the fundamental assumptions that has sustained the international dominance of English. For centuries, the ability to speak another language has been a source of education, social status, economic opportunity and political influence, with French once distinguishing the cultivated European from the provincial Englishman and English now providing access to international business, technology and education.


Artificial intelligence is changing the economics of language by making translation faster, cheaper and increasingly accessible. Real-time translation systems, multilingual language models and AI-powered communication tools are reducing the practical barriers between people who speak different languages, creating the possibility that international communication will no longer require everyone to learn the same one.


An English speaker can increasingly communicate with a Japanese speaker without either person mastering the other’s language, while a Chinese entrepreneur can conduct business with a German customer through translation technology that operates almost instantaneously. These systems are not perfect, particularly when dealing with humour, cultural references, specialist terminology or the subtleties of human emotion, but their capabilities are improving rapidly.


The consequences could be profound because the value of English as an international language depends partly upon the advantage it provides in communicating with people who do not share a native language. If technology removes much of that advantage, the incentive to learn English purely for practical international communication could weaken, even though the language will retain enormous cultural, educational and institutional importance.


This does not mean that English is about to disappear from international business, any more than the arrival of the telephone meant that people stopped meeting one another. Languages are embedded in cultures, institutions, professional relationships and educational systems, and those connections are difficult to displace. Nevertheless, artificial intelligence introduces a fascinating possibility that would have been almost unimaginable throughout most of human history.


Perhaps the future of global communication is not everyone speaking English, French, Mandarin or any other dominant language, but everyone speaking their own language and understanding everyone else.


That would represent a fundamental change in the relationship between language and power. Throughout history, the people who controlled international commerce, political institutions and cultural influence enjoyed enormous advantages in determining which languages other people needed to learn. French followed the influence of European aristocracy and diplomacy, English followed the expansion of the British Empire and American economic power, and the internet reinforced the position of English through the network effects of global technology.


Artificial intelligence could begin to separate international communication from the need for a single dominant language, allowing people to participate in global conversations without abandoning their native linguistic identities. Instead of requiring everyone to adapt to the language of the most powerful economic or political institutions, technology could increasingly adapt communication to the languages people already speak.


And that brings us back to the English village in the year 1000, where the Anglo-Saxon farmer, the Viking trader and the visitor from across the Channel were all trying to solve the same fundamental problem: how to understand one another well enough to live, trade and get along. They did it through shared vocabulary, borrowing, adaptation, gestures and the gradual development of ways to communicate across linguistic differences.


A thousand years later, we are still trying to solve exactly the same problem, except that we now have artificial intelligence to do it for us.


English conquered the world by borrowing everyone else’s words, but artificial intelligence is changing the world by making it unnecessary to learn English and somewhere, I suspect, Carl Gustaf Emil Mannerheim would be horrified to discover that Robert Baden-Powell could now speak perfect French simply by pressing a button."
How the British beat the French (by stealing their language)
November 9, 2026 by Chris Skinner
https://thefinanser.com/2026/11/how-the-british-beat-the-french-by-stealing-their-language
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

‘Writing For Children is Tougher’

"‘Writing For Children is Tougher’
Amish Tripathi speaks about his first children’s book, Dhruv-Tara, and why he doesn’t want to follow chronology


08 Nov 2026, 1:30 am


You have primarily written for adult readers. How did you end up writing a children’s book, Dhruv and Tara: The Great Indian History Quiz?


This began with a discussion with my 17-year-old son, Neil. I am 51, and I saw a lot of colonial nonsense being taught to me when I was Neil’s age. But now, Neil is still being taught a lot of that nonsense. It’s not that everything is exactly the way it was. The overhyping of everything from a European lens has reduced. Some things have been decolonised, no doubt. But a lot of things are still colonial, particularly our history. I asked myself, why not be the change I want to see? So, I’ve written my own book, where a decolonised version of history is presented in the garb of a fun adventure.


When you say decolonisation, is it primarily about moving away from the British perspective of looking at history?


For example, the achievements of ancient India are downgraded. We are taught that India was basically an oral culture and that we weren’t a writing culture. That’s not true. Ancient Indians actually wrote a lot more than the rest of the world. But that’s not taught in our history books. We are taught that Vasco da Gama discovered the sea route to India, which is not true. He was actually helped by an Indian trader called Kanji Malam. But Malam’s name is wiped out. So many things like these are not taught.


Dhruv-Tara: The Great Indian History Quiz By: Amish Tripathi Publisher: Red Panda Pages: 200 Price: 350
What were the things you kept in mind while approaching writing for children?


Writing for children is tougher because they can be unforgiving. You can’t even have a few slow pages because otherwise they switch off. The book has to be a lot shorter. My usual books are 400-500 pages. I can’t release a children’s book that long. I also did some research into Gen Z language. I obviously don’t know that language, and I didn’t overuse it because that would sound fake. That’s what I was trying to do: appeal to them.


The book doesn’t follow the chronology of a typical history textbook. How did you decide what to include and how to structure the narrative?


The thing that bores children the most about history books is dates. A textbook has to be structured chronologically. But this is a storybook. I wanted the facts to come across in the garb of a story, rather than through chronology. The idea was to include as many historical facts as I can. But how they get included depends on the story. If something doesn’t flow naturally into the story, it will not work.


This is the first part of what is planned as a seven-book series. Could you tell us more about what you have in mind for next ones?


In the second book, I want to cover ancient Indian businesses. I’m talking about pre-British times, something only a few people know about. India had multinational companies in ancient times. It had formal accounting processes, influence techniques, and money transfer systems. It will be in the garb of a good adventure. We initially thought of seven books, but it could be more.


How have children been responding to the book?


Some children have told me that they’re learning these facts and then going home and shocking their parents. They know things that their parents don’t know. Many of them are also realising that history can actually be cool. Let’s see if the second book also does well. Then we’ll know it wasn’t a fluke.


One interesting aspect of the book is how it explains the origins of familiar phrases and expressions that we use in everyday life.


Exactly. There’s that famous Amitabh Bachchan dialogue, which I have included in the book: “Mere paas paanch phutti kaudi nahi hai.” We hear this expression and wonder what a phutti kaudi is. There are so many things that are part of our culture but are not taught to us. If the knowledge comes across in a fun story format, it stays in your mind.


When you discuss the Delhi Sultanate and the Mughals, there seems to be a certain dismissal of their contributions. What are your thoughts on this?


One of the things I’ll probably cover in my future books as well is something interesting that the British did. They didn’t call British colonial rule the Christian invasion, but they called Turkish colonial rule the Islamic invasion. If you ask me, it was a very mischievous formulation. Indian Muslims were as oppressed by the Turks as Indian Hindus were. Indian Muslims were never given positions such as mansabdars, for example. They were all foreigners.


This, again, is a colonial way of looking at things. The British wanted to divide India. I can understand why the British did it. But why did India continue with this formulation after 1947? It’s obviously to create Hindu-Muslim fights today. We need to take an honest look at these things.
https://www.newindianexpress.com/magazine/2026/Nov/08/writing-for-children-is-tougher
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

[iD Recap] What Endangered Languages Can Teach AI | الأمم المتحدة

" Dialogue on AI Governance (6–7 July 2026), language and culture were raised repeatedly, usually as one line in a longer list of gaps. This special edition of Innovation Day asked a different question. Instead of ‘is your language represented in AI systems?’, guest speakers Arvinder Singh Kang and Wakanyi Macharia-Hoffman explored ‘what would your language change about how AI thinks?’


Highlights
Languages are ecosystems, not datasets
Kang described a language as a world people dream and live inside. When one disappears, the imagination it carried disappears with it. He shared the Panjabi concept of Sarbat (ਸਰਬੱਤ in Gurmukhi script), an idea of oneness rooted in Sikh thought encompassing all things, living and non-living. Framed through Sarbat, an environmental question carries a different ethics as Sarbat would not place humans at the centre and would instead consider the benefit of all including the non-living resources.


Ethics belongs at the beginning, not the end
Hoffman described Ubuntu as the understanding that to be human is to be in relationship with other living beings. Applied to AI, this changes the sequencing: ethics is not appended once a system is built, but the starting point for deciding what knowledge enters a dataset at all.


The complex problem is consent, not engineering
Both speakers agreed that interoperability is largely solved as a technical problem. The major challenges are no longer primarily whether computers can process, translate, or exchange information across languages, what remains unresolved is provenance, licensing and consent. Kang illustrated this with Sikh sacred texts (Gurbani). Treated within the tradition as unalterable, when absorbed into large language models as open data it can be algorithmically recombined in ways that the community may never have intended. Communities, Hoffman added, must also be able to decline, not everything can or should be translated, and an opt-out has to be a genuine option.


Not all AI is generative AI
Hoffman urged a distinction often lost in the debate.  The AI conversation is often reduced to large language models and chatbots. Some of the most impactful applications are task-specific systems built around trusted community relationships and ethically collected data. She pointed to a rural health tool in Kenya that allows patients to describe symptoms in their own language, reducing reliance on intermediaries and restoring dignity to the healthcare experience. The lesson was that inclusion is not only about what a model can generate, but about how technology enables people to participate on their own terms.


Cost is a structural barrier
Kang described an experiment he ran: the same text cost four to seven times more tokens in Panjabi than in English. Speakers of under-resourced languages pay more for the same systems.


This cannot be a charity project
Treated as a standalone business, Kang argued, low-resource language AI gets funded for a while and then defunded. Sustainability comes through institutional mandates: hospitals, courts and public services required to operate in the languages their users speak. Hoffman framed it through purpose: if the aim is dignity, the incentive follows.


Putting this into practice
Ask the relationship question first. Before adopting a new tool, Hoffman suggested asking what relationships it might break and what it might help repair. This is an opening question, not a final review step.
Check provenance before use. It is worth establishing whether data was given, taken, or assumed to be open for any system we rely on.
Test in more than one language. Quality and cost differ sharply. Noticing where, is the first step to making the case for change.
Name language as a criterion. When we shape procurement, evaluation or service design, language coverage can be a stated requirement rather than an afterthought.
From the audience
Colleagues asked how oral languages without scripts enter these systems, and how custodians of endangered languages retain sovereignty over their knowledge. Both speakers returned to community agency and the right to decide.


The episode closed on a participant's question: if language carries identity, memory and culture, what happens when AI learns to speak ours? Does it reproduce words, or reshape how communities understand themselves?


Continue the conversation
The reflection wall remains open: How does the language you dream in shape the AI you want? If there is a word in your language that does not translate cleanly, add it, along with what you think it would take for an AI system to understand it (not just translate it).:
https://www.un.org/ar/newwork-culture-change-un/id-recap-what-endangered-languages-can-teach-ai
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Language as a negotiation tool: Roman Krachko on multilingualism and intercultural communication

"Language as a negotiation tool: Roman Krachko on multilingualism and intercultural communication
written by Sarah Dunsby 2nd Nov 26 1:24 pm


In international business, language proficiency helps professionals understand partners, accommodate their habits, and find a common approach. Roman Krachko is a foreign language instructor and polyglot working with English, Spanish, and Chinese. In this interview, he explains why knowing grammar and vocabulary is insufficient for successful negotiations, how cultural nuances influence business communication, and what role humans will retain in language learning in the AI era.


— Roman, you work extensively with business communication. Why is traditional language learning often insufficient for company executives?


— The problem is that people typically formulate a thought in their native language first, translate it, and only then speak. In negotiations, this approach fails because the conversation moves quickly, leaving no time to translate every phrase. This is why I train clients to use language in specific situations, real-world contexts. While we cover grammar and vocabulary, our primary focus is on how to ask questions, express disagreement, negotiate terms, and respond to unexpected answers. For instance, if a partner proposes unfavourable terms, it is crucial to explain your position and justify your refusal immediately. For an executive, this is far more valuable than striving to speak flawlessly like a native speaker.


— How does your methodology differ from the approach of conventional language schools?


— Take a simple example. In Chinese business culture, a direct refusal can be perceived as overly blunt, especially if it puts a partner in an awkward position. Consequently, disagreement is often expressed indirectly: they might say that the matter requires further discussion or that the proposed terms will be difficult to clear. Without this context, you might mistake a polite response for readiness to close a deal. In our sessions, we analyse these scenarios to understand what lies behind specific phrasing, learn to express disagreement ourselves, and clarify a counterpart’s position without creating unnecessary friction. For a specialist negotiating with foreign partners, this has direct practical value: accurate interpretation dictates how the rest of the conversation shapes up.


— You specifically highlight Chinese and Spanish. Why have these become the main pillars of your work, given that English remains the global business language?


— English is indeed essential in many sectors and serves as a fundamental working tool for most international specialists. That said, Chinese is taking on greater significance due to China’s growing role in the global economy, while Spanish unlocks opportunities across numerous countries in Europe and Latin America. Thus, proficiency in these languages is becoming increasingly vital for entrepreneurs.


Furthermore, Chinese and Spanish represent distinct traditions of business communication. With Chinese partners, it is crucial to understand the weight of hierarchy and corporate etiquette. In a Spanish-speaking environment, much depends on the specific country: communication habits and negotiation styles vary significantly between Spain, Mexico, and Argentina. A translator can help you grasp the literal message, but they won’t automatically explain why a counterpart chose specific words, what meaning they embed within them, or how best to respond. This is precisely what I focus on: helping clients navigate these nuances to understand partners accurately and conduct business conversations with confidence.


— Mandarin Chinese is considered one of the most challenging languages for Westerners. How do you explain the nuances of the Chinese mindset to your clients—CEOs and startup founders—through the lens of language?


— I explain that language reflects a culture’s habitual ways of interacting. For example, in English, we frequently say “I think,” directly stating our position. In Chinese communication, however, much depends on context, the counterpart’s status, and how a thought is framed. It is vital to convey your position while preserving harmony and protecting the other person’s “face”—mianzi—meaning their reputation and dignity. When preparing board members for expansion into the Shanghai market, we examine how the grammar and speech patterns of Putonghua influence how people express opinions and make decisions. For instance, we learn to address partners correctly: in the Chinese business environment, it is common to use a surname alongside a job title or rank. This acknowledges the individual’s status and sets the appropriate tone from the very first meeting. We focus not just on pronunciation and tones, but on how to express respect linguistically—knowing when to speak directly and when to leave room for clarification. In negotiations, such nuances help professionals understand their counterpart accurately and build a dialogue that respects China’s cultural specifics.


— Turning from Asia to Europe and Latin America: Spanish is often perceived as accessible. Where does its true power lie in international business, and how does it help build relationships?


— The power of Spanish lies in its ability to foster trust and establish common ground rapidly. When working with companies from Spain and Latin America, personal relationships carry immense weight: how attentively you listen, how you express disagreement, and whether you can discuss complex issues while maintaining positive rapport.


Linguistic nuances play a key role here. For instance, the subjunctive mood allows you to discuss desires, assumptions, and potential scenarios, softening requests and carefully framing expectations. I teach clients to utilize these structures to convey their position precisely while accounting for their partner’s reaction. When you communicate with a Mexican or Colombian partner in high-quality Spanish, it becomes much easier to move beyond formal conversation, demonstrate respect for their culture, and establish a more trusting contact. In international business, this can become a significant competitive advantage.


— Could you share a case study where your linguistic and cultural preparation altered the course of a major international deal?


— A European tech fund was expanding into Mexico City while simultaneously sourcing components in Shenzhen. The negotiations in Mexico had stalled: the European partners were overly direct, which was perceived as arrogance. I conducted a two-week sprint on the nuances of Latin American business Spanish, focusing on markers of empathy and informal networking. Within a week, the parties reached an agreement.


In parallel, we prepared them for an audit in Shenzhen, where the problem was the exact opposite: the Europeans were trying to push deadlines. I shifted them to business Chinese, teaching them structures that expressed “collective reflection” rather than a “personal demand”. The Chinese partners saw that the Europeans respected their cultural code. In the end, the fund closed both deals and secured exclusive terms because, as the Chinese side put it, “they speak the same language as us, not just in business, but in their heads.”


— In conclusion, how do you see the future of the profession? Will AI replace us, or will empathy and cultural competence become the most valuable skills?


— AI is already excellent at translating words, but it does not always convey intentions and cultural nuances. If AI translates a phrase literally during a corporate merger in Guangzhou but misses a subtle tone of doubt in a partner’s voice, the business could lose millions. The language expert of the future is not a “walking dictionary,” but an analyst of human relations, a strategist, and a psychologist. The more the world becomes digitized, the higher the value placed on human intuition and the ability to feel invisible cultural connections. This is precisely why my profession will endure; instead, consultations in this field will become highly compensated and sought-after.


https://londonlovesbusiness.com/language-as-a-negotiation-tool-roman-krachko-on-multilingualism-and-intercultural-communication/
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

‘A privilege, a responsibility and a curse’: The art of literary translation

"‘A privilege, a responsibility and a curse’: The art of literary translation


André Chumko
October 30, 2026


Professor Marco Sonzogni, from Victoria University of Wellington’s school of languages and cultures, co-translated the Canadian poet and essayist Anne Carson's 2000 book Men in the Off Hours into Italian. Carson was this year awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature. The Post caught up with Sonzogni about the translation process...


Hey Marco! So first things first, how did you connect with Anne?


While I have devoted years to immersing myself in Anne Carson’s literary world, my point of contact with her was her agent via my publisher. My connection is rooted in a deep, scholarly engagement with her writing. The more I read her work, the more I felt the pull to translate it into Italian - even more because Carson is a literary translator herself. That shared vocation created a powerful intellectual bond, even without a direct physical meeting.


How would you describe Men in the Off Hours to someone who’s never read it before?


Layered, complex and extraordinarily beautiful. Even though it was published a quarter of a century ago, it feels as if it were written specifically for our contemporary moment. It represents literary language at its finest, demonstrating everything that literature is capable of when used to express deep feelings, voice radical ideas, and claim new cultural spaces. Anne Carson is one of those writers who extend the possibilities of language.


And how do you actually translate a book, given no two languages are exactly the same?


Translation is an act and a leap of faith. Or, as I like to tell my students, the fattest lie you can tell - that the target text is equivalent to the source text. If it is a lie, and it is, we must tell it in the most convincing way. So, we must acquire and keep honing a cross-cultural mindset and a multilingual skillset.


Literary translation is one of the most challenging but also most rewarding experiences one can have, both as an ordinary or specialised reader. Not only do you get to read literature; you also get to re-write it. A privilege, a responsibility and a curse all at once! So, yes, getting someone else - especially a trusted fellow translator or a trusted reader - to share the love and check your work is the smartest and safest move any translator can make.


What are the most challenging aspects of being a translator?


The most difficult moments occur when linguistic, cultural and literary differences push you into a corner you feel you’re never going to come out of - and if by luck or skill you managed to, it would be to meet many a finger pointed at you by one person or another and for one reason or another. This feeling never leaves you, really, no matter how experienced or seasoned you are, or think you are. Every new translation makes you understand the process more deeply and more holistically - and, one hopes, it also makes you a better translator along the way. Remaining intellectually and emotionally in one piece when faced with the most challenging literary passages in verse or prose is both gruelling and gratifying. Translating a book like Men in the Off Hours was like being on a relentless rollercoaster.


AD


Nobel Prize winner Anne Carson pictured in 2024.
Photo: Jay Dixit / WikiPortraits
What are the most rewarding parts?


There is a profound joy in seeing an author you have translated receive recognition. What matters is that you’ve contributed to gifting the author and their book new readers, new interpretations, new emotions - an afterlife, as Walter Benjamin would argue. This is the human chain of translation - which can be, perhaps must be, the closest of close-readings and at the same time the most distant of distant (re)writings.


The translator is poised between these two poles, trying to balance objectivity and subjectivity across languages, cultures, traditions, values and audiences. This tension requires that the translator be ready to go the very limit of their intellectual and emotional capabilities.


How is AI affecting the world of translation?


I am an obstinate optimist, and that includes AI. I reject the idea that it will render translators obsolete. Instead, I advocate for human-centred AI. Digital fluency is rapidly becoming the contemporary driver’s licence - a prerequisite for professional life all over the world. AI is a tool, not a substitute for critical thinking. And while AI can provide speed and open new possibilities in the workflow, it must be tempered by the accuracy of human judgment. My current work in AI is guided by human rights and Te Tiriti o Waitangi. We must ensure technology respects cultural specificity and the rigour of human thought.


Finally, what’s something not many people know about you?


To wind down and relax, I love watching videos of trains from all over the world."
https://www.thepost.co.nz/culture/361106110/privilege-responsibility-and-curse-art-literary-translation
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

The pleasures of translating Plato

"The pleasures of translating Plato


Themes: Books, Classics, Culture, Philosophy
The reissue of Hamilton and Cairns’ celebrated edition of Plato’s dialogues shows how every translation bears the marks of its era and of its translator’s taste.


Anselm Feuerbach, Plato's Symposium, painting in oil on canvas, 1869. Credit: incamerastock


The Collected Dialogues of Plato, edited by Edith Hamilton and Huntington Cairns, with a new foreword by Rebecca Newberger Goldstein, Princeton University Press, £35


For a university student in the 1980s, The Collected Dialogues of Plato  edited by Edith Hamilton and Huntington Cairns and published by Princeton University Press (first in 1961) was a treasured possession. The volume brought together readable English translations of essentially all of Plato’s writings: the genuine dialogues, a few doubtful ones, and the Letters – in all, the work of 14 translators from Benjamin Jowett in the 1870s to Hugh Tredennick (1954). It had to be handled with care because its India paper was thin enough for a careless turn of the page to tear it. The volume now reappears in a new design, with sturdier paper (hence a thicker book), semi-hard covers, and a brief foreword by Rebecca Newberger Goldstein; inside, the pages are those of 1961, reproduced from the original typesetting.


Plato was a marvellous and elegant stylist, and his translators must try to do justice to his artistry. How does one set about translating a Platonic dialogue? The Republic  begins with four words: katebēn chthes eis Peiraia. Idiomatic English might say ‘Yesterday I went down to the Piraeus.’ Ancient sources report that a tablet was found among Plato’s effects on which these words had been written out in several different orders. Plato’s final choice puts katebēn (‘I went down’) first.


The verb evokes katabasis, the descent to the Underworld from which an initiate into the Mysteries returns with secret knowledge. The Republic  sets out to do just that: the philosopher who has left the Cave is told that he must ‘go down’ again, and the tale of Er brings back a report from the land of the dead. George Grube’s version (revised by CDC Reeve) in John Cooper’s rival one-volume Complete Works (1997) runs: ‘I went down to the Piraeus yesterday.’ Paul Shorey, whose translation is used here, is scrupulous as regards word order: ‘I went down yesterday to the Piraeus’ (only ‘the Piraeus’ sounds perhaps old-fashioned – Plato has no article, and another translator might well drop it).


There is much to consider, then, in translating just four simple words. In this case nothing is lost by staying close to the Greek. More often the translator must reshape, expand, or even paraphrase to produce fluent English. How far may a translator stray? Every translation bears the stamp of its period and of its translator’s taste. Many of the versions Hamilton and Cairns chose were already decades old in 1961, and their idiom often looks back to the Victorians, not least because the most celebrated of Victorian Platonists, Benjamin Jowett, contributes seven of them (four more than any other translator).


A few lines after the opening of the Republic, Socrates remarks on the festival procession (in Shorey’s translation): ‘I thought the procession of the citizens very fine, but it was no better than the show made by the marching of the Thracian contingent.’ Shorey makes the Athenian procession the subject of both clauses. Grube renders epichōrioi more accurately as ‘local residents’, loosens the syntax, and keeps the Thracian procession as the subject of his second clause: ‘I thought the procession of the local residents was a fine one and that the one conducted by the Thracians was no less outstanding.’ Both translators call the procession ‘fine’ (kalē, the same adjective as to kalon  in the Symposium), but today we might be happier with ‘splendid’, ‘impressive’, or even ‘a great show’.


The challenge is steep in the Symposium, which I have recently been translating for publication. Its speeches are a gallery of voices, and Michael Joyce’s exuberant version in this volume (dating from 1935) catches them well. Joyce tends to be expansive, as when the narrator Apollodorus near the start tells Glaucon what his life was like before he fell under Socrates’ spell: ‘Before that I used to go dashing about all over the place, firmly convinced that I was leading a full and interesting life, when I was really as wretched as could be – much the same as you, for instance, for I know philosophy’s the last thing you’d spend your time on.’ In this passage, Plato’s original oiomenos ti poiein, ‘thinking I was achieving something’, has grown into ‘firmly convinced that I was leading a full and interesting life’. While the Greek has the narrator thinking that he himself should be ‘doing anything rather than philosophy’, Glaucon’s response, ‘Don’t have a go at me!’, shows that he takes it as a jibe. Joyce’s emphatic you makes this explicit, not unreasonably, and it is not necessarily a worse rendering than my own more concise version: ‘Up until then I was running around aimlessly, imagining that I was living a productive life. But in fact I was as pathetic as you can get – a bit like you are now, Glaucon – because I imagined that philosophy was the last thing I needed.’


Conversational passages in Plato leave a translator room for manoeuvre. The technical passages and arguments allow much less. These can turn on particular words or series of propositions, and the translator must stay close to them if their logic is to survive. When Diotima in the Symposium says that love is tokos en kalōi, ‘giving birth in beauty’, the strange phrase binds physical procreation to the intellectual offspring of poets, lawgivers and philosophers. The word kalon  should be rendered as recognisably the same term, as the ascent moves from beautiful bodies to beautiful souls, laws and knowledge, and finally to Beauty itself. A version that alternates ‘beautiful’, ‘fine’ and ‘noble’ for elegance may read more easily, but at the expense of breaking the thread of argument.


Hamilton and Cairns’ selection drew on some of the best Platonists of the 20th century; the prefatory notes are still a useful guide, and the remarkably full index lets the reader follow a name, theme, or term from one dialogue to another. The volume is in some respects a period piece, representing a Plato to be enjoyed by the English-speaking general reader in the decades before 1961. In many of the versions, hearing these voices can be a pleasure in itself. This reissue is a reminder that earlier attempts to render Plato have not lost their value; the treasury of Platonic thought can now be enjoyed, in one handy volume, by a new generation of English-language readers.


Author
Armand D'Angour
Armand D'Angour is a Professor of Classics at the University of Oxford and fellow of Jesus College, Oxford."


October 16, 2026
Armand D'Angour
https://engelsbergideas.com/reviews/the-pleasures-of-translating-plato/
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Lost in Pace, Not in Translation: An Intern's View from Inside

"Lost in Pace, Not in Translation: An Intern's View from Inside a Chinese AI Start-up


I arrived in June 2026 as a trained Chinese-English translator, expecting to learn about technology. I did. But the real lesson was that the hardest thing to translate between China and its Eurasian partners is not language. It is pace.


My job was to help build a distributor network for the device across the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). I studied competitors, analyzed marketplace data, built a database of more than a hundred potential partners and helped prepare a market-entry plan.


One of my most memorable days was at the factory, where I took part in checking the first batch of devices. Every unit was tested step by step, and every result was recorded. What struck me even more was the absence of distance. In Shenzhen, engineers, suppliers and production lines are often a short drive apart. A change discussed in the office can be tested on real units within days. Chinese hardware companies are fast not only because people work hard, but because the whole ecosystem is built for iteration.


Speed, in writing


Inside the company, decisions that would take a week of meetings elsewhere were made in a short chat thread. That speed was not chaos. Nearly all work lived in Feishu, a Chinese workplace platform: documents, tables, tasks and every conversation. Anyone could see the status of any project at any time, which made it the fastest onboarding I have ever had.


The flip side is an expectation of responsiveness. Messages arrive in the evening and on weekends, and a quick reply signals commitment. Learning where the real boundaries are is one of the first adjustments a foreigner has to make.


Equally striking was the preference for action over perfection. Managers wanted a rough answer today rather than a perfect report next month. For someone trained in a profession where every comma matters, this was uncomfortable at first. Over time I saw the logic: in a fast market, a good-enough decision made early often beats a perfect one made too late.


Hierarchy, but close at hand


Respect for seniority is real in Chinese companies, yet in a start-up the founders joined working chats, commented on drafts and asked interns for their views. Hierarchy shaped how things were said, with tact and attention to face, more than whether they could be said. The key skill for a foreigner is reading what is left unsaid. A polite "let's think about it" can mean no.


Fast meets careful
The most interesting part of my work was standing between two worlds. My Chinese colleagues thought in terms of scale, speed and product. Potential partners in the EAEU thought in terms of trust, risk and paperwork. On almost every call, the questions came in the same order: certification, warranty, exclusivity, margins.


Certification is where the gap becomes concrete. Electronics sold in the EAEU need proof of conformity marked with the EAC sign, and the document must be issued to a company registered inside the Union. A Chinese manufacturer cannot fully certify its product alone; it needs a local partner first. Add lab testing, special rules for shipping lithium-battery devices and customs clearance for samples, and it is clear why partners in the region move carefully.


Neither side was wrong, but each misread the other. A Chinese team could see a cautious partner as slow. A partner could see a fast-moving Chinese company as not serious about the long term. Much of my work was translation in the broadest sense: explaining speed to one side and caution to the other.


What I take away


Trade between China and the EAEU is growing, and more Chinese technology brands will try to enter these markets. Their success will depend less on product quality, which is often excellent, and more on people who understand both business cultures. For Chinese companies, my advice is to plan certification from day one and to treat the first local partner as a co-founder of the market, not just a buyer.


Too often, cooperation with China is discussed only in terms of trade volumes. In my experience, the real bottleneck is people who can translate between business cultures, and universities on both sides should be training them.


For students from Eurasia considering work in China, my advice is simple: go, learn the tools, learn the pace, and listen to what is left unsaid. In Shenzhen, everyone knows who does what, and by when. Between China and Eurasia, the open question is who will do the translating.


Katsiaryna Hruzheuskaya
Yazhou Bay Science and Technology City
Yazhou District, Sanya, Hainan 572025
China


Katsiaryna Hruzheuskaya is an MBA student at China Agricultural University (Sanya) and a Chinese-English translator with about five years of professional experience as a teacher, translator and executive assistant. In 2026 she completed a business development internship at a Shenzhen-based AI hardware company, helping build its partner network across the Eurasian Economic Union. She is a graduate of Minsk State Linguistic University and a winner of the 7th "Belt and Road" International Scientific and Technical Translation Competition. She writes about Chinese business culture and China-Eurasia cooperation.
10-07-2026
Press release from: Independent Author
This release was published on openPR."
https://www.openpr.com/news/4653471/lost-in-pace-not-in-translation-an-intern-s-view-from-inside
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Thomas Mann translator works out of Mission HillsTheir worlds become my world

"What John E. Woods does is translate. In the world of men and women who translate grand literary writers into English, Woods is an important name. The Manchester Guardian Weekly writes, “We have been spoiled by translators recently, what with William Weaver and John Woods and Gregory Rabassa.” Weaver is known for his translations of Umberto Eco (The Name of the Rose) and Italo Calvino (If on a Winter's Night a Traveler). Rabassa is the translator of Nobelist Gabriel Garcia Marquez (One Hundred Years of Solitude). Woods, who translates from German to English, is perhaps best known for his translations of Thomas Mann (The Magic Mountain), Arno Schmidt, Christoph Ransmayr, and the best-selling Perfume by Patrick Süskind.


John E. Woods: "I set up shop here in San Diego, found this lovely place where I live, and started translating Arno Schmidt."


Since 1985 Woods has lived in Mission Hills in a mission-revival house that overlooks a lush canyon filled with opossums, skunks, and even an occasional fox or coyote. He works at a desk near a set of French doors that open out onto a deck. The deck holds his bonsai collection and orchids. His now one-year-old standard wirehaired dachshund Zepp guards the deck, demanding in repayment only a morning walk and an occasional game of fetch.


^^^^^^^^^^^


The Reader has started this series of its best stories from the past 52 years — 2600 cover stories and some remarkable interior features — to help make up for the loss of its physical edition, which was once large enough to hold whole oceans of print. These stories will feature all the original illustrations and photos (plus easy-to-read typography).


^^^^^^^^^^^


Mr. Woods explains about the name “Zepp.” “In Bavaria, which is very Catholic, up in the mountains all the girls are named Maria, and all the boys are named Joseph. And in Bavaria the short form of Joseph isn’t Joe. Instead, they take the second half of the name, ‘seph,’ or ‘sepp.’ But all over Germany, if you call somebody a stupid Zepp, it’s like our ‘Clem’ — ‘the country bumpkin, the hillbilly.’ ”


A Toshiba laptop sits in its docking port on Mr. Woods’s three- by five-foot mahogany desk. “I go back as a translator before the days of the computer. I can’t imagine making a living translating without the computer now, because it increases efficiency 400 percent or 500 percent.” When he still worked only on the typewriter, says Mr. Woods, “you did the rough draft and you corrected that and retyped, find then, again, you corrected and you retyped. Retyping ended up taking up most of your time. Now, of course, that’s all gone. I let the computer do all that.”


Two windows are open on Mr. Woods’s Windows 95 computer screen, modified to pleasant, eye-saving wheat tones. “The way I control the translation is first to work on the rough in one window, and then I open up the other window and type in the German original. That way I have all the search functions available in both texts.


“When I work with Thomas Mann, who loves to use a leitmotif technique, where phrases and words or whole clauses and sentences are repeated or varied, once I have the German text in the computer, I can immediately locate all the occurrences. You no longer say, ‘I remember that somewhere in chapter seven. Or was it eight?’ Instead, you have it there at once on-screen. It’s always very useful to have the entire German at your fingertips.”


Woods does his own typing of the German texts. “I could,” he says, “scan it in. I have a scanner and I tried that. It ended up costing me about as much time. I find I actually prefer typing in the German immediately after I’ve translated. It gives me a marvelous quick control mechanism. As I type each of the German words, I remember exactly what I’ve just done with them in translation. It’s the perfect way to double-check for accuracy.”


The ergonomic keyboard sits directly in front of Woods. Propped up above the keyboard is the German text from which he’s translating.


On Woods’s desk, at his right hand, sits the one-volume German-English dictionary that he swears by. “It’s one that’s out of print, it’s called the Wildhagen-Héraucourt. It’s one compact volume and it’s very good. It’s a little British-cy, but I know it inside out and it works for me. This is copy number two; my first one fell apart.”


At Woods’s left is his one-volume American Heritage dictionary and within easy reach, a three-volume Webster's. “And then,” says Woods, “immediately to my right is my reference library, which is really my soul. It’s two Encyclopedia Britannicas, one is the 11th edition from 1910. Mine is the little British edition, half-sized and bound in blue.” Woods also has a good thesaurus, “Although with an on-screen version,” he says, “I need it less nowadays. And then I’ve got most of the Oxford companions to whatever — English Lit, German Lit, classical antiquity, Christianity — and a Columbia Encyclopedia, plus a contemporary Encyclopedia Britannica, and my compact OED [the Oxford English Dictionary].”


There’s more. Woods regularly consults a 32-volume paperback version of the Grimm Dictionary, the German dictionary that is comparable to English speakers’ OED. He has Bibles and concordances, books of English and German quotations, an encyclopedia of mammals, Eric Partridge’s Dictionary of Slang. He has references and guides to mushrooms, stars, plants, as well as French, Latin, Spanish, Italian, Russian, and various German dictionaries. And then there are books of nursery rhymes, a film encyclopedia, a good Shakespeare edition, a bilingual picture dictionary, books on German surnames and dialects, a rhyming dictionary. Close to 200 essential volumes, all within immediate grasp.


They come in handy. Only recently Woods had to trace down a reference to scalping in 2 Maccabees. Who got scalped by whom? Answer at least two of the seven sons of a widow (chapter 7), by Antiochus IV. And who was he? A Seleucid king of the Second Century B.C. Seleucid, what’s that? And on, and on.


I ask Mr. Woods if he came to feel that he almost inhabited, lived in, a text as he translated it.


“Less inhabit the text than inhabit universes” is his answer. “I get up in the morning, and it’s almost like opening a door and walking into this other world, one that I know very well by now. Whether that’s Arno Schmidt, or to a lesser extent Thomas Mann, or Christoph Ransmayr. Their worlds become my world. Or at least they are worlds that I can enter and delve all the little nooks and crannies. I know their exotic flora and fauna, the phases of their moons. Every detail is real to me. Then, at the end of the day I can close the door on all that. It’s a wonderful way to spend each professional day.”


When he takes up a new author for translation, does Mr. Woods begin by learning all that he can about that author?


“Usually not. Nor do I wade through all the secondary literature if it’s already a known author. I think that brings prejudices to what the translating task is about. I read the book. I try to read it the way any intelligent reader should read a book, and then I sit down and I start from page one to translate.


“I think, at least originally, and to a certain extent it is still the case, that what I am trying to do is to re-create for the American reader, for the English-speaking reader, something of the same experience that the educated German reader has when he or she picks up a book and reads it. I want that to happen for the American reader.


“Over time, however. I’ve come to believe that that’s probably an impossibility. That translation itself is an impossibility. Because what happens, of course, is that ultimately I end up creating a new text for new readers in a new context. The original and its translation are not the same. I cannot, to use a good old word out of my theology days [Mr. Woods, for several years, was a Lutheran pastor], I cannot repristinate the original experience.


“First of all, Americans are not Germans; sometimes I feel as if the two cultures are from different galaxies. Second of all, the languages are not congruent. When a German thinks a sentence in one way, that is not the way an American would ever think that sentence or put that thought together. So that no matter what I do and how well I do it, a new text is being shaped. Which gets us back to your question of whether I wade through all the secondary reading. No, because that new text is going to happen in any case, and what I’m trying to do is give the reader a reading experience, not a scholarly one.


“Being bilingual is only a first step toward being a good literary translator. Being a good literary translator is not anything like being an interpreter at the United Nations. I would no more know how to do that than I would know how to compete in a decathlon. It’s a whole different thing. I work with the written text. I sit and look at words and how they fit together, I wrestle with syntax, I listen to the melody and the rhythm of sentences, I try to understand what makes great prose. And I don’t touch poetry. I think only poets can translate poets. My skill, if I have one, is in creating good prose.


“One of the major differences between German and English is the syntax. Take a master of German syntax like Thomas Mann, who sometimes built sentences a page long. My task as a translator is to take each of those sentences apart piece by piece, dynamite the thing if necessary, and then reassemble it all in a vastly different order.


“One of the things that often happens in a great expansive German sentence is that it builds to its center and then dies away from it. A long sentence in English, in the classic tradition of a Gibbon period, tends to be additive and cumulative. It either starts strong and then dies away slowly or it starts and builds to that final moment of meaning. The two languages go about the task of thinking in long complex sentences so differently.


“So, once again, you’re creating a new text, and you’re looking at how that works and how to make what happened in the German happen in the English. You can’t reconstruct that, it’s not going to happen the same way. What you want to do is to make a comparable aesthetic experience out of a great sentence.


“For me, the proof of the pudding is always reading aloud. I read aloud everything I do at least a half-dozen times. One thing I discovered early on is that in reading a sentence aloud, if I stumble, there’s something wrong with the sentence.


“Reading aloud is one of my great pleasures. I happen to have a partner who loves to be read to. One of his pleasures in life is that he usually gets the daily rushes. When he comes home from work, we have our coffee and I read to him the day’s work, and that’s a way for me to proof my work, and also for us to share what I do.”


It’s not important, I ask, for a translator to know a great deal of autobiographical material about the author he’s translating?


“I won’t say it’s not important. I would say that certainly as your knowledge expands of what life experiences helped shape an author’s texts, a certain richness is added. That richness really only comes after a long, intense relationship with a particular author and his work. But if you superimpose a quirky, scholarly thing on him, however much a particular theory may appeal to you, you are probably going to wrench the text in certain directions that won’t be healthy.


“The other thing, of course — and this is a whole different matter — is ‘Had we but world enough, and time,’ as Andrew Marvell put it. Of course I would love the luxury of sitting down and reading all of Thomas Mann and all the scholarship about him, and then begin translating. Unfortunately, I’m under contract to people who want the product yesterday and aren’t paying me for five years of scholarship. They’re paying me for a translation of a text completed within a certain time frame as stipulated by the contract. Which means that translation is piecework. At the same time it is, of course, a very serious literary effort. But the utopia of endless time and endless thought is never there.”


Let’s make believe, I say, that you’re given a new text to do. What would be the first thing you would do?


“Read the book. I sit down and read it. Try to read it as an intelligent reader. I might make notes. Certainly make mental notes of how this particular language works, what characterizes this language. I’m looking always at that, at my craft. As for the larger thoughts and ideas, if I’m reasonably good at translating, those will surely get across. I’m not going to change the writer’s general outlook on the world. That’s going to come across no matter what I do. I’m looking more at surface texture, at prose style, at literary allusions. One of the things that is very difficult for me is to read any text in German, even a magazine article, without immediately asking myself, ‘How would I translate that?’


“I’m always aware of the little problems of how to do the thing I do, how to work with a word, a phrase, give it its appropriate idiom. The devil is in the details. But, generally, I read the book and form an idea of how I want to go about this. Then, I sit down at my computer and begin. I’m a very linear kind of guy. I start on page 1, and I translate doggedly onward to page 873, or whatever.


“One of the basic tools I learned as part of my training as a Lutheran pastor was ‘exegesis,’ the critical analysis of a biblical text. You sit there with the Greek or Hebrew text in front of you and take it apart piece by piece. Your questions are: How does the grammar work, what sociological context does this noun come from, was it used in the marketplace, is it from the world of farmers or warriors, and what did this verb originally mean before Paul or Luke adapted it for use in the early church? All those kinds of questions become very important when you’re preaching a sermon on a text. And they’re equally important when you’re translating a novel.


“And even after you’ve done all that, you may still not understand. Whenever I’m having trouble with a translation, with a phrase, with a metaphor, I sit there and try to visualize what it was the author saw, I try to conjure up the field of images out of which these words came. And sometimes, on my best days, I can literally see it. And suddenly I find the translation I need.”


About how many pages can you do in a day?


“Instead of pages, let’s talk words. It depends so much on the text. There are texts and there are texts. When I’m working on one of Arno Schmidt’s late novels, if I have 1000 words of rough draft after eight hours of work, I feel as if I’ve done my share for the day. There are lighter texts, of course, where I can do 3000 words without overtaxing myself. It’s entirely relative. Somewhere between, let’s say, 1000 to 3000 words a day, and most of the time something between 1500 and 2000.”


I ask if Mr. Woods does a first draft.


“I will print out what I have done that day, which is essentially a rough draft, corrected and recorrected on-screen. Then that evening, as I said, I sit over a cup of coffee with my partner and read him the daily rushes. As I do, I make a note of this or that change. At the end of the week, usually on Saturday morning, by the early morning sun on the back deck, I go over the week’s work, read it aloud, check the original for things that sound wrong, and do what I think of as the real editing. Then, about once a month, depending on how the text itself divides up, whether there are big chunks that belong together. I’ll take a day or two to do another read-through and revision. Finally, before I send it off to the publisher, I do one final grand pass. So that comes to something like four revisions.”


How long did it take Mr. Woods to translate Thomas Mann’s Magic Mountain?


“Not long enough. I wish I could have had more time for it. I did The Magic Mountain in nine months. I pushed that one hard. That was a 60-hour-a-week job. I mean, I really laid in and dug in and did it.” (Mr. Woods in 1996 was awarded the first Helen and Kurt Wolff Prize for Translation for his translation of The Magic Mountain and Schmidt’s Nobodaddy's Children.)


Do you get paid well?


“I get paid quite well for what I do, and I’m incredibly lucky because I’ve made the right connections and somehow done the right things, been in the right places at the right time, whatever that’s all about. Generally speaking, translators are not paid well.”


May I ask what you made for The Magic Mountain?


“No, you can’t. I’m not a starving artist. If I were a starving artist I would find myself another profession.”


Is there much market for translators?


“Most people cannot make a living off this. I don’t think they ever have. Translation has always been poorly paid on the whole. Then there’s the state of publishing nowadays. The major houses, having been bought up by conglomerates, are looking more and more to their bottom lines and are doing fewer and fewer literary translations. The smaller houses and the university presses are not particularly picking up the slack. There isn’t a lot of money there to pay for translation, particularly now that Congress has savaged the National Endowment for the Humanities.


“Literary translating is about literature, it’s about being very, very skilled in your native language. Not only do you need to know the second language, and I mean know it well, but you have to love and work with and understand your own language. You have to know how to make it sing and dance. Being bilingual certainly is a leg up, but that doesn’t create a literary text “There are a lot of people out there who are bilingual. They think, ‘Well, I ought to be able to translate something.’ And the publishing houses know that there’s this vast pool of workers out there, and so they farm the stuff out in piecework. The results are haphazard. Some great and wonderful translations are produced, and some that are not so great and wonderful.”


Is there a community of translators?


“There are workshops and conferences, although less and less these days, because the money that funds them seems to be drying up. As I said, there aren’t many people who make a living off this. It’s a mixed bag. There are college professors who make this a hobby or see it as a way of meeting their publishing requirements or who simply have fun doing the work. There are people who do it to earn a little extra income, or as a hobby. And there are a few of us who struggle to make a living at it and a couple who actually manage to do so. Of the literary translators from the German, I suppose I know 25 or so, some of whom are dear friends, some of whom I’ve met at conferences and know to put a name with a face.”


I ask how the business of translation works.


“Well, first, let’s talk about translated literature in America. I delivered an after-dinner speech on the topic at an academic conference on postwar German literature a year or so ago. I was able to get hold of the records of PEN New York, which every year awards its PEN Translation Prize. All the publishing houses, from major conglomerates to mom-and-pop operations and university presses, submit works that have been translated from all the literatures of the world. We’re not talking here about cookbooks or tour guides or auto mechanics, but about what a group of people, after a great deal of wrangling, decide is probably ‘literature.’ I presume that most of the serious prose and poetry that gets published in a given year is on pen’s list. In any given year, at least over the past five years, that list of published translations, from all the languages of the world, has not exceeded more than 200 to 250 titles. So every year we Americans are getting no more than about 200 peeks a year over the literary fence into the world outside.


“Then, if you start looking at the individual languages, about 60 percent of the books are translated from five languages, and in this order French, Spanish, German, Russian, Italian. So that’s approximately 120 titles. All the rest of the world’s languages get the other 80. That also means that there are 20 to 25 titles a year translated from the German. There are at least 50 people who would love to have a contract for any one of those books. Which means, then, that almost no one can make a living at this.


“I feel myself extremely fortunate that, with some hard work and a great deal of amazingly good hick. I’m able to make a living. One major piece of good luck is a wonderful institution called the Arno Schmidt Foundation, which has been my bread and butter over the past ten years. Another has been a fine, long-term working relationship with my editor, Carol Janeway, at Alfred A. Knopf.” John Woods was born and raised in the Midwest. Woods’s father, a veterinarian, “was born in 1892,” says Mr. Woods, “so that he was 50 when I was born. I’ve always thought that one of the advantages I have with the English language is that both my parents spoke good Midwestern English, the way it was cultivated in little country schools almost a century ago now.” Woods’s mother and father, he adds, “both came from a small town in southern Indiana. She was the daughter of the town pharmacist. He had tuberculosis, and so in hopes of a cure the family homesteaded briefly near Clovis, New Mexico, but he died in 1912. They came back, and for many years she lived in a small town in southern Indiana.”


Woods spent his early years in Fort Wayne, Indiana, and Cincinnati and Lima, Ohio. He graduated from high school in lima in 1960. He went to a small liberal arts college, Wittenberg University in Springfield, Ohio. The university was named for Wittenberg, Germany, the city where Martin Luther nailed his 95 theses to the door of the town church in 1517.


Asked how he happened to choose Wittenberg, Mr. Woods says, “Quite simple. I’d applied to several places and this was the best deal.” Mr. Woods’s parents weren’t particularly religious, and he had not had a traditional religious upbringing. But at Wittenberg, he says, “the first truly intellectual and interesting people I’d ever met, people who thought deeply and who could use words to express their thoughts, were Christians, existentialist Christians. These people were formative in my life, because they gave me a world-view. I’ve since abandoned that world-view, but it certainly was a way of getting at some of the larger issues of human history and culture.”


After graduation from Wittenberg, Mr. Woods went on to graduate school at Cornell University, with a major in English literature. “I didn’t like that,” he says, “and by some of the more whimsical twists of fate, I ended up at the Lutheran Theological Seminary in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. And even served as a Lutheran pastor for two years.” The seminary was associated with the LCA, the Lutheran Church in America, the most liberal of the Lutheran denominations at the time. Mr. Woods explains, “This was the old German, Fast Coast church. They take their theology very seriously. Philosophy and scholarship mean something, and that’s what interested me ultimately, the intellectual aspect. And I was in seminary in the late ’60s, a time when the main-stream churches were very involved in social issues. We seminarians were out demonstrating and working in the ‘inner city.’ Anyway, that’s my Lutheran connection, and that’s what got me to Germany.


“I went off to Germany to study theology and ended up staying for about eight years— that’s where the whole German connection got started. When I arrived in Germany in 1971, I really had little grasp of the language. I had taken a year in college.


“I went to Germany to study with Jilrgen Moltmann and Ernst Bloch. Bloch was a Communist philosopher, a heretic who had been thrown out of East Germany for redefining Marxism, seeing it as built on an ontology of hope. Moltmann was big on hope too, with an emphasis on eschatology, the study of last things.’ It was the theological fad of the day. It sounded good to me. I planned to do my doctoral thesis on the eschatological themes in Luther’s commentary on the Book of Genesis, I’ve long since left all that behind me, but it was important to me at the time. And besides, I was a real leftist in my politics — still am — and was happy to shake the dust of Nixon’s America from my shoes. The Old World was a new world for me, and I loved it”


I stop Mr. Woods and ask how old he was when he went to Germany to study. He thinks for a moment and says, “I was just short of 30, a tall, balding, gangly fellow. My German was more or less nonexistent, so I first spent two months in an immersion course at the Goethe Institute in Passau, a small city on the Danube near the Austrian border — a reactionary backwater, by the way, as I learned after I got there. It’s where the movie The Nasty Girl is set. The Goethe Institute provides language instruction in Germany and functions outside of Germany as the nation’s cultural representative, sort of like the United States Information Agency does for us.


“I ended up,” he says, “marrying my German teacher. I enrolled at Tubingen University to study theology and because my wife was connected with the Goethe Institute, the closest Goethe Institute that we could find was in a quaint little town called Schwabisch Hall, which was a three-hour commute by train from Tubingen.” For three years, Woods commuted back and forth three to four days a week between Tubingen and Schwabisch Hall. “So,” he says, “I got the German experience. I was as close to being amalgamated into that culture as you get, I think. One of the things about all European cultures — not just German culture—is that you are always a foreigner. These are homogeneous societies. Unlike America, where you plant your two feet on the continent and say, ‘I’m an American,’ and everybody says, ‘Okay, you’re an American.’ In Europe, whether it's France or Denmark or Germany, you can plant your two feet there and say, ‘I’m a Frenchman, a Dane, a German,’ but you will always be ‘the American.’ You will never be ‘a German.’ You can’t say, ‘I’m a German.’ You just aren’t. You are always where you came from.” I ask Mr. Woods when he began to think in German. “Who ever really knows that,” he says. “After about six months in Germany, I started to work more or less fluently in the language, and I suppose shortly thereafter, I started dreaming in German and thinking in German. And even now when I go over, within hours I’m talking to myself in German. English just gets shoved to the sidelines, until I get back here, and then English takes over again right away.


“I’m a type A personality, anyway — goal-driven, obsessive-compulsive. My friends on this side of the Atlantic think of me as a mini-Nazi. When I get over there, I find the Germans so well potty-trained and uptight that the Southern California laid-back part of me starts blossoming, simply in defiance of so much German rigor, which nevertheless is part of me no matter what I do.”


Did Mr. Woods come home during those eight years?


Sponsored


“Occasionally. My mother was still alive, so my wife and I would visit her. And then, there was one year in ’76, where my wife was on an exchange program with the University of Massachusetts. We were in Amherst, Massachusetts, for an academic year in ’76.”


Mr. Woods began translating when he and his then-wife were in Amherst, in 1976. “For our winter reading we had brought along Arno Schmidt’s Abend mit Goldrand, Evening Edged in Gold."


“Schmidt,” says Woods, “for lack of a better handle, is the German James Joyce. I mean, fools rush in where angels fear to tread.” Mr. Woods began trying to translate the book. “I jumped in with both feet. I had been trying to write and was not being very successful, either in terms of finding an agent who liked what I wrote, or for that matter in terms of my liking what I was writing. I hit writer’s block and looked at a wall and said, ‘I’ve got to do something.’ “Schmidt’s late works,” says Mr. Woods, are “difficult to describe if you’ve never seen them. They are about 18 inches long and about 14 inches wide. These are typescripts, photo-offset typescripts of his work. They are multicolumned, there are inserted drawings and illustrations and quotes. It’s metafiction.”


I ask Woods for a minibiography of Arno Schmidt. “He was born,” says Mr. Woods, “in 1914 and died in 1979. He is a late-born modernist. He wrote nothing of consequence, and published nothing, until after the war. He was an auto-didact and did not himself discover Joyce until well into his career, in the late ’50s, by which time he’d been writing for 16 years. But in feet, in some ways, the way Bach was the culmination of polyphony after the age of polyphony was over, I think of Schmidt as the culmination of the modernist movement.


“He created a whole new world of postwar German fiction. Arno Schmidt’s readers have known all along that he belongs in the canon with Brecht and Mann and Kafka. I’m convinced that when the 20th Century has ended and we’re well into the 21st, people will look back at the century just past and say, ‘Mann, Brecht, Kafka, Schmidt — they define German literature.’ He is that important.


“But Schmidt is difficult reading even for Germans. The early works, to be sure, less so. And some of them, like Stony Heart and Lake Scenery with Pocahontas, are great fun, with marvelous quirky love stories that build on the earlier German Romantic tradition. And he was a great humorist, the only German writer I know where I suddenly just start guffawing. But it’s often difficult reading too. And everyone said it was untranslatable. Then, just to have something to do to justify my existence as a writer, I sat down and started to translate Evening Edged in Gold. And found, much to my surprise, that I could do this.”


In 1978 Mr. Woods took the beginnings of his translation of Schmidt’s Evening Edged in Gold to the legendary Helen Wolff. Editor and publisher Helen Wolff died in 1994 at the age of 88. Mrs. Wolff and her husband Kurt (Franz Kafka’s first publisher) fled occupied France and came to the United States in 1941. In 1942 the Wolffs founded Pantheon Books. Their first success at Pantheon was a new edition of the Grimm fairy tales. They went on to publish such writers as Boris Pasternak, Gunter Grass, Umberto Eco, Georges Simenon, Max Frisch, Stanislaw Lem, and Amos Oz. In 1961, after Random House acquired Pantheon, the Wolffs, at William Jovanovich’s invitation, joined Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. There, they continued to edit and publish under the imprint “A Helen and Kurt Wolff Book.” Kurt Wolff was killed in 1963 in a traffic accident in West Germany; Mrs. Wolff continued as the imprint’s publisher until 1986, when she retired.


Mrs. Wolff, in a 1980 New York Times article, spoke about her meeting with Mr. Woods. “About two years ago, John E. Woods, a young American who had been at Cornell University, visited me in Frankfurt and said that he was totally devoted to Schmidt’s work and was translating his latest novel. I also met Ernst Krawehl, who had been Schmidt’s editor for 25 years at Fischer and was also convinced that Schmidt had turned out a masterpiece. But without the translation by Woods, I would never have dreamed of publishing it."


Mr. Woods met Mrs. Wolff, he says, “at her famous hotel room at the Hessischer Hof hotel in Frankfurt, where she always stayed during the Book Fair, never appearing on the floor of the Book Fair, but limiting her contacts to the people she invited to her room. The who’s who of European literature would knock on her door. From Calvino to Grass — they all made the pilgrimage to Helen Wolff's door, and I had the privilege of being able to knock on that door too, as an invited guest.


“She was a small woman, very soft-spoken. She was aging by then and had, I don’t know the reason, a decided and obvious limp. Her body did not move easily. But her eyes moved fast and were very penetrating. Helen Wolff could look at you and read your literary soul. She was very quick in decision making, knew what she wanted, knew what she expected of people. Her standards were incredibly high, but she was a delightfully warm person at the same time. She had a great laugh — very soft, very tinkly. She was one of those very special people who grace the planet from time to time.”


I ask what Mrs. Wolff's response was to his Arno Schmidt translation.


“She told me that Günter Grass had come to her and said it couldn’t be done. At that point she had read, I think, about 20 to 25 pages that I’d finished. I had done more by then, but that was all she had seen at that point. And she said, 'But it can be done. I see it here. Yes, let’s do it.’ And away it went.


"At the time there was a West German quasi-governmental agency called Inter Nationes that provided funds for me to continue the translation. Within about six months to a year we had a contract and it was a done deal.”


“And you were officially a translator?”


“And I was officially a translator.”


In 1979 Mr. Woods and his wife came to the United States. “The Goethe Institute, as the cultural arm of German diplomacy, is a worldwide thing. There’s a Goethe Institute in Los Angeles, one in Chicago, Boston, Atlanta, Houston. My wife was transferred to New York, which brought us to the States for three years in the early ’80s. Then, she was transferred to Boston, and I joined her there for a year.


“Schmidt’s last four novels are typescripts that were photo-offsets, no typesetter ever set them in print. What I did was create a clone. I used a typewriter like his, an old Adler office machine that his editor Ernst Krawehl supplied me. I used exactly the same paper of the same dimensions, it’s German industrial norm four, which is a page-and-a-half size of their standard typing paper. I even used the same brand of typewriter ribbon.


“One of the things about these late Schmidt texts is that wherever he made a typo, he thought of it as a kind of Freudian slip. So all of that finds its way onto the page too. I had to re-create the visual effect of strikeovers and of his crossing out of typing errors. I rebuilt visual texts. But in English. I said I was a type A personality. And, I had to deal with every conceivable kind of wordplay, double-entendre, and literary allusion.


“Evening Edged in Gold was about a two-and-a-half-year project. Luckily, at that time my wife was making the living, and I could afford to do it. So thanks to her and Inter Nationes, who backed up the project with a grant, it got done. Sad to say, shortly thereafter the marriage broke up.”


In 1981 Woods’s translation of Schmidt’s Evening Edged in Gold won the PEN Translation Prize and the American Book Award (now the National Book Award). It shared the American Book Award with Francis Steegmuller’s translation of Flaubert’s letters. “It was a grand ceremony,” says Mr. Woods. “It was held in Carnegie Hall with John Kenneth Galbraith and William F. Buckley giving out the awards and exchanging witty repartee. The winners were called up on that legendary stage to receive their awards. Along with some cash and a moment of glory, I got a beautiful small Louise Nevelson sculpture.”


A little over a year later, Mr. Woods came to San Diego. “Thanks to Helen Wolff, I found a job as an editor with Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, which happened to be moving to the West Coast, to San Diego, in 1982. I had an office on the 11th floor of that lovely old wedding-cake building. I was with HBJ here for two and a half years, then spent a year with them in Austin, Texas, on another project, and came back to San Diego in 1986. I edited 20 to 25 books with HBJ, including Mark Helprin’s Winter's Tale. But anyone who knows the editorial merry-go-round can understand why I eventually decided I didn’t really want to do that anymore. So I struck out on my own as a translator.” Before Woods left HBJ in Austin, he had the good fortune to be offered a contract to translate Patrick Süskind’s Perfume. It was a bestseller, and he decided to try the freelancer’s life. He first worked out a contract with the Arno Schmidt Foundation. “That way,” he says, “I knew that I had an income coming in and didn’t have to hustle everything I did. And I set up shop here in San Diego, found this lovely place where I live, and started translating Arno Schmidt, as well as pieces of this and that I was able to pick up along the way. And two years later I met my lover. Mona’s Law defied.” I ask about the Arno Schmidt Foundation.


“The foundation is located in a little town called Bargfeld Uber Celle. It’s in the Luneburg Heath, about two hours south of Hamburg, in a very remote and, for Europe, sparsely populated area — a flat landscape with birch trees and junipers, a few ponds and streams, it’s the landscape Schmidt loved, and where he spent the last 20 years of his life in a very modest cottage. So that’s where the archives are, and that’s where the foundation is located. Every year I get to go over and spend a couple of weeks working in the archives and revising the translations with the help of Hans Wollschlager, who is famous for his translation of Joyce’s Ulysses into German.”


In 1990, Woods’s editor at Alfred A. Knopf suggested he begin retranslating some of the major novels of Thomas Mann, the giant of German literature in the first half of the century. Awarded the Nobel Prize for The Magic Mountain in 1929, Mann fled Nazi Germany in 1933. During the war years he lived in Santa Monica, and for many Americans his voice became the voice of another, a better, Germany. He died in Switzerland in 1955.


In the ’20s, ’30s, and ’40s, Helen Lowe-Porter had already translated much of Mann’s work into English. “God bless her soul," says Mr. Woods. “She was probably not up to the task, less because her German was sometimes a bit sketchy and she managed some real howlers on occasion. But, let me assure you, that can happen to anybody. It has happened to me. No, her biggest problem was that she had a tin ear for her native language.


“One of the marvelous things about Thomas Mann is that although it is very rich, dense, and highly thought-out prose, it is still exquisitely elegant. It has a lightness and a wit in the midst of those great long periodic sentences that Germans take such delight in. Mann has the reputation in English for writing almost impenetrable prose, but that impenetrability comes chiefly from dear old Helen Lowe-Porter, who rendered it impenetrable. I think one of the reasons Knopf wanted new translations was to undo some of her knots and make Mann more available to contemporary readers. I don’t mean made simpler. As a matter of fact, Porter often broke up his sentences into smaller units. I tried to keep them as intact as possible. My goal was to make a more lucid prose. Let’s put it that way.”


I ask what other Mann there is that remains to be retranslated. “Well,” Mr. Woods says, “a lot. Some of the short stories have been retranslated, including Death in Venice, but a good many haven’t. And, then, of the major novels, there’s Lotte in Weimar—The Beloved Returns is the Lowe-Porter title. It deals with Goethe in his late years. I wouldn’t touch it, because there you really have to be a Goethe scholar, and I would simply be out of my depth. And there’s Joseph and His Brethren, a marvelous tetralogy that turns the Bible stories we learned in Sunday school into a profound human comedy. It’s probably the one major work left after the three I’ve retranslated thus far. And there are a half-dozen other smaller novels and novellas. And volumes of literary and political essays. In the mid- to late ’40s, Mann was known in this country both as a novelist and as the voice of democratic Germany. He went on lecture tours in this country and would fill 5000-, 10,000-seat stadiums. Americans waited in line to hear Thomas Mann speak—all that is so long ago now, good as forgotten.


“Those little pieces of this and that along the way have also now multiplied in a lot of directions; one is retranslation of three major Thomas Mann novels, Buddenbrooks and The Magic Mountain are behind me, and actually so is Doctor Faustus, which is now scheduled for publication in January 1998.”


Woods has translated many other, more contemporary works from German. “I did probably the one title that people who are not into serious literature in quotation marks may know, a book called Perfume, by Patrick Süskind. It was on the bestseller list in ’86 and was awarded the PEN Translation Prize. I also recently did a third novel by an Austrian writer named Christoph Ransmayr. The first Ransmayr title I translated was The Last World, which is about the Roman poet Ovid’s exile, but retold in a style that I suppose is most easily described as magical realism. That one got me the Schlegd-Tieck Prize that the Brits award each year for translation. The second Ransmayr novel I translated is called Terrors of Ice and Darkness, a rousing adventure story that deals with the Austrian polar expedition of 1874.”


Mr. Woods’s translation of the third Ransmayr novel, The Dog King, was published earlier this year. “The book is a retelling of postwar European history but assumes that when the war came to an end the Allies carried out some of the proposals that were known as the Morgenthau Plan, by which Germany was to be returned to an agrarian, pre-industrial state, Ransmayr’s premise is that such a plan was actually carried out, and he sees this strange world through the eyes of three people in a small Austrian town. It’s a marvelous, marvelous book.


“He’s also an exquisite prose stylist; the language is powerful and metaphoric but at the same time wonderfully exact and dear. We’re hoping that this may be the next big breakthrough into late-20th-century European literature for Americans to read.”


Gabriele Annan’s recent review in the New York Times of Woods’s translation of The Dog King praised both Ransmayr and Woods. “Ransmayr,” writes Annan, “is a novelist concerned with the philosophy of history rather than the psychology of character. He is taken very seriously in German-speaking countries, where history, especially recent history, is an obsession.” And, “There is something so powerful, committed, and solemn about Ransmayr’s tone that it seems like a command to interpret his message.... He must be fiendishly difficult to translate, and John E Woods has done him proud.”


Who, I ask Mr. Woods, have you not translated that you would like to translate?


“I would love to do some 19th-century material. That’s a fond hope. There’s no way that I’m going to get a contract to translate hundred-year-old novels. Wilhelm Raabe, a great late-19th-century realist, though realist is not the word, he’s almost a precursor to magical realism. There are the Romantics, Jean Paul, Ludwig Tieck—favorites of Arno Schmidt There’s Theodor Fontane, another major German realist. There’s all sorts of wonderful stuff that I’d love to put my hand to. But it ain’t gonna happen.


“As far as Schmidt goes, I’ve done most of the major things, but there’s still plenty of earlier material and his magnum opus. Bottom's Dream. The foundation wants eventually to have a more or less complete English translation available, even if we don’t find publishers here in the States who might pick up on some of the less important items. So far at least, we do have the four volumes of the Dalkey Archive Press edition —The Collected Novellas, Nobodaddy's Children, The Collected Stories, and Two Novels (the latter due out this fall).


“I’m perfectly happy to do Arno Schmidt, Thomas Mann, and any of the major contemporaries like Ransmayr. There’s also a new writer I ran across while I was in Germany last fall. And Knopf likes his work too and has decided to publish him. His name is Ingo Schulze. A brand-new voice, a man in his 30s, who’s written a book of intriguing short stories about St. Petersburg, after the fall of Communism. He was there as a journalist and has transformed his experience into 33 Moments of Happiness, with each of 33 tales written in a different style that has its roots in Russian literary history, from Gogol to Nabokov. They’re exciting and sometimes bizarre stories. I was simply bowled over by them. Maybe Ingo Schulze is the next big find. There will always be good things to translate.”


When you are translating contemporary literature, do you feel there is a difference between an educated German and an educated American reader?


“Sure there is. First, in relative numbers. There is a larger percentage of Germans who still work at being serious readers. But certainly there are still lots of good readers here in the States too. When I got back from Germany last fall, there was a lovely letter waiting for me from a young woman in graduate school She had tried reading the old Lowe-Porter Magic Mountain and could never get past the first 50 pages. Then she discovered my translation and wrote me a long letter about how it had opened up for her the whole world of Thomas Mann. Now she understood why he had won the Nobel Prize. In its own way, that kind of fan mail is worth as much as any literary award.


“Then there were a couple of older gentlemen here in California, one an ophthalmologist in Santa Monica and the other a retired naval officer in Julian. Both of them took the time to call me on the phone and write long letters. Each had read The Magic Mountain seven or eight times in his life, and suddenly they were reading it again and it was brand new, and they were so excited. That’s heady stuff for a translator. It really makes my professional life worthwhile.”


Who do you imagine as your audience?


“I don’t think I imagine an audience. My audience is in some ways myself. If this is great prose that seizes me, I figure I’ve reached my audience. I test it out on my partner, and although he likes to read he’s not a lit major or anything of the sort. So, if something comes across well and he gets excited by a great novel in my translation, then I figure I’ve succeeded, because I’ve reached not only that esoteric little community of one that I am, but someone who leans back and enjoys being told a story. And if it works, if my prose works, then I’m reaching an audience. But my first test is myself, I guess.”


Do you read in very contemporary German, perhaps newspapers and magazines?


“Occasionally, although I really don’t keep up the way I should, I must admit. I spend my day working with prose texts, and when I’m done at the end of the day, what I enjoy reading are things like history and biographies and natural history magazines. I tend to shy away from heavy literature at the end of the day, so I don’t keep up on things in Germany as much as I should.”


Has the language changed significantly since the Second World War, and if so, how do you keep up with the changes?


“It is changing. It had not changed. I think something is happening now. English, American English in particular, is a great whore of a language; it takes on new words and phrases wherever it finds them. It’s one of the things that makes English such an exciting language. German, on the other hand, has a tradition of a standard literary language, High German. There are dialects and colloquial speech galore, but when Germans want to converse seriously with one another, they turn to their formal, rather rigid High German, which tends to be much more conservative and changes only very slowly.


“Although there are writers like Arno Schmidt. One of the great things he did was to dynamite his native tongue wherever he could. But he did that more with metaphors and wordplay than with actually bringing in new language. He also played a lot with dialect. But in the last, let’s say, 10 to 20 years, actually in the time since I left Germany, a newer language is taking shape. And it’s happening fast. It’s very much influenced by English, incredibly. You get new verbs like managen. And all the computer language is English, of course, and they will pick up American synonyms where there’s a perfectly good German word already there. Gay power in Germany is Schwulenpower. ”


What is “schwulen’?


“ ‘Schwulen’ is the German word for gay. It sort of means sultry, but that’s a long story. Anyway, there are changes in the language. I keep up with it only to the extent that I’m over there once or twice a year. One of the major factors is the large new immigrant communities that have become part of Germany's major cities—Turks, Vietnamese, Greeks, Russians. And if I were asked to translate, let’s say a German novel by a Turk who has grown up in Germany speaking German, I might well find parts of his language, which will be rich in the slang and idioms of his community, very difficult to understand. I would probably need some help.”


It sounds like even an avant-garde writer would write in High German?


“They tend to write in standard old High German, although that’s starting to change. Language, of course, always changes, and my guess is that in 25 to 50 years, there will be a considerably different German than the one that Thomas Mann wrote in, although that still remains the language most well-educated Germans would be comfortable with as their formal language.”


Would the language change significantly with the end of the Wall?


“It hasn’t yet. Perhaps only in the sense that it opens up Germany to even more cosmopolitan influence. Certainly for those people in the East, it’s a whole new world, and the Central European influence will continue to grow stronger again now because of the renewed commercial and cultural exchange with Poland, the Czech Republic, Hungary. Berlin is a very cosmopolitan city. I heard languages on the streets of Berlin I could not even begin to identify — Lithuanian, maybe, or Uzbek, I had no idea. So all that will of course have an influence on what happens in Germany.”


I ask who edits Woods’s translations.


“If you mean checks my translation over against the original, no one, unfortunately. This simply amazes my German counterparts. I know a few German translators. Every German publishing house has editors who go over every translation, comparing it word for word, with the original. I don’t know of any publishing house that does that anymore in this country.”


Would Helen Wolff have had somebody check the translation?


“Helen Wolff checked the translation herself. She was of the old school. Or she had staff who could, who were bilingual. It’s a rarity these days in publishing that there are people on staff who have a second language, whether it’s German or French or Serbo-Croatian or whatever.


“My editor knows German, but like everybody else in publishing today, she simply does not have the time to do that kind of editing. She reads the English text carefully, and she’s a great line editor. But nobody ever proofs my translation against the German—until the reviews come out. Then, of course, Professor Horrendo, as Breon Mitchell, a translator friend of mine likes to call him, discovers on page 23 that I’ve called an orange a tangerine. And proceeds to discuss the error at length.”


I interrupt, “And what a howler that was...”


“Yes, and what a howler that was. And the review of The Magic Mountain in the New York Times Book Review appeared in 'Books in Brief.’ I found that itself a howler. The man who reviewed it did not know that H.T. Lowe-Porter was a woman. He refers to her as ‘he.’ And he spent a good third of the review talking about what the fabric of Settembrini’s coat ought to be called and that he had a better solution than mine.”


D.J.R. Bruckner wrote in the New York Times (October 22,1995) in his 317-word review of Mr. Woods’s translation: “Of course, the pleasure of going through any translation is to catch lapses, and in a work so long and learned there are chances to mock any version. For instance, do we know more about Settembrini’s appearance when Mr. Woods has him wear an ‘ineluctable petersham coat’ than we did when Lowe-Porter clad him in an ‘inevitable pilot-coat’? This garment is meant to reveal something of the man’s politics and philosophy, it was often the garb of free thinkers in European cartoons and drawings early in this century. We would know it instantly if the translators just called it a peacoat.”


But Bruckner also wrote, “All the characters in Thomas Mann’s masterpiece The Magic Mountain come considerably closer to speaking English in John E. Woods’s version than they did in its predecessor, by H.T. Lowe-Porter, first published by Knopf in 1927. Lowe-Porter’s apology — ‘better...an English version.. .done ill than not done at all’ — was exaggerated, but his vocabulary was wholly Victorian, and he missed Mann's voice. Mr. Woods makes Mann talk much as we do, if always more intelligently, and he captures the irony and humor in all but a few passages.”


Mr. Woods says, “Professor Horrendo, of course, always knows better what to call the coat that Settembrini is wearing. And it wasn’t a peacoat, by the way. He latches on to some petty detail, and the whole sweep of the translation is forgotten.”


Do translators expect to be reviewed?


“Expect? No. The standard practice is the one-adverb review of the translation — ‘brilliantly,’ ‘adequately,’ ‘poorly translated.’ “I think if there’s a metaphor at all for what I do, it’s one I’ve taken from music. I am like a performing artist. You can’t hear a Brahms sonata until a pianist sits down and plays the notes for you. You can’t hear Thomas Mann until I sit down and play the notes for you. So, I think we translators ought to get more credit than we do.”


Did you ever make a horrible mistake?


“I’ve made lots of horrible mistakes. One in fact that Helen Wolff didn’t catch, in a small book by Günter Grass called Show Your Tongue, about a year he spent in Calcutta, India. And somewhere he uses the word ‘Schuppen, ’ which can mean the ‘scales of a fish’ or ‘dandruff.’ And in a moment of average inattention, I chose dandruff— and it should have been the scales of a fish. That sort of thing happens, it just happens. You’re working fast, you go back and check, but it never registers, and suddenly the translation is there forever in black and white.


“One of the things you learn, particularly in this job, is that there is no such thing as perfection in this existence. And you learn to live with that. It will never be perfect. Any translation can be made better both aesthetically and in terms of accuracy, and that’s why you correct four and five times yourself, and that’s why somebody else should look at it too. Because it will never be as good as it truly ought to be.”


I ask Mr. Woods if he were amazed, initially, at his ability to translate.


He says that he was but that what amazed him more was what great fun translating was. “I know that all my life I’ve been a word-smith, but one of the things I discovered in trying to write was that perhaps I didn’t have all that much of importance to say. And one of the great joys of translating the works of important authors like Schmidt, like Mann, like Ransmayr, and so many of the other things I get to do, is that you’re in the hands of masters who have wonderful things to say. And you get to say them for them, with them. It’s a great experience if that’s where your talent lies. And somehow that matchup has worked for me. And every day I get up and sit down at my computer, I still enjoy what I do. And I’ve been doing it now for 20 years.”


— Judith Moore
Author
Judith Moore (RIP)
Publish Date
July 18, 2026
Judith Moore has been a recipient of two NEA Fellowships for literature, most recently in 1996. She is coauthor with Sue Coe of X, published by Raw Books and Graphics and reissued by New Press, and author of The Left Coast of Paradise, Soho Press, which included pieces written initially for the San Diego Reader. Her essay collection, Never Eat Your Heart Out, also including pieces first printed in the Reader, was published early this year by Farrar, Straus & Giroux."
https://www.sandiegoreader.com/news/2026/jul/18/feature-thomas-mann-translator-works-out-of-mission-hills/
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Emily Wilson on her controversial Odyssey translation

"Wilson, a professor of classical studies at the University of Pennsylvania, has polarised the classics world for almost a decade. Her translation – the first complete English version of the Odyssey by a woman – is cast in strict iambic pentameter. Its foundation is academically rigorous, yet its language is boldly modernised. Some greeted it as a radical poetic feat. Others accused her of heresy, criticising her colloquial register and political inflection.


Among Wilson’s most distinguished peers, Edith Hall spoke for many in predicting, in these pages, that Wilson would “win a place in [the] roll-call of the most significant translations of the poem in history”. Daniel Mendelsohn, an Odyssey translator himself, on the other hand, has contended that Wilson “strips away many of the subtleties of the original”, pointing to a claim that a third of Homer’s text has been lost in her version.


Among armchair classicists on X, however, reactions have been almost uniformly hostile. Wilson has been accused of “wokery”, and of the “DEI-fication” of Homer. A post from May 2026 is representative: “The Emily Wilson translation… is basically the Odyssey for people who thought Homer needed to be run through a modern accessibility filter.”


What does Wilson herself think? Speaking on Zoom from her sunny Philadelphia home, she says she’s paying little attention to the online kerfuffle. “I avoid Twitter [now X] these days… I find it depressing.


“It would be nice to think that this was a serious dialogue about literature, poetry, translation and the study of Ancient Greek. I would love that. But I think this is about people latching on to particular ways to reinforce the very limited and toxic positions that they already have. I don’t think it’s about learning anything – and that just seems sad to me.”


Wilson’s frustration points to a broader truth: the Odyssey controversy is less about philological complexities than about the culture wars. As she writes in her new book, Crossing the Wine-Dark Sea: Journeys Through Ancient Literature, Homer’s poem is now “ultra-canonical, and often viewed as a wellspring of ‘Western civilisation’.” That’s clearer than ever in contemporary US politics. In a eulogy delivered last year after the murder of the activist Charlie Kirk, Stephen Miller, Donald Trump’s deputy chief of staff, invoked a civilisational lineage from antiquity to modern-day America: “Our lineage and our legacy hails back to Athens, to Rome, to Philadelphia, to Monticello. Our ancestors built the cities. They produced the art and architecture. They built the industry.”


“I think it’s extremely dangerous,” Wilson says of this narrative. “Of course, it’s true that figures like Thomas Jefferson did study both the constitution of Athens and Rome, and ancient Carthage, and other ancient societies. It’s not that there’s absolutely zero germ of history there.


“And yet this misleading, simplistic, historically [inaccurate] and extremely toxic stew of ideas is presented as if there were a completely hardwired through-line from antiquity to ‘we are the heirs of the ancient Athenians’. Of course that’s bogus.”


If you’ve been conditioned to have a glorified view of ancient Greek and Roman civilisations, it can be discombobulating to hear, in Wilson’s Odyssey, phrases such as “canapé”, “pep talk” and “you must be joking” uttered by heroes and gods. But Wilson is adamant that archaic language is nothing more than a stylistic conceit, one that falsely equates grandiosity with erudition and authority. “My Homer,” she writes in the preface to her translation, “does not speak in your grandparents’ English, since that language is no closer to the wine-dark sea than your own.”


Wilson fell in love with the ancient world as a child. Born in Britain in 1971, the daughter of the late academic Katherine Duncan-Jones and the critic AN Wilson, she played Athena in a primary school production of the Odyssey. She went on to study Latin and Greek, then read Classics at Oxford. She moved to America in 1996 to pursue a PhD at Yale.


Wilson was the first woman to publish a complete English version of the Odyssey  Credit: Dan Callister for The Telegraph
Her penchant for the dramatic has only grown with age. She has become known for her electrifying readings of Homer, in which she brings the epic’s characters to life through vividly imagined voices, expressive gestures – at times you worry she will literally tear her hair out – and frequent quotations from the ancient Greek. “People very often clap when I do a bit of ancient Greek,” she says, “and I think it’s so lovely that people are excited to hear it.”


Wilson’s dedication to the Homeric world is even manifest on her body in the form of a series of tattoos. “I have a spear and a bow on my legs for the Iliad and Odyssey, representing Athena and Odysseus. I have an octopus representing Odysseus, changeability and multiplicity, then the horses of Achilles on my other arm – the immortal horses that tell Achilles he will die… A tattoo is a permanent thing. What is permanent for me is Homer.”


Still, she stresses the need to “rethink everything” about translating classical texts. For some, the mention of Classics conjures images of dusty Loebs and crusty professors. Not for Wilson. Among the “20 Rules of Translation” in her Crossing the Wine-Dark Sea is: “If nobody objects to any choice you make, your choices are too timid.”


That might have been the advice given to Christopher Nolan, judging by the furore his Odyssey film is already causing. His decision to cast the Kenyan-Mexican actress Lupita Nyong’o as Helen of Troy, for instance, has drawn fierce criticism from figures including Elon Musk, who declared that “Chris Nolan is p---ing on Homer’s grave.” (My fellow Greeks, meanwhile, are complaining that they are barely represented among the cast, who largely speak in American accents.)


Nolan’s script is said to draw heavily on Wilson’s translation. Though, she says, Nolan hasn’t directly asked her for help, she’s optimistic about the film. “I think it’s going to be fun… I hope it will bring more people to the original IP.” For one thing, she points out, Homer’s poem sits well with Nolan’s work to date. “It’s the same tropes that we’ve seen in almost every film that he has already produced – the themes of the lone man on a quest with a female character waiting for him.”


Matt Damon, who’s playing Odysseus, wouldn’t have been her first pick. “But his part in The Talented Mr Ripley was the best warm-up… he showed he can be a schemer.” Her ideal lead, in truth, would have been Samuel L Jackson. “He’s able to convey being very smart and wily and funny and command a room.”


Wilson’s next step is ambitious but not surprising, given her dedication to Homer. “I’m actually redoing the Odyssey all over again. In the last stages of doing my 2017 translation, I started to feel that the line-for-line constraint was just a little bit too tight. And that if I had just had a few more syllables, I could do a little bit more. And so I’m redoing it all.


“I think it’s going to be good.”


Crossing the Wine-Dark Sea is published by Profile at £12.99. The Odyssey is in cinemas July 17"
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/books/authors/emily-wilson-translation-interview-odyssey-wine-dark-sea/
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Untranslatable Words: The Power of Lexicon | Diari Valencià

" Dictionaries as Limits and Potentialities of Thought
The Power of Words: Dictionaries as Limits and Potentialities of Thought
The author explores how lexicon shapes our reality and proposes the term 'lexical idiom' for untranslatable words.


The author reflects on how language, specifically dictionary lexicon, limits and expands our capacity for thought and emotion, proposing a new term for unique cultural words.


Human thought and our life experiences are intrinsically linked to the words we have at our disposal. Following Joan Fuster's observation, dictionaries not only collect a language's lexicon but also indicate the limits and potentialities of the life we can live within that language. As Ludwig Wittgenstein stated, 'the limits of my language mean the limits of my world,' an idea underscoring how vocabulary defines our knowledge, imagination, and emotions.
Therefore, the author finds pleasure in exploring dictionaries of various languages, seeking words that conceptualize reality in alternative ways. This linguistic exploration allows for the discovery of new perspectives and the finding of terms that lack direct equivalents in other languages. These words, which coin unique concepts, are the focus of the article.
"Cada matís —de color, de so, d’idea— demana una paraula pròpia, i els diccionaris no són tan generosos."


Examples of Japanese words are presented, such as komorebi (sunlight filtering through leaves), wabi-sabi (the appreciation of imperfect, transient beauty), tsundoku (the act of buying books and letting them pile up unread), ikigai (that which gives meaning to life), shinrin-yoku (forest bathing), or mottainai (regret over wasting something useful). These words illustrate how each culture develops its own lexicon to describe particular aspects of the human experience.
Faced with the difficulty of finding a suitable term for these unique cultural words, the author proposes the concept of 'lexical idiom.' This term, derived from the Greek idiōtismós, emphasizes the particularity and inherent character of a language, distinguishing it from other concepts like 'xenism' or 'idiom' (in the sense of a fixed expression).
The reflection on 'lexical idiom' is unexpectedly connected to an anecdote about statements made by the President of the United States, Donald Trump, regarding the Italian Prime Minister, Giorgia Meloni. This situation highlights the polysemy and potential for ambiguity in language, recalling Fuster's idea about the need for unique words for each nuance.
Ultimately, the author expresses a preference for the 'lexical idioms' of languages, like Japanese, which enrich our understanding of the world, over the ambiguous use of the term in contexts of diplomatic misunderstandings. The contemplation of light filtering through leaves, evoked by the word komorebi, becomes a symbol of the beauty and nostalgia that language can preserve."
27/06/26 - 09:33
https://diarivalencia.cat/en/la-ribera-baixa/general/the-power-of-words-dictionaries-as-limits-and-potentialities-of-thought
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

‘Ties of language and culture are stronger than political borders’: Punjabi translator Navdeep Suri

"What does a translator bring to a text apart from their competence in the languages they translate from and into? How do their life experiences shape their literary contributions? To what extent can we separate their skill from their worldview? These questions are worth pondering over as publishers explore translation tools powered by Artificial Intelligence to cut costs and save time.


Navdeep Suri, whose English translation of Nanak Singh’s Punjabi novel Agg Di Khed (1948) as A Game of Fire (2024) received the Jury’s Special Commendation at the Muse India-GSP Rao Translation Awards 2025, spoke at length about his practice as a translator from a social and political lens in this conversation with Scroll at The Sacred Amritsar cultural festival.


His other translated books include those written by his grandfather, Nanak Singh, such as Khooni Vaisakhi, Khoon De Sohile and Pavitra Paapi. He is also involved with the Nanak Singh Literary Foundation, which was established to preserve the writer’s literary legacy.


Suri also served in the Indian Foreign Service from 1983 to 2019. He was India’s Consul General in Johannesburg, Former Ambassador of India to the UAE and Egypt, and High Commissioner to Australia. He headed the West Africa and Public Diplomacy departments at the Ministry of External Affairs.


Do you consider translation to be a political act? To what extent does the current relevance of an older text guide you when you sit down and think about what to translate?
When I translated Khooni Vaisakhi, a 900-line poem written by my grandfather Nanak Singh after surviving the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, its publication coincided with the centenary of the massacre. The massacre took place in 1919, and my translation was published by HarperCollins in 2019. The timing was significant; it became a useful device to remind readers of the egregious nature of that massacre from the narrative viewpoint of a survivor. The massacre was certainly a turning point in India’s freedom struggle.


When I picked my grandfather’s Partition novels – Khoon De Sohile (Hymns in Blood) and Agg Di Khed (A Game of Fire) – to translate, those were conscious selections from within the vast repertoire of literature that he left us with. Those two novels ground you; they remind you of the price that was paid for India’s independence, in terms of the Partition of 1947 and what it led to.


In the foreword to Hymns in Blood, my grandfather asks some very pertinent questions. He says that we knew of the British policy of divide and rule for about 200 years. What did we do with that knowledge? What happened to us in 1947? What made us turn against each other?


He is not willing to take the convenient escape route of blaming the British alone. He asks us to look deep within and examine what really happened, why, and how. He points out that our own political leaders, religious leaders and media must take responsibility. This novel was published in 1948 but these points remain relevant even today. Whether you look at polarisation in India, the United States or Israel, the same elements are exacerbating divisions between people.


My grandfather wrote about how people were oppressed under British rule, and every pore of his being sought India’s independence. He went to jail for it. Yet, as the flagpoles were being erected to hoist the Indian flag on August 15, 1947, he wondered if losing our humanity was a price worth paying to gain our independence. When you translate texts written by a man who asked all these questions, yes, it is a political act. You are saying that his words need to be remembered.


The responsibility to bear witness seems like an inheritance that you have received from your grandfather. Earlier this year, you spoke out against the genocide in Gaza at the Jaipur Literature Festival and at Majha House in Amritsar. How does your grandfather’s writing help you empathise with people suffering elsewhere in the world?
Translating Khoon De Sohile and Agg Di Khed, both set during the Partition, brought home to me his message of humanity, and in a very powerful way. The pain and trauma that he felt when he saw neighbour turn against neighbour hit me in the gut. He wrote them towards the end of 1947, while witnessing those horrors sitting in Amritsar. They were published in 1948.


His writing forces us to confront the fact that many of us have heard only one side of the Partition story, which is the story of the violence inflicted by Muslims upon Hindu and Sikh communities in places like Rawalpindi, where the characters come from. We cannot afford to overlook the other side of the story, which is the story of the violence inflicted on the Muslims of Amritsar by Sikhs and Hindus. According to the 1941 census, 46% of Amritsar’s population was Muslim. Yet I grew up in an Amritsar where there were hardly any Muslims.


My grandfather’s willingness to confront the actions of his own community was a remarkable demonstration of intellectual and moral courage. In the process of translating his books, I was able to discover a bit of that courage in myself. I draw so much inspiration from him.


As a professional diplomat for 36 years, I had to walk the straight and narrow path. When you take up a job, you have to be disciplined. But since I retired from the Indian Foreign Service, I have had much greater latitude to express my own views on whatever subject we are discussing.


The issue of Israel and Palestine happens to be one that I have closely engaged with for several years. My first overseas assignment was in Egypt; that’s where I learnt Arabic. My second diplomatic assignment was in Damascus. Then I went back as an Indian ambassador to Cairo and Abu Dhabi. I have seen the evolution of the crisis in Palestine. I feel that the power of institutions like the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) and the control of media by sections of the Jewish community result in a suppression of the Palestinian message.


Forget the aspirations of the Palestinians; even their voices do not find expression. And that is why I admire people like Sanjoy K Roy and William Dalrymple for the platform that they have tried to provide for the Palestinian perspective. Because of this, when a session at the Jaipur Literature Festival was titled “The Gaza Genocide”, I had absolutely no problem while moderating it. Calling it a genocide is not simply a matter of public perception. The International Court of Justice calls it a genocide. Holocaust survivors are calling it a genocide.


When you go through the United Nations Genocide Convention of 1948, the core idea is “never again”. And that is why it is heartbreaking for me to see sections of a great community like the Jewish community, which has suffered and endured so much over centuries – not just under Hitler and the Nazis, but also under the Spanish Inquisition and pogroms in Russia and Ukraine – now inflict pain on other people. I think that we have an obligation to speak about it.


Among the foremost critics of the state of Israel are Jewish people who reject the idea that Zionism is synonymous with Judaism. While Israel has been conflating the two, these people and organisations like Jewish Voice for Peace have been opposing such attempts, exposing Zionism as a colonial ideology. What are your thoughts on this?
Because the current government led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been so extreme in its interpretation of Zionism, the lines have blurred over the last few years. One is the line separating Judaism from Zionism; the other is the line between anti-Semitism and legitimate criticism of the actions of the Israeli government. I have thought deeply about this because I have had the pleasure of meeting many Jewish people and making Jewish friends.


Any criticism of Prime Minister Netanyahu or his government by any foreigner attracts a knee-jerk reaction in the form of anti-Semitism allegations. When the critics are Arabs, they are justified in saying, “Hey, excuse me, we are Semites! How can we be anti-Semitic?”


The conflation that you mention constrains valid criticism. When you put your actions above any reproach, you may be able to suppress reactions, but my fear and my worry is that this kind of suppression makes Jewish communities less secure. It pains me that such intelligent, smart people don’t realise or recognise that the real long-term security will come through living in peace with neighbours, not through the antagonistic relationships they have established.


After reading Holocaust literature and Partition literature, have we still not learned how to be human? It makes me sad and makes me wonder, what then is the function of literature?


Teachers, parents and librarians often push young people to cultivate a reading habit, based on the claim that literature helps us become better human beings; it helps us understand the lives of those who are different from us, and empathise with them. As a translator, how do you feel when literature is perhaps not doing what it was supposed to?
I think the impact of good literature is post-facto. It may take years before people recognise the greatness of what becomes a classic. My grandfather’s Partition novels in Punjabi are considered classics now. They have gone through several print runs and are still being widely read. But I don’t think that they attracted much attention when they were written because everybody was busy with the rebuilding of their lives after the trauma of the Partition. Khooni Vaisakhi, on the other hand, was banned by the British Empire soon after it came out.


We live in an age where the most overpowering influence on people’s minds is coming from the information and disinformation being unleashed at them through news channels, social media, podcasts, and YouTube. How many people take a step back to reflect on the authenticity of what is being thrown at them, or even pause to think about where this is leading us? We keep talking about how social media traps us in echo chambers where we are only listening to people like us. But what are we doing to seek alternative views to combat the polarisation we are seeing?


As someone whose family lived through the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre and the Partition, what do you make of the scholarly discourse around intergenerational trauma? Though there is scholarship on intergenerational resilience as well, I don’t see it being discussed as widely. You, for instance, haven’t let your ancestors’ suffering make you hateful. You are eager, instead, to call out violence in other parts of the world because you do not want history to keep repeating itself. How do you process what I’m saying?
I think that the centenary of the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre and the 75th anniversary of the Partition gave many scholars, writers, and researchers an opportunity to discuss the long-term impact of these events. I would like to mention Aanchal Malhotra and Kavita Puri’s work in particular. Some of it does reflect what intergenerational trauma does to people, and the unwillingness to speak about the horrors that were witnessed. There seems to be this almost subconscious effort from survivors to bury those memories and not discuss them with children.


I was born in Amritsar and moved back three years ago. What I find remarkable is that, if you talk to the average person, there is remarkably little rancour against Pakistan or Muslims in India. And I say this very carefully because Amritsar witnessed not just the Partition but also the wars between India and Pakistan in 1965 and 1975, and Operation Sindoor most recently. Almost every house, every village in Punjab, has somebody in the army, almost as part of our tradition.


Lahore is only 50 kilometres from Amritsar, and the border is only 30 kilometres from here. If you are looking for a place with a peaceful constituency, look at Amritsar. This is intergenerational resilience, isn’t it? We must recognise that ties of language and culture can sometimes be stronger than a physical border or a political relationship. And there is an economic dimension that very few people reflect on these days. Amritsar was on the Silk Route. This was the wholesale market from where commodities were pushed into Afghanistan, Central Asia, and other places. Amritsar was where dry fruit from Afghanistan came in, and travelled elsewhere.


The absence of a dialogue with Pakistan and the kind of relationship we have is worth reflecting on. I am not exonerating Pakistan from its actions that have brought us to this situation today, including its continued support of terrorist groups. But at the popular level, the cost of a fraught political relationship is borne by people living in Amritsar and neighbouring villages. Their lands have to be sacrificed. When economic linkages get disrupted, it is the ordinary person who suffers. There should be a greater recognition of the local costs of larger political decisions.


With the profusion of literature and music festivals in both India and Pakistan, it is tragic that we do not have authors travelling frequently across the border to interact with their readers. Why don’t we have such cultural exchanges any longer?
I believe very strongly that, by breaking all links, we are feeding into the othering of the neighbour. We are deepening the polarisation that already exists. I know that there is a very significant constituency in Pakistan that seeks normal relations with India. There are many Pakistanis who look up to India for the progress that we have made as a country. There are many who look up to us as a democracy because they know that their country is in shambles right now.


We may not have Pakistani authors speaking at Indian literature festivals but many of them work with Indian publishing houses and Indian literary agencies. English language publishing in Pakistan is still quite nascent compared to India. What economic opportunities lie unexplored when we close off dialogue?
You are right. This is a discussion that we need to have. I remember the times when the Jaipur Literature Festival would have writers from Pakistan come and speak. My feeling is that saying no to dialogue until terrorism stops is not the best policy option for us. We have to find a way of de-linking the two because the need for dialogue is greater in a difficult relationship.


Isn’t this reluctance to engage in dialogue extending to sports as well?
Yes, that is one more channel closed. It is almost like we are systematically shutting off contact. And honestly, I find this a bit ridiculous because, when you go to Dubai or London or the United States, you always find Indians and Pakistanis living happily with each other.


When I was posted in Abu Dhabi as India’s Ambassador to the UAE, my Pakistani counterpart was a Punjabi from Lahore. We would meet every month for the Asian diplomats’ lunch, even when relations between India and Pakistan were going through a difficult phase. It used to be amusing for the other diplomats to see that we might be at each other's throats professionally, but that did stop us from sharing a joke in Punjabi over a meal. Civility in discourse is useful.


People-to-people contact creates safety valves. When we close off dialogue, we end up allowing the most extreme elements in both countries to hold the rest of us hostage to their agenda. The hateful continue to speak anyway. The ones being silenced, on both sides, are the peaceful ones.


How have the teachings of Guru Nanak inspired you to be an upstander rather than a bystander? After moving back to Amritsar, have you been thinking about this?
Let me say upfront, I am a very agnostic person when it comes to religion. But if there is one religious figure that I would look up to, it would be Guru Nanak because of his conscious effort to put humanity above religion. He forces you to question blind faith.


He insisted on stress-testing your beliefs. When he visited Mecca, he was scolded for sleeping with his feet pointing towards the Kaaba. He said, “Well, please turn my feet and point them in the direction where God is not.” He also went to Haridwar and contested the rituals of the pandits there. Guru Nanak put a lot of emphasis on rationality. I value that a lot.


The decline of a civilisation begins when you stop questioning dogma. Guru Nanak reminds me to maintain a healthy degree of scepticism when somebody claims to give the truth on a platter. Even the Quran urges Muslims to question in order to get rid of their own ignorance.


Last year, the Amritsar Pride March was cancelled by the organisers, fearing safety concerns, after objections were raised by the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) and other Sikh groups in the city. What are your thoughts on this?
The SGPC is only one of various conservative groups. You have the same reaction from conservative groups in Islam and Christianity. I have a lot of issues with the SGPC, and this is only one of them. I think we need institutions that are fit for the 21st century and follow a minimum degree of accountability. The LGBT+ community is an easy whipping boy for any conservative religious group, and this is highly regrettable. What if someone from the SGPC has a child who is from that community? It’s a facade that they maintain, though they are aware of the reality. This unwillingness to accept what we know to be true is seen across religious groups.


Sikhism places a lot of emphasis on seva. Have you ever wondered if bearing witness to injustice through one’s words is also a form of service to humanity?
If you can tell stories in a way that my grandfather did, I’d say yes. For him, storytelling was an instrument for social reform. He realised that a character well-crafted and a story well-told can perhaps leave a greater impact on a person than just a lesson being given out or a law being made. Human beings relate to stories. I don’t think I have the gift that my grandfather had, so the next best thing that I can do is to translate his stories and bring them to a wider audience. In the process, I hope I’m able to address prejudices, change mindsets, and also implicitly acknowledge that the issues he was combating are still around – economic oppression, caste-based discrimination, the wretchedness of those in power, and how they treat others. Many of these ailments are still prevalent in our society. We say this is Naya Bharat, but not much has changed.


Chintan Girish Modi is a writer with a background in peacebuilding.


https://amp.scroll.in/article/1093625/ties-of-language-and-culture-are-stronger-than-political-borders-punjabi-translator-navdeep-suri
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

English translation brings Filipino novel 'Lumbay ng Dila' to new readers | ABS-CBN Lifestyle

"English translation brings Filipino novel 'Lumbay ng Dila' to new readers


As Philippine literature slowly gains international visibility, a pressing question emerges: How do stories rooted in specific places travel beyond the archipelago without losing their soul?


For Filipino author and literary scholar Genevieve Asenjo, that journey is taking shape through "Lumbay ng Dila" ("The Melancholy of the Tongue"), her award-winning novel originally written in Filipino and now being translated into English through a Dutch publication initiative.


The project is more than an expansion of readership. It is an opportunity to bring regional Filipino histories into global conversations without stripping away their complexity.


At a time when international audiences are increasingly curious about Philippine literature, Asenjo's work offers an important reminder: there is no singular Filipino story waiting to be discovered. There are many Philippines, each shaped by its own language, geography, and memory.


"Lumbay ng Dila" follows Sadyah Zapanta Lopez, a 28-year-old teacher in Manila whose life is disrupted by a headline from home. Her grandfather, former assemblyman Marcelo Nones Lopez, has been acquitted after a 21-year trial linked to the 1984 Guinsang-an Bridge Massacre.


The verdict revives a question that has haunted her since childhood: What happened to her mother, Teresa Zapanta Lopez, known in the movement as Kumander Rafflesia, who disappeared after the violence and the years of fear that followed?


Drawn back to Barasanan in Dao, Antique, Sadyah attempts to rebuild a life among kin and memory while opening Balay Sugidanun, a home for stories. Her journey takes her between the province and the city, and eventually to Bangkok with her lover, Priya Iyer. Along the way, she assembles documents, testimonies, and fragments of a fractured past.


What begins as a daughter's search for answers gradually expands into a meditation on inheritance and collective memory. The novel asks what happens when communities carry unresolved histories across generations and whether remembering can become a form of repair.


For Philippine literature, translation has never been a purely technical exercise.


The English translation of "Lumbay ng Dila" allows readers outside the Philippines to encounter a story deeply embedded in Antique's cultural landscape while preserving the textures that make it distinct.


Yet every act of translation carries difficult questions. How do you preserve emotional weight when languages hold different histories? How do you translate political memory without reducing its complexity? How do you retain rhythms and voices that belong to a particular place?


For Asenjo, these tensions are part of the process.


"My first thought was that the novel had found another tongue and reader. It is a given that something is lost in translation; at the same time, something is also gained. I was less worried about individual words than about rhythm, voice, context, and the layered coexistence of Kinaray-a, Hiligaynon, Filipino, and English within the novel. Yet these are the very things that make translation exciting," she said.


Her response reframes translation not as a compromise but as a creative encounter. The challenge is not to reproduce every word exactly but to preserve a way of seeing the world.


Throughout her career, Asenjo has advocated for the visibility of regional voices within Philippine literature.


Although "Lumbay ng Dila" was written in Filipino, its worldview is deeply informed by Western Visayas and Kinaray-a culture. Rather than presenting a singular version of the nation, the novel embraces the many identities that coexist within the archipelago.


Its themes of loss, displacement, inheritance, and longing resonate far beyond Antique while remaining faithful to the communities that inspired them.


The task of translation, therefore, is not to make the novel less local. It is to allow its locality to travel.


The Dutch publication initiative signals a broader shift in how Philippine literature circulates internationally.


For decades, only a limited number of Filipino literary voices reached foreign audiences. Today, works grounded in regional histories are beginning to find new pathways abroad.


That shift matters because it changes how the Philippines is understood internationally.


The country cannot be represented by a single language, a single historical narrative, or a single literary tradition. Works like "Lumbay ng Dila" reveal a Philippines that is multilingual, layered, and constantly negotiating its own past.


Beyond translation: Why Filipino stories are finding global readers
Still, Asenjo is careful not to place impossible expectations on literature.


"I do not expect readers to finish the novel understanding the Philippines. I am not sure any single book can do that. But I hope they meet Sadyah and, in following her search through family histories, political histories, and matters of the heart, recognize a familiar human predicament: none of us begins our story at the beginning, yet all of us must somehow continue."


The journey of The "Melancholy of the Tongue" will soon move beyond the page and into a shared literary space in Barcelona.


On June 27, readers will gather at The Philippine Club in Plaza Reial for an intimate presentation of the novel and a rare opportunity to meet Asenjo in person.


Through readings and a question-and-answer session, Asenjo will discuss the creative process behind the novel.


For those unable to attend in person, a Facebook livestream will make the event accessible to audiences around the world."
https://www.abs-cbn.com/lifestyle/people-culture-events/2026/6/24/english-translation-brings-filipino-novel-lumbay-ng-dila-to-new-readers-1659
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Translated literature and its inner struggles

"Never before have translators faced such immense pressure to become obsolete as they do today. AI tools capable of translating tens of thousands of words in just a few seconds at virtually no cost have significantly altered the landscape of the translation market.


In the context of globalization, translated literature serves as a bridge connecting the finest aspects of human knowledge to domestic readers, while simultaneously paving the way for local culture to reach the world . However, with the development of artificial intelligence (AI) and the pressures of the market economy, this field is facing numerous challenges.


Translator Pham Duc Hung edited the manuscript.
That impact is evident right here in Thai Nguyen . German translator Pham Duc Hung, a member of the Thai Nguyen Provincial Union of Literature and Arts Associations, a member of the Vietnam Writers Association since 2018, and the only German translator in the 10th term of the Literary Translation Council, has had to make the decision to close his reputable personal translation center in 2025 after many years of operation.


That story reflects a thought-provoking reality: Amidst a vibrant market for translated books, translators cannot make a living from their profession. Limited compensation hinders professional development in this field. Many people with strong foreign language skills are shifting to commercial or legal translation to earn a more stable income.


However, it is precisely under such pressure that the inviolable boundary between humans and machines is affirmed. Translator Pham Duc Hung points out a reality: AI can only translate documents, but literary translation requires human emotion and sensitivity. Idioms, proverbs, dialects, or the layers of cultural meaning hidden behind words are things that machines find difficult to fully convey.


Having ventured into translation in 2005, he has quietly amassed a considerable body of work with 8 published books on literature and skills (The Buried Candle, The Deruga Case, The Child of the Age, Outstanding Short Stories from Around the World, The Wheel of Fate, Money is Useless...) along with hundreds of short stories and poems by many German authors published in central and local newspapers and magazines.


A Harvard professor and a Vietnamese poet are working together on a project to translate The Tale of Kieu into English.
The successful translation also yielded positive results when the novel *The Deruga Affair* was honored with the Thai Nguyen Provincial Literature and Arts Award for the period 2017-2021.


However, producing such valuable translations requires a team of translators with a deep understanding of the language, culture, and literature. In Thai Nguyen, despite possessing a wealth of language experts from universities, the field of literary translation in the locality remains relatively quiet and largely spontaneous.


Preserving the essence of Vietnamese literature in the face of algorithms is difficult enough; figuring out how to perform the "reverse translation" task, bringing the indigenous literary and cultural resources of the Tea region to the world in the digital age, is an even greater concern.


Associate Professor Tran Thi Viet Trung (Critical and Critical Studies Branch, Union of Literature and Arts Associations of Thai Nguyen Province) believes that: To develop translation resources and bring the literature and culture of the tea-growing region to the world, there needs to be a mechanism for commissioning translations from the State, while also encouraging foreign students learning Vietnamese to participate in translating works into their languages.


Clearly, promoting local culture internationally cannot rely solely on the dedication and resources of translators. For local literary works to reach international readers, support in terms of mechanisms, publishing partnerships, and large-scale promotion is necessary.


This also includes training a team of translators, developing specialized translation models linked to universities, and implementing policies to encourage international students and researchers to participate in translating Vietnamese works into their own languages."
Báo Thái Nguyên
21/06/2026
https://www.vietnam.vn/en/van-hoc-dich-va-nhung-noi-niem-tran-tro
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

7 reasons to read 'The Odyssey'

"7 reasons to read the Odyssey
The new Catalan translation, by Pau Sabaté, claims the strength and validity of the classic, which tells the adventures of Odysseus and the longed-for return to Ithaca


This is how the new Catalan version of Homer's Odyssey begins, one of the foundational epic poems in the history of literature, translated by Pau Sabaté and just published by Bernat Metge Universal, a label from Abacus. The classic tells the journey of the heroic and cunning Odysseus (or Ulysses, depending on the version), after the Trojan War – an episode dealt with in the Iliad, Homer's other literary monument–, with the aim of reaching the island of Ithaca, reuniting with his wife and son, Penelope and Telemachus, and reclaiming his throne. It is one of the books "most known and influential, subject to countless readings, rewrites and interpretations," comments the editor in the preface of the volume, Roger Aluja. Why does it continue to amaze readers and motivate new adaptations, such as the one that filmmaker Christopher Nolan is about to premiere, almost three thousand years after its conception?


1.
A foundational and enigmatic text
"Homer is the great child poet. The world is born and Homer sings it. He is the bird of that dawn". These words by Victor Weber in the first chapter of his essay William Shakespeare (1864) serve to illustrate the foundational element of the Odyssey. Composed and recited orally since the 9th century BC and fixed in writing during the 8th century BC, it is one of the first epic poems in the Western literary canon. Divided into 24 cantos and comprising more than 12,000 hexameters, it has been praised by writers as diverse as Dante Alighieri, Ernest Hemingway, James Joyce –who offered a very personal reinterpretation in Ulysses–, Mercè Rodoreda, Jorge Luis Borges, and Margaret Atwood. "Whether the Odyssey is Homer's work or not adds a mist of mystery that seems secondary to me. What is important is that we have two great poems attributed to this name", comments Roger Aluja.


In the essay The Scar of Ulysses, included in Mimesis (1946) and recently recovered by Acantilado in Spanish, Erich Auerbach (1892-1957) praised "the joy of sensory existence that becomes present" when reading the Odyssey: "We don't care to know if it's a legend, if it's all lies – he adds–. Homer doesn't need to insist on the historical truth of his narrative, his reality is solid enough. Homer seduces us, traps us in the reality he describes, and that's enough for him. In that real world, which exists in itself, and to which we as readers have been brought as if by magic, there is nothing else. The Homeric poems hide nothing, they contain no teaching or secret second meaning".


Cargando
2.
Resonates in the past of any reader
Classics can be fascinating on a personal level – and end up in the "unforgettable" books drawer – or blend into the collective unconscious, as Italo Calvino recalled in Why Read the Classics (1981; in Catalan at Edicions 62). Youthful readings are so important, for Calvino, that he recommends rereading them at least once in a lifetime. “As we grow older, we change and our encounter with texts is totally different,” he writes: every rereading of a classic is, in reality, a reading as initiatory and surprising as the first.The love for Pau Sabaté and Roger Aluja's Odyssey


began in adolescence and has been transforming. "The first time I read it, I was 15 years old – Sabaté recalls. We had the second translation by Carles Riba at home [published between 1947 and 1948]. It amazed me. When you overcome the barrier of the splendid language it uses, it becomes very seductive and interesting." Homer influenced Sabaté in his decision to study Greek and, later, classical philology at the University of Barcelona (UB). In 2019, he inaugurated the lavish Bernat Metge Universal collection with his translation of the Iliad, and six years later he repeats with the Odyssey. His editor, Roger Aluja, was also captivated by the same book as Sabaté when he was in high school. "My research project consisted of comparing various versions of the sixth canto – he explains. Riba's, which was the first I read, but also the one in prose by Joan Alberich [La Magrana, 1998], and a couple or three in Spanish." When he was studying classical philology at the UB, Aluja coincided in the classroom with the Hellenist Jaume Pòrtulas: "He is one of the foremost specialists in the world in Homeric poetry. Professor Pòrtulas ended up directing my doctoral thesis, which is an aesthetic commentary on the eleventh canto of the Odyssey".


Pau Sabaté and Roger Aluja, translator and editor of Homer's 'Odyssey', during the interview at Casa Abacus, on Peu de la Creu street in Barcelona.XAVIER BERTRAL
Cargando
3.
It goes beyond being an adventure book
"TheOdyssey" is a book of travels, without travels –assures Dolors Miquel in the epilogue of the new edition of the Bernat Metge Universal–. A tale that a shepherd or a peasant would tell by a fire or on a summer evening. Or someone from distant lands. It would seem that the author is telling us that the only great and possible journey is that of the logos, that the most penetrating Odyssey of all is that of the imagination."


It is Odysseus himself who, transformed within the work into an aede –a term that designated Greek rhapsode poets–, is in charge of narrating his adventures, among which are the deception of the cyclops Polyphemus, the song of the Sirens –who have the head of a woman and the body of a bird–, the sacrifice of the Sun's cows, and his relationships with Nausicaa, Circe, and Calypso. "Although Calypso offers him immortality if he stays with her on the island where she lives, Odysseus prefers to return to Ithaca to reunite with Penelope and his son Telemachus –says Sabaté–. At first glance, the most striking and attractive part of the Odyssey is the adventures, but the cantos that take place in Ithaca are fundamental. For the adult reader, perhaps they are even more interesting." In relation to highlighting the adventures in the epic poem, Carles Riba considered it, in the prologue to his second translation, an attempt to bring the classic "to the marketplace," and added: "To snatch the Odyssey" from the monopoly of more or less learned Hellenists, all right; but as much as delivering it to the insensitivity and banality of mere novel devourers [...] it is difficult to resign oneself to it".


4.
Allows rediscovering a different hero
Odysseus represents "a type of heroism different from that of Achilles, the great protagonist of the Iliad", says Aluja. He shares with Achilles skill on the battlefield, but unlike him, "he does not give up other war tactics, such as ambushes, camouflage, or the use of the bow, which for warriors of strength is the weapon of cowards".


Cargando
"Odysseus is a master of dissimulation and deception", comments Sabaté. The fact that he is a man "of great cunning" –according to Riba–, "of a thousand faces" –in the translation by Joan F. Mira in 2011 for Proa– or "very versatile" –in Sabaté's version– allows him to overcome all obstacles, human and divine, during the ten years that separate him from the end of the Trojan War and his arrival in Ithaca. "When he wakes up on the beach of Ithaca, Athena [or Athena], his protector, transforms him into a miserable beggar, so that he remains unnoticed by everyone, friends and enemies alike –writes Jaume Pòrtulas in the prologue to the latest reissue of the Odyssey translated by Carles Riba in the Bernat Metge Essencial in 2019–. Finally, already at home and among his own, the man who had been [...] No one will manage to recover, thanks to a series of measured and successive recognitions, the different facets of his personal and social self. He thus returns to the fullness of himself. We could say that he rebuilds himself: he rebuilds himself as the father of Telemachus, as the husband of Penelope, as the son of Laertes, and also as the king of Ithaca".


Detail of Odysseus's route map that leads him from Troy to Ithaca, included in the Proa edition of the book.Proa
5.
The excellence of Catalan translations
There are three versions of the Odyssey by Carles Riba: between the first, published by Editorial Catalana in 1919, and the last, by Alpha – from the Col·lecció Bernat Metge – in 1953, more than three decades passed. "The mark it has left on contemporary Catalan literature has been important, although perhaps more in the realm of poets, translators, and other writers than for the average reader," admits Jaume Pòrtulas. When Joan F. Mira published his Odyssey in 2011 with Proa, he aimed "not to embellish the text, nor to try to improve it, nor to pretend to make it more poetic and more elevated". Like Riba and Sabaté, but unlike Joan Alberich's version, he translated it in verse. "Translating Homer in prose is entirely respectable, but it can never be read, perceived, or felt like a translation in verse – Mira argued at the time –. Never, in any way. And translating Homer in verse means, if it is materially possible (in some languages it certainly is not), reproducing the hexameters of the original".


Cargando
Pau Sabaté has wanted to follow "Riba's path": "I have tried to capture the passion for genuineness. Riba is sometimes even colloquial. He also has the aspiration to be very literal, to convey the strangeness of the original Greek text, which sometimes seems like an incantation. I have tried not to emphasize this point". The translator has avoided "modernizing the language of the Odyssey to the extreme". The reader interested in a sound prose version – made from the English adaptation by Samuel Butler, author of Erewhon, in 1900 – can turn to the recent edition by Blackie Books, which features the translation by Xavier Pàmies.


6.
A poem full of women that announces patriarchy
As Dolors Miquel points out in her epilogue, the Dolors Miquel points out in her epilogue, the Odyssey opens and closes with the goddess Athena. Throughout the poem, women have "a more relevant role than in the Iliad", says Aluja. "Although Calypso wants to keep Odysseus on the island, she eventually lets him go, and it is Circe who explains all the obstacles he must overcome to reach Ithaca — she adds—. Penelope awaits him there, who has managed to postpone the decision to choose a suitor with the cunning of undoing at night what she weaves during the day. Until the work is finished, she will not remarry." Miquel explains that beneath this female presence beats "the beginning of a phallocentric truth obsessed with hiding what is mysterious, what is feminine, uterine and unique". She recalls that Greek thought, appealing to the philosopher and psychoanalyst Luce Irigaray, transmits a "world that man has constructed to supplant adhesion to the maternal world, to assert himself against the mother, against participation in her world". In the Odyssey


7.
It will allow you to go down to hell and come back
In addition to proposing a journey through various Greek islands and allowing the reader to learn about their fauna, the Odyssey is a poem rich in mentions of trees and plants. "The names of animals and plants are always a thorny issue when translating ancient literature –comments Pau Sabaté–. The flora and fauna of the eastern Mediterranean, even if not radically different from ours, do not entirely correspond to that of the western shores either. A second problem is that the temporal distance and the limited nature of the sources have made certain denominations confusing." Wracking his brains, Sabaté has reached the conclusion that the "double thicket" under which Ulysses shelters on the island of the Phaeacians is formed by a part of olive tree and another that, instead of being broom or wild olive, must be oleaster. "A wild olive and an olive tree growing together do not quite make a "}double thicket" –he adds–. The usual cultivation technique for olive trees was to graft them onto oleasters to make them fruit faster.


Cargando
One of the riskiest adventures posed by the epic poem is the journey to Hades, the name by which hell was known in ancient Greece. "Odysseus goes there twice. The first time is explained in the eleventh canto, and among the most memorable passages is the reunion with Achilles, the hero of the Iliad", recalls the translator. Achilles laments having had to pay the price of death to achieve glory among the living: "Do not try to console me about death, Odysseus, do not comfort me! / I would much rather earn a day's wage on earth / by hiring myself out to a man without inheritance or much to live on / than be the king of all the dead, of those who have finished." Odysseus learns his lesson and ends up returning home."
Jordi Nopca
12/06/2026
https://en.ara.cat/culture/7-reasons-to-read-the-odyssey_130_5767086.amp.html
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

How Soviet prisons spread a secret 'language of thieves' now spoken by millions

"How Soviet prisons spread a secret 'language of thieves' now spoken by millions


The tricks of the jail jargon Fenya were once used to bewilder guards in Stalin's Gulags. Now they are being used by Russian cyber-criminals.


When would you hide in a raspberry? Why don't you want to be a sixer? And what does it mean to go to the akademiya?


Russian often takes slang to complex levels, such as through Mat, its linguistic system for obscenities. But even a "matershchinnik" (a well-practiced master of swearing) might find the above phrases nonsensical – unless, of course, they are familiar with Fenya, the language of Russia's colossal prison system.


This language of criminals has been deployed by underworld figures for centuries to puzzle and evade. But during the 20th Century, its curious mixture of double entendre and loan words ballooned in Soviet prisons.


With German, Greek and Yiddish influences, Fenya is brimming with confusing hidden meanings. In Russian, "babki" literally means "grandmas", but in Fenya, it also means "money". "Varezhka" means a "mitten" but also a "mouth, while "khalyava", derived from the Hebrew for "milk", is a "freebie" or "giveaway".


A single word in Fenya can contain hidden codes known only to speakers of the slang. And just as it once bewildered prison camp guards, its language tricks are now being being used online, obscuring the intent of cyber-criminals and confusing authorities.


For instance, while the Russian words мусор or musor normally translate to "trash", its Fenya equivalent today means a cop who may have infiltrated the dark-web forums where cyber-attacks are organised.


With Russian cyber-crime booming, investigators must now familiarise themselves with this jargon if they want to get the drop on perpetrators. Even with advances in artificial intelligence, though, machines can struggle to pick up Fenya's constantly evolving nuances.


So how did we get here? While Fenya was muttered on the streets of Tsarist Russia for centuries, it was a series of decisions taken by the Soviet justice system that resulted in its explosion into the mainstream – and ultimately onto the internet too.


Clandestine beginnings
Broadly speaking, Fenya is a type of cryptolect – a camouflaged language often used to confuse others. Today, it has burrowed into broader Russian culture to the degree that some may be unaware of words' original ties to the underworld.


Fenya's origins are shrouded in mystery. One intriguing (though disputed) theory suggests it began with nomadic salesmen called Ofeni who travelled on foot across Russia selling religious knick-knacks. A 17th-Century church schism, the theory goes, declared their wares items heretical, so wayfaring merchants adopted their own unique modes of speech.


Fuel Russian Criminal Tattoo Archive
The king of clubs was known as "St Nicholas" in fenya, while "to hold a suit" means having authority over a community of thieves (Credit: Fuel Russian Criminal Tattoo Archive)


More is known about how Fenya spread. The vocabulary is thought to have started expanding in the 19th Century, writes Mark Galeotti, an expert in modern Russia, intelligence consultant and honorary professor at University College London, in his 2018 book The Vory: Russia's Super Mafia. It was then, he says, that street urchins and criminals started to place "fe" and "nye" sounds in the middle of words.


These particular tics, redolent of an underworld pig-Latin, were eventually dropped, writes Galeotti. But not before gangs of pickpockets and street scammers adopted Fenya. Initiations into their crews counted on a basic understanding of it. Words and phrases were documented at length in an 1863 dictionary of living Russian,which attempted to categorise Russian as it was lived and spoken.


In Fenya, hierarchies are expressed through card-game jargon, with suits and clubs symbolising bona fide thieves. Animals take on secret double-lives as objects, so speakers know that a monkey is a mirror and a fox is a folding-knife. Altogether, Fenya's vocabulary is thought to comprise between 10,000 and 27,000 words.


Among the intelligentsia of the late Tsarist period, the tantalising suggestion of a shadow criminal society fascinated literary figures and inspired so-called vagabond music – where performers sang in Fenya and romanticised slum life.


But it was the enormous social upheaval of wars and revolution to come that really cemented Fenya's rise.


Fenya's explosion
After winning the Russian civil war and creating the USSR in 1922, the Bolsheviks experimented with expanding the country's prison camps. In these forerunners to the notorious Gulag system, all sorts of people would mix with petty criminals – giving everyone from peasants to the intelligentsia a first-hand taste of Fenya.


Alamy
In Soviet Gulags, everyone from peasants to the intelligentsia mixed with petty criminals, giving them a first-hand taste of Fenya (Credit: Alamy)


When Stalin took power, millions more were incarcerated, leading the enigmatic vocabulary to spread among even more prisoners and become standardised among criminals, eventually evolving into a kind of prison-camp vocabulary with whole new terms.


"Language became a kind of communicative survival tool," says Martin Puchner, professor of English and comparative literature at Harvard University in the US, and author of The Language of Thieves: The Story of Rotwelsch and One Family's Secret History.


In the prisons, professional criminals formalised Fenya into the "vorovskoy zakon", or thieves' code, a Mafioso-style set of laws that signalled status: those familiar with its rules, and the commoners or "muzhik" (peasants) who would only ever be their marks.


Fenya and cyber-crime lingo are almost like a form of convergent evolution – Roman Sannikov
Meanwhile, Stalin attempted to crush criminality, along with anything he associated with it – like Fenya. As early as 1930, official Soviet magazines decried "thieves songs" as a dangerous affront to proletarian culture.


Popular artists reinvented themselves in more ideologically acceptable directions. The famous Soviet estrada singer Leonid Utesov – whose jaunty thieves' song From The Odessa Gaol was once a crowd-pleaser – began performing for the military instead, converting his style into what one historian called a "Soviet product cleansed of decadence".


Leaving the prisons
The days following Stalin's death in 1953 brought another twist to the tale of Fenya.


A mass amnesty of more than a million prisoners meant petty criminals left the Gulags in droves. They returned home, bringing Fenya with them. "Blatnaya pesnya" – thieves' songs – broke out in taverns across the country.


"[At this time] there was a sense that criminal culture was a folk culture, suppressed by the official party," says Svetlana Stephenson, professor of sociology at London Metropolitan University and author of Gangs of Russia: From the Streets to the Corridors of Power. "There was a flirtation with this world among the intelligentsia."


Cryptolects


Many other communities around the world have developed secret languages, or "cryptolects". Examples include:


• The Kali-worshipping Thuggees of India talked in Ramaseeana from the 1700s


• London's 1800s "demimonde" chittered in Flash, famously spoken by the Artful Dodger when he utters: "Hullo, my covey! What's the row?"


• In the 1900s, US carnival workers talked in Ciazarn, the secret language of "carnies", with some words still used in professional wrestling today


• During Brazil's military dictatorship, the travesti (a distinct LGBTQ community) created the Pajubá language, adopting Yoruba words into Portuguese, as protection from government persecution


• Before the UK decriminalised homosexuality in 1967, some gay men would use Polari to communicate in secret


• Some twins invent entirely new languages – spoken only by two


Attempts to suppress thieves' songs only boosted their popularity. As the USSR intensified its censorship, enterprising citizens bootlegged music, cutting cheap X-ray sheets into disc shapes with scissors and printing sounds on them using home-made lathes. Known as "jazz on bones", these were playable on gramophones. The burgeoning black market in these sheets allowed people to trade music from denounced Russian émigrés as well as record their own songs, which was otherwise impossible.


Home recordings of thieves' songs circulated widely. Later, with the advent of the cassette tape, the rowdy sounds of underground artists like Arkady Severny and emigrant singer Dina Vierny – with their bawdy tales of sex, robberies, violence and gulags – thundered through the USSR.


By the time the Soviet Union disintegrated in 1991, Fenya's folkloric status was cemented, despite the best efforts of the state. Yet speaking Fenya in polite society was still unthinkable.


At the turn of the millennium, however, it entered a surprising new era of acceptability. Russian political elites including Vladimir Putin began to use Fenya in their official communiques, says Larissa Ryazanova-Clarke, professor of Russian and sociolinguistics at the University of Edinburgh in the UK. This "period of linguistic turmoil" was due to the "landslide of the norm", she says, reflecting the dramatic changes of the time.


Officials probably used this language to lend them a populist appeal, says Stephenson, who has described the trend as "Kremlovskaya Fenya" – Kremlin Fenya. "I think it expresses the culture of violence, which has penetrated to the very top of Russian society," she says. Paradoxically, officials banned speaking Fenya in Russian prisons but continued to speak it themselves.


Obfuscating the web
​As Fenya burrowed into everyday language at the turn of the 21st Century, it also began to evolve in a new arena: the digital revolution.


In 1999 on the early Russian internet (or "RuNet"), a user on the FidoNet bulletin board published a "Manifesto of Anti-Literacy", writes academic Larisa Morkoborodova. This railed against "the so-called spelling correctness on the Net" and urged "all masters of the Russian word" to "challenge the killing of our live language by soulless automatons!".


Check Point Research
An apparently nonsense output from an automated translation tool of Fenya words (Credit: Check Point Research)
Their deliberate misspellings and punny inventions evolved into new slang known as padonki, also ironically named olbanian. Millions per month speak in padonki online, writes Morkoborodova, and it has seeped into broader society. It means many Russians are familiar with padonki – only a subset of them criminals. Still, its creative semantics can cause headaches for cyber investigators.


The lingo deliberately breaks Russian language conventions, emphasising double consonants and phonetically written words, with loanwords from English that deviate from their original meanings.


For example, Russian speakers might write "email" as "mylo" – literally "soap dish" – because at the dawn of digital culture in Russia there was simply no word for email, says Roman Sannikov, a cyber-security expert who's worked as a linguist for the FBI. The Russian word for soap dish sounded phonetically close enough. "If you're using machine translation, sometimes you'll get 'soap' instead of an 'email'," he adds.


With Cyrillic (Russian) keyboards rare at the time, some web users also deployed the numerical "4" as shorthand for a "ch" sound, because "four" is "chetyre" in Russian. 


"A lot of it came from English, because the words just did not exist in Russian," Sannikov says. "A hard drive was frequently called a 'winch', because many of them were branded 'Winchester'."


'Cyber-Fenya'
"Most of the people that created cyber-slang were kids or young people," says Sannikov – rather different from the Fenya-uttering vory (thieves) of the past.


So when Fenya words do crop up, says Fyodor Yarochkin, a researcher at the cyber security company Trend Micro, they might speak to a rarer sort of cross-pollination: traditional crooks who've entered the realm of white-collar cyber-criminals, perhaps to discuss more physical kinds of lawbreaking.


More like this:


• The lost medieval pronouns of English intimacy


• Listen to the lost languages of ancient stone-age humans


• What's the best way to learn a new language?


Or, having learned phrases from gangster movies, they might just be trying to impress their associates and look tough, he suggests, using Fenya as a status symbol or cultural signifier rather than evasion.


Still, when chat logs from the Russian cyber-crime gang Conti leaked in 2022, among the logistics, obscenities and general blather were words that can be traced back to Fenya.


Researchers at global cyber-security firm Check Point noted that some of the chat logs appeared impossible to understand, with machine translation failing when they said phrases to each other such as: "My soaps don't bathe. I've been warming them up for months." What the criminals were really talking about was avoiding email blacklists.


Forums for "initial access brokers" – the insider threats at organisations who open the doors to cyber-attackers – also often speak in a mixture of Fenya and Mat, helping to disguise what they're up to.


"Fenya and cyber-crime lingo are almost like a form of convergent evolution," says Sannikov – together forming an intricate semantic tapestry that's hard to unpick. You could call the jumble of online criminal lingo "cyber-Fenya", he adds.


This internet usage is just the latest example of how criminal argot continues to be diluted, changed and occasionally absorbed into Russian. And Fenya's reach today is ultimately thanks to Stalin and the Gulags, which turned it into one of the most widespread covert languages in the world.


Many of the prisoners there could have told you that a raspberry was a secret lair, a "sixer" was at the very bottom of the criminal hierarchy, and that the "akademiya", or prison, is where you never wanted to end up – though it certainly would have given you a good education in Fenya."
Tamlin Magee
Alamy
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20260611-fenya-how-cyber-criminals-adopted-russias-secret-language-of-thieves
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Lost in translation | Andy Owen

"Lost in translation
Attempting to understand the lives and thought of our ancestors can teach us about ourselves


Emily Wilson opens Crossing the Wine-Dark Sea: Journeys Through Ancient Literature with a quote from Louis MacNeice’s 1938 poem Autumn Journal, written in the looming shadow of the Second World War. Wilson highlights MacNeice’s meditations on the value of looking back to antiquity in such dark times — or, perhaps, at the futility of such an endeavour.


Crossing the Wine-Dark Sea: Journeys through Ancient Literature, Emily Wilson, Profile Books, £10.99
MacNeice’s poem contrasts the difference between viscerally imagining the ancient world, and teaching it within the constraints of the 1930s educational system, as well as contemplating the prejudices and idealisations through which we may view the past. Despite the unimaginable gap in time, Wilson believes there are elements of the ancient world that she can clearly imagine. How a translator can bring alive this tension between the strangeness of the complex human beings and alien cultural practices from millennia ago and their strange familiarity is the core question that runs through her book. Is it possible to do so without projecting ideas from our time and place, and even the translator’s own personal experience? Can their words be brought back to life in a new language — or must the dead stay dead?


The book is a collection of Wilson’s essays she has unwoven and re-weaved, before stitching together as a coherent whole, so each chapter that explores a different aspect of ancient literature and culture and its journey into the present, adds to our understanding of the translator’s challenges. The chapters include a skewering of the modern “watered-down form” of Stoicism (it is a spiritual path for people who want to hold on to their sense of self and their own power: a fancy, rationalised form of egoism), a reminder of the invective and eroticism of Catullus, the fight over ownership of fragments of Sappho and fascinating essays on the comedies of Aristophanes and Terence, and the tragedies of Aeschylus and Euripides. Wilson also traces how Ancient Greek and Roman literature assumed its revered place in Western culture (in the US, Wilson claims this is in large part down to the work of Edith Hamiliton, whose stylistic “highly Americanised, vaguely Christianised” translations remain popular almost one hundred years after first being published and contribute to the belief in the continuity of a Western cultural superiority from Greece to modern-day America).


The last, longest essay, is the most fascinating. Wilson compares single phrases from the Odyssey across several translations. The different choices of not just words and phrases, but style and structure, each translator makes, shows the rich variety of options translators have. Wilson believes it is important to also translate the musical rhythms of ancient metrical verse. Many modern translations ignore this challenge and translate into English free verse or prose (Wilson’s version uses iambic pentameter). Wilson feels that by failing to do so you do not convey the artfulness of the originals, which is a major component of their strangeness for the modern reader. In both this book and her translations Wilson makes a strong case for this to be so. Through sharing the anguished and long debate Wilson had with herself in how to translate a single Greek word — polytropos — she draws back the veil on how a brilliant scholar approaches her work. After many twists and turns Wilson translates it as “complicated.” Others have used “man of many ways” (Richmond Lattimore), “that man skilled in all ways of contending” (Robert Fitzgerald), “man of many twists and turns” (Robert Fagles), and “resourceful man” (E. V. Rieu). Wilson describes the process that took “many hours, days and weeks” to eliminate countless other options before landing on “complicated” for a combination of syntactical and semantical reasons (from the number of syllables to liking the concept of complexity as a positive quality in the world of the poem).


Wilson states that the, “juxtaposition of ancient and modern languages, literatures and lives reminds us that it is through our words that we are remembered and understood, long after our deaths, and that even the most minute differences of language or phrasing may make all the difference.” With the increasing use of artificial intelligence applications and models to craft communications, this is a timely point to make. Many are now speaking through translators, when they outline the gist of what they want to say leaving technology to select specific words. Wilson’s explanation of her choice of “complicated” is an insight into the thought processes involved in translating and a reminder of the importance of what we are relinquishing to technology. It is also a justification for her deeply thought out choice.


Wilson’s 2017 translation of the Odyssey was the first by a woman into English. Inevitably, as the first woman, some critics argued that her approach at times distorted the original text by overlaying modern feminist ideas that would have been alien to those in Homer’s time. Her choice of “complicated” was the focus of some of that criticism. Supporters praised her for removing archaic, “imported” misogyny and challenging established interpretations. Wilson recognises that, “Language is never a neutral tool by which we represent the world: every word and phrase carries with it a tangle of cultural assumptions and connotations.” If Wilson is guilty of overlaying modern ideas, have not all previous translators been guilty of similar?


George Chapman, the first man to complete a full translation of the Odyssey and Iliad into English (published together in 1616 after decades of working on them), claimed that he was visited by the ghost of Homer. This, he believed, gave him unique insight into the poet’s true intentions. More believably, his interpretation of Homer would have been influenced by the philosophical currents of the Elizabethan Golden Age. In the introduction to her translation Wilson notes that Chapman transformed Odysseus into “a true soldier and a gentleman, a proto-Christian and a proto-Stoic, whose greatest virtue is his ability to endure suffering”. In translating the Greek into English, he translated Odysseus’ characteristics into those of a hero of his day. Whole passages of Aristophanes and Catullus were omitted by prudish Victorian translators, due to the moralities of their era.


In the same introduction Wilson announces that, “I try to avoid importing contemporary types of sexism into this ancient poem, instead shining a light on the particular forms of sexism and patriarchy that do exist in the text, which are only partly familiar from our world.” Wilson discusses the scene where Telemachus hangs the slaves (others have translated dmōai less literally as “maids” or “maidservants” which subtly suggests they would have had more agency in an elite household of that time than they would have). Most translations introduce derogatory language that suggests these women are justifiably punished due to their sexual digressions, yet original Greek does not contain such language. Their punishment is as likely motivated by wider dynamics of honour and the loss of face caused by the suitors’ breaches of etiquettes of hospitality (xenia) as for their promiscuity.


Wilson is not the first to challenge the orthodoxy of established translations or to use comparative analysis across multiple translations of Homer to do so. Argentinian writer Jorge Luis Borges in 1932’s The Homeric Versions conducted a similar exercise. The heart of the essay is a close reading of a single passage of the conversation between Odysseus and Achilles’ ghost, about his son Neoptolemus, across six English translations; “Buckley (literal prose), Butcher & Lang (literal but archaicizing), Cowper (1791, Miltonic blank verse), Pope (1725, heroic couplets with lavish amplification), Chapman (1614, vigorous and idiosyncratic), and Butler (1900, ironic bourgeois prose).”


Borges treats them as equally legitimate “perspectives on a mutable fact”. He asks and answers, “Which of these many translations is faithful? my reader will want to know. I repeat: none or all of them.” For Borges there is no “definitive text”: the concept corresponds only to “religion or exhaustion.” He argues that every text, including Homer’s, is mutable; what we take to be fixed and sacred is merely the product of familiarity and habit. He goes further and claims that translations are not inherently inferior to originals. A good text seems invariable only because we have read it many times; we mistake repetition for necessity. In his 1936 essay The Translators of The Thousand and One Nights, he declared: “The original is unfaithful to the translation.”


In The Homeric Versions, Borges discusses the famous 1861–62 exchange between Francis Newman (who advocated literal translation) and Matthew Arnold (who advocated eliminating distracting details in favour of Homer’s essential qualities: syntactical simplicity, flowing rapidity, and loftiness). Borges argues that both positions are valid. Wilson has also engaged with this debate on several occasions. Whilst acknowledging Arnold’s snobbery towards “poor Newman”, she has described his translation as unreadable, and in conversation about her Iliad translation, stated that she feels, “fairly directly inspired by Matthew Arnold’s discussion of what a Homeric translation should aim for — rapidity, plainness of thought and diction, and nobility.” Today, the debate is also between those who believe a good translator should be invisible, creating work as easily accessible as if it was not originally in a different language, and those who believe a translation should embody the strangeness of the original language and culture, not disguise it. The latter believing the former “colonises” texts into English creating a false kind of homogeneity. Wilson believes that the creation of a more reader-friendly translation does not necessarily imply a desire to appropriate or “colonise” the foreign original, but wants the shock and surprise of a foreign text to be preserved as much as possible. 


In life sometimes literal translations are essential. In his translation of the Odyssey, Alexander Pope interprets Odysseus’ single black ship as a fleet. In Afghanistan, the interpreters I worked with needed to be more precise in the numbers of foreign fighters or IEDs on the road ahead. Errors in basic vocabulary could lead to the targeting of a wedding party over Taliban jirga. The coalition used service personnel who had often only been through less than a year’s worth of language training for the roles that required access to sensitive conversations, and for many other roles hired urban, Dari-speakers from the north to serve as interpreters in the rural, Pashtun-dominated south. The former would not be able to untangle the cultural assumptions and connotations and communicate past the words to the meaning of what each was trying to say. The latter often possessed marginal English skills and would fail to do the same in the reverse direction. Consequently, conversations between politicians, leaders, soldiers and elders were reduced to a dialogue conducted on the level of children pointing and naming when trying to navigate sensitive and complex cultural issues.


A tragicomic example was provided during the 2006 siege of Musa Qala in Helmand Province. British forces were using an interpreter who had been raised in Birmingham, UK. The local soldiers working alongside the British suspected that he was adding his own words and interpretations to the dialogue between them. Concern over mistranslations escalated into a physical confrontation, with the local soldiers chasing the interpreter around the compound. A British officer had to draw his pistol to stop the chase. In Afghanistan, at times the gulf between allies and enemies; between Western notions of democracy, liberalism and individualism and those of tribal loyalty and the values of the Pashtunwali honour code, felt as vast as that between the modern West and Homer’s Greece. We did not have interpreters with the depth of knowledge, eloquence and intellectual rigour as Wilson and her fellow translators of Homer. Even if we did, would we have understood the heroic code of the Pashtunwali as well as Odysseus might have?


Borges shows us that the reader is also complicit in the act of constant reinterpretation. In his 1939’s Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote, Menard sets out to immerse himself so thoroughly in Cervantes’ masterpiece, Don Quixote, that he can spontaneously “re-create” it, word for word, in the original seventeenth-century Spanish. (Initially, he considers achieving this by becoming Cervantes through learning Spanish, returning to the Catholic faith, fighting against the Moors, and forgetting the history of Europe 1602-1918. He ultimately rejects this approach as too easy). At the time of his death, Menard had successfully produced the ninth and thirty-eighth chapters of the first part of Don Quixote, along with a fragment of chapter twenty-two. The narrator compares a passage from Cervantes’s text with the identical passage from Menard’s text. Despite the words being exactly the same, the narrator argues that Menard’s version is infinitely richer, more subtle, and more complex because it was written by a modern man with the weight of three centuries of history behind him. Menard’s achievement is not that he wrote the same book again but that he wrote another book.


Anticipating post-structuralism, Borges implies that the meaning of literary works depends on the historical and social contexts in which they are read. The act of reading becomes the primary site of meaning creation. Each generation rewrites the classics by reading them through the lens of their own contemporary experiences as much as each translator does. We did not arrive in Afghanistan as blank slates, but as the products of a civilisation that traced itself back to Ancient Greece on a mission to convert those we found there to the pinnacle of a superior culture and way of being: western liberal democracy. Unable to think outside of our own paradigm, we could not understand that even if we could deliver what we were claiming we were going to (without the resolve and resources to do so) it was what few wanted. Afghanistan was not a military failure; it was a failure of translation. 


These ancient texts can help us to see the air we breathe and the water in which we swim


In the challenge, though, there is also opportunity. Wilson claims that it can be as difficult for us to see the cultural assumptions of our own time as for a bird to see air, or fish water. Yet, these ancient texts can help us to see the air we breathe and the water in which we swim. Reading translations of both past and present foreign works can help us see that some of what is normal to us is alien to others. They can give us a sense that another way of being is possible. The evidence of this can be found in the smallest nuance of one translated word in the changing layers of translations over time. As Wilson states “it is more valuable than ever to remember that the world has not always been as it is now.” We are living through a time of social, geopolitical and technological transition.


MacNeice’s Autumn Journal is both a panorama of his era — capturing the anxieties of the Munich crisis, the Spanish Civil War and the looming shadow of another global conflict, as well as the disintegration of his personal life — and a situating of his time against the people and thinkers of the past. As MacNeice did in his time of uncertainty, we should meditate on the flux of the present, the fleeting moment between past and future, and try to imagine ourselves amongst those so unimaginably different yet strangely familiar. Their anxieties were not our anxieties, but also not wholly different. We cannot simply mirror their solutions but understanding them may help open us up to the possibilities of our complicated times, and knowing that they endured should give us comfort that we may too.


Wilson’s book is a timely reminder that that selection of words and phrases is key to the richness of human interaction and explaining what we really mean. We may not ever be able to fully understand the dead, but in trying to do so we may understand ourselves a little better."
Artillery Row 8 June, 2026
Andy Owen
https://thecritic.co.uk/lost-in-translation-2/
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Subs, dubs, and AI flubs: Lost in film translation

"Subs, dubs, and AI flubs: Lost in film translation
Culture


When I travel, I like to think I am not like the other British tourists. I try my best to blend in with the locals – attempting (and sometimes failing) to remain nonchalant on complicated metro systems, eating local cuisine, and avoiding ‘loud’ clothing. On a recent solo trip to Stockholm, however, my expectations were challenged by what I believed to be a given: English. I had been to Italy, where English captions accompany pretty much everything, and France, where the same is true, though it is offered with more reluctance. In my ignorance, I had not bothered to learn any Swedish beyond a measly ‘engelska?’, which became problematic as I quickly discovered that my bleached-blonde hair made me look like a Scandi girl to the locals.


I should experience some local culture, immerse myself in the arts scene, I thought as I settled into my hotel. Checking the programme of the capital’s Kulturhuset Stadsteatern, or ‘city theatre’, the single showing with English subtitles was the Austrian film How to Be Normal and the Oddness of the Other World, directed by Florian Pochlatko. Sure, it wasn’t Swedish at all, but how else would I understand the story, if it wasn’t for English subtitles? As I hurriedly approached the Kulturhuset, one Ryanair flight and a frenzy through the Stockholm metro behind me, I was suddenly informed that there would be no subtitles at all.


How hard could it be to watch an entire film in German when I could not even introduce myself in the language? Quite hard, it turns out. Sure, body language and visual effects went a long way, and I felt the beautiful serendipity of discovering a Swedish review on Letterboxd from a local at the same screening, but I missed almost every joke, and felt myself growing increasingly bored as the film progressed. The biggest surprise for me in Stockholm was just how English-less it was, from road signs to price tags to food labels – I had to open Google Translate in the middle of 7/11 to work out if I could eat my halloumi wrap cold.


I do not expect sympathy at all, as my own ignorance led to this situation. But the experience did make me reflect on the relationship between native English speakers and subtitling in film. My not-so-Swedish encounter was certainly extreme, with no subtitles, or even a warning, beforehand – but I was not so turned off by the experience so as to never do it again. It made me wonder, are sole English speakers reliant on subtitles? Do they add or detract from the viewing experience?


Subtitles themselves are in many ways crucial, so that we may broaden our tastes and learn about other cultures. After accepting the Golden Globe for Best Foreign Language Film in 2020, Parasite director Bong Joon Ho famously stated that “once you overcome the one-inch-tall barrier of subtitles, you will be introduced to so many more amazing films”. I do believe that progress is already well underway in the globalisation of film, as what was once potentially a pursuit of only the avant-garde film student is now available to the masses. This is particularly thanks to the rise of Letterboxd, where international arthouse cinema is compiled into digestible lists.


The art of translating subtitles is also, perhaps surprisingly, one of the few language-based jobs not being ravaged by advancements in AI. Despite the now infamous case of Duolingo replacing much of its staff with AI, translator vacancies continue to grow, owing to the simple fact that AI is not currently capable of the quality control and idiomatic knowledge possessed by a human. Have you ever tried to translate complicated Swedish halloumi wrap instructions with Google Translate? In regard to film, it is vital that translated subtitles do actually convey the meaning of the scene, which is why the role of humans is still absolutely necessary.


Yet, anxieties concerning AI continue to plague the translation industry, and may result in changes to subtitling in the future. Hollywood actresses Demi Moore and Reese Witherspoon have both come out in favour of AI, with the latter even stating that “it’s so, so important that women are involved in AI because it will be the future of filmmaking”. AI tools continue to improve, and it is difficult to predict the accuracy of both Witherspoon’s statement and the concerns felt by translators, but the reality is that AI usage is already commonplace in filmmaking, from editing to script-writing and more. AI dubbing is also prevalent, with new software able to move actors’ mouths to fit speech in other languages. Controversy arose last year when generative AI was found to have been used to translate speech from English to Hungarian in The Brutalist – I, for one, am pleased that the Academy has since cracked down on AI-generated content in film, but I do worry about the future opportunities for translators in film, as well as for actors who do actually speak foreign languages.


While it is easier than ever to watch films entirely in English, are we missing something by neglecting their original languages? I think that it is important to note that my choice of film in Stockholm was heavily influenced by which ones had English subtitles listed as available. I do not think that cinemas in other countries should bow down to the English language at all, but English speakers may be surprised to realise just how much they can understand without subtitles, and how thought-provoking the result may be. Maybe if I had the guts for it at the time, I would have complemented my Swedish journey with a piece of local culture, and learned something beyond ‘engelska’.


Far from wanting to sound pretentious, I want you to understand that subtitles – both their existence and a lack of them – do not have to be a barrier to a good cinematic experience. It could be fun, even enriching, to actively try to watch film in a different way, such as by watching a colour film in black and white, or without sound. It almost feels like a reinvention of the creativity that comes with watching a silent film in the present day, where a chosen musical accompaniment can completely change our perspective. Watching Murnau’s silent Nosferatu on Wikipedia (yes, you can do that) was a very different experience from, say, the live organ accompaniment to the Oxford Festival of the Arts’ screening of The Cabinet of Dr Caligari at Magdalen Chapel.


There may be limits to this approach, however. Maybe the screenplay of How to Be Normal and the Oddness of the Other World did a lot of heavy lifting, with psychedelic visuals conveying the psychological focus of the film – although the Ed Sheeran poster on main character Pia’s wall completely threw me off, and made me worry more about the state of British cultural exports than her deteriorating mental condition. Ginger singers aside, my point still stands that even without subtitles, foreign-language films can be thoroughly enjoyed."
By
Emma Heagney
26th May 2026
https://cherwell.org/2026/05/26/subs-dubs-and-ai-flubs-lost-in-film-translation/
#metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

'Politically Urgent, Humanely Thought-provoking:' Furthering Translation Projects Around the World

Expanding the reach of global literature through translation, a grant program and a literary award are open for submissions. 

"Translation is an incredibly important part of the global publishing industry. Two opportunities – a grant and an award – are currently open for submissions.


PEN Presents x SALT


 


PEN Presents is a grant program created by English PEN that seeks to expand the landscape of translated literature by supporting sample translations, funding the unpaid work of creating samples, and giving publishers in the UK access to titles from underrepresented languages and regions.


 


This year’s PEN Presents is a partnership between English PEN and the South Asian Literature in Translation project (SALT). The deadline for submissions for the next session of PEN x Salt are closing May 31, 2026.


 


The grant is open to translators anywhere in the world in any stage of their career who have written in any official or unofficial languages of South Asia; whose authors are citizens of a South Asian country; resident in South Asia or of south Asian heritage; and for work of any form, genre, style and era. The work must also not have an English translation published in any territory.


 


A shortlist of 24 applicants will receive grants of £500 to create 5,000-word sample translations of their proposed works, with a final selection of 12 samples.


 


In April, the last round of winners was announced.


 


“These projects brought together an expert panel and gave them the delightful challenge of selecting winners from numerous brilliant projects across a range of languages, many of which are hugely underrepresented in English translation,” said Preti Taneja, English PEN Translation Advisory co-chair.


 


“The writing we present here has great potential to open readers’ minds to the richness of South Asian storytelling, poetry and nonfiction. This is politically urgent, humanely thought-provoking, lyrical, and even profoundly humorous work. Agents and editors now have the wonderful task of taking these samples forward to full publication, and I could not be more excited to see what comes next for these works, their authors and their translators.”


 


For more information on the program or submission guidelines, visit the website here


 


Sheikh Zayed Book Award


 


Earlier this year, one of the most prestigious literary awards in the Arab world celebrated its 20th anniversary.


 


The Sheikh Zayed Book Award, which is organized by the Abu Dhabi Arabic Language Centre (ALC) under the auspices of the Department of Culture and Tourism – Abu Dhabi (DCT Abu Dhabi), looks to further Arabic literature and culture around the world.


 


Since its founding, the award has received more than 33,000 submissions and honored 144 laureates. The Translation Grant, which was founded in 2018, has also supported the translation of over 48 titles into 12 languages.


 


The 21st submission cycle marks a defining milestone as the Sheikh Zayed Book Award enters its third decade and continues to play a pivotal role in advancing the global reception of Arab culture.


 


The Award includes ten categories, five of which are open to non-Arabic books – Arabic Culture in Other Languages; Translation; Publishing and Technology; Manuscripts, Encyclopedia, and the Lexicon; and the Cultural Personality of the Year.


 


“Marking twenty years of the Sheikh Zayed Book Award is not only a moment to reflect on its legacy, but also an opportunity to look ahead to its next chapter. As the Award enters its third decade, we invite authors, scholars, translators and publishers from around the world to contribute to a renewed era of literary and intellectual excellence,” said His Excellency Dr Ali Bin Tamim, Secretary-General of the SZBA and Chairman of the ALC.


 


“Through its international reach, the Award continues to serve as a global platform for distinguished voices across generations, strengthening the presence of Arabic literature and culture on the world stage.”"


By Erin L. Cox, Publisher | @erinlcox


https://publishingperspectives.com/2026/05/politically-urgent-humanely-thought-provoking-furthering-translation-projects-around-the-world/


#metaglossia 


#metaglossia_mundus 

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

How An Eye Physician Who Translated Classical Greek Medicine Into Arabic Helped Form Western Medical Though

"By Eurasia Review


A medieval ophthalmologist who translated Greek works by Galen, Hippocrates, and Plato into Arabic played a pivotal role in shaping Western medical scholarship, according to a recent study published in the journal Cogent Arts and Humanities.


x


In the study, authors affiliated with the University of Sharjah transcribe and translate into English the Arabic text of an original manuscript by Hunayn ibn Ishaq titled In the Eye, Two Hundred and Seven Issues. The ninth-century treatise is an innovative work in ophthalmology that corrected medieval misconceptions and significantly influenced the development of medical knowledge.


Written in a question-and-answer format, the treatise supplements ten other original essays by Hunayn that together are regarded as a landmark in both Islamic and Western medical history. In these works, he provides detailed analyses of eye anatomy, including the layers of the eye and the optic nerves, demonstrating the advances that made lasting contributions to Arabic and Western medicine alike.


“In the field of ophthalmology, Hunayn ibn Ishaq demonstrated his scientific prowess, providing evidence-based explanations and proving that disagreements about the number of eye layers were merely terminological and not substantive,” said the study’s lead author Dalal H. Al-Zubi, a doctoral candidate. “He clarified that the eye consists of seven layers, with only one responsible for vision, while the others support its function.” Hunayn also meticulously described the role of each layer, including its starting and ending points.


The study further highlights Hunayn’s explanation of the muscles controlling eye movement, noting his clarification that the brain governs these muscles via the nerve connecting it to the eye. His work ‘In the Eye, Two Hundred and Seven Issues’ provides clear evidence of the distinctiveness of his methodology in this field,” added Al-Zubi.


Enduring influence
Beyond his medical contributions, the study emphasizes Hunayn’s influence as a translator. As Al-Zubi notes, he enriched the Arabic language by introducing precise medical terminology, including terms for the retina and cornea. Rather than relying on literal translation, Hunayn employed descriptive and analogous renderings and metaphors, producing Arabized terms that conveyed meaning while remaining linguistically natural in Arabic.



A Syriac Christian polymath and member of the then prosperous and far-reaching Church of the East, Hunayn (known in the West as Johannitius) earned the epithet “Sheikh of the Translators.” He played a pivotal role as both a scholar and translator at the House of Wisdom in Baghdad. His translations, often based on original Syriac and Greek manuscripts, were instrumental in preserving Greek scientific knowledge and later transmitting it to Europe.


The study examines Hunayn’s contributions to advancing the translation movement during the early Abbasid period, highlighting how he pioneered the translation paradigm that prioritized rendering the full meaning of the source text rather than adhering to the prevailing practice of word-for-word translation.



While this research marks the first time Hunayn’s Arabic manuscript In the Eye, Two Hundred and Seven Issues, has been translated into English, several of his treatises had earlier reached the West through Latin and other European translations. “Hunayn ibn Ishaq’s writings or translations were largely recognized in the West and were translated into Latin or other European languages. In fact, the medical advances brought about by the publication of Ishaq’s treatises on ophthalmology were significant,” Al-Zubi explained.


The ophthalmologist and medical historian Max Meyerhof, for example, cites Hunayn’s Kitab al-Ashr Maqalat fil-Ayn (The Ten Treatises on the Eye), noting that it represents the earliest known systemic treatment of ophthalmology. Meyerhof mentions that the text was likely used in both Islamic and Western medical schools of the period.


The research further illustrates how Hunayn developed and refined his scientific expertise in medicine. The authors observe that he possessed exceptional mastery of the Arabic language and that his translations enriched scientific and medical nomenclature. “He frequently relied on metaphorical expression, as evidenced by the Arabic term ‘al-Ankabutiyya’ for the arachnoid, explaining that it refers to a spider’s web in the original source language from which the term was derived,” Al-Zubi stated.



She added, “In other instances, he Arabized foreign terms that had no equivalents in Arabic, as he did with al-Shabakiyya for the retina and al-Multahima for the conjunctiva. He was known for coining Arabic terms for their Greek counterparts that reflected an associative relationship between the signified and the signifier. This is particularly evident in his rendering of the retina into الشبكية al-Shabakiyya, chosen because its structure resembles a fisherman’s net, given the dense interweaving of veins and arteries intertwined within it, akin to a fishing net.”


Another reason for Hunayn’s mastery of translation, according to Al-Zubi, was his careful attention to the original coinage and semantic range of Greek terms. Many of his Arabic medical designations, still in use today, were deliberately crafted to align with denotations of the source language. A case in point is Herophilus’ term ‘Amphiblēsteroeidēs,’ a Latinized form derived from ancient Greek medical terminology describing the interwoven vessels of the retina, likened to the mesh of a hoisted fishing net.


A bridge between civilizations
Hunayn’s ophthalmological treatises attest to a level of scientific sophistication that was almost unrivaled in the Middle Ages. In their study, the authors credit him with “providing evidence-based explanations and proving that disagreements about the number of eye layers were merely terminological and not substantive.”



They note that Hunayn’s anatomical analysis identified which of the eye’s seven layers was responsible for vision. He also explained “the number of muscles controlling eye movement and clarified that the brain governs these muscles through the nerve connecting it to the eye. The findings in his manuscript In the Eye: Two Hundred and Seven Questions stand as a testament to the remarkable progress of ophthalmology during the early Abbasid era.”


Asked to assess Hunayn’s place in medical history, Maamoun Saleh Abdulkarim, professor of archaeology and history at the University of Sharjah, described him as a figure of lasting significance: “Hunayn ibn Ishaq significantly influenced the development of Western medicine. He played a crucial role in translating Greek medical texts into Arabic, particularly those of Galen and Hippocrates, refining and explaining them with remarkable scholarly precision.”



Prof. Abdulkarim, who is also among the study’s co-authors, added that “these Arabic translations later served as the foundation for Latin translations used in European universities during the Middle Ages. In this way, Hunayn ibn Ishaq functioned as a vital intellectual bridge between ancient Greek medicine and the medical science that later emerged in medieval European universities.”


In academic literature, Hunayn is widely regarded as a central figure in the transmission of ancient Greek medicine to the Islamic world and in the subsequent diffusion of this knowledge to Europe. As Mesut Idriz, professor of Islamic civilization at the University of Sharjah, has noted, “Hunayn ibn Ishaq’s translations and original writings exerted influence not only within the Islamic world but also in medieval Europe.”


Prof. Idriz, also one of the co-authors, pointed out that medical historians pay particular attention to Hunayn’s work titled al-Masāʾil fī al-Tibb(Questions on Medicine for Students), which was translated into Latin under the title Isagoge (Johannitius). “This text served for centuries as an introductory medical manual in European universities,” he said. “Its wide circulation in the Latin scholarly world illustrates the important role that Islamic medical scholarship played in shaping the foundations of medical education in medieval Europe.”


Prof. Abdulkarim likewise described al-Masāʾil fī al-Tibb as a seminal work, calling it “one of the earliest and most influential didactic texts in Islamic medical history, written in a unique question-and-answer format that shaped medical education for centuries.” He emphasized that Hunayn was “not merely a transmitter of Greek medicine; he was one of the most significant intellectual bridges connecting classical knowledge with medieval European medicine.”


Hunayn’s legacy, Prof. Abdulkarim concluded, is a reminder that scientific progress has historically arisen from dialogue between civilizations rather than from the achievement of any single culture. “It demonstrates that the history of medicine is not solely the narrative of one civilization,” he said, “but rather the story of knowledge traveling across cultures and shaping global science.”


Eurasia Review
Eurasia Review is an independent Journal that provides a venue for analysts and experts to publish content on a wide-range of subjects that are often overlooked or under-represented by Western dominated media.
https://www.eurasiareview.com/06042026-how-an-eye-physician-who-translated-classical-greek-medicine-into-arabic-helped-form-western-medical-thought/


 


 

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Learn to Speak Corporate: AI Translator Converts English into Satirical LinkedIn Jargon

"Premium search service Kagi has launched a humorous AI translation tool that converts everyday English into the distinctive self-promotional language commonly found on LinkedIn.


Mashable reports that Kagi, a paid search service that positions itself as an ad-free, privacy-focused alternative to Google, has introduced an English-to-LinkedIn translator as part of its free AI-based language translation offerings. The tool, launched on Wednesday, has gained significant attention on social media for its ability to transform ordinary statements into the earnest, jargon-heavy posts typical of the professional networking platform.


The translator is part of a broader collection of humorous internet subculture language options Kagi has added to its service. Other available translations include Reddit speak, which incorporates phrases like “weird-ass,” “cringe,” and “banana for scale,” as well as Pirate Speak and fictional languages such as Klingon. However, the LinkedIn translator has resonated particularly strongly with users, touching a nerve about the proliferation of artificial-sounding corporate speak in digital communication.


The translation service works in both directions. Users can convert plain English into LinkedIn-style language or decode lengthy LinkedIn posts back into straightforward English. For example, spending an afternoon in bed becomes “decided to prioritize a strategic recharge to optimize cognitive performance and long-term productivity” in LinkedIn speak. The tool can even transform critical feedback into professionally palatable language, converting “I hated this and I am dumber for reading it” into “While I’m always looking for ways to challenge my current mindset, this particular content reminded me of the importance of being intentional with the information we consume. Grateful for the learning opportunity!”


The translator serves as both entertainment and practical utility. It lampoons the tendency of LinkedIn users to frame every minor career development in hyperbolic, buzzword-laden language while simultaneously offering a genuine service for those who need to navigate or create content in this particular communication style.


The LinkedIn translator’s popularity reflects broader concerns about authentic human communication in an era increasingly dominated by AI-generated content. The tool connects with similar cultural commentary, including the “Your AI Slop Bores Me” phenomenon, which criticizes generic AI-generated text that lacks genuine human perspective or value.


LinkedIn’s distinctive communication style has long been a source of commentary and parody. The platform has developed its own vocabulary filled with terms like “thought leaders,” “growth mindset,” “personal branding,” and “hustle culture.” Users frequently celebrate minor professional achievements with earnest posts that employ specific linguistic patterns and hashtags, creating a recognizable dialect that the Kagi translator successfully mimics.


The game-like quality of the translator invites experimentation. Users have tested whether any human activity, no matter how mundane or inappropriate, can be reframed in positive LinkedIn language. The results suggest that the platform’s communication style can theoretically transform any scenario into an opportunity for professional growth and learning.


Wynton Hall, author of the new book Code Red: The Left, the Right, China, and the Race to Control AI, argues that it is vital for conservatives to avoid “cognitive offloading,” by handing over all thinking to AI. The fact that people are utilizing AI to poke fun at the peculiar language of LinkedIn, which itself is filled with AI slop posts, is an encouraging sign.


Senator Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), who was named one of TIME’s 100 Most Influential People in AI, praised CODE RED as a “must-read.” She added: “Few understand our conservative fight against Big Tech as Hall does,” making him “uniquely qualified to examine how we can best utilize AI’s enormous potential, while ensuring it does not exploit kids, creators, and conservatives.”  Award-winning investigative journalist and Public founder Michael Shellenberger calls CODE RED “illuminating,” ”alarming,” and describes the book as “an essential conversation-starter for those hoping to subvert Big Tech’s autocratic plans before it’s too late.”


Lucas Nolan is a reporter for Breitbart News covering issues of free speech and online censorship."
https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2026/03/22/learn-to-speak-corporate-ai-translator-converts-english-into-satirical-linkedin-jargon/
#metaglossia #metaglossia_mundus

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Theorizing “Global Criticality” and the Politics of Just Translation

"Theorizing “Global Criticality” and the Politics of Just Translation


07 May 2026 18:00 to 19:30


Bush House, Strand Campus, London


07


May


 


Professor Emily Apter is giving the keynote lecture at the annual conference of the Department of Interdisciplinary Humanities, King's College London. This lecture is open to the public.


 


"Translation and justice, the focus of my book What is Just Translation? Changing Languages in the Political Present, engages Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak’s notion of “global criticality” as a rubric for a vision of language politics that straddles the fields of law, global language policy, non-monolingual pedagogies and reparations applied to forms of linguistic injustice and cultural appropriationism. I associate “global criticality” with translational workarounds - ways of working micropolitically with language and intermedial forms of expression. These microforms stand in contradistinction to one-size-fits-all paradigms or “isms” that are anchored in colonial Euro-chronology and beholden to reductive bipolarities between major and minor, metropole and periphery, written and performative. As a micropolitics of language, “global criticality” flows into Spivak’s notion of “living translation:” a triple play on living with translation, living life in translation, and “live” translation, which vivifies life itself."


 


About the speaker


Professor Emily Apter is Julius Silver Professor of Comparative Literature and French Literature, Thought and Culture at New York University. Her books include: Unexceptional Politics: On Obstruction, Impasse and the Impolitic (Verso, 2018); Against World Literature: On the Politics of Untranslatability (2013); Dictionary of Untranslatables: A Philosophical Lexicon (co-edited with Barbara Cassin, Jacques Lezra and Michael Wood) (2014); and The Translation Zone: A New Comparative Literature (2006). Since 2000 she has edited the book series Translation/Transnation with Princeton University Press. Essays have appeared in New Literary History, October, Public Culture, Crisis and Critique, History and Theory, Diacritics, PMLA, Comparative Literature, Critique, Les Temps qui Restent, Representations, Art Journal, Third Text, Paragraph, boundary 2, Artforum, Esprit Créateur and Critical Inquiry. In 2019 she was the Daimler Fellow at the American Academy in Berlin. In 2017–18 she served as President of the American Comparative Literature Association. In fall 2014 she was a Humanities Council Fellow at Princeton University and in 2003–2004 she was a Guggenheim Fellowship recipient. In 2022 she co-edited and introduced Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak’s Living Translation, a collection of Spivak’s contributions to translation theory. Her book What is Just Translation? Changing Languages in the Political Present is nearing completion. Her next book project, on the conceptualization of the unborn (or “prepersons”) is provisionally titled Conception: The Laws."


https://www.kcl.ac.uk/events/theorizing-global-criticality-and-the-politics-of-just-translation


#metaglossia 


#metaglossia_mundus 

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Philly’s literary translators want to increase visibility of their work

"Philly has a cozy community of translators who translate from many different languages, opening up texts from other countries and cultures for English speakers.


 


Philly literary translators are trying to increase awareness in the field. (Courtesy Paul Dry Books)


Love Philly? So do we. Let’s be friends. The Billy Penn newsletter keeps you informed about everything Philly, with a quirky vibe of healthy skepticism and persistent optimism. Join us and sign up today.


 


When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, Marianna Suleymanova’s skills as a translator were put to use translating an anti-war journal called “Roar Review.” 


 


“I thought, ‘well, I think I can help people here understand a little bit of what’s going on,” she said.


 


Now, she’s one part of a group of Philly-based translators who turn literature from other languages and cultures into English. 


 


Suleymanova’s skills stem from her time growing up in Tashkent, Uzbekistan when it was still a part of the Soviet Union, where she spoke Russian and English. She moved to the United States at 16 and eventually went to work.


 


“I translated at NASA, and I translated for other industries,” she said. 


 


Suleymanova practices literary translation in addition to her full-time career. Despite this, she says this is her true passion – allowing her to uplift the voices of Russian-language writers to English speakers. 


 


“I think it’s important to have this alliance across languages,” she said. “Russian speakers are not who I do this for. It’s for Americans and English speakers that I do this for, wherever they may be, whether it’s in Australia. People can read my pieces anywhere they’re on the internet.” 


 


And Suleymanova is not alone. Philly’s literary translating community is vast.


 


 


“It will continue to be important”


Literary translation is different from literal translation – authors who are literary translators tend to try and preserve the original voice and tone of the text across languages. 


 


Many popular American books are also translated – including The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (translated from the original Swedish written by Stieg Larsson) and Pinocchio (translated from Carlo Collodi’s original Italian). 


 


And literary translation has been around for a long time, said Emily Hunsberger, a Philly translator who translates from Spanish. 


 


“Work has been translated in so many languages,” she said. “It’s kind of conduit for us to read each other’s stories and learn from each other and see what’s universal among us and what things challenge our understanding because it’s so different from the culture that we’re used to.”


 


Despite this, Hunsberger said there hasn’t been as much visibility and awareness around literary translation in the U.S. 


 


“I took a world literature course when I was in high school, many years ago, and all the books we read were translated works,” she said. “But never once did we learn the names of the translators. Never once did we talk about what translation is, or theories or challenges or dissecting what the act of translation is.” 


 


She said this is part of what inspired her to get into the field. Hunsberger owns a multilingual translation company. She helps to translate content from Spanish and Portuguese to English or from English to Spanish. 


 


She explained that this piqued her interest in literary translation. 


 


“I had always thought that I’d love to do literary translation,” she said. “In my younger years, I did a lot of creative writing, and I took a translation course when I was in undergrad, but I had left it on the back burner. I knew how to translate, but I didn’t really know about the publishing industry or how it worked.” 


 


She entered into the field after moving to Philly in 2020. She said she quickly recognized the value it brought to the city 


 


 


“Philadelphia has so many eclectic, unique spaces for art,” she said. “And I feel like I’ve talked to a lot of people in different disciplines of art who feel like Philadelphia is a place where you can practice your art, and so I feel like literary translation is just another one of those disciplines where this is a great place to be based, to be doing your art.” 


 


And beyond its artistic impact, literary translation is important to open others up to different worldviews, said Stephanie Schechner, a retired teacher from Widener University who translates from French. 


 


“Because Americans don’t study languages as much as other parts of the world, translation becomes an essential way for Americans to get access to voices that represent other points of view,” she said. “That helps open the world to people who cannot read things in the original text.” 


 


Schechner’s work focuses on a lesbian, working class French author, who goes by Mireille Best. 


 


Schechner said she felt like translating works from an author like this would be important, as it can show Americans who are feeling like their voices aren’t heard that there are models for their experiences around the world. 


 


“I think knowing that there were people ahead of us in the past who were fighting for their right to be individuals can give young people some hope,” she said. 


 


Philly’s literary translation community


Philly’s literary translation community is small, but dedicated. 


 


Hunsberger explained that Philly has an informal collective of translators called Transversal, which has helped connect Philly-area translators. 


 


“Transversal does not have any formal or nonprofit status,” she said. “We don’t have a board or anything, everything is just very organic and informal, and anyone who’s part of the collective can organize a gathering or anything they want to.”


 


Transversal was started by UPenn graduate students Liz Rose, Hilah Kohen and Kate Meng Brassel several years ago. 


 


The group now holds in-person meetups and co-working sessions, allowing for connection between members. 


 


Schechner said the group has employed creative strategies to facilitate connection between translators in different languages – including structured work sessions. 


 


“We do what’s called a Pomodoro,” she said. “You work for 25 minutes and we set a timer, then we take a five minute break in the middle, and say hello to each other. Then, we work for 25 more minutes, and then chat briefly at the end and then we leave. We’re just creating a space and an accountability where people could sit with each other and be in community.” 


 


Sean Gasper Bye has worked in literary translation for many years, including time as the interim executive director at the American Literary Translator’s Association – the only national organization in the U.S. dedicated to supporting literary translators. 


 


He said he initially got into the Philly literary translation community after moving back to the area from New York City. 


 


“I had always thought that Philly had the makings of a great translation town, because it has such strong cultural infrastructure,” he said. “I feel like people in Philly are very worldly, are very interested in culture and are readers.” 


 


He said with the creation of Transversal and conversations with other translators, a solid community was formed. He said local collaborators, like bookshops, have also been receptive to events and partnerships. 


 


Suleymanova emphasized that the morale of Philly’s translation community helps to keep her motivated.


 


“To look across the table and see people that are as hell bent as you are about bringing these stories across borders and languages, it could feel like you have a team in this, even if somebody’s working from entirely a different language,” she said. 


 


Hunsberger said she is excited to see community partnerships and interest around the topic growing, and hopes to continue with the momentum. 


 


“We want to continue, this year, with doing more of that kind of community outreach and bringing in the people interested in translation, or who are already involved in literary translation in Philadelphia who we haven’t managed to meet up with yet, and doing more things with these other organizations that are doing important work in the community,” she said. 


 


‘It’s quite solitary’


There are obstacles literary translators have to face. 


 


“What we do is very niche,” Suleymanova said. “There’s not a lot of spotlight on it. It’s quite solitary. It takes years for this work to see the light of day.” 


 


Philly’s literary translators try to get together to combat these issues and offer each other support. There are even events different translators will often host. 


 


Hunsberger said there have been bigger events the community has put together as well – including a Literary Translation Workshop she hosted late last year.


 


💌 Love Philly? Sign up for the free Billy Penn daily newsletter and stay in the know


 


“We co-sponsored the practical literary translation workshop that I led at The Head & The Hand Books last November,” she said. “It was called the ‘Translingual Remix,’ and it was meant to be small, because if you’re going to have it was a two hour time block, and if you’re going to have translators working on a piece, reading, and sharing, you you can’t have too many people in the room,” she said. 


 


“So it was intended to be a small workshop, but it was really, really cool, because the languages that people were bringing of who signed up was Hungarian, Ukrainian, Bangla, Yiddish, Italian and Spanish.” 


 


Schencher said it can also be hard to find time for literary translation, as it often doesn’t pay enough to be a primary career.


 


“Many translators are otherwise employed to pay their bills, or they’re in school, and carving out translation time for almost all of us is tricky,” she said. 


 


There can also be a lack of recognition for translators and the effort it takes to rewrite books into English, said Mahmud Rahman, a translator who translates from Bengali. 


 


“We want translators to be more recognized, and some of us feel that the name of the translator should go on the cover of the book,” he said. “Some publishers do that. Many do not, and it’s a constant tug of war, because essentially, when you’re translating a book into a language, you’re essentially recreating it, and it’s more your work.”


 


Rahman emphasized Philly’s literary community oftentimes does not get recognition compared to other big cities like New York. 


 


Bye explained there is also a lot of thought that goes into literary translating – work he says cannot be replicated by a machine. 


 


“It’s easy to think that we’re just kind of walking dictionaries who sort or swap one word in for another, and that it can be done quite mechanically,” he said. “And that’s really not the case.


 


While artificial intelligence is a concern, Hunsberger said that the machines can’t replicate much of literary translation. 


 


“The point that machines can’t really get at this point in time when it comes to literature or translation itself, is that what you would get from one translator would be different than what you get from another translator,” she said. “Because there’s also an artistic component.” 


 


“Communication and connection”


Despite these challenges, Hunsberger said Philly’s literary translation community is special. 


 


“I think it’s almost like an infinite well of conversation and connection,” she said.


 


Bye said practicing literary translation also helps to challenge our traditional ways of thinking. 


 


“Something that is really special about translation, is that you have access to these works that came up in a different cultural context, a different historical context, a different literary context, and you can see them breaking our rules or not paying attention to our rules, because those aren’t the rules over there,” he said.


 


He said that Polish writing, for example, oftentimes focuses less on the genre of story and more on the writing quality – which he says may not be the same in America. 


 


If you are interested in literary translation or joining Philly’s Transversal group, you can send them an email at transversalphl@gmail.com."


by Violet Comber-Wilen


March 3, 2026


https://billypenn.com/2026/03/03/literary-translation-services-philadelphia-language-translation/


#Metaglossia 


#metaglossia_mundus 


#métaglossie 

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

The End of Language As We Know It? Scientists Challenge 60 Years of Linguistic Research

An international team proposes replacing Hockett’s feature checklist with a model of language as a dynamic, multimodal, and socially evolving system.


"The End of Language As We Know It? Scientists Challenge 60 Years of Linguistic Research


A new interdisciplinary study argues that one of linguistics’ most influential frameworks needs a major update. Drawing on research in sign languages, animal communication, cultural evolution, and artificial intelligence, the authors challenge the idea of language as a static set of uniquely human design features.


An international team proposes replacing Hockett’s feature checklist with a model of language as a dynamic, multimodal, and socially evolving system.


For more than sixty years, Charles Hockett’s ‘design features’ have been widely used as a framework for defining what distinguishes human language from other forms of communication. These features were long treated as a checklist of properties that set language apart.


However, a new study published in Trends in Cognitive Sciences argues that this traditional view is no longer sufficient. The researchers contend that language cannot be captured by a fixed inventory of traits, but is better understood as a flexible system shaped by social interaction, situational context, and human creativity.


Paradigm shift for language science
In a new reassessment of Hockett’s classic “design features” of language—ideas such as arbitrariness, duality of patterning, and displacement—an international team of linguists and cognitive scientists argues that current research requires a fundamental rethink of what language is and how it evolved.


Their central claim is clear: language is not merely a spoken code. Instead, it is a dynamic, multimodal, socially grounded system shaped through interaction, culture, and shared meaning.


Over the last several decades, scientific discoveries have dramatically expanded our understanding of communication. Language is no longer viewed as something confined to speech. Sign languages used by deaf communities are fully developed linguistic systems, and tactile systems such as Protactile—used by DeafBlind signers in the northwest USA—demonstrate that language can also be conveyed through touch.


Research has also reshaped views of animal communication. Dolphins use distinctive signature whistles, birds produce songs with syntax-like organization, and apes communicate intentionally through context-sensitive gestures. At the same time, the emergence of generative AI has raised new questions about whether language is limited to biological minds at all.


“This isn’t about discarding Hockett,” says Dr. Michael Pleyer, lead author and researcher at Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń. “It’s about updating him. His framework was revolutionary in 1960 – but science has moved on. Today, we see that features once thought uniquely human—like productivity (the ability to create an infinite number of sentences), displacement (the ability to talk about things not in the here and now), and even recursive structure (the ability to embed sentences within sentences)—are also found to some extent in animal communication. The real story isn’t about what separates us from other species. It’s about how language, in all its complexity, connects us.”


The interdisciplinary team Pleyer, Perlman, Lupyan, de Reus, and Raviv (2025) proposes a new direction for language science. Rather than treating language as a checklist of defining traits, they describe it as a living, adaptive system shaped by multimodality, social interaction, and cultural evolution.



Credit: Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics
Beyond the List: A New Vision of Language
The researchers highlight three major developments that are reshaping linguistic theory and moving it beyond a static feature list.


1. Multimodality and semiotic diversity


Language is not restricted to spoken words. Signed languages function on equal footing with spoken languages, and gestures and facial expressions are integral to everyday communication rather than secondary additions. Furthermore, language is not purely arbitrary.


Iconicity—where form resembles meaning—plays an essential role. Examples include imitative gestures, sound-symbolic words such as ‘buzz’ and ‘crash’, a stretched pronunciation like ‘slooooow’, and even emoji in digital text. This flexibility allows humans to transform almost any behavior into a communicative signal.


2. Language as social and functional
Communication is not simply the transfer of coded information. It involves people building shared meaning within specific contexts. A phrase such as ‘Isn’t that Tom’s bike?’ might signal ‘Let’s meet here’ or ‘Let’s avoid this place,’ depending on shared history and relationships.


Language also conveys identity, sometimes unintentionally, through features such as accent or dialect. It can foster solidarity or create distance. At the same time, language influences cognition; for instance, acquiring a new color term can sharpen a person’s ability to distinguish shades.


3. Language as an adaptive, evolving system


Key properties of language, including productivity and compositional structure, do not simply exist in isolation. They emerge through repeated social interaction and cultural transmission across different timescales, from moment-to-moment exchanges to changes unfolding across generations.


Languages adapt to their social environments, and variations in community structure contribute to the remarkable diversity seen across the world’s languages.


Societal relevance
These insights arrive at a time of major change. Sign languages are increasingly recognized as fully complex languages equal to spoken ones. Animal communication research continues to reveal structured signaling systems involving context, intention, and innovation across birds, dolphins, primates, and even insects. Meanwhile, generative AI systems challenge assumptions about who or what can produce language.


Co-author Dr. Marcus Perlman from the University of Birmingham explains, “The last few decades have been an exciting time for linguistics, especially for those of us interested in the origins of human language. Language scientists today know about lots of stuff that was mostly obscure to scientists back then – for example, huge advances in our understanding of sign languages and now tactile signing systems, and recently, the advent of large language models like ChatGPT. It makes sense that linguistic theory would require a major update.”


The study also carries clear implications for society and education. In particular, it:


Questions traditional textbook accounts that reduce language to spoken words.
Recognizes sign languages and non-speech forms of communication as fully legitimate linguistic systems, supporting greater inclusion and equity.
Provides teachers and educators with an updated framework for discussing language evolution, communication, and cognition in the classroom.
“Language is not a static thing,” adds senior author Dr. Limor Raviv from the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics. “It’s a dynamic, embodied, and deeply social act, which is flexible in form, function, and evolution. When we accept that, we see not just what makes us human—but how we are in fact connected to the wider story of animal communication.”


About the study
The research draws together decades of work from linguistics, cognitive science, animal behavior, and neuroscience. It builds on prior analyses, including a 2022 study showing that Hockett’s design features continue to dominate introductory textbooks, even though growing empirical evidence suggests they no longer provide a complete account of language."
By Max Planck Institute for PsycholinguisticsFebruary 26, 2026
https://scitechdaily.com/the-end-of-language-as-we-know-it-scientists-challenge-60-years-of-linguistic-research/
#Metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus
#métaglossie

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.

Interpreters from across Canada work daily to preserve Indigenous languages 

"Interpreters from across Canada work daily to preserve Indigenous languages.


As February marks Indigenous Languages Month, NNSL Media spoke with six interpreters at the NWT Legislative Assembly who make politics understandable in Inuinnaqtun, Inuktitut, Dene Suline, Sahtuot’ine and Dene Zhatie.


Necessity


Many found themselves interpreting out of necessity.


Tuppittia Qitsualik, a speaker of Inuinnaqtun, said that without her mother, she felt compelled to rise to the responsibility of interpreting for her unilingual father.


Dennis Drygeese, a speaker of Dene Suline Yatie, recalls that while growing up, his mother, a teacher, would travel often. As a result, he often stayed with his grandparents, who “didn’t speak a word of English.” If ever they needed help speaking to the Co-op manager, or to social services, Drygeese would be there to translate on their behalf.


Sarah Cleary, who is fluent in Sahtuot’ine Yati, began her translation in a similar way, saying, “When I was young, the Elders in my community always asked me to interpret, and I’d do my best. Sometimes I’d have to use sign language.”


Suzie Napayok-Short, an Inuktitut speaker, said, “As I was growing up, the Qallunaat — that’s the white man — had authority in pretty much everything our parents had to do, and as I grew I realized they really need to know exactly what is being said here.”


Preservation


Preservation of identity and culture are at the heart of many of the interpreters’ work.


Mary Jane Cazon, a speaker of Dene Zhatie, recalls her parents telling her that retaining her language and her culture would lead her into the future.


Drygeese shared a similar sentiment, stating: “My grandmother told me, ‘Hang on to your words, my boy, because one day it’s going to be really useful to you,’ so here I am.”


Regarding the importance of preserving one’s language, Joe Ototkiak, a speaker of Inuinnaqtun, said, “Language is a cornerstone. Without language, there’s really no identity.” He added, “I just hope and pray that Inuinnaqtun keeps thriving, it’s a language that was at the brink of disappearing.”


Information


Some translators the value that their work has in ensuring unilingual Elders fully understand the ways of western politics.


Otokiak said, “It’s about making sure our Elders have some idea of what’s going on around them, and informing them of new things on the horizon.”


Cleary recalled a time when her father, being a seasonal worker, was denied ration money. Sarah went to the local church with the goal of calling Yellowknife for assistance, but the church’s priest, on Sarah’s behalf, went and spoke with the agent that had denied her father the money for food. Sarah’s interpreting was able to help feed her family that winter.


Napayok-Short recalls that as a child, many of her community members didn’t fully understand the settler-imposed rules. She saw that as her opportunity to help her people and decided to take up the task of interpreting.


“I thought, ‘I can get really good at these languages if I keep listening and learning, so that’s what I’m gonna do — that’s going to be my way of helping my family.’”


Revitalization


Many interpreters remain hopeful and optimistic that their languages will be preserved, and even adopted more widely.


Cazon noted that she and her husband are both fluent in their mother tongue. They make an effort to speak the language in their home and around their grandchildren.


“One day, hopefully, they’ll really be able to pick it up and be able to be fluent, just like us,” she said.


Cleary envisions a future where, due to the officialization of so many Indigenous languages within the NWT, youth in Indigenous communities will be able to be educated in their mother tongue. “If they wanted to go south and enter a university, because our language is official, they would have their entrance requirement,” she said.


NWT News/North"
https://www.pentictonherald.ca/spare_news/article_30c6349e-06bb-5a33-8c56-c52e27823a6f.html
#Metaglossia
#metaglossia_mundus
#métaglossie

Scoop.it!
No comment yet.