Home Office to reconsider asylum plea of Afghan interpreter blown up on British front line patrol after extraordinary U-turn
Father of three, 26, suffered horrific wounds in Taliban attack that killed Army captain
Border Agency told him 14 months after application was submitted that he had no evidence of being either Afghan or under threat
Change of heart after complaints from MPs and media coverage
By DAVID WILLIAMS
PUBLISHED: 14:10 GMT, 2 October 2012 | UPDATED: 18:50 GMT, 2 October 2012
Comments (40)
Share
British Army translator Mohammad Rafi Hottak pictured showing his scars following the Taliban blast
The Home Office made an extraordinary U-turn tonight and withdrew a letter telling an Afghan interpreter blown up by the Taliban while on patrol with British troops his asylum application was rejected.
The rare about-turn came hours after publicity highlighting the farcical handling of the case of Mohammad Rafi Hottak by the controversial UK Border Agency, whose refusal of the claim was met with disbelief and anger by the military and MPs.
Last night the Agency said it would look again at the case after it appeared that the most basic checks had not been made by officers investigating the 26 year-old's claim despite it having been lodged 14 months ago.
A delighted Mr Hottak hailed the decision as a 'victory for common sense', adding that: ' The reasons given for rejection were unbelievable and showed thorough checks had just not been made in my case.
'I now have renewed hope but I am still cautious given what has happened… this latest decision to cancel the letter shows at least that people are still working to help me find justice. I still can't believe the letter I was sent.'
In that astonishing letter of rejection, which raised new questions about the handling of asylum cases, Mr Hottak was told one of the reasons he would not be allowed to build a new life in Britain was because Home Office investigators did not have evidence of how he was injured.
Incredibly, the father of three was also told he had provided no evidence he was an Afghan, he had the same fingerprints as another asylum claimant and there was no evidence his life was under threat if he had remained in his homeland.
More...
Labour's Love Lost: Ed Balls reveals he has not taken wife Yvette on a date for 10 years
Labour's tax bombshell: Hours before Ed Miliband's big speech his frontbench team suggest a hike in income tax and axing benefits for wealthy pensioners
All pupils should study English and maths until 18, says Miliband as he proposes biggest education reform for decades
In fact, all the details could have been simply obtained from Ministry of Defence records, including those of how Mr Hottak was blown up by an improvised explosives device – a blast that killed a British officer – and that his life was saved by surgeons in hospital at Camp Bastion.
A devastated Mr Hottak, whose asylum case has already been raised in Parliament, claimed: 'It is as if the Home Office has been blind to my case and what happened to me and fellow interpreters in Afghanistan. I have army officers who I worked with supporting my case but this appears to mean nothing.
Captain John McDermid, pictured with his wife, Gill, was killed in the blast that injured Mr Hottak
'I am depressed and I will appeal, I always saw Britain as a just country that I was proud to serve, that provided shelter for those whose lives were at risk but this has shaken that belief. All I want is a better future for myself and my kids.'
The rejection shocked both MPs and those in the military who worked beside Mr Hottak in the most dangerous parts of Helmand province.
Julian Brazier MP, a member of the Defence select Committee, said he would raise the matter with both Immigration and Armed Forces ministers while Sir Menzies Campbell, the former Liberal Democrat leader, called for Home Secretary Theresa May to investigate.
One soldier has written to the Home Office speaking at his 'disappointment' as the handling of a 'hero's' case, saying Britain was turning its back on him and branding him a liar.
Faced with personal death threats and those to his family, Mr Hottak had paid £8,000 to people smugglers more than a year ago, to reach Britain, walking into a Central London police station to make his plea for asylum.
Fluent in three languages, including English, Mr Hottak worked for the US military as an interpreter in 2004 before switching to the British two years later following in the footsteps of his elder brother.
It was on the morning of November 14, 2007 that while on foot patrol with a joint British Afghan force near the centre of Sangin, Helmand province, an IED was triggered.
Mr Hottak's boss Captain John McDermid, 43, of 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment was killed, Mr Hottak badly wounded.
He still recalls the huge flash, the noise and the searing pain as he was thrown several metres into the air before ending up bleeding profusely as Army medics rushed to the aid of the injured.
The interpreter suffered horrific shrapnel wounds to the head, neck, arms and chest that required 170 stitches. He also temporarily lost the use of his hand and was deaf in one ear for more than a year.
Julian Brazier, MP, (left) said he would raise the matter with immigration and Armed Forces ministers while Sir Menzies Campbell said he would ask Home Secretary Theresa May (right) to investigate before the U-turn
Mr Hottak was injured in a blast while patrolling with UK troops in Helmand Province, Afghanistan (file picture)
Thanks to the work of doctors, Mr Hottak returned to work after three months but was unfit for front line duties and was given a job at Camp Souter, the main British recruitment base in Kabul, the Afghan capital.
His role involved interviewing prospective interpreters as well as liasing with the families of colleagues killed or injured, sometimes returning the remains of the dead to their families.
It was then that he began to receive death threats both by letter and telephone – threats he told British officers about. Some threatened him, some his family. He moved house and changed telephones but the threats continued.
Keith Vaz described Mr Hottak's treatment as 'a disgrace'
One Taliban letter referred to Mr Hottak and his brother by name. It warned: 'They are doing a very important job for the aggressive infidels, so we want you to catch them and deal with them through Islamic Sharia,' said the note, hand-written in Pashtu, the main language in southern Afghanistan.
'If you can't catch these two, catch their father so they will come to rescue him.'
At one point a British officer wrote him a note to take to a senior police officer in Kabul to ask him for help. But Mr Hottak said: 'The first thing the police officer said was, “You work for the Nato forces so they should look after you, not us. There are hundreds of people like you and I cannot provide bodyguards for all of them'."
Underlining the threats was the fact that the Taliban had been responsible for the kidnap and murders of translators as well as the intimidation of their families who were warned that unless their relatives left the British, they would become targets.
More than 40 Afghan translators are said to have resigned from working with the British because of the threats.
Mr Hottak, who has not seen his youngest child, is now living in a hostel in Leicester, where he is unable to work and receives £36 a week to live on.
He is doing a course at a local college and says : 'Other translators have been granted asylum but they are refusing me on the weakest possible reasons. I have Army officers who vouch for who I am, what happened to me and the fact that I served loyally and well with British troops yet this seems to count for very little.'
He added : 'I am desperate and depressed, I risked my life to help British soldiers, my family and Afghanistan and it seems to count for nothing.
'I read reports of killers and criminals who have been granted asylum – it seems that they are desirable but people like me who have never done anything wrong and whose life will be in danger in my own home because I worked with British troops are not. It is a strange situation.'
Keith Vaz, chairman of the Commons Home Affairs Committee and Mr Hottak's MP, has called the young man's treatment a disgrace.
Mr Hottak said that one reason for his asylum rejection was that investigators could not confirm that his surname was Afghan – something that could have been done simply through Google.
Another was that military identification cards supporting the application contained different spellings of his name – Afghan names are spelt in a variety of ways when written in English.
Last night a UKBA spokesperson said: ‘The increased level of publicity around this case has led to new and significant information, which was not provided during the application process, coming to light today.
'As a result of this additional information, we have informed Mr Hottak this evening that we have withdrawn our decision and will fully review his application.’
MOST READ NEWS
Previous
1
2
3
Next
'We're desperate for any news. Please, please help find...
'I was a virgin of 16 when Jimmy Savile raped me. My mother...
Call girl 'beat retired accountant to death' in his $1.5m...
Medical student, 23, found dead in bedroom after telling...
Three civil servants suspended after government is forced to...
Nursery workers arrested over death of girl, 3, who became...
Lottery winner who scooped £5.5m and spent the lot claimed...
Missing girl April 'played in suspect's car two days before...
Model, 23, dies after falling nine floors from balcony of...
How 2m motorists drive 'unwittingly' without insurance when...
'Please accept this little outcast son of mine': The...
Tears for Pc Nicola: Thousands of police pay their respects...
Share this article:
Facebook
Twitter
Google+
Messenger
LinkedIn
Digg it
Newsvine
Fark
Nowpublic
Reddit
Print article
Email article
Ads by Google:
The Progressive Realist
a metablog about American foreign policy
www.progressiverealist.org
Online University
Bachelor in International Relations Earn your Degree Online.
www.aiu.edu/University
Add your comments Comments (40)
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
NewestOldestBest ratedWorst rated
View all
This case merely identifies how intellectually bereft the Immigration Department are. The useless case officer who was identified as a female on the news last night, didn't have the common sense or the intellect to carry out her job by making simple basic checks. She should be dismissed from the service.
- Rayjon , Spain, 03/10/2012 09:16
Click to rate Rating 36 Report abuse
Taliban, terroists, criminals all sorts who hate us and our way of life seem to have no problem whatsoever staying in the country, at our expence. Someone who help us is up for deportation? What a mess UK plc is
- bertbucket , Swindon, 03/10/2012 09:00
Click to rate Rating 47 Report abuse
Loyalty and honour mean nothing in Britain today.
- GR , London, 03/10/2012 05:31
Click to rate Rating 42 Report abuse
He and his family can live at my house here in the U.S. Does anybody in the highest of elected offices in the U.K. have the clearance or ability to put a signature on a piece of paper and just make this right?
- Squirmyntwitch , Las Vegas, 03/10/2012 03:14
Click to rate Rating 28 Report abuse
This is disgusting !!!! Shameful treatment by typical jobs worth plebeians !
- banki , Shaftesbury Dorset, 03/10/2012 03:14
Click to rate Rating 28 Report abuse
@Deborah, It is the UK border agency at fault NOT the home office.
- Amar , England (UK), 03/10/2012 02:03
Click to rate Rating 16 Report abuse
This man, and his family, should have been offered passage to the UK after his injuries. What a disgrace.
- Nicky , Lincs, 03/10/2012 01:43
Click to rate Rating 31 Report abuse
Since Cameron became PM U-Turns are the norm.
- Mike_expat_Brit_OAP , Khon Kaen, Thailand, 03/10/2012 00:57
Click to rate Rating 14 Report abuse
Who's running this madhouse?
- Over Taxed and Over Here , Whitby UK, 02/10/2012 23:55
Click to rate Rating 20 Report abuse
Give him a "Dummy Hook" then he can stay here and claim mi££ions of the taxpayer!.
- Royal785 , Dundee, 02/10/2012 23:03
Click to rate Rating 26 Report abuse
The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.
Add your comment
You have 1000 characters left.
Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.
I agree to the House Rules
For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.
TermsClear Submit Content
BingSite Web Enter search term:Search
FEMAIL TODAY
Finally a smile as Chantelle Houghton moves out... but her happiness turns to rage when her new home goes to 'someone else'
Can't catch a break
'I went blonde because I was bored': Tulisa reveals reason behind THAT hair as she prepares her X Factor acts for the live shows
Excuses, excuses
The diva vs the wild child rapper: Nicki Minaj's foul mouthed rant at Mariah Carey after 'being called a b**** by fellow American Idol judge'
That's one way to get attention! Kim Kardashian's pal Brittny Gastineau bares all in a lace top with no bra
Trying to upstage someone?
Could a pair of £39 jeans give you a booty like Kim Kardashian? Bargain online brand claims to have invented the ULTIMATE bottom lift trousers
She's a Belieber! Kylie Jenner, 15, indulges her teenage side at Justin Bieber concert
Went hell for leather in
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2211760/Asylum-application-rejected-Afghan-interpreter-blown-Taliban-patrol-British-troops.html#ixzz28FvaLfJq
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook