Tracking Transmedia
Follow
Find
78.8K views | +31 today
 
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia Storytelling & Immersion Experiences
onto Tracking Transmedia
Scoop.it!

The Anti-Panel: Empower the Audience

The Anti-Panel: Empower the Audience | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Thanks anti-panel members for an interesting and valuable discussion. #disruptsyd

— Alex Ford (@alexkford) September 5, 2013




The traditional panel has real limits. Experiments are required for new formats to address disruptive, adaptive and emergent issues.


Yesterday at Disrupt.Sydney,  Ben Gilchriest, Mani Thiru and I ran an experiment with an Anti-Panel.


Why hold an Anti-Panel?


The traditional panel format is broken when the questions being considered are adaptive, complex or emergent. A traditional panel can be:



Disengaging:  The panel supposedly has all the power, expertise and knowledge. They deign to answer questions from a large group of supplicants. The audience sits, listens and watches.  A facilitator often shapes the whole event and dominates the discussion. One person speaks at a time. The tendency is for people to seek to hold everyone’s attention.


Lacking collaboration:  Panellist may or may not build on others’ views. Debates rarely occur or get explored. The audience has little chance to collaborate with the panel or each other.


Lacking diversity: Only panellists views get heard. Questions are rationed. Questioning may be intimidating in a large group. Group think can occur with few views on offer. Panels are often very chosen from a limited demographic of expertise.


Narrow in contributions: Discussion is limited to verbal questions and answers. Other forms of interaction are limited and usually very formal. Feelings and intuition is disdained. Shallow, concise and entertaining answers dominate discussion.


Focused on a correct answer: Panels are heavily dependant on technical expertise. There is no room for creativity or experimentation. Reflection time is not available to any participants


Linear:  Panels are always ‘moving on in the interest of time’.  Iteration is limited. 



In line with the spirit of Disrupt.Sydney we set out to disrupt the panel model with something more connected, more collaborative, more adaptive and more open to diverse contributions.


How do you hold an Anti-Panel?


The first change is to make the anti-panellists servants of the conversation. Instead of an audience, there is a room full of participants working together. The role of anti-panellists is to facilitate the participants to discuss the issues.


Then you need to open up the format. We used a structure which ran from the personal to the group, explored a number of contributions (visual, emotional, allowed for movement in the room, etc) and iterated the discussion across:



opening: to set a common context, understanding and a little role modelling by the anti-panellists of the openness, flexibility and informality of the approach.


individual reflection by the anti-panel & other participants to draw what they found significant.  This used drawing to engage another perspective of reflection and to speed later sharing.


small group sharing and discussion of the drawings to draw connections & similarities, explore doubts, questions and differences.  


a full room discussion of insights, lessons, actions, new thoughts and other connections.  Explicitly in this conversation we asked and encouraged questions to introduce a discussion of feelings and concerns to explore and to widen the conversation to include domains that had not yet been discussed.


closing reflections from the panel of any points of synthesis or intuitions that they have drawn and an open invitation for the participants to share their insights.



I suspect each anti-panel would need to be different to be tailored to its participants, time allowance and topic, so I have deliberately left out further details of time allocation, questions, etc. We found ours changed as we learned what the participants needed. We would have liked to have included more leverage of digital capture and sharing in the discussion.  That remains an opportunity for a future anti-panel.  


The anti-panellists played a role as participants in discussion, timekeepers, facilitators through open questioning to draw in additional views and tried to keep a perspective of the whole conversation. Adaptive leadership questions that explore purposes, concerns, circumstances and that drew reflection on elements of the system proved valuable.


At Disrupt.Sydney, this format worked very well for the discussion on the topics of disruption. The participant feedback was very positive. We drew a rich range of perspectives from the participants, allowed the participants to shape the discussion and presented many opportunities to build, draw connections or add other elements to the topic of discussion.


More Experimentation Required


Our experience was a worthwhile first experiment. More will be learned as others leverage a fundamentally different approach to sharing the expertise of a room full of talented people with the passion to engage in a topic.


Let us know what you change and what you learn from your anti-panel.  Post your experiences in the comments. Open experimentation, collaboration and iteration can only improve the results.


Credit: Credit for the idea of the anti-panel belongs with Matt Moore who helped us plan the session and was sadly unable to join us in bringing it to life.

Via Jonathan Belisle
more...
No comment yet.

From around the web

Tracking Transmedia
Tracking Transmedia, Crossmedia, Interactive & Digital Storytelling
Your new post is loading...
Your new post is loading...
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Why I Won't Swap #GoT Sansa Rape for Dany & her Dragons

Why I Won't Swap #GoT Sansa Rape for Dany & her Dragons | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Why I won’t swap GoT porn & Sansa rape for Dany & her dragons anymore.
siobhan-o-flynn's insight:

Big discussions happening re. this Sunday's episode & I was struck by the way the narrative structure of GoT leverages the complicity of the audience, see sawing between repulsive scenes & the fantastic... 

more...
No comment yet.
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia Storytelling meets Tourism
Scoop.it!

Virtual Reality Immersion Demonstrates its Potential

Virtual Reality Immersion Demonstrates its Potential | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Danish short film "The Doghouse" is an experiment in how far virtual reality can immerse a person into another's mindset.

Via Soraia Ferreira
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Reddit Joins the Fight Against Trolls

Reddit Joins the Fight Against Trolls | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Reddit, the online message forum, announced last week that it is updating its policies to curb harassment between users on its site. The decision follows Twitter’s roll-out of new anti-harassment tool
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Lance Weiler’s must-read story about the future of storytelling

Lance Weiler’s must-read story about the future of storytelling | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
The founder of Columbia University's Digital Storytelling Lab gives us an inside look at his work at the University and how the Lab is designing stories for the 21st Century.
more...
Annette Simmons's comment, May 21, 9:00 AM
Fantastic article!
Daniel Christian's curator insight, May 21, 4:22 PM

As Scooped by @siobhan-o-flynn

Jeni Mawter's curator insight, Today, 2:13 AM

What matters is that the work is making an emotional connection in some way and that the story is leaving room for those experiencing it to be playful.

Read more: http://kidscreen.com/2015/05/13/lance-weilers-must-read-story-about-the-future-of-storytelling/#ixzz3aqSsLXpS

Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Trailer watch: a first look at Between, a Netflix original series

Trailer watch: a first look at Between, a Netflix original series | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
A new thriller about a town where everyone over the age of 22 is killed by a deadly disease
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Game sales to reach $113B in 2018; about three-quarters of all revenues this year will be digital

Game sales to reach $113B in 2018; about three-quarters of all revenues this year will be digital | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
China and the U.S. will duke it out for overall market share, according to a new study from games market analyst Newzoo.
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

What ‘Empire’ And Other Hip-Hop Dramas Say About America

What ‘Empire’ And Other Hip-Hop Dramas Say About America | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Street-savvy shows featuring a healthy dose of hip-hop swagger and style are finding viewers far beyond the traditional black audience. You can thank the Millennials for that.
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Strand and deliver: Amie Mills on the rise of transmedia storytelling

Strand and deliver: Amie Mills on the rise of transmedia storytelling | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
It used to be so simple. Find an audience (usually from someone or something with enough money to own mass media), put an ad in front of that audience and roll around on a bed laden with cash, laughing maniacally. ...
more...
No comment yet.
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia: Storytelling for the Digital Age
Scoop.it!

Film Insight Season 2 Episode 5: Maya Zuckerman on Transmedia

Film Insight Season 2 Episode 5: Maya Zuckerman on Transmedia | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it

Via The Digital Rocking Chair
more...
The Digital Rocking Chair's curator insight, May 12, 4:52 PM


Producer Foundry:  "Randy [Hall] and Ben [Yennie] welcome Maya Zuckerman, co-founder of TransmediaSF, to answer the question, "what is transmedia?" and why every filmmaker needs to pay attention to this way of thinking about their projects."

Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Digital Media Literacy + Cyber Arts + Performance Centers Connected to Fiber Networks
Scoop.it!

The Ridiculous Jobs Of The Digital Economy, Illustrated As Children's Book Characters | Ariel Schwartz | FastCoExist

The Ridiculous Jobs Of The Digital Economy, Illustrated As Children's Book Characters | Ariel Schwartz | FastCoExist | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it

The white male venture capitalist, the overpaid programming intern, the corporate social responsibility specialist: if you work at a corporate or tech startup job, you probably know these people. What you probably don't know is what these people would look like as Richard Scarry-inspired illustrated animals.

Tony Ruth, a creative director at a Chicago design firm, has provided us with that vision in BusinessTown, a parody Tumblr of today's workforce (with an emphasis on Silicon Valley stereotypes) described as "An ongoing project attempting to explain our highly intangible, deeply disruptive, data-driven, venture-backed, gluten-free economic meritocracy to the uninitiated. With apologies to Richard Scarry."

 

Click headline to read more and view the pix gallery-


Via Chuck Sherwood, Senior Associate, TeleDimensions, Inc
more...
No comment yet.
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia: Storytelling for the Digital Age
Scoop.it!

10 Reasons You Should Make a Web Series (Instead of an Indie Film)

10 Reasons You Should Make a Web Series (Instead of an Indie Film) | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it

Via The Digital Rocking Chair
more...
No comment yet.
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Documentary Evolution
Scoop.it!

Behind the Scenes with the Makers of the Interactive Documentary After the Storm

Behind the Scenes with the Makers of the Interactive Documentary After the Storm | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
The making of the Independent Lens online exclusive interactive documentary After the Storm created for online, tablet, and mobile viewing.

Via mirmilla
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Channel 4 excites Twitter with Persona Synthetics ads #transmedia

Channel 4 excites Twitter with Persona Synthetics ads #transmedia | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
The best in visual communication
more...
Fausto Cantu's curator insight, May 13, 2:07 PM

Campaña "Persona Synthetics"

Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from #transmediascoop
Scoop.it!

The Difficult Client "You"

The Difficult Client "You" | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
I’ve had a number of epiphanies over the past few days, mostly because I’ve spent almost every waking hour of those days in the company of a lot of highly intelligent and creative people in the for...

Via Simon Staffans
siobhan-o-flynn's insight:

thanks Simon!

more...
Simon Staffans's curator insight, Today, 7:54 AM

One thought I had that I felt I would like to share...

Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

ABC Family Launches 'Stitchers' Virtual Reality App That's 'Very Minority Report'

ABC Family Launches 'Stitchers' Virtual Reality App That's 'Very Minority Report' | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
The network’s new sci-fi procedural has its own smartphone app and headsets that promises to immerse users in a 360-degree video experience
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

The Generational Content Gap: How Different Generations Consume Content Online [INFOGRAPHIC]

The Generational Content Gap: How Different Generations Consume Content Online [INFOGRAPHIC] | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
As online audiences continue to grow and diversify, it's essential for content marketers to understand what resonates with their customers. One of the most important factors is how different
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Review: Netflix’s ‘Between’ Puts a Polite Damper on Growing Old

Review: Netflix’s ‘Between’ Puts a Polite Damper on Growing Old | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
The streaming site’s new Canadian science-fiction series focuses on a small town where a mysterious disease is killing residents over 21.
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Snapchat: A New Mobile Challenge for Storytelling

Snapchat: A New Mobile Challenge for Storytelling | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Talya Minsberg, a social media editor, describes one of The Times’s latest social experiments: using Snapchat to tell stories.
siobhan-o-flynn's insight:

'For starters, once you really take a look at Snapchat, you realize that most of your preconceived notions of the mobile app are false. There are really creative individuals and organizations making some pretty compelling stories on Snapchat, and watching a story on Snapchat is less passive than you may think. When you are watching a story, you have to hold your finger down on the screen.'

 
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Has the Golden Age of TV Been Replaced by the Age of Rape and Torture?

Has the Golden Age of TV Been Replaced by the Age of Rape and Torture? | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Recently the violence on a number of television shows has ticked up so far it's threatened to alienate even the most hardcore viewers. Orphan Black has taken an ultra-violent turn in Season 3, incl...
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Graffiti and Street Artists Finish Makeover of 191st Street Tunnel - ANIMAL

Graffiti and Street Artists Finish Makeover of 191st Street Tunnel - ANIMAL | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
As part of the New York City DOT's ongoing beautification projects, urban artists have been working in partnership with the agency for the past week to mak
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

Tumblr Brings Massive Improvement To The Way You Can Search

Tumblr Brings Massive Improvement To The Way You Can Search | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Tumblr is one of the fastest growing platforms and a large amount of content is added onto the platform every day. But, until now, searching for something on Tumblr was not exactly an easy thing. Thankfully, this has changed. Also Read: Tumblr’s Update Makes Writing Even More Awesome Tumblr will now let you search content…
more...
No comment yet.
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia Storytelling meets Tourism
Scoop.it!

7 Futurists On What To Expect In The Next Decade

7 Futurists On What To Expect In The Next Decade | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it

From smartphone apps that can do seemingly everything to driverless cars and eerily humanlike robots, the past decade has seen dramatic advances in science and technology. What amazing advances ar


Via Soraia Ferreira
more...
No comment yet.
Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia 4 Kids
Scoop.it!

Teens, Social Media & Technology Overview 2015

Teens, Social Media & Technology Overview 2015 | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
Smartphones are fueling a shift in the communication landscape for teens. Nearly three-quarters of teens now use smartphones and 92% of teens report going online daily — including 24% who say they go online "almost constantly."

Via cynthia jabar
more...
cynthia jabar's curator insight, May 13, 11:53 PM

Teenage girls use social media sites and platforms — particularly visually-oriented ones — for sharing more than their male counterparts do. For their part, boys are more likely than girls to own gaming consoles and play video games.

Rescooped by siobhan-o-flynn from Transmedia Storytelling meets Tourism
Scoop.it!

How the ‘Internet of Things’ is changing digital content marketing...

How the ‘Internet of Things’ is changing digital content marketing... | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
The emerging capability of networked devices to sense and interact with each other and their environments, also known as the Internet of Things (IoT), is bringing undeniable changes. According to a report by Gartner, between 2015 and 2020, the IoT devices will increase, globally, from nearly 5...

Via Soraia Ferreira
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by siobhan-o-flynn
Scoop.it!

YouTube's most watched game is 'Minecraft,' obviously

YouTube's most watched game is 'Minecraft,' obviously | Tracking Transmedia | Scoop.it
'Minecraft' is the most watched game on YouTube in the past 10 years, even though it was only released six years ago.
more...
No comment yet.