Politics for the ...
Follow
Find
1.0K views | +6 today
 
Scooped by GDBrin
onto Politics for the Twenty-first Century
Scoop.it!

The "Tytler" Calumny -- Is Democracy Hopeless?

The "Tytler" Calumny -- Is Democracy Hopeless? | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

The widely-circulated nostrum called the "Tytler Calumny" is the great example of what has gone wrong with the mental processes of our friends on the right, who used to be represented in sage debate by great minds like Barry Goldwater and Friedrich Hayek and William F. Buckley... but who are now reduced to slinging around aphorisms and fact-free fox-assertions.

more...
No comment yet.

From around the web

Politics for the Twenty-first Century
Politics for the Twenty-first Century
A moderate approach for a sane world
Curated by GDBrin
Your new post is loading...
Your new post is loading...
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The simple trick allowing citizens to bypass gerrymandering

The simple trick allowing citizens to bypass gerrymandering | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Gerrymandering’s top malignant effect has been radicalization of U.S. politics. Having engineered for themselves safe districts where the minority party has no chance, politicians have rendered November Congressional elections moot. Yet, this only shifted tension to the primary; a district’s most vociferous 5 percent can oust established representatives.


But consider: Gerrymandering lumps birds-of-a-feather till each district is “owned” by one party or another. Democratic voters in a Republican-owned district – or Republicans in a Democratic-owned district – will never cast a vote of legislature in the only election that matters: the majority party’s primary. Unless…unless you hold your nose and re-register with whatever party owns your district. This holds, whether you’re a Democrat in a Republican district, or vice versa

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

How Far Conservatism Has Changed

How Far Conservatism Has Changed | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

The real legacy of the Founding Fathers to us is a political process: a system of disagreement, debate, and compromise that has kept democracy vibrant in America for more than two hundred years, but that regularly comes under attack.


How extreme has been the veer off any path of sane conservatism?  

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Honoring the Losing Majority

Honoring the Losing Majority | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

The election will be determined by clumps of electors that are awarded by winner-takes-all. Those on the victorious side will gather all the marbles, leaving the losers bitterly muttering about getting even next time. Might there be some way to acknowledge the losing minority in a presidential election, without grinding their face in humiliation, making them determined to do the same thing, when their turn comes around? 

 

Imagine a candidate or new President Elect making the following pledge: "If I become president, I promise to ask my honorable opponent to pick a panel of Americans who will have control over my appointment calendar one afternoon per month. And I expect my opponent to serve on that panel. On that afternoon, I shall meet with -- and listen to -- any individuals or delegations that panel may choose. Millions of Americans will then know that I do not live in a tower of ideological isolation. I will answer questions and hear dissenting points of view."

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

How Democrats and Republicans Wage War

How Democrats and Republicans Wage War | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

I hope to shed some badly-needed perspective on the most important foreign policy matter of all... when and how we, as a country, choose to fight. Do the two U.S. political parties differ in how they wage war? What are their distinctions in doctrine, policy, professionalism, style and effectiveness?

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The Electoral College: A Surprisingly Easy Fix

The Electoral College: A Surprisingly Easy Fix | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it
It turns out that the Electoral College, per se, is not what distorts the system so badly. It is the winner-takes-all method of allocating each state's electors. Can we break the winner-takes-all habit?

There is precedent. Decades ago, both parties allocated delegates to their national nominating conventions by winner-takes-all, until this blatant unfairness was challenged, then eliminated. So why not take the next step by dropping it from the process of choosing electors? Again, this would require no tinkering with the Constitution, though changing applicable state laws might entail a fight. 

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Restore Independent Advisory Agencies

Restore Independent Advisory Agencies | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Nothing could better indicate the turn in our national fortunes than to see science no longer dismissed as a realm of pointy-headed boffins, but viewed as part and parcel of our nation's future. It is essential to restore the Office of Technology Assessment, and other science advisory agencies in Congress.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Free the Inspectors General

Free the Inspectors General | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Free the Inspectors General: Establish a new and important post, the office of Inspector General of the United States... or IGUS. 

 

Far from creating another vast new bureaucracy, this proposal would mostly utilize payroll slots that already exist, today. Every major department or agency has an internal Inspector General (IG) charged with examining operations and issuing warnings -- when it comes to minor infractions -- or else stepping in more vigorously when things get out of hand.

 

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

"Neo-Reactionaries" drop all pretense: End democracy and bring back lords!

"Neo-Reactionaries" drop all pretense: End democracy and bring back lords! | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

A new movement among geeks is called the "Neo-Reactionary Movement"  -- a quasi-new cult that yearns for the ancien régime of monarchy and feudal rule. One that rejects Adam Smith and Franklin and the entire Enlightenment.  And above all -- democracy.

 

Klint Finley describes it thus:  "Neoreactionaries believe that while technology and capitalism have advanced humanity over the past couple centuries, democracy has actually done more harm than good. They propose a return to old-fashioned gender roles, social order and monarchy."

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

21st century politics

21st century politics | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

A collection of articles from David Brin on the issues, elections, economics and politics of our day. Here you'll find essays about:
*Can a small transaction fee save Wall Street?
* How to simplify our tax system non-politically using a computer program and a simple boundary condition.
* Is there a difference between a global warming "skeptic" who has questions about the science and a "denialist" who spouts the same delaying tactics used by Big Tobacco, in the 1980s?
* In 1947 Democrats purged themselves of fanatical fringe loonies and saved their party. Are Republicans capable of similar courage and will? There is a precedent!
Let us strive for a return to the pragmatic, scientific, can-do-eager nation that was so admired. That deserved to lead the world.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The "Tytler" Calumny -- Is Democracy Hopeless?

The "Tytler" Calumny -- Is Democracy Hopeless? | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

The widely-circulated nostrum called the "Tytler Calumny" is the great example of what has gone wrong with the mental processes of our friends on the right, who used to be represented in sage debate by great minds like Barry Goldwater and Friedrich Hayek and William F. Buckley... but who are now reduced to slinging around aphorisms and fact-free fox-assertions.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

American Exceptionalism... versus what has made America exceptional

American Exceptionalism... versus what has made America exceptional | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

The United States of America has been the most exceptional thing ever to happen to humanity. I say this not out of reflex triumphalism or chauvinism, but as a simple matter of outcomes appraisal. Indeed, I bet that in the grand context of time, the American Experiment will turn out to have been one of the major reasons, if we wind up succeeding as a species and even reaching for the stars. Yet...those amazing accomplishments weren't accomplishments of jingoist flag-waving but of relentless, day-to-day creativity, good-natured progress and lots of self-critique by every generation of new Americans.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

What is Freedom?

What is Freedom? | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

The whole issue of "freedom" boils down much deeper than the surface levels where it is usually discussed. Let me try to explain. 

For 2,000 years the enemies of democracy, led by that infamous so-called “philosopher” Plato, have tried to undermine the Periclean experiment by couching the debate in terms that work to the detriment of freedom. In order to do this, they pulled many tricks. Foremost, they emphasized and concentrated on the LEAST important and least honorable aspect of democracy -- majority rule -- while downgrading the most important aspect (the one emphasized by Pericles) which is open and knowing reciprocal accountability.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The Left-Right Axis Redux: More on the War of Ideas

The Left-Right Axis Redux: More on the War of Ideas | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

 I am one of the leading proponents for abandoning the left-right axis, it is hard for me to say what are the leading ideas of the left. But let me try with a four-state metaphor.

Capital "L" Left = loony mystical platonists who want power over us so that they can (for our own good) ensure rule by philosopher kings who ERADICATE class differences.

Capital "R" RIGHT = loony mystical platonists who want power over us so that they can (for our own good) ensure rule by philosopher kings who EMPHASIZE class differences.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Voter ID Laws: Scam or Accountability?

Voter ID Laws: Scam or Accountability? | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Voter ID Laws: Scam or Accountability? If these laws weren’t aimed solely at stealing elections, the states in question would have accompanies the new regulations with measures aimed at helping their citizens to comply with the new regulations…

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Yes, Polarization Is Asymmetric—it’s not about physics... but politics

Yes, Polarization Is Asymmetric—it’s not about physics... but politics | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it
The worst aspect of all polarization this has been the devolution of politics into cliches, outright lies and a relentless disdain toward science… along with every other “smartypants” profession, from medical doctors and teachers to journalists, economists, civil servants, skilled labor and law professionals. All are now targets of trumped-up hatred. And not all of it from the right! The far-left contains plenty of anti-modernists.
Isaac Asimov once commented: "There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there has always been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge."
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

150 years after Lincoln at Gettysburg… Can we maintain our resolve? Our Union?

150 years after Lincoln at Gettysburg… Can we maintain our resolve? Our Union? | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

One side of our national character hungers for change and tomorrow. To treat the future - the range of possible futures -- as ambition-attracting terra incognita, across which our children will explore and stride, better than we are in every way, even if that means repudiating many of our now-unclear assumptions and errors! Preparing those much-better generations for a boundless future is our dedicated proposition. Our mission.
But there is an opposing passion -- the temptation to wallow in nostalgia, romanticism, sanctimony, authority and the comforting rigidity-of-caste that dominated nearly every other civilization, across 6000 years. It was called feudalism and humanity's greatest heroes fought to liberate us from that beastly, limiting and dismal way of life.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Modern(ist) Political Subtlety - or Why "Majority Rule" is a Deadly Ruse

Modern(ist) Political Subtlety - or Why "Majority Rule" is a Deadly Ruse | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

But what does 'consent' really mean? Majority rule helps guarantee against the worst kinds of tyranny - those featuring iron-fist repression by a truly narrow, unaccountable and coercive elite. Hence, if we ever do have a dictatorship, it will cover the fist with silken gloves, and suffer great lengths to convince us that "we" (the majority) voted for it. Still, that will not protect minorities. Nor will it ensure that statecraft is performed with attention to CITOKATE. (Criticism is the only known antidote to error.)Indeed, it is quite possible for majorities to be flat out, cockeyed wrong.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Time for a 2-D or 3-D Political Map? Models, Maps & Visions of Tomorrow

Time for a 2-D or 3-D Political Map? Models, Maps & Visions of Tomorrow | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Re-evaluate everything you assumed about reflex politics. Many have noticed that the hoary "left-right axis" sheds no useful light on our complex world. Attempts to spread it onto two or three dimensions suffer from flaws like "tendentiousness." I offer a landscape that seems to do better, but the real point here is to step back and see our present squabbles in the context of our grinding climb from caves to village, kingdom and... civilization.

This study was created for a rebel libertarian society, aiming to divert the movement from Rand-Rothbard madness, back to Adam Smith. But the broad perspectives apply to all people who are sincere about adding grownup breadth to their politics.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The Jefferson Rifle: Guns and the Insurrection Myth

The Jefferson Rifle: Guns and the Insurrection Myth | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it
We accept a state interest in demanding that all drivers be licensed and that all cars be registered and well-maintained. Why not apply similar standards to the other machines most responsible for premature, violent death in this country -- firearms? In California, where the DMV has lately acquired an astonishing reputation for good service, one could envision renaming it the “Department of Motor Vehicles and Firearms”. A hunting shotgun might be treated like a normal car. You want an AK-47? Then take as many tests -- and get as much insurance -- as a professional trucker who wants to drive an 18-wheeler. If your gun is stolen, report it like a missing auto. Fail to lock it up properly? Your insurance rates go up.
more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Why the Candidates Should (But Won’t) Stipulate

Why the Candidates Should (But Won’t) Stipulate | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

What's wrong with two leaders finding patches of consensus amid a sea of discord? It has a name - stipulation... as when attorneys in a case agree to agree about a set of points, so the trial can focus on areas where they disagree.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Gerrymandering American Democracy: More Fragile Than We Think

Gerrymandering American Democracy: More Fragile Than We Think | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Quietly, without much comment or notice, the practice of gerrymandering has transformed from a dismal-but-bearable tradition of occasional opportunism into a cancer eating at the heart of democracy itself, rendering our votes nearly meaningless in some states. When it comes to certain types of elections -- those that choose our delegates for the legislative branch of government -- most Americans have been denied any chance to choose their representatives. They have no real choice at all.

By quietly and gradually cranking up a process called gerrymandering, members of the Political Caste -- in both parties -- have managed to effectively seal most of us away from the very franchise that we all consider to be one of our most basic American birthrights.

 

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The Hidden Danger to Public Servants: BLACKMAIL

The Hidden Danger to Public Servants: BLACKMAIL | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

In observing -- with some approval -- the departure of the corrupt, incompetent and astonishingly lazy 109th Congress, it is not without some worry that we greet the young and hopeful 110th. Will cynics prove right? While negotiating the ethical and political minefield that is Washington, always remain wary of a particular worst-case scenario... one that can systematically undermine even the most well-meaning politicians.

That worst-case scenario is BLACKMAIL.

 

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Can We Perform Another 'Miracle of 1947'?

Can We Perform Another 'Miracle of 1947'? | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

After sharp Republican setbacks in two successive elections, the latest buzz is about a looming 're-alignment' in American politics. No one ever said it would be easy to fight for a chastened and rational conservatism -- one that is no longer misled by crooks and crazies. Life wasn't easy, either, for the Democrats of 1947. But they kept faith with the moderate spirit of our American wing of the Enlightenment. And liberalism has -- for all its ups and downs -- stayed relevant to this day.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

The Republican Party's Neocon Re-Invention

The Republican Party's Neocon Re-Invention | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Republicans began their own long journey of re-appraisal in the wake of Barry Goldwater's crushing defeat in 1964, then intensified their efforts after the debacle of Watergate. William F. Buckley, during the 1964 campaign, recognized the dominance of liberalism at that time. He urged that conservatives see themselves as 'well-planted seeds of hope, which will flower on a great November day in the future, if there is a future.' Soon, concentrated efforts began, at places like the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute, to forge networks of expertise in theory, policy and political operations, filling in every component for a vigorous new age of conservatism.

more...
No comment yet.
Scooped by GDBrin
Scoop.it!

Despair amid signs of hope...

Despair amid signs of hope... | Politics for the Twenty-first Century | Scoop.it

Imagine if Pepsi and Coke had arranged to divide up the cola market into tidy little local geographic monopolies, where each could charge whatever they liked for colored sugar water... while claiming that their nearly 50:50 overall split means “healthy competition”! Hell, they could even do this while hating each others’ guts,the same way that democrats and republicans now do. The same way that English and French feudal lords despised each other... and yet acted in mutual support against the common foe. Uppity commoners.

more...
No comment yet.