A 21-year-old woman arrested for investigation of drunk driving and manslaughter after a crash that killed six people had her license suspended as a teenager for driving under the influence, according to state Department of Motor Vehicle records.
Marcus Irving's insight:
This story raises the question, is drinking excessive amounts of alcohol a disease that should be treated as such, or is it a poor choice made by the individual, in which their actions while under the influence should be given no special considerations. This tragic story is about a 21 year old woman from Diamond bar C.A. who had a previous dui from when she was 17,and just recently was involved in a drunk driving accident that took the lives of 6 people, including her own sister. The woman responsible for the accidents’ name is Olivia Culbreath and she is the mother of a newborn. If a person has a newborn baby that they are responsible for and decides that drinking and driving and putting people’s lives at risk is more important than being safe for the sake of her child, how should they be punished? Do you believe she should be seen as someone who made a mistake and given the opportunity to be rehabilitated (like the boy in the affluenza case), or tried and punished as a criminal offender?
After working as a dental assistant for ten years, Melissa Nelson was fired for being too “irresistible” and a “threat” to her employer’s marriage. “I think it is completely wrong,” Nelson said. ”I think it is sending a message that men can do whatever they want in the work force.” On Friday, the all-male Iowa State Supreme Court ruled that James Knight, Nelson’s boss, was within his legal rights when he fired her, affirming the decision of a lower court. “We do think the Iowa Supreme Court got it completely right,” said Stuart Cochrane, an attorney for James Knight. “Our position…
Marcus Irving's insight:
It is presumed that attractive people are more competent and socially graceful than their counterparts. Well what happens when that same beauty that draws admiration from so many becomes a negative aspect in one’s life. Here we see Melissa Nelson, who is the married mother of two children and a dental assistant of ten years, being fired from her job for being too pretty. Her boss claims that her beauty was too tempting and felt like their working relationship would have led to an affair if she remained employed with his practice. During the final year of her employment her boss (male) sent her some sexually inappropriate text messages that were discovered by his wife, which in turn led to Melissa’s termination. An all male supreme court ruled in favor of her boss stating, “he was within his legal rights to fire her, because it wasn’t a matter of gender but a matter of inappropriate behavior.” I think one issue that is being overlooked here is the fact that her boss assumes that just because he might be the type of person that would commit adultery that Melissa would partake in it as well. Where does he have the right to say that they would have an affair (based on what), and shouldn’t his wife be more concerned with his behavior and not Melissa’s, who has been nothing but a professional in the workplace? How would feminist theory look at this as a case of gender bias, and what is the stigma against attractive women who are considered to dress provocatively in the workplace? Also, how are patriarchy and aesthetic norms of attractiveness relevant to this case?
Last week an Orange County jury saved a former cop from
Marcus Irving's insight:
Once again, we see how labeling and stigma can play such an important role when determining who is right, and who is wrong. Here we have a case of a woman with a sexually exploitative job, and a police officer, who is suppose to serve and protect the public. This particular incident reminds me of the class reading we did last week, in which the cop arrested an innocent girl and persisted that she to had to be guilty of something, stating, “You know how these girls are,” (referring to her promiscuity) Officer David Alex Park, whom I might add is a married man, gets awarded the verdict of not guilty on 10 accounts of sexual abuse. The officer was said to have had a prior incident with the woman in which he pulled her over and found drug paraphernalia in her car but decided to let her go only after getting her phone number. Would this type of behavior have been tolerated if the woman had been a politician or a doctor, and not a stripper, who’s label comes with the notion that they are all sexual deviants who enjoy a good time? Do you see this falling under the routine activity theory, in which there has to be a motivated offender, a suitable target and the absence of a capable guardian for a deviant act to take place? Let me know what you think, as well as how you feel about this specific act of deviance.
As the saying goes, there is two sides to every story. For this particular story I happened to be visiting Albuquerque on a vacation before I became a resident, when this incident took place. What the article reads is that, while on a two month sabbatical to perform surgeries on Native Americans in Gallup, African American NY city heart surgeon and member of the Army reserves, received a dislocated shoulder, among other injuries while being subdued by police officers in front of a downtown liquor establishment for showing aggression towards APD officers. As the incident occurred the Dr. claims to have been called a “boy”, mocked and had the relevancy of his profession scrutinized. While the Dr. sais he was just having a conversation with the bar owner about poor treatment from the businesses employees that sparked the altercation with the police, the bar owner sais it was the man’s hostility and manner that caused the officers to act accordingly. The Dr. attributes his handling to race, leaving the question: would there have been the same level of force administered by the officers if he had been white and identified himself as a heart surgeon? I personally don’t go to the bar in question because of complaints from friends I have that are of Hispanic, African American & Native American backgrounds, who have also spoke of a lack of service and shitty attitudes from some of the wait staff. Was this a case of a patron being out of line who got what any other person would had received in the same situation or a case of being guilty by way of color? Is there any relevance to the reading Saints and Roughnecks that might give some insight to this particular incident?
A young man allegedly hacked his mother to death with an ax — then grinned for the cameras at his Long Island arraignment Friday. Deranged suspect Sean Farrell, 24, called…
Marcus Irving's insight:
The story of 24 year old Sean Farrell, who murdered his own mother by way of ax and then avoided police by admitting himself to a mental hospital brought me back to our in class discussion on mental disorders. The question I ask is should Sean face the same level of punishment for his crime as someone who is considered “normal” or “sane”? Are the results of pain, anger and loss not the same to the victim’s family as those in any other instance? Also the fact that he had the awareness to check himself into a hospital after committing the crime may lead one to consider that there is a possibility that Sean knew he was doing something wrong, but insisted on doing it anyway despite the consequences. In the case of a crime by way of mental disorder, is there any sociological theories that may explain or help us understand the motives behind the action, such as free will theory, routine activity theory or labeling theory, or is it just a case of a person who is not in their right state of mind, under no circumstances to be evaluated the same way as someone who is perfectly coherent? Is there a level of subjectivism (bias on how you see something) when it comes to how we punish crimes that are committed by someone who is considered mentally ill? My personal opinion is that the type of crime and who it is committed against can sometimes persuade our judgment when deciding what level of punishment to prescribe. Also is there any instance such as, selling drugs, doing drugs, hate crime and etc. where a mental disorder should not lead to lightened sentencing or hospitalization?
We've heard of people stealing money so that their family can eat, but this Japanese man took this took this to a whole different level – he went on a y
Marcus Irving's insight:
add your insight...
I found this story interesting because it illustrates how someone could break a social norm (burglary), not in an attempt to satisfy one’s own needs but rather to benefit the lifestyle of one’s pets. This article details an unemployed male who acquires $180,000 over the course of 32 home thefts in an attempt to feed his cats gourmet quality meals (LOL). It led me to ask the question: what kinds of social bonds may have been absent in this mans life to allow him to put his own freedom and well being at risk for the adoration of animals? Also what theory would best explain this mans behavior? Could this be a example of Routine Activity Theory. in which all three elements just lined up for deviance to occur, or possibly another explanation fits the situation. What would lead a person to commit crimes against other human beings just to provide such luxury for pets? From a macro level analysis I wonder, does mass media play a role in this mans behavior. Is this a case of Anomie, where television depicts such a glamorous portrayal of how people pamper their pets that the man felt he couldn’t provide a suitable level of pleasure for his companions with the means he had available and decided to turn to a life of crime out of frustration. What do you guys think about this, I’d like to know?
Sharing your scoops to your social media accounts is a must to distribute your curated content. Not only will it drive traffic and leads through your content, but it will help show your expertise with your followers.
How to integrate my topics' content to my website?
Integrating your curated content to your website or blog will allow you to increase your website visitors’ engagement, boost SEO and acquire new visitors. By redirecting your social media traffic to your website, Scoop.it will also help you generate more qualified traffic and leads from your curation work.
Distributing your curated content through a newsletter is a great way to nurture and engage your email subscribers will developing your traffic and visibility.
Creating engaging newsletters with your curated content is really easy.